On the experimental validation of model-based dose calculation algorithms for 192Ir HDR brachytherapy treatment planning

There is an acknowledged need for the design and implementation of physical phantoms appropriate for the experimental validation of model-based dose calculation algorithms (MBDCA) introduced recently in 192Ir brachytherapy treatment planning systems (TPS), and this work investigates whether it can be met. A PMMA phantom was prepared to accommodate material inhomogeneities (air and Teflon), four plastic brachytherapy catheters, as well as 84 LiF TLD dosimeters (MTS-100M 1  ×  1  ×  1 mm3 microcubes), two radiochromic films (Gafchromic EBT3) and a plastic 3D dosimeter (PRESAGE). An irradiation plan consisting of 53 source dwell positions was prepared on phantom CT images using a commercially available TPS and taking into account the calibration dose range of each detector. Irradiation was performed using an 192Ir high dose rate (HDR) source. Dose to medium in medium, [Formula: see text], was calculated using the MBDCA option of the same TPS as well as Monte Carlo (MC) simulation with the MCNP code and a benchmarked methodology. Measured and calculated dose distributions were spatially registered and compared. The total standard (k  =  1) spatial uncertainties for TLD, film and PRESAGE were: 0.71, 1.58 and 2.55 mm. Corresponding percentage total dosimetric uncertainties were: 5.4-6.4, 2.5-6.4 and 4.85, owing mainly to the absorbed dose sensitivity correction and the relative energy dependence correction (position dependent) for TLD, the film sensitivity calibration (dose dependent) and the dependencies of PRESAGE sensitivity. Results imply a LiF over-response due to a relative intrinsic energy dependence between 192Ir and megavoltage calibration energies, and a dose rate dependence of PRESAGE sensitivity at low dose rates (<1 Gy min-1). Calculations were experimentally validated within uncertainties except for MBDCA results for points in the phantom periphery and dose levels  <20%. Experimental MBDCA validation is laborious, yet feasible. Further work is required for the full characterization of dosimeter response for 192Ir and the reduction of experimental uncertainties.

[1]  Mark Oldham,et al.  A practical three-dimensional dosimetry system for radiation therapy. , 2006, Medical physics.

[2]  Mark J. Rivard,et al.  Overview on the dosimetric uncertainty analysis for photon-emitting brachytherapy sources, in the light of the AAPM Task Group No 138 and GEC-ESTRO report , 2012 .

[3]  W. Butler,et al.  Erratum: Update of AAPM Task Group No. 43 Report: A revised AAPM protocol for brachytherapy dose calculations (Medical Physics (2004) 31 (633-674)) , 2004 .

[4]  J. Williamson,et al.  Report of the Task Group 186 on model-based dose calculation methods in brachytherapy beyond the TG-43 formalism: current status and recommendations for clinical implementation. , 2012, Medical physics.

[5]  A. Micke,et al.  Multichannel film dosimetry with nonuniformity correction. , 2011, Medical physics.

[6]  T. Olding,et al.  Cone beam optical computed tomography for gel dosimetry I: scanner characterization , 2010, Physics in medicine and biology.

[7]  M. Oldham,et al.  Characterization of a new radiochromic three-dimensional dosimeter. , 2006, Medical physics.

[8]  Constantinos Loukas,et al.  A user-oriented procedure for the commissioning and quality assurance testing of treatment planning system dosimetry in high-dose-rate brachytherapy. , 2016, Brachytherapy.

[9]  Larry A DeWerd,et al.  Determination of exit skin dose for I192r intracavitary accelerated partial breast irradiation with thermoluminescent dosimeters. , 2010, Medical physics.

[10]  M. Maryanski,et al.  Characterisation of PRESAGE: A new 3-D radiochromic solid polymer dosemeter for ionising radiation. , 2006, Radiation protection dosimetry.

[11]  Andrew Nisbet,et al.  Design and implementation of a film dosimetry audit tool for comparison of planned and delivered dose distributions in high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy , 2013, Physics in medicine and biology.

[12]  E Pantelis,et al.  Current state of the art brachytherapy treatment planning dosimetry algorithms. , 2014, The British journal of radiology.

[13]  Eleftherios Pappas,et al.  BrachyGuide: a brachytherapy‐dedicated DICOM RT viewer and interface to Monte Carlo simulation software , 2015, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[14]  K. Shortt,et al.  The response of lif thermoluminescence dosemeters to photon beams in the energy range from 30 kV x rays to 60Co gamma rays. , 2003, Radiation protection dosimetry.

[15]  Luc Beaulieu,et al.  The collapsed cone algorithm for 192Ir dosimetry using phantom-size adaptive multiple-scatter point kernels , 2015, Physics in medicine and biology.

[16]  K. Zourari,et al.  PO-0970: Tissue segmentation significance for individualized 192Ir brachytherapy dosimetry , 2013 .

[17]  L. Dewerd,et al.  Development of a phantom to validate high-dose-rate brachytherapy treatment planning systems with heterogeneous algorithms. , 2015, Medical physics.

[18]  Mark Oldham,et al.  An investigation of the accuracy of an IMRT dose distribution using two- and three-dimensional dosimetry techniques. , 2008, Medical physics.

[19]  M. Oldham,et al.  On the feasibility of comprehensive high-resolution 3D remote dosimetry. , 2014, Medical physics.

[20]  J. Dempsey,et al.  Evaluation of the gamma dose distribution comparison method. , 2003, Medical physics.

[21]  J. Williamson,et al.  Monte Carlo-aided dosimetry of a new high dose-rate brachytherapy source. , 1998, Medical physics.

[22]  Influence of phantom material and dimensions on experimental 192Ir dosimetry. , 2009 .

[23]  Yunzhi Ma,et al.  Validation of the Oncentra Brachy Advanced Collapsed cone Engine for a commercial (192)Ir source using heterogeneous geometries. , 2015, Brachytherapy.

[24]  Jan Seuntjens,et al.  Radiochromic film dosimetry of HDR (192)Ir source radiation fields. , 2011, Medical physics.

[25]  K. Zourari,et al.  Dosimetric accuracy of a deterministic radiation transport based 192Ir brachytherapy treatment planning system. Part I: single sources and bounded homogeneous geometries. , 2010, Medical physics.

[26]  John S. Hendricks,et al.  Initial MCNP6 Release Overview , 2012 .

[27]  J. Williamson,et al.  Update of AAPM Task Group No. 43 Report: A revised AAPM protocol for brachytherapy dose calculations. , 2004 .

[28]  Andrew Nisbet,et al.  Verification of high dose rate brachytherapy dose distributions with EBT3 Gafchromic film quality control techniques , 2013, Physics in medicine and biology.

[29]  A multicentre 'end to end' dosimetry audit for cervix HDR brachytherapy treatment. , 2015, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[30]  C. Soares,et al.  Influence of phantom materials on the energy dependence of LiF:Mg,Ti thermoluminescent dosimeters exposed to 20–300 kV narrow x-ray spectra, 137Cs and 60Co photons , 2014, Physics in medicine and biology.

[31]  Larry A DeWerd,et al.  A dosimetric uncertainty analysis for photon-emitting brachytherapy sources: report of AAPM Task Group No. 138 and GEC-ESTRO. , 2011, Medical physics.

[32]  Y. De Deene,et al.  Radio-physical properties of micelle leucodye 3D integrating gel dosimeters , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[33]  E Pantelis,et al.  Dosimetric accuracy of a deterministic radiation transport based (192)Ir brachytherapy treatment planning system. Part III. Comparison to Monte Carlo simulation in voxelized anatomical computational models. , 2012, Medical physics.

[34]  J. Galvin,et al.  Radiochromic film dosimetry: recommendations of AAPM Radiation Therapy Committee Task Group 55. American Association of Physicists in Medicine. , 1998, Medical physics.

[35]  J. Seuntjens,et al.  Improving the energy response of external beam therapy (EBT) GafChromicTM dosimetry films at low energies (≤ 100 keV). , 2014, Medical physics.

[36]  L. Muren,et al.  Temperature dependence of the dose response for a solid-state radiochromic dosimeter during irradiation and storage. , 2011, Medical physics.

[37]  Ibrahim Khalil,et al.  A clinical decision-making mechanism for context-aware and patient-specific remote monitoring systems using the correlations of multiple vital signs , 2017, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[38]  L. Muren,et al.  Temperature and temporal dependence of the optical response for a radiochromic dosimeter. , 2012, Medical physics.

[39]  G. A. Carlsson,et al.  Response of LiF:Mg,Ti thermoluminescent dosimeters at photon energies relevant to the dosimetry of brachytherapy (<1 MeV). , 2011, Medical physics.

[40]  Firas Mourtada,et al.  Comparison of a finite-element multigroup discrete-ordinates code with Monte Carlo for radiotherapy calculations , 2006, Physics in medicine and biology.

[41]  M Mathot,et al.  Gafchromic film dosimetry: four years experience using FilmQA Pro software and Epson flatbed scanners. , 2014, Physica medica : PM : an international journal devoted to the applications of physics to medicine and biology : official journal of the Italian Association of Biomedical Physics.

[42]  Simon J. Doran.  How to perform an optical CT scan: an illustrated guide , 2013 .

[43]  A Nisbet,et al.  Comparison of methods for the measurement of radiation dose distributions in high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy: Ge-doped optical fiber, EBT3 Gafchromic film, and PRESAGE® radiochromic plastic. , 2013, Medical physics.

[44]  Tomas Kron,et al.  Dosimetry of ionising radiation in modern radiation oncology , 2016, Physics in medicine and biology.

[45]  M. J. Berger.  ESTAR, PSTAR, and ASTAR: Computer programs for calculating stopping-power and range tables for electrons, protons, and helium ions , 1992 .

[46]  Å. Carlsson Tedgren,et al.  Determination of absorbed dose to water around a clinical HDR (192)Ir source using LiF:Mg,Ti TLDs demonstrates an LET dependence of detector response. , 2012, Medical physics.

[47]  Jose Perez-Calatayud,et al.  Dose calculation for photon-emitting brachytherapy sources with average energy higher than 50 keV: report of the AAPM and ESTRO. , 2012, Medical physics.

[48]  Annette Haworth,et al.  A generic high-dose rate (192)Ir brachytherapy source for evaluation of model-based dose calculations beyond the TG-43 formalism. , 2015, Medical physics.

[49]  Åsa Carlsson Tedgren,et al.  Collapsed cone dose calculations for heterogeneous tissues in brachytherapy using primary and scatter separation source data , 2017, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[50]  E Pantelis,et al.  Dosimetric accuracy of a deterministic radiation transport based 192Ir brachytherapy treatment planning system. Part II: Monte Carlo and experimental verification of a multiple source dwell position plan employing a shielded applicator. , 2011, Medical physics.

[51]  H. Yoriyaz,et al.  Monte Carlo studies on water and LiF cavity properties for dose-reporting quantities when using x-ray and brachytherapy sources , 2016, Physics in medicine and biology.

[52]  D. Baltas,et al.  Experimental determination of the Task Group-43 dosimetric parameters of the new I25.S17plus (125)I brachytherapy source. , 2014, Brachytherapy.

[53]  M. Oldham,et al.  An investigation of PRESAGE® 3D dosimetry for IMRT and VMAT radiation therapy treatment verification , 2015, Physics in medicine and biology.

[54]  P. Vial,et al.  Radiological properties of the PRESAGE and PAGAT polymer dosimeters. , 2008, Applied radiation and isotopes : including data, instrumentation and methods for use in agriculture, industry and medicine.

[55]  M. Oldham,et al.  A comprehensive evaluation of the PRESAGE/optical-CT 3D dosimetry system. , 2008, Medical physics.

[56]  A basic dosimetric study of PRESAGE: the effect of different amounts of fabricating components on the sensitivity and stability of the dosimeter. , 2010, Physics in medicine and biology.

[57]  L A DeWerd,et al.  LiF:Mg,Ti TLD response as a function of photon energy for moderately filtered x-ray spectra in the range of 20-250 kVp relative to 60Co. , 2008, Medical physics.