Evaluating osteological ageing from digital data

Age at death estimation of human skeletal remains is one of the key issues in constructing a biological profile both in forensic and archaeological contexts. The traditional adult osteological methods evaluate macroscopically the morphological changes that occur with increasing age of specific skeletal indicators, such as the cranial sutures, the pubic bone, the auricular surface of the ilium and the sternal end of the ribs. Technologies such as computed tomography and laser scanning are becoming more widely used in anthropology, and several new methods have been developed. This review focuses on how the osteological age‐related changes have been evaluated in digital data. First, the 3D virtual copies of the bones have been used to mimic the appearance of the dry bones and the application of the traditional methods. Secondly, the information directly extrapolated from CT scans has been used to assess qualitatively or quantitatively the changes of the trabecular bones, the thickness of the cortical bones, and to perform morphometric analyses. Lastly, the most innovative approach has been the mathematical quantification of the changes of the pelvic joints, calculating the complexity of the surface. The importance of new updated reference datasets, created thanks to the use of CT scanning in forensic settings, is also discussed.

[1]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  Computed Tomography Scanning and Three‐Dimensional Visualization of Mummies and Bog Bodies , 2007 .

[2]  Frank J Rühli,et al.  Diagnostic paleoradiology of mummified tissue: interpretation and pitfalls. , 2004, Canadian Association of Radiologists journal = Journal l'Association canadienne des radiologistes.

[3]  Pascal Adalian,et al.  Lateral angle and cranial base sexual dimorphism: a morphometric evaluation using computerised tomography scans of a modern documented autopsy population from Denmark. , 2016, Anthropologischer Anzeiger; Bericht uber die biologisch-anthropologische Literatur.

[4]  Daniel Rougé,et al.  Virtual and macroscopical studies of mummies--differences or complementarity? Report of a natural frozen Siberian mummy. , 2010, Forensic science international.

[5]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  The Use of CT Scans in Estimating Age at Death by Examining the Extent of Ectocranial Suture Closure , 2015, Journal of forensic sciences.

[6]  Daniel Rougé,et al.  Application of the Iscan Method to Two‐ and Three‐Dimensional Imaging of the Sternal End of the Right Fourth Rib * , 2008, Journal of forensic sciences.

[7]  Sebastian K T S Wärmländer,et al.  Zygomaticomaxillary suture shape analyzed with digital morphometrics: reassessing patterns of variation in American Indian and European populations. , 2012, Forensic science international.

[8]  M. Galland,et al.  A three‐dimensional geometric morphometrics view of the cranial shape variation and population history in the New World , 2016, American journal of human biology : the official journal of the Human Biology Council.

[9]  Daniel Rougé,et al.  Virtual anthropology and forensic identification: report of one case. , 2007, Forensic science international.

[10]  Norbert Telmon,et al.  Geometric morphometric analysis reveals sexual dimorphism in the distal femur. , 2016, Forensic science international.

[11]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  The Lateral Angle Revisited: A Validation Study of the Reliability of the Lateral Angle Method for Sex Determination Using Computed Tomography (CT) , , 2013, Journal of forensic sciences.

[12]  F Teasdale,et al.  Morphometric evaluation. , 1982, Contributions to gynecology and obstetrics.

[13]  Peter Mygind Leth,et al.  The use of CT scanning in forensic autopsy , 2007, Forensic science, medicine, and pathology.

[14]  G. Acsadi,et al.  History of Human Life Span and Mortality , 1971 .

[15]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  Facial recognition and laser surface scan: a pilot study , 2009, Forensic science, medicine, and pathology.

[16]  Cristina Cattaneo,et al.  Quantitative Analysis of the Morphological Changes of the Pubic Symphyseal Face and the Auricular Surface and Implications for Age at Death Estimation , 2015, Journal of forensic sciences.

[17]  F. Bookstein,et al.  Virtual Anthropology: A guide to a new interdisciplinary field , 2011 .

[18]  Cynthia A. Wilczak,et al.  Three‐dimensional Surface Area of the Distal Biceps Enthesis, Relationship to Body Size, Sex, Age and Secular Changes in a 20th Century American Sample , 2013 .

[19]  Cristina Cattaneo,et al.  Technical note: Reliability of Suchey-Brooks and Buckberry-Chamberlain methods on 3D visualizations from CT and laser scans. , 2013, American journal of physical anthropology.

[20]  Andrew H. Gee,et al.  Cortical Thickness Mapping to Identify Focal Osteoporosis in Patients with Hip Fracture , 2012, PloS one.

[21]  Matthew Meredith,et al.  Morphometric modelling of ageing in the human pubic symphysis: sexual dimorphism in an Australian population. , 2014, Forensic science international.

[22]  F J Rühli,et al.  Age‐dependent changes of the normal human spine during adulthood , 2005, American journal of human biology : the official journal of the Human Biology Council.

[23]  Hitoshi Biwasaka,et al.  Three dimensional surface analyses of pubic symphyseal faces of contemporary Japanese reconstructed with 3D digitized scanner. , 2013, Legal medicine.

[24]  Norbert Telmon,et al.  Age at death estimation of adult males using coxal bone and CT scan: a preliminary study. , 2009, Forensic science international.

[25]  Cristina Cattaneo,et al.  Forensic age estimation based on the trabecular bone changes of the pelvic bone using post-mortem CT. , 2013, Forensic science international.

[26]  Chahin Pachai,et al.  Cranial sutures and craniometric points detected on MRI , 2005, Surgical and Radiologic Anatomy.

[27]  Mutsumi Hayakawa,et al.  Age estimation by quantitative features of pubic symphysis using multidetector computed tomography , 2014, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[28]  Hervé Rousseau,et al.  Human Coxal Bone Sexual Dimorphism and Multislice Computed Tomography: Geometric Morphometric Analysis of 65 Adults , 2012, Journal of forensic sciences.

[29]  C. Lovejoy,et al.  Ectocranial suture closure: a revised method for the determination of skeletal age at death based on the lateral-anterior sutures. , 1985, American journal of physical anthropology.

[30]  M. G. Belcastro,et al.  Variation of the degree of sacral vertebral body fusion in adulthood in two European modern skeletal collections. , 2008, American journal of physical anthropology.

[31]  Hervé Rousseau,et al.  Age at Death Estimation Using Multislice Computed Tomography Reconstructions of the Posterior Pelvis * , 2009, Journal of forensic sciences.

[32]  C. Lovejoy,et al.  Radiographic changes in the clavicle and proximal femur and their use in the determination of skeletal age at death. , 1985, American journal of physical anthropology.

[33]  Christoph P. E. Zollikofer,et al.  Virtual Reconstruction: A Primer in Computer-Assisted Paleontology and Biomedicine , 2005 .

[34]  V Burdin,et al.  Determination of age at death: assessment of an algorithm of age prediction using numerical three-dimensional CT data from pubic bones. , 1999, American journal of physical anthropology.

[35]  Andrew Wade,et al.  Preliminary Radiological Assessment of Age‐related Change in the Trabecular Structure of the Human Os Pubis * , 2011, Journal of forensic sciences.

[36]  Lyle W. Konigsberg,et al.  Paleodemography: Transition analysis: a new method for estimating age from skeletons , 2002 .

[37]  Andrew Scott,et al.  An independent test of the technique of aging skeletal material from the sternal end of the right fourth rib , 2000 .

[38]  Bridget F B Algee-Hewitt,et al.  An enhanced computational method for age-at-death estimation based on the pubic symphysis using 3D laser scans and thin plate splines. , 2015, American journal of physical anthropology.

[39]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY AND COMPUTED RADIOGRAPHY OF LATE BRONZE AGE CREMATION URNS FROM DENMARK: AN INTERDISCIPLINARY ATTEMPT TO DEVELOP METHODS APPLIED IN BIOARCHAEOLOGICAL CREMATION RESEARCH* , 2012 .

[40]  Alfredo Cigada,et al.  Personal Identification by the Comparison of Facial Profiles: Testing the Reliability of a High‐Resolution 3D–2D Comparison Model , 2012, Journal of forensic sciences.

[41]  J. Nemeskéri History of Human Life Span and Mortality , 1971 .

[42]  Davide Caramella,et al.  An investigation of Etruscan cremations by Computed Tomography (CT) , 2010, Antiquity.

[43]  Bridget F.B. Algee-Hewitt,et al.  The reality of virtual anthropology: Comparing digitizer and laser scan data collection methods for the quantitative assessment of the cranium. , 2016, American journal of physical anthropology.

[44]  Inmaculada Alemán Aguilera,et al.  Image analysis of pubic bone for age estimation in a computed tomography sample , 2015, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[45]  Sotiris K Manolis,et al.  Sex determination by three-dimensional geometric morphometrics of the vault and midsagittal curve of the neurocranium in a modern Greek population sample. , 2016, Homo : internationale Zeitschrift fur die vergleichende Forschung am Menschen.

[46]  T. Wingate Todd,et al.  Age changes in the pubic bone. VIII. Roentgenographic differentiation , 1930 .

[47]  Judith E. Adams,et al.  Egyptian Mummies and Modern Science: Imaging in Egyptian mummies , 2008 .

[48]  N Lynnerup,et al.  A Non-Invasive Technique for Age at Death Determination , 1990, Medicine, science, and the law.

[49]  J. Simonsen,et al.  Computed tomography as routine in connection with medico-legal autopsies. , 2007, Forensic science international.

[50]  Marcel A Verhoff,et al.  Ossification Degrees of Cranial Sutures Determined with Flat‐Panel Computed Tomography: Narrowing the Age Estimate with Extrema , 2010, Journal of forensic sciences.

[51]  J. Waddington,et al.  Facial surface analysis by 3D laser scanning and geometric morphometrics in relation to sexual dimorphism in cerebral–craniofacial morphogenesis and cognitive function , 2005, Journal of anatomy.

[52]  H. Garvin,et al.  A morphometric analysis of prognathism and evaluation of the gnathic index in modern humans. , 2016, Homo : internationale Zeitschrift fur die vergleichende Forschung am Menschen.

[53]  D Schranz,et al.  Age determination from the internal structure of the humerus. , 1959, American Journal of Physical Anthropology.

[54]  Bridget F B Algee-Hewitt,et al.  Modeling Bone Surface Morphology: A Fully Quantitative Method for Age‐at‐Death Estimation Using the Pubic Symphysis , 2015, Journal of forensic sciences.

[55]  M Y Işcan,et al.  Metamorphosis at the sternal rib end: a new method to estimate age at death in white males. , 1984, American journal of physical anthropology.

[56]  José Antonio Sánchez Sánchez,et al.  Determining sex by bone volume from 3D images: discriminating analysis of the tali and radii in a contemporary Spanish reference collection , 2012, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[57]  Tanya Uldin,et al.  Virtual anthropology: a comparison between the performance of conventional X-ray and MDCT in investigating the trabecular structure of long bones. , 2013, Forensic science international.

[58]  D. Wescott,et al.  Estimation and Evidence in Forensic Anthropology: Age‐at‐Death , 2008, Journal of forensic sciences.

[59]  Mutsumi Hayakawa,et al.  Age estimation by multidetector CT images of the sagittal suture , 2013, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[60]  G. Rutty,et al.  Forensic institutes across the world place CT or MRI scanners or both into their mortuaries. , 2008, The Journal of trauma.

[61]  Sebastian K T S Wärmländer,et al.  Identification of Group Affinity from Cross‐sectional Contours of the Human Midfacial Skeleton Using Digital Morphometrics and 3D Laser Scanning Technology *,‡ , 2011, Journal of forensic sciences.

[62]  Alexandra E Wink,et al.  Pubic Symphyseal Age Estimation from Three‐Dimensional Reconstructions of Pelvic CT Scans of Live Individuals , 2014, Journal of forensic sciences.

[63]  Cristina Cattaneo,et al.  Surface Curvature of Pelvic Joints from Three Laser Scanners: Separating Anatomy from Measurement Error , 2015, Journal of forensic sciences.

[64]  G. Weber,et al.  Virtual anthropology. , 2015, American journal of physical anthropology.

[65]  Daniel Rougé,et al.  Application of the Suchey-Brooks method to three-dimensional imaging of the pubic symphysis. , 2005, Journal of forensic sciences.

[66]  C. Lovejoy,et al.  Chronological metamorphosis of the auricular surface of the ilium: a new method for the determination of adult skeletal age at death. , 1985, American journal of physical anthropology.

[67]  A. Chamberlain,et al.  Age estimation from the auricular surface of the ilium: a revised method. , 2002, American journal of physical anthropology.

[68]  Sebastian K T S Wärmländer,et al.  Sexual dimorphism in human browridge volume measured from 3D models of dry crania: a new digital morphometrics approach. , 2012, Forensic science international.

[69]  Michael J. Thali,et al.  Estimation of sex and age of “virtual skeletons”–a feasibility study , 2009, European Radiology.

[70]  Ho-Jung Cho,et al.  Morphometric Evaluation of Korean Femurs by Geometric Computation: Comparisons of the Sex and the Population , 2015, BioMed research international.

[71]  George R. Milner,et al.  Skeletal Age Estimation: Where We Are and Where We Should Go , 2012 .

[72]  H. Rousseau,et al.  Virtual anthropology and forensic identification using multidetector CT. , 2014, The British journal of radiology.

[73]  Douglas H. Ubelaker,et al.  Forensic Anthropology: Methodology and Diversity of Applications , 2007 .

[74]  Hervé Rousseau,et al.  Ontogeny of Size and Shape Sexual Dimorphism in the Ilium: A Multislice Computed Tomography Study by Geometric Morphometry , 2013, Journal of forensic sciences.

[75]  S. Brooks,et al.  Skeletal age determination based on the os pubis: A comparison of the Acsádi-Nemeskéri and Suchey-Brooks methods , 1990 .

[76]  Niels Lynnerup,et al.  Age estimation by 3D CT-scans of the Borremose Woman, a Danish bog body , 2011 .

[77]  Andrew H. Gee,et al.  Imaging the femoral cortex: Thickness, density and mass from clinical CT , 2012, Medical Image Anal..

[78]  Daniel Franklin,et al.  The application of traditional and geometric morphometric analyses for forensic quantification of sexual dimorphism: preliminary investigations in a Western Australian population , 2012, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[79]  C. Boesch,et al.  Virtopsy, a new imaging horizon in forensic pathology: virtual autopsy by postmortem multislice computed tomography (MSCT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)--a feasibility study. , 2003, Journal of forensic sciences.

[80]  F. Joffre,et al.  Virtual Autopsy and Forensic Identification—Practical Application: A Report of One Case , 2007, Journal of forensic sciences.

[81]  Jean-Pierre Bocquet-Appel,et al.  Farewell to paleodemography , 1982 .

[82]  C. Stringer,et al.  Geometric morphometric study of the regional variation of modern human craniofacial form. , 2002, American journal of physical anthropology.

[83]  M. Singh,et al.  Changes in trabecular pattern of the upper end of the femur as an index of osteoporosis. , 1970, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.