Psychotherapy for depression in adults: a meta-analysis of comparative outcome studies.

Although the subject has been debated and examined for more than 3 decades, it is still not clear whether all psychotherapies are equally efficacious. The authors conducted 7 meta-analyses (with a total of 53 studies) in which 7 major types of psychological treatment for mild to moderate adult depression (cognitive-behavior therapy, nondirective supportive treatment, behavioral activation treatment, psychodynamic treatment, problem-solving therapy, interpersonal psychotherapy, and social skills training) were directly compared with other psychological treatments. Each major type of treatment had been examined in at least 5 randomized comparative trials. There was no indication that 1 of the treatments was more or less efficacious, with the exception of interpersonal psychotherapy (which was somewhat more efficacious; d = 0.20) and nondirective supportive treatment (which was somewhat less efficacious than the other treatments; d = -0.13). The drop-out rate was significantly higher in cognitive-behavior therapy than in the other therapies, whereas it was significantly lower in problem-solving therapy. This study suggests that there are no large differences in efficacy between the major psychotherapies for mild to moderate depression.

[1]  G. Andersson,et al.  Psychological treatment of depression: A meta-analytic database of randomized studies , 2008, BMC psychiatry.

[2]  P. Cuijpers,et al.  Characteristics of effective psychological treatments of depression: a metaregression analysis , 2008, Psychotherapy research : journal of the Society for Psychotherapy Research.

[3]  D. Chambless,et al.  Specificity of treatment effects: cognitive therapy and relaxation for generalized anxiety and panic disorders. , 2007, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[4]  Joseph P. McFall,et al.  What are the active ingredients in cognitive and behavioral psychotherapy for anxious and depressed children? A meta-analytic review. , 2007, Clinical psychology review.

[5]  R. Bagby,et al.  Attachment as moderator of treatment outcome in major depression: a randomized control trial of interpersonal psychotherapy versus cognitive behavior therapy. , 2006, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[6]  David C. Atkins,et al.  Randomized trial of behavioral activation, cognitive therapy, and antidepressant medication in the acute treatment of adults with major depression. , 2006, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[7]  M. Klein,et al.  Self-system therapy as an intervention for self-regulatory dysfunction in depression: a randomized comparison with cognitive therapy. , 2006, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[8]  J. Markowitz,et al.  A comparative trial of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy for "pure" dysthymic patients. , 2005, Journal of affective disorders.

[9]  Carol M Woods,et al.  Publication bias in research synthesis: sensitivity analysis using a priori weight functions. , 2005, Psychological methods.

[10]  J. Milgrom,et al.  A randomized controlled trial of psychological interventions for postnatal depression. , 2005, The British journal of clinical psychology.

[11]  P. Cuijpers,et al.  Psychologische behandeling van depressie: een systematisch overzicht van meta-analyses, , 2005 .

[12]  P. Wilson,et al.  Comparative efficacy of behavioral and cognitive treatments of depression , 1983, Cognitive Therapy and Research.

[13]  W. Marshall,et al.  Experimental analysis of a cognitive-behavioral therapy for depression , 1977, Cognitive Therapy and Research.

[14]  G. Maina,et al.  Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Brief Dynamic and Supportive Therapy with Waiting List Condition in Minor Depressive Disorders , 2004, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics.

[15]  M. Hautzinger,et al.  Kognitive Verhaltenstherapie bei Depressionen im Klimakterium , 2004 .

[16]  R. Nagel,et al.  Telephone-Based Treatment for Family Practice Patients with Mild Depression , 2004, Psychological reports.

[17]  D. Altman,et al.  Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses , 2003, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[18]  P. Cooper,et al.  Controlled trial of the short- and long-term effect of psychological treatment of post-partum depression , 2003, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[19]  C. Moleiro,et al.  A comparison of the Dodo, EST, and ATI factors among comorbid stimulant-dependent, depressed patients , 2003 .

[20]  N. Tarrier,et al.  Maternal depression and child behaviour problems Randomised placebo-controlled trial of a cognitive ^ behavioural group intervention , 2003 .

[21]  P. Areán,et al.  Problem-solving therapy versus supportive therapy in geriatric major depression with executive dysfunction. , 2003, The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

[22]  K. Dobson,et al.  Cognitive therapy of depression: pretreatment patient predictors of outcome. , 2002, Clinical psychology review.

[23]  B. Wampold,et al.  A meta-(re)analysis of the effects of cognitive therapy versus 'other therapies' for depression. , 2002, Journal of affective disorders.

[24]  D. Mohr,et al.  Comparative outcomes for individual cognitive-behavior therapy, supportive-expressive group psychotherapy, and sertraline for the treatment of depression in multiple sclerosis. , 2001, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[25]  C. Dowrick,et al.  Problem solving treatment and group psychoeducation for depression: multicentre randomised controlled trial , 2000, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[26]  S Duval,et al.  Trim and Fill: A Simple Funnel‐Plot–Based Method of Testing and Adjusting for Publication Bias in Meta‐Analysis , 2000, Biometrics.

[27]  P. Bower,et al.  Randomised controlled trial of non-directive counselling, cognitive-behaviour therapy and usual general practitioner care in the management of depression as well as mixed anxiety and depression in primary care. , 2000, Health technology assessment.

[28]  Bright Ji,et al.  Professional and paraprofessional group treatments for depression: a comparison of cognitive-behavioral and mutual support interventions. , 1999 .

[29]  R. Neimeyer,et al.  Professional and paraprofessional group treatments for depression: a comparison of cognitive-behavioral and mutual support interventions. , 1999, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[30]  J. Markowitz,et al.  Treatment of depressive symptoms in human immunodeficiency virus-positive patients. , 1998, Archives of general psychiatry.

[31]  I. Blackburn,et al.  A meta-analysis of the effects of cognitive therapy in depressed patients. , 1998, Journal of affective disorders.

[32]  A. Kazdin Research design in clinical psychology, 3rd ed. , 1998 .

[33]  Jack L. Vevea,et al.  Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. , 1998 .

[34]  P. Cuijpers Minimising interventions in the treatment and prevention of depression. Taking the consequences of the 'Dodo Bird Verdict'. , 1998, Journal of mental health.

[35]  L. Teri,et al.  Behavioral treatment of depression in dementia patients: a controlled clinical trial. , 1997, The journals of gerontology. Series B, Psychological sciences and social sciences.

[36]  N. Jacobson,et al.  A component analysis of cognitive-behavioral treatment for depression. , 1996, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[37]  E. Gaffan,et al.  Researcher allegiance and meta-analysis: the case of cognitive therapy for depression. , 1995, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[38]  J. Markowitz,et al.  Individual psychotherapies for depressed HIV-positive patients. , 1995, The American journal of psychiatry.

[39]  R. Carney,et al.  Cognitive Behavior Therapy, Relaxation Training, and Tricyclic Antidepressant Medication in the Treatment of Depression , 1995, Psychological reports.

[40]  L. Luborsky Are common factors across different psychotherapies the main explanation for the Dodo Bird verdict that "Everyone has won so all shall have prizes"? , 1995 .

[41]  L. Mynors-Wallis,et al.  Randomised controlled trial comparing problem solving treatment with amitriptyline and placebo for major depression in primary care , 1995, BMJ.

[42]  Daniel Bowman,et al.  The Efficacy of Self-Examination Therapy and Cognitive Bibliotherapy in the Treatment of Mild to Moderate Depression , 1995 .

[43]  Richard T. Connis,et al.  Comparison of brief group therapies for depressed cancer patients receiving radiation treatment. , 1995, Public health reports.

[44]  R. Liberman,et al.  Behavioral group therapy. , 1994, Hospital & community psychiatry.

[45]  D. gallagher-Thompson,et al.  Comparative effects of cognitive-behavioral and brief psychodynamic psychotherapies for depressed family caregivers. , 1994, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[46]  P. Areán,et al.  Comparative effectiveness of social problem-solving therapy and reminiscence therapy as treatments for depression in older adults. , 1993, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[47]  L. Y. Stevenson,et al.  Outcome of cognitive-behavioral and support group brief therapies for depressed, HIV-infected persons. , 1993, The American journal of psychiatry.

[48]  W. Shadish,et al.  Mediators and moderators in meta-analysis: there's a reason we don't let dodo birds tell us which psychotherapies should have prizes. , 1991, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[49]  R. Daldrup,et al.  Predictors of differential response to cognitive, experiential, and self-directed psychotherapeutic procedures. , 1991, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[50]  R. Neimeyer,et al.  Psychotherapy for the treatment of depression: a comprehensive review of controlled outcome research. , 1990, Psychological bulletin.

[51]  Robert Rosenthal,et al.  How are we doing in soft psychology , 1990 .

[52]  P. Lachenbruch Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (2nd ed.) , 1989 .

[53]  S D Imber,et al.  National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. General effectiveness of treatments. , 1989, Archives of general psychiatry.

[54]  K. Dobson A meta-analysis of the efficacy of cognitive therapy for depression. , 1989, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[55]  R. Zettle,et al.  Group cognitive and contextual therapies in treatment of depression. , 1989, Journal of clinical psychology.

[56]  J. Deffenbacher,et al.  A comparison of cognitive and interpersonal-process group therapies in the treatment of depression among college students. , 1988 .

[57]  F. Wolf Meta-Analysis: Quantitative Methods for Research Synthesis , 1987 .

[58]  L. Thompson,et al.  Comparative effectiveness of psychotherapies for depressed elders. , 1987, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[59]  L. Covi,et al.  Cognitive behavioral group psychotherapy combined with imipramine in major depression. , 1987, Psychopharmacology bulletin.

[60]  S. Rude Relative benefits of assertion or cognitive self-control treatment for depression as a function of proficiency in each domain. , 1986, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[61]  A. Nezu Efficacy of a social problem-solving therapy approach for unipolar depression. , 1986, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[62]  H. Strupp,et al.  SPECIFIC AND NONSPECIFIC FACTORS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY: A PROBLEMATIC PARADIGM FOR PSYCHOTHERAPY RESEARCH , 1986 .

[63]  W. Stiles,et al.  "Are all psychotherapies equivalent?". , 1986, The American psychologist.

[64]  J. Horan,et al.  Attending to Experimental Construct Validity in the Evaluation of Cognitive and Behavioral Treatments for Depression. , 1985 .

[65]  L. Thompson,et al.  Efficacy of psychotherapy in the treatment of late-life depression , 1984 .

[66]  Donald B. Rubin,et al.  A Simple, General Purpose Display of Magnitude of Experimental Effect , 1982 .

[67]  L. Thompson,et al.  Treatment of major depressive disorder in older adult outpatients with brief psychotherapies. , 1982 .

[68]  P. Wilson,et al.  Combined pharmacological and behavioural treatment of depression. , 1982, Behaviour research and therapy.

[69]  M. Hersen,et al.  Social skills training compared with pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy in the treatment of unipolar depression. , 1981, The American journal of psychiatry.

[70]  L. Comas-Díaz Effects of cognitive and behavioral group treatment on the depressive symptomatology of Puerto Rican women. , 1981, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[71]  Lillian Comas-D az,et al.  Effects of cognitive and behavioral group treatment on the depressive symptomatology of Puerto Rican women. , 1981, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[72]  T. Oei,et al.  Depression and self-esteem: an investigation that used behavioral and cognitive approaches to the treatment of clinically depressed clients. , 1981, Journal of clinical psychology.

[73]  Alan E. Kazdin,et al.  Research Design in Clinical Psychology , 2021 .

[74]  D. Thornton,et al.  Coping skills training as a component in the short-term treatment of depression. , 1980, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[75]  P. Lewinsohn,et al.  Assertion training: effectiveness in the treatment of depression. , 1980, Journal of clinical psychology.

[76]  D. Rimm,et al.  Cognitive, assertive, and insight-oriented group therapies in the treatment of reactive depression in women. , 1980 .

[77]  Gene V. Glass,et al.  The benefits of psychotherapy , 1980 .

[78]  M. Kovács Cognitive therapy in depression. , 1980, The Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis.

[79]  A. Hakstian,et al.  Clinical depression: comparative efficacy of outpatient treatments. , 1979, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[80]  P. Lewinsohn,et al.  Nonspecific improvement effects in depression using interpersonal skills training, pleasant activity schedules, or cognitive training. , 1979, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.

[81]  M. L. Smith,et al.  Meta-analysis of psychotherapy outcome studies. , 1977, The American psychologist.

[82]  B. Shaw Comparison of cognitive therapy and behavior therapy in the treatment of depression. , 1977, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[83]  L. Rehm,et al.  A self-control behavior therapy program for depression. , 1977, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[84]  Marianne Padfield The Comparative Effects of Two Counseling Approaches on the Intensity of Depression Among Rural Women of Low Socioeconomic Status. , 1976 .

[85]  L Luborsky,et al.  Comparative studies of psychotherapies: is it true that "everybody has won and all must have prizes"? , 1975, Proceedings of the annual meeting of the American Psychopathological Association.

[86]  P. Davidson,et al.  The Behavioral management of anxiety, depression, and pain , 1976 .

[87]  C. Rogers On Becoming a Person: A Therapist's View of Psychotherapy , 1961 .