Applications of artificial neural networks in health care organizational decision-making: A scoping review

Health care organizations are leveraging machine-learning techniques, such as artificial neural networks (ANN), to improve delivery of care at a reduced cost. Applications of ANN to diagnosis are well-known; however, ANN are increasingly used to inform health care management decisions. We provide a seminal review of the applications of ANN to health care organizational decision-making. We screened 3,397 articles from six databases with coverage of Health Administration, Computer Science and Business Administration. We extracted study characteristics, aim, methodology and context (including level of analysis) from 80 articles meeting inclusion criteria. Articles were published from 1997–2018 and originated from 24 countries, with a plurality of papers (26 articles) published by authors from the United States. Types of ANN used included ANN (36 articles), feed-forward networks (25 articles), or hybrid models (23 articles); reported accuracy varied from 50% to 100%. The majority of ANN informed decision-making at the micro level (61 articles), between patients and health care providers. Fewer ANN were deployed for intra-organizational (meso- level, 29 articles) and system, policy or inter-organizational (macro- level, 10 articles) decision-making. Our review identifies key characteristics and drivers for market uptake of ANN for health care organizational decision-making to guide further adoption of this technique.

[1]  V. Ranjani,et al.  Data Mining Applications In Healthcare Sector: A Study , 2013 .

[2]  Asil Oztekin,et al.  An Analytical Approach to Predict the Performance of Thoracic Transplantations , 2012 .

[3]  Joarder Kamruzzaman,et al.  Neural Networks in Healthcare: Potential and Challenges , 2006 .

[4]  N. Ch. Sriman Narayana Iyengar,et al.  Optimal feature selection using a modified differential evolution algorithm and its effectiveness for prediction of heart disease , 2017, Comput. Biol. Medicine.

[5]  Michele Molinari,et al.  Levels in Decision Making and Techniques for Clinicians , 2015 .

[6]  Necdet Süt,et al.  Assessment of the performances of multilayer perceptron neural networks in comparison with recurrent neural networks and two statistical methods for diagnosing coronary artery disease , 2007, Expert Syst. J. Knowl. Eng..

[7]  Hong Qiao,et al.  Comparing data mining methods with logistic regression in childhood obesity prediction , 2009, Inf. Syst. Frontiers.

[8]  Dursun Delen,et al.  A comparative analysis of machine learning methods for classification type decision problems in healthcare , 2014, Decis. Anal..

[9]  G. Peter Zhang,et al.  The Effect of Misclassification Costs on Neural Network Classifiers , 1999 .

[10]  Rebecca Henderson,et al.  The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Innovation , 2018, The Economics of Artificial Intelligence.

[11]  Fatimah Ibrahim,et al.  Non-invasive diagnosis of risk in dengue patients using bioelectrical impedance analysis and artificial neural network , 2010, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[12]  P. Snow,et al.  Artificial neural networks: current status in cardiovascular medicine. , 1996, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[13]  Simon Fong,et al.  Applying a hybrid model of neural network and decision tree classifier for predicting university admission , 2009, 2009 7th International Conference on Information, Communications and Signal Processing (ICICS).

[14]  Tom M. Mitchell,et al.  Machine Learning and Data Mining , 2012 .

[15]  Mary Malliaris,et al.  Revenue Generation in Hospital Foundations: Neural Network versus Regression Model Recommendations , 2011, DMIN.

[16]  Bin Huang,et al.  Opening the black box of neural networks: methods for interpreting neural network models in clinical applications. , 2018, Annals of translational medicine.

[17]  Ritu Agarwal,et al.  The Digitization of Healthcare: Boundary Risks, Emotion, and Consumer Willingness to Disclose Personal Health Information , 2011, Inf. Syst. Res..

[18]  David W Young,et al.  Strategic decision-making in healthcare organizations: it is time to get serious. , 2006, The International journal of health planning and management.

[19]  Hsinchun Chen,et al.  Medical Data Mining on the Internet: Research on a Cancer Information System , 1999, Artificial Intelligence Review.

[20]  Héctor Mesa,et al.  A hybrid learning approach to tissue recognition in wound images , 2009, Int. J. Intell. Comput. Cybern..

[21]  Geoffrey E. Hinton,et al.  Learning representations by back-propagating errors , 1986, Nature.

[22]  Matthew Chalmers,et al.  Shakra: Tracking and Sharing Daily Activity Levels with Unaugmented Mobile Phones , 2007, Mob. Networks Appl..

[23]  Jimeng Sun,et al.  Opportunities and challenges in developing deep learning models using electronic health records data: a systematic review , 2018, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[24]  Michal Tkác,et al.  Artificial neural networks in business: Two decades of research , 2016, Appl. Soft Comput..

[25]  Matthew Belmonte,et al.  Prediction of attention in autism from single-trial EEG using artificial neural networks , 1997, SIGB.

[26]  Mollie E. Brooks,et al.  Generalized linear mixed models: a practical guide for ecology and evolution. , 2009, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[27]  Kwai-Sang Chin,et al.  Modeling daily patient arrivals at Emergency Department and quantifying the relative importance of contributing variables using artificial neural network , 2013, Decis. Support Syst..

[28]  Chang W. Lee,et al.  Assessment of HIV/AIDS-related health performance using an artificial neural network , 2001, Inf. Manag..

[29]  Simon Davies,et al.  Data Mining Medical Information: Should Artificial Neural Networks Be Used to Analyse Trauma Audit Data? , 2006, Int. J. Heal. Inf. Syst. Informatics.

[30]  Valérie Bourdès,et al.  Prediction of persistence of combined evidence-based cardiovascular medications in patients with acute coronary syndrome after hospital discharge using neural networks , 2011, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[31]  Massimo Buscema,et al.  The concept of individual semantic maps in clinical psychology: a feasibility study on a new paradigm , 2014 .

[32]  Adam Wright,et al.  What Workforce is Needed to Implement the Health Information Technology Agenda? Analysis from the HIMSS Analytics™ Database , 2008, AMIA.

[33]  J V Tu,et al.  Advantages and disadvantages of using artificial neural networks versus logistic regression for predicting medical outcomes. , 1996, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[34]  Bo K. Wong,et al.  Neural network applications in business: A review and analysis of the literature (1988-1995) , 1997, Decis. Support Syst..

[35]  Holly Jordan Lanham,et al.  Implications of complex adaptive systems theory for the design of research on health care organizations , 2009, Health care management review.

[36]  Nilanjan Dey,et al.  Effect of fuzzy partitioning in Crohn’s disease classification: a neuro-fuzzy-based approach , 2016, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[37]  Nagesh Shukla,et al.  Applying a Novel Combination of Techniques to Develop a Predictive Model for Diabetes Complications , 2015, PloS one.

[38]  John A McPherson,et al.  Routine intraoperative completion angiography after coronary artery bypass grafting and 1-stop hybrid revascularization results from a fully integrated hybrid catheterization laboratory/operating room. , 2009, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[39]  T. Ploetz,et al.  Unsupervised home monitoring of Parkinson's disease motor symptoms using body-worn accelerometers. , 2016, Parkinsonism & related disorders.

[40]  Grantham Pang,et al.  A prediction model of blood pressure for telemedicine , 2018, Health Informatics J..

[41]  A. Lymberis,et al.  Smart wearables for remote health monitoring, from prevention to rehabilitation: current R&D, future challenges , 2003, 4th International IEEE EMBS Special Topic Conference on Information Technology Applications in Biomedicine, 2003..

[42]  Stephan Kudyba,et al.  Identifying factors that impact patient length of stay metrics for healthcare providers with advanced analytics , 2010, Health Informatics J..

[43]  Holger R. Maier,et al.  Data splitting for artificial neural networks using SOM-based stratified sampling , 2010, Neural Networks.

[44]  Stefan Wermter,et al.  Hybrid neural systems: from simple coupling to fully integrated neural networks , 1999 .

[45]  Jeanette Nolting.  Developing a Neural Network Model for Health Care , 2006, AMIA.

[46]  Javier Bajo,et al.  Integrating case-based planning and RPTW neural networks to construct an intelligent environment for health care , 2009, Expert Syst. Appl..

[47]  Khairil Anuar Arshad,et al.  Artificial Neural Networks' Applications in Management , 2011 .

[48]  J. Nilsson,et al.  Artificial neural networks in pancreatic disease , 2008, The British journal of surgery.

[49]  Ivan Jordanov,et al.  An overview of the use of neural networks for data mining tasks , 2012, Wiley Interdiscip. Rev. Data Min. Knowl. Discov..

[50]  Giulia Massini,et al.  The perception of corruption in health: AutoCM methods for an international comparison , 2017 .

[51]  Geoffrey E. Hinton,et al.  ImageNet classification with deep convolutional neural networks , 2012, Commun. ACM.

[52]  Michele Piana,et al.  A Hybrid Supervised/Unsupervised Machine Learning Approach to Solar Flare Prediction , 2017, ArXiv.

[53]  Leopoldo C. Cancio,et al.  Development and validation of a machine learning algorithm and hybrid system to predict the need for life-saving interventions in trauma patients , 2013, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[54]  Paul Rubel,et al.  Ambient Intelligence and Pervasive Architecture Designed within the EPI-MEDICS Personal ECG Monitor , 2008, Int. J. Heal. Inf. Syst. Informatics.

[55]  Abbas Sheikhtaheri,et al.  Developing and Using Expert Systems and Neural Networks in Medicine: A Review on Benefits and Challenges , 2014, Journal of Medical Systems.

[56]  J P Shepherd,et al.  treatment planning: A controlled trial of three referral methods for patients with third molars. , 2000, British Dental Journal.

[57]  Samee Ullah Khan,et al.  A survey on context-aware recommender systems based on computational intelligence techniques , 2015, Computing.

[58]  Nils J. Nilsson,et al.  Artificial Intelligence , 1974, IFIP Congress.

[59]  Kurt Hornik,et al.  Approximation capabilities of multilayer feedforward networks , 1991, Neural Networks.

[60]  R. Gatchel,et al.  A decision-making framework for adaptive pain management , 2013, Health Care Management Science.

[61]  Z. Reitermanová.  Data Splitting , 2010 .

[62]  Peter Szolovits,et al.  The coming of age of artificial intelligence in medicine , 2009, Artif. Intell. Medicine.

[63]  Martin J. Liu,et al.  Predicting RFID adoption in healthcare supply chain from the perspectives of users , 2015 .

[64]  Paulo J. G. Lisboa,et al.  The Use of Artificial Neural Networks in Decision Support in Cancer: a Systematic Review , 2005 .

[65]  S. Agatonovic-Kustrin,et al.  Basic concepts of artificial neural network (ANN) modeling and its application in pharmaceutical research. , 2000, Journal of pharmaceutical and biomedical analysis.

[66]  Jiawei Han,et al.  Data Mining: Concepts and Techniques , 2000 .

[67]  P. Plsek,et al.  The challenge of complexity in health care , 2001, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[68]  Adeola Awowale.  Decision Making in Healthcare Systems: Roles and Responsibilities , 2017 .

[69]  B. Samanta,et al.  Automated diagnosis of cardiac state in healthcare systems using computational intelligence , 2008 .

[70]  Payam Saadat.  A Complex Adaptive Systems Perspective to Appreciative Inquiry , 2015 .

[71]  Jitendra V. Singh.  Performance, Slack, and Risk Taking in Organizational Decision Making , 1986 .

[72]  Igor Kononenko,et al.  Machine learning for medical diagnosis: history, state of the art and perspective , 2001, Artif. Intell. Medicine.

[73]  Yee Whye Teh,et al.  A Fast Learning Algorithm for Deep Belief Nets , 2006, Neural Computation.

[74]  Bo K. Wong,et al.  Neural network applications in finance: A review and analysis of literature (1990-1996) , 1998, Inf. Manag..

[75]  Joachim Diederich,et al.  The truth will come to light: directions and challenges in extracting the knowledge embedded within trained artificial neural networks , 1998, IEEE Trans. Neural Networks.

[76]  Ke Zhang,et al.  Characteristics of Good Clinical Educators from Medical Students' Perspectives: A Qualitative Inquiry using a Web-Based Survey System , 2008, Int. J. Heal. Inf. Syst. Informatics.

[77]  W Penny,et al.  Neural Networks in Clinical Medicine , 1996, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[78]  Brijesh Verma,et al.  Hybrid ensemble approach for classification , 2011, Applied Intelligence.

[79]  Mukta Paliwal,et al.  Neural networks and statistical techniques: A review of applications , 2009, Expert Syst. Appl..

[80]  T. Murdoch,et al.  The inevitable application of big data to health care. , 2013, JAMA.

[81]  Nilmini Wickramasinghe,et al.  Artificial Neural Network Excellence to Facilitate Lean Thinking Adoption in Healthcare Contexts , 2014 .

[82]  Olabode Olatubosun,et al.  Diabetes Diagnosis with Maximum Covariance Weighted Resilience Back Propagation Procedure , 2015 .

[83]  Ivan Nunes da Silva,et al.  Artificial Neural Network Architectures and Training Processes , 2017 .

[84]  W S McCulloch,et al.  A logical calculus of the ideas immanent in nervous activity , 1990, The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence.

[85]  Payam Hanafizadeh,et al.  Neural Network-based Evaluation of the Effect of the Motivation of Hospital Employees on Patients' Satisfaction , 2010, Int. J. Heal. Inf. Syst. Informatics.

[86]  George Cybenko,et al.  Approximation by superpositions of a sigmoidal function , 1989, Math. Control. Signals Syst..

[87]  Craig Kuziemsky,et al.  Decision-making in healthcare as a complex adaptive system , 2016, Healthcare management forum.

[88]  João Luís Garcia Rosa,et al.  How an epileptic EEG segment, used as reference, can influence a cross-correlation classifier? , 2017, Applied Intelligence.

[89]  Harleen Kaur,et al.  Empirical Study on Applications of Data Mining Techniques in Healthcare , 2006 .

[90]  Lior Rokach,et al.  Data Mining And Knowledge Discovery Handbook , 2005 .

[91]  K. J. Dalton,et al.  Artificial neural networks for decision support in clinical medicine. , 1995, Annals of medicine.

[92]  Ligia Paina,et al.  Understanding pathways for scaling up health services through the lens of complex adaptive systems. , 2012, Health policy and planning.

[93]  Sujeet Kumar Sharma,et al.  Understanding and predicting the quality determinants of e-government services: A two-staged regression-neural network model , 2015 .

[94]  Haipeng Shen,et al.  Artificial intelligence in healthcare: past, present and future , 2017, Stroke and Vascular Neurology.

[95]  Rickmer Braren,et al.  [A primer on machine learning]. , 2019, Der Radiologe.

[96]  I. Cockburn,et al.  The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Innovation: An Exploratory Analysis , 2018 .

[97]  Mark John Somers,et al.  Neural Networks in Organizational Research: Applying Pattern Recognition to the Analysis of Organizational Behavior , 2006 .

[98]  Pedro Antonio Gutiérrez,et al.  Hybrid Artificial Neural Networks: Models, Algorithms and Data , 2011, IWANN.

[99]  Fábio Silva Aguiar,et al.  Development of two artificial neural network models to support the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in hospitalized patients in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil , 2016, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[100]  Purwanto,et al.  A dual hybrid forecasting model for support of decision making in healthcare management , 2012, Adv. Eng. Softw..

[101]  Yaling Yang,et al.  Integrating Neural Networks for Risk-Adjustment Models , 2008 .

[102]  Murat Kayri,et al.  Data Optimization with Multilayer Perceptron Neural Network and Using New Pattern in Decision Tree Comparatively , 2010 .

[103]  G. Vozikis,et al.  Improving Health Care Organizational Management Through Neural Network Learning , 2002, Health care management science.