Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) for Environmental Development and Transfer of Antibiotic Resistance

Background: Only recently has the environment been clearly implicated in the risk of antibiotic resistance to clinical outcome, but to date there have been few documented approaches to formally assess these risks. Objective: We examined possible approaches and sought to identify research needs to enable human health risk assessments (HHRA) that focus on the role of the environment in the failure of antibiotic treatment caused by antibiotic-resistant pathogens. Methods: The authors participated in a workshop held 4–8 March 2012 in Québec, Canada, to define the scope and objectives of an environmental assessment of antibiotic-resistance risks to human health. We focused on key elements of environmental-resistance-development “hot spots,” exposure assessment (unrelated to food), and dose response to characterize risks that may improve antibiotic-resistance management options. Discussion: Various novel aspects to traditional risk assessments were identified to enable an assessment of environmental antibiotic resistance. These include a) accounting for an added selective pressure on the environmental resistome that, over time, allows for development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB); b) identifying and describing rates of horizontal gene transfer (HGT) in the relevant environmental “hot spot” compartments; and c) modifying traditional dose–response approaches to address doses of ARB for various health outcomes and pathways. Conclusions: We propose that environmental aspects of antibiotic-resistance development be included in the processes of any HHRA addressing ARB. Because of limited available data, a multicriteria decision analysis approach would be a useful way to undertake an HHRA of environmental antibiotic resistance that informs risk managers. Citation: Ashbolt NJ, Amézquita A, Backhaus T, Borriello P, Brandt KK, Collignon P, Coors A, Finley R, Gaze WH, Heberer T, Lawrence JR, Larsson DG, McEwen SA, Ryan JJ, Schönfeld J, Silley P, Snape JR, Van den Eede C, Topp E. 2013. Human health risk assessment (HHRA) for environmental development and transfer of antibiotic resistance. Environ Health Perspect 121:993–1001; http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1206316

[1]  K. Mølbak,et al.  Adverse health events associated with antimicrobial drug resistance in Campylobacter species: a registry-based cohort study. , 2005, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[2]  Jianzhong Shen,et al.  Occurrence of chloramphenicol-resistance genes as environmental pollutants from swine feedlots. , 2013, Environmental science & technology.

[3]  W. van Schaik,et al.  A multiresistance megaplasmid pLG1 bearing a hylEfm genomic island in hospital Enterococcus faecium isolates. , 2011, International journal of medical microbiology : IJMM.

[4]  J. Jacobs,et al.  ESBL-Positive Enterobacteria Isolates in Drinking Water , 2012, Emerging infectious diseases.

[5]  Jianying Hu,et al.  Antibiotic-resistance profile in environmental bacteria isolated from penicillin production wastewater treatment plant and the receiving river. , 2009, Environmental microbiology.

[6]  Nicholas J Ashbolt,et al.  Assessing pathogen risk to swimmers at non-sewage impacted recreational beaches. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[7]  E. Topp,et al.  Management Options for Reducing the Release of Antibiotics and Antibiotic Resistance Genes to the Environment , 2013, Environmental health perspectives.

[8]  A. Havelaar,et al.  Risk profile on antimicrobial resistance transmissible from food animals to humans , 2010 .

[9]  Nicholas J Ashbolt,et al.  An in-premise model for Legionella exposure during showering events. , 2011, Water research.

[10]  Diarmaid Hughes,et al.  Antibiotic resistance and its cost: is it possible to reverse resistance? , 2010, Nature Reviews Microbiology.

[11]  S. McEwen.  Quantitative human health risk assessments of antimicrobial use in animals and selection of resistance: a review of publicly available reports. , 2012, Revue scientifique et technique.

[12]  Emma L Snary,et al.  Antimicrobial resistance: a microbial risk assessment perspective. , 2004, The Journal of antimicrobial chemotherapy.

[13]  T. Wassenaar,et al.  Re-analysis of the risks attributed to ciprofloxacin-resistant Campylobacter jejuni infections. , 2007, International journal of antimicrobial agents.

[14]  Ursula Obst,et al.  Detection of antibiotic-resistant bacteria and their resistance genes in wastewater, surface water, and drinking water biofilms. , 2003, FEMS microbiology ecology.

[15]  Mats Tysklind,et al.  Contamination of surface, ground, and drinking water from pharmaceutical production , 2009, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[16]  Hajo Grundmann,et al.  Mortality and Hospital Stay Associated with Resistant Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli Bacteremia: Estimating the Burden of Antibiotic Resistance in Europe , 2011, PLoS medicine.

[17]  G. Cambray,et al.  The SOS Response Controls Integron Recombination , 2009, Science.

[18]  Heather K. Allen,et al.  Functional metagenomics reveals diverse β-lactamases in a remote Alaskan soil , 2009, The ISME Journal.

[19]  G. Barker,et al.  Meta-Analysis of Experimental Data Concerning Antimicrobial Resistance Gene Transfer Rates during Conjugation , 2008, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[20]  J. E. Rogers,et al.  The Shared Antibiotic Resistome of Soil Bacteria and Human Pathogens , 2012 .

[21]  O. Nybroe,et al.  Cu exposure under field conditions coselects for antibiotic resistance as determined by a novel cultivation-independent bacterial community tolerance assay. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[22]  O. Nybroe,et al.  Increased pollution-induced bacterial community tolerance to sulfadiazine in soil hotspots amended with artificial root exudates. , 2009, Environmental science & technology.

[23]  E. Topp,et al.  Class 1 Integrons, Selected Virulence Genes, and Antibiotic Resistance in Escherichia coli Isolates from the Minjiang River, Fujian Province, China , 2010, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[24]  W. Abraham.  Megacities as Sources for Pathogenic Bacteria in Rivers and Their Fate Downstream , 2010, International journal of microbiology.

[25]  T. Hald,et al.  Assessing the differences in public health impact of salmonella subtypes using a bayesian microbial subtyping approach for source attribution. , 2010, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[26]  Division on Earth.  Risk Assessment in the Federal Government: Managing the Process , 1983 .

[27]  K. Travers,et al.  Morbidity of infections caused by antimicrobial-resistant bacteria. , 2002, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[28]  C N Haas,et al.  A risk assessment framework for the evaluation of skin infections and the potential impact of antibacterial soap washing. , 1999, American journal of infection control.

[29]  A. Boxall,et al.  Impacts of anthropogenic activity on the ecology of class 1 integrons and integron-associated genes in the environment , 2011, The ISME Journal.

[30]  G. B. Golding,et al.  Antibiotic resistance is ancient , 2011, Nature.

[31]  E. Kristiansson,et al.  Pyrosequencing of Antibiotic-Contaminated River Sediments Reveals High Levels of Resistance and Gene Transfer Elements , 2011, PloS one.

[32]  D. Vose,et al.  Framework for Microbial Food‐Safety Risk Assessments Amenable to Bayesian Modeling , 2011, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[33]  I. Xagoraraki,et al.  Correlation of tetracycline and sulfonamide antibiotics with corresponding resistance genes and resistant bacteria in a conventional municipal wastewater treatment plant. , 2012, The Science of the total environment.

[34]  Dominic L Boccelli,et al.  Development of a neural-based forecasting tool to classify recreational water quality using fecal indicator organisms. , 2012, Water research.

[35]  M. Florek,et al.  CTX-M-15-producing Escherichia coli clone B2-O25b-ST131 and Klebsiella spp. isolates in municipal wastewater treatment plant effluents. , 2011, The Journal of antimicrobial chemotherapy.

[36]  Jin Wang,et al.  Modified failure mode and effects analysis using approximate reasoning , 2003, Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf..

[37]  Aamir Fazil,et al.  A Multifactorial Risk Prioritization Framework for Foodborne Pathogens , 2010, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[38]  K. Kümmerer.  Antibiotics in the aquatic environment--a review--part II. , 2009, Chemosphere.

[39]  C. Soumet,et al.  Resistance to phenicol compounds following adaptation to quaternary ammonium compounds in Escherichia coli. , 2012, Veterinary microbiology.

[40]  Ramanan Laxminarayan,et al.  A framework for global surveillance of antibiotic resistance. , 2011, Drug resistance updates : reviews and commentaries in antimicrobial and anticancer chemotherapy.

[41]  M. Barza.  Potential mechanisms of increased disease in humans from antimicrobial resistance in food animals. , 2002, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[42]  D. Larsson,et al.  Effluent from drug manufactures contains extremely high levels of pharmaceuticals. , 2007, Journal of hazardous materials.

[43]  José A. Oliveira,et al.  Multiresistance, beta‐lactamase‐encoding genes and bacterial diversity in hospital wastewater in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil , 2011, Journal of applied microbiology.

[44]  Louise Swift,et al.  Wildlife Trade and the Emergence of Infectious Diseases , 2007, EcoHealth.

[45]  D. Daffonchio,et al.  Visual Evidence of Horizontal Gene Transfer between Plants and Bacteria in the Phytosphere of Transplastomic Tobacco , 2009, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[46]  L. Piddock,et al.  Persistence of Transferable Extended-Spectrum-β-Lactamase Resistance in the Absence of Antibiotic Pressure , 2012, Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy.

[47]  C. Gerba,et al.  Risk assessment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in water. , 2009, Reviews of environmental contamination and toxicology.

[48]  N. Neumann,et al.  The role of drinking water in the transmission of antimicrobial-resistant E. coli , 2011, Epidemiology and Infection.

[49]  Michiel Rutgers,et al.  Integration of bioavailability, ecology and ecotoxicology by three lines of evidence into ecological risk indexes for contaminated soil assessment. , 2008, The Science of the total environment.

[50]  Luca Vezzaro,et al.  Comparison of different uncertainty techniques in urban stormwater quantity and quality modelling. , 2012, Water research.

[51]  D. Andersson,et al.  Persistence of antibiotic resistance in bacterial populations. , 2011, FEMS microbiology reviews.

[52]  Edward Topp,et al.  The scourge of antibiotic resistance: the important role of the environment. , 2013, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[53]  K. Mølbak,et al.  Quinolone resistance is associated with increased risk of invasive illness or death during infection with Salmonella serotype Typhimurium. , 2004, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[54]  Evers Eg,et al.  Campylobacter source attribution by exposure assessment , 2008 .

[55]  C. Baker-Austin,et al.  Aquatic systems: maintaining, mixing and mobilising antimicrobial resistance? , 2011, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[56]  Arti Kapi.  The evolving threat of antimicrobial resistance: Options for action , 2014 .

[57]  M. Evans,et al.  Short-term and medium-term clinical outcomes of quinolone-resistant Campylobacter infection. , 2009, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[58]  Buchang Zhang,et al.  Nanoalumina promotes the horizontal transfer of multiresistance genes mediated by plasmids across genera , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[59]  S. Koike,et al.  Fate and transport of antibiotic residues and antibiotic resistance genes following land application of manure waste. , 2009, Journal of environmental quality.

[60]  M. Ackermann,et al.  Second messenger signalling governs Escherichia coli biofilm induction upon ribosomal stress , 2009, Molecular microbiology.

[61]  H. Sørum,et al.  Prevalence of antibiotic resistance genes in the bacterial flora of integrated fish farming environments of Pakistan and Tanzania. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[62]  Linus Sandegren,et al.  Selection of Resistant Bacteria at Very Low Antibiotic Concentrations , 2011, PLoS pathogens.

[63]  Aaron I. Packman,et al.  Transport and Fate of Microbial Pathogens in Agricultural Settings , 2013 .

[64]  R. Balasubramanian,et al.  Influence of Air Quality on the Composition of Microbial Pathogens in Fresh Rainwater , 2012, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[65]  J. Rose,et al.  Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment , 1999 .

[66]  S. Levy,et al.  Antibacterial resistance worldwide: causes, challenges and responses , 2004, Nature Medicine.

[67]  Klaus Kümmerer,et al.  Antibiotics in the aquatic environment--a review--part I. , 2009, Chemosphere.

[68]  Dong Li,et al.  Antibiotic Resistance Characteristics of Environmental Bacteria from an Oxytetracycline Production Wastewater Treatment Plant and the Receiving River , 2010, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[69]  Joo-Hyon Kang,et al.  Distribution of antibiotic resistance in urban watershed in Japan. , 2012, Environmental pollution.

[70]  A Fazil,et al.  Choices, choices: the application of multi-criteria decision analysis to a food safety decision-making problem. , 2008, Journal of food protection.

[71]  E Ferguson,et al.  From comparative risk assessment to multi-criteria decision analysis and adaptive management: recent developments and applications. , 2006, Environment international.

[72]  Annette Davison,et al.  Water safety plan manual: Step-by-step risk management for drinking-water suppliers. , 2009 .

[73]  Judith Rousseau,et al.  Quantitative Risk Assessment from Farm to Fork and Beyond: A Global Bayesian Approach Concerning Food‐Borne Diseases , 2008, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[74]  Mark W. LeChevallier,et al.  A conceptual framework to assess the risks of human disease following exposure to pathogens. ILSI Risk Science Institute Pathogen Risk Assessment Working Group. , 1996, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[75]  E. Cooper,et al.  Preliminary risk assessment database and risk ranking of pharmaceuticals in the environment. , 2008, The Science of the total environment.

[76]  D. Cummings,et al.  Broad dissemination of plasmid-mediated quinolone resistance genes in sediments of two urban coastal wetlands. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[77]  Judit Lienert,et al.  Multiple-criteria decision analysis reveals high stakeholder preference to remove pharmaceuticals from hospital wastewater. , 2011, Environmental science & technology.

[78]  Timothy A. Johnson,et al.  Diverse and abundant antibiotic resistance genes in Chinese swine farms , 2013, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[79]  Antoinette Ludwig,et al.  Identifying associations in Escherichia coli antimicrobial resistance patterns using additive Bayesian networks. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[80]  A. Matussek,et al.  Quantification of genes encoding resistance to aminoglycosides, 𝛃-lactams and tetracyclines in wastewater environments by real-time PCR , 2009, International journal of environmental health research.

[81]  C. Manaia,et al.  Diversity and Antibiotic Resistance Patterns of Sphingomonadaceae Isolates from Drinking Water , 2011, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[82]  Stefan Wuertz,et al.  Studying plasmid horizontal transfer in situ: a critical review , 2005, Nature Reviews Microbiology.

[83]  C. Knapp,et al.  Antibiotic Resistance Gene Abundances Correlate with Metal and Geochemical Conditions in Archived Scottish Soils , 2011, PloS one.

[84]  M. Gillings,et al.  Are humans increasing bacterial evolvability? , 2012, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[85]  PRINCIPLES AND GUIDELINES FOR THE CONDUCT OF MICROBIOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT CAC/GL-30 (1999) , 2001 .

[86]  C. Nakamura,et al.  Characterisation of potential virulence markers in Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from drinking water , 2008, Antonie van Leeuwenhoek.

[87]  Mary E. Wilson,et al.  NDM-1 and the Role of Travel in Its Dissemination , 2012, Current Infectious Disease Reports.

[88]  E. Cytryn,et al.  The soil resistome: The anthropogenic, the native, and the unknown , 2013 .

[89]  T. C. Ngo,et al.  blaNDM-1–positive Klebsiella pneumoniae from Environment, Vietnam , 2012, Emerging infectious diseases.

[90]  Ord,et al.  Microbial Risk Assessment Guideline: Pathogenic Microorganisms with Focus on Food and Water , 2013 .

[91]  Tong Zhang,et al.  Metagenomic insights into chlorination effects on microbial antibiotic resistance in drinking water. , 2013, Water Research.

[92]  Mi-Hyun Park,et al.  The modified SWAT model for predicting fecal coliforms in the Wachusett Reservoir Watershed, USA. , 2012, Water Research.

[93]  K. Manoylov,et al.  Positive and negative selection towards tetracycline resistance genes in manure treatment lagoons , 2012, Journal of applied microbiology.