Hybrid models as transdisciplinary research enablers

Modelling and simulation (M&S) techniques are frequently used in Operations Research (OR) to aid decision-making. With growing complexity of systems to be modelled, an increasing number of studies now apply multiple M&S techniques or hybrid simulation (HS) to represent the underlying system of interest. A parallel but related theme of research is extending the HS approach to include the development of hybrid models (HM). HM extends the M&S discipline by combining theories, methods and tools from across disciplines and applying multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary solutions to practice. In the broader OR literature, there are numerous examples of cross-disciplinary approaches in model development. However, within M&S, there is limited evidence of the application of conjoined methods for building HM. Where a stream of such research does exist, the integration of approaches is mostly at a technical level. In this paper, we argue that HM requires cross-disciplinary research engagement and a conceptual framework. The framework will enable the synthesis of discipline-specific methods and techniques, further cross-disciplinary research within the M&S community, and will serve as a transcending framework for the transdisciplinary alignment of M&S research with domain knowledge, hypotheses and theories from diverse disciplines. The framework will support the development of new composable HM methods, tools and applications. Although our framework is built around M&S literature, it is generally applicable to other disciplines, especially those with a computational element. The objective is to motivate a transdisciplinarity-enabling framework that supports the collaboration of research efforts from multiple disciplines, allowing them to grow into transdisciplinary research.

[1]  M. Polk Transdisciplinary co-production: Designing and testing a transdisciplinary research framework for societal problem solving , 2015 .

[2]  G. Heimeriks,et al.  Disciplinary, Multidisciplinary, Interdisciplinary: Concepts and Indicators. , 2001 .

[3]  Simon J. E. Taylor,et al.  A distributed simulation methodological framework for OR/MS applications , 2017, Simul. Model. Pract. Theory.

[4]  Valerie Belton,et al.  A toolkit of designs for mixing Discrete Event Simulation and System Dynamics , 2017, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[5]  B. Nicolescu,et al.  Methodology of Transdisciplinarity , 2014 .

[6]  Joachim Schummer,et al.  Multidisciplinarity, interdisciplinarity, and patterns of research collaboration in nanoscience and nanotechnology , 2004, Scientometrics.

[7]  Susan K. Gardner Paradigmatic differences, power, and status: a qualitative investigation of faculty in one interdisciplinary research collaboration on sustainability science , 2013, Sustainability Science.

[8]  Paul A. Fishwick,et al.  Handbook of Dynamic System Modeling , 2007 .

[9]  Andreas Tolk S-SIW-008-1-How is M & S Interoperability different from other Interoperability Domains ? , 2011 .

[10]  Mumtaz Karatas,et al.  Optimising the barrier coverage of a wireless sensor network with hub-and-spoke topology using mathematical and simulation models , 2019, Comput. Oper. Res..

[11]  A. Collin,et al.  Multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary, and transdisciplinary collaboration: implications for vocational psychology , 2009 .

[12]  J. George Shanthikumar,et al.  A Unifying View of Hybrid Simulation/Analytic Models and Modeling , 1983, Oper. Res..

[13]  Andreas Tolk,et al.  Multidisciplinary, Interdisciplinary, and Transdisciplinary Research , 2016 .

[14]  Duncan A. Robertson Agent-Based Models and Behavioral Operational Research , 2016 .

[15]  Loo Hay Lee,et al.  Simulation optimization in the era of Industrial 4.0 and the Industrial Internet , 2016, J. Simulation.

[16]  Thomas A. Finholt,et al.  NEESGRID: A DISTRIBUTED COLLABORATORY FOR ADVANCED EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING EXPERIMENT AND SIMULATION , 2004 .

[17]  Mamadou K. Traoré,et al.  Multi-Perspective Modeling and Holistic Simulation , 2019 .

[18]  Kevin W. Boyack,et al.  Approaches to understanding and measuring interdisciplinary scientific research (IDR): A review of the literature , 2011, J. Informetrics.

[19]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  An Application of Distributed Simulation for Hybrid Modeling of Offshore Wind Farms , 2015, SIGSIM-PADS.

[20]  Angela O'Mahony,et al.  Priority Challenges for Social and Behavioral Research and Its Modeling , 2018 .

[21]  Pieter J. Mosterman,et al.  Cyber-physical systems challenges: a needs analysis for collaborating embedded software systems , 2016, Software & Systems Modeling.

[22]  Suzanne Bakken,et al.  Defining interdisciplinary research: conclusions from a critical review of the literature. , 2007, Health services research.

[23]  Hamid Tohidi,et al.  Organizational learning and learning organization , 2012 .

[24]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  Facets of trust in simulation studies , 2021, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[25]  Sally C. Brailsford,et al.  Towards incorporating human behaviour in models of health care systems: An approach using discrete event simulation , 2003, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[26]  C. Whittaker,et al.  Report 9: Impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to reduce COVID19 mortality and healthcare demand , 2020 .

[27]  S. Eubank,et al.  Commentary on Ferguson, et al., “Impact of Non-pharmaceutical Interventions (NPIs) to Reduce COVID-19 Mortality and Healthcare Demand” , 2020, Bulletin of Mathematical Biology.

[28]  Richard E. Kopp,et al.  Combined analog-digital simulation , 1961, AFIPS '61 (Eastern).

[29]  Andreas Tolk,et al.  Reference modelling in support of M&S—foundations and applications , 2013, J. Simulation.

[30]  Audun Sandberg,et al.  Structuring wicked problems in transdisciplinary research using the Social–Ecological systems framework: An application to the montado system, Alentejo, Portugal , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[31]  Gregory Zacharewicz,et al.  Smackdown: Adventures in simulation standards and interoperability , 2011, Proceedings of the 2011 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[32]  David Simon,et al.  Crossing boundaries: complex systems, transdisciplinarity and applied impact agendas , 2015 .

[33]  R. Hiatt,et al.  The social determinants of cancer: a challenge for transdisciplinary science. , 2008, American journal of preventive medicine.

[34]  Richard M. Fujimoto,et al.  Parallel and distributed simulation , 1995, 2015 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[35]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  FROM HYBRID SIMULATION TO HYBRID SYSTEMS MODELLING , 2018, 2018 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[36]  Anne E. Trefethen,et al.  The UK e-Science Core Programme and the Grid , 2002, Future Gener. Comput. Syst..

[37]  Alois Ferscha,et al.  Parallel and Distributed Simulation , 1996, Proceedings of HICSS-29: 29th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences.

[38]  Tamas Kiss,et al.  Enabling Cloud-Based Computational Fluid Dynamics With a Platform-as-a-Service Solution , 2019, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics.

[39]  Eric W. K. Tsang Organizational Learning and the Learning Organization: A Dichotomy Between Descriptive and Prescriptive Research , 1997 .

[40]  John Mingers,et al.  Combining IS Research Methods: Towards a Pluralist Methodology , 2001, Inf. Syst. Res..

[41]  Wayne H. Wolf,et al.  Cyber-physical Systems , 2009, Computer.

[42]  Robert Stevens,et al.  e-Science and biological pathway semantics , 2007, BMC Bioinformatics.

[43]  Tobias Lorenz,et al.  Towards an orientation framework in multi-paradigm modeling Aligning purpose, object and methodology in System Dynamics, Agent-based Modeling and Discrete-Event-Simulation , 2006 .

[44]  Chen Feng,et al.  Conceptual Framework to Optimize Building Energy Consumption by Coupling Distributed Energy Simulation and Occupancy Models , 2014, J. Comput. Civ. Eng..

[45]  Anne E. Trefethen,et al.  e-Science and its implications , 2003, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

[46]  Kirsten Howard,et al.  A Synergistic Approach , 2008 .

[47]  Malin Mobjörk Consulting versus participatory transdisciplinarity: A refined classification of transdisciplinary research , 2010 .

[48]  Kathy Kotiadis,et al.  PartiSim: A multi-methodology framework to support facilitated simulation modelling in healthcare , 2015, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[49]  Bhakti S. S. Onggo,et al.  Approaching parallel computing to simulating population dynamics in demography , 2016, Parallel Comput..

[50]  A. Tiwari,et al.  Simulation to Enable a Data-Driven Circular Economy , 2019, Sustainability.

[51]  Stewart Robinson,et al.  Conceptual modelling: Knowledge acquisition and model abstraction , 2008, 2008 Winter Simulation Conference.

[52]  Gabriele D'Angelo,et al.  Simulation of the Internet of Things , 2016, 2016 International Conference on High Performance Computing & Simulation (HPCS).

[53]  Richard M. Weatherly,et al.  The aggregate level simulation protocol: an evolving system , 1994, Proceedings of Winter Simulation Conference.

[54]  John S. Edwards,et al.  Enhancing discrete-event simulation with big data analytics: A review , 2019, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[55]  Simon J. E. Taylor,et al.  Experiences in simplifying distributed simulation: The HLA development kit framework , 2017, J. Simulation.

[56]  Patrick T. Hester,et al.  Towards a theory of multi-method M&S approach: Part I , 2014, Proceedings of the Winter Simulation Conference 2014.

[57]  John Ladbrook,et al.  GRIDS-SCF: An Infrastructure for Distributed Supply Chain Simulation , 2002, Simul..

[58]  J. Klein Learning in Transdisciplinary Collaborations: A Conceptual Vocabulary , 2018 .

[59]  Arie Shoshani,et al.  The Earth System Grid: Supporting the Next Generation of Climate Modeling Research , 2005, Proceedings of the IEEE.

[60]  Lisa R. Lattuca Learning Interdisciplinarity: Sociocultural Perspectives on Academic Work , 2002 .

[61]  J. Klein Interdisciplinarity and Transdisciplinarity : Keyword Meanings for Collaboration Science and Translational Medicine , 2014 .

[62]  Edward Griffor,et al.  Framework for Cyber-Physical Systems: Volume 1, Overview , 2017 .

[63]  Rajkumar Buyya,et al.  iFogSim: A toolkit for modeling and simulation of resource management techniques in the Internet of Things, Edge and Fog computing environments , 2016, Softw. Pract. Exp..

[64]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  Exploiting grid computing, desktop grids and cloud computing for e‐science , 2010 .

[65]  Andreas Tolk,et al.  Purpose and benefits of hybrid simulation: Contributing to the convergence of its definition , 2017, 2017 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[66]  Stephen John Turner,et al.  Bridging the gap: A standards-based approach to OR/MS distributed simulation , 2012, TOMC.

[67]  Dorien J. DeTombe Complex Societal Problems in Operational Research , 2002, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[68]  Arnim Wiek,et al.  A transdisciplinary approach for formalized integrated planning and decision-making in complex systems , 2009, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[69]  Gabriele Bammer,et al.  Strengthening community operational research through exchange of tools and strategic alliances , 2017, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[70]  Boris V. Sokolov,et al.  A multi-structural framework for adaptive supply chain planning and operations control with structure dynamics considerations , 2010, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[71]  Ann Taket,et al.  Creative Problem Solving: Total Systems Intervention. , 1991 .

[72]  Simon J. E. Taylor,et al.  Comparing conventional and distributed approaches to simulation in a complex supply-chain health system , 2009, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[73]  Simon J. E. Taylor,et al.  Speeding up simulation applications using WinGrid , 2009, Concurr. Comput. Pract. Exp..

[74]  Carlos M. Lemos,et al.  Pitfalls in the Development of Agent-Based Models in Social Sciences: Avoiding Them and Learning from Them , 2019, New Approaches to the Scientific Study of Religion.

[75]  Ami Marowka,et al.  The GRID: Blueprint for a New Computing Infrastructure , 2000, Parallel Distributed Comput. Pract..

[76]  Bernard P. Zeigler,et al.  Theory of Modeling and Simulation: Discrete Event & Iterative System Computational Foundations , 2018 .

[77]  Andreas Tolk,et al.  Hybrid simulation studies and Hybrid Simulation systems: Definitions, challenges, and benefits , 2015, 2015 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[78]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  Analysing trade-offs in container loading: combining load plan construction heuristics with agent-based simulation , 2013, Int. Trans. Oper. Res..

[79]  Andreas Tolk,et al.  Human Simulation: Perspectives, Insights, and Applications , 2019, New Approaches to the Scientific Study of Religion.

[80]  Bob Jones,et al.  The Organization and Management of Grid Infrastructures , 2009, Computer.

[81]  Jeff Clanon Organizational transformation from the inside out: reinventing the MIT Center for Organizational Learning , 1999 .

[82]  J. McLeod,et al.  Interdisciplinary working in public health research: a proposed good practice checklist , 2018, Journal of public health.

[83]  Kai Helge Becker,et al.  An outlook on behavioural OR - Three tasks, three pitfalls, one definition , 2016, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[84]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  The fitness and survival of the OR profession in the age of artificial intelligence , 2020, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[86]  R. Lawrence Deciphering Interdisciplinary and Transdisciplinary Contributions , 2010 .

[87]  Kathleen E. Halvorsen,et al.  Managing the wicked problem of transdisciplinary team formation in socio-ecological systems , 2016 .

[88]  Simon J. E. Taylor,et al.  Speeding up simulation applications using WinGrid , 2009 .

[89]  Wai Kin Chan,et al.  On the modelling of transportation evacuation: an agent-based discrete-event hybrid-space approach , 2014, J. Simulation.

[90]  Bernard P. Zeigler,et al.  Theory of Modelling and Simulation , 1979, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics.

[91]  E. Yeh ‘How can experience of local residents be “knowledge”?’ Challenges in interdisciplinary climate change research , 2016 .

[92]  Martin Kunc,et al.  Strengthening the reporting of empirical simulation studies: Introducing the STRESS guidelines , 2019, J. Simulation.

[93]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  The transformation competence perspective , 2008, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[94]  D. C. Miller,et al.  SIMNET: the advent of simulator networking , 1995, Proc. IEEE.

[95]  Pieter J. Mosterman,et al.  Hybrid simulation for cyber physical systems: a panel on where are we going regarding complexity, intelligence, and adaptability of CPS using simulation , 2018, SpringSim.

[96]  Edwin Z. Crues,et al.  The Distributed Space Exploration Simulation (DSES) , 2007 .

[97]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  The logic and methods of OR consulting practice: towards a foundational view , 2018, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[98]  Robert L. Axtell,et al.  WHY AGENTS? ON THE VARIED MOTIVATIONS FOR AGENT COMPUTING IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES , 2000 .

[99]  Marko A. Hofmann,et al.  Epistemic and normative aspects of ontologies in modelling and simulation , 2011, J. Simulation.

[100]  Robert Fildes,et al.  Reassessing the scope of OR practice: The Influences of Problem Structuring Methods and the Analytics Movement , 2015, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[101]  Paul V. Stock,et al.  Defining Terms for Integrated (Multi-Inter-Trans-Disciplinary) Sustainability Research , 2011 .

[102]  M. Lamanna The LHC computing grid project at CERN , 2004 .

[103]  Ann van Ackere,et al.  Simulation and Laboratory Experiments: Exploring Self-Organizing Behavior in a Collective Choice Model , 2016 .

[104]  Fiona J. Newton,et al.  Approaching the wicked problem of obesity: an introduction to the food system compass , 2017 .

[105]  Richard E. Nance,et al.  A history of discrete event simulation programming languages , 1993, HOPL-II.

[106]  A. Tiwari,et al.  Digitisation and the Circular Economy: A Review of Current Research and Future Trends , 2018, Energies.

[107]  Bernard P. Zeigler,et al.  Theory of Modelling and Simulation , 1979, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics.

[108]  R. Nicholls,et al.  Large‐Scale Transdisciplinary Collaboration for Adaptation Research: Challenges and Insights , 2018, Global challenges.

[109]  Yaneer Bar-Yam,et al.  Opinion: What models can and cannot tell us about COVID-19 , 2020, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[110]  Bruce Edmonds,et al.  Computational Models That Matter During a Global Pandemic Outbreak: A Call to Action , 2020, J. Artif. Soc. Soc. Simul..

[111]  Katharina Burger,et al.  Developing a smart operational research with hybrid practice theories , 2019, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[112]  B. Feng,et al.  HYBRID MODELLING AND SIMULATION (M&S): DRIVING INNOVATION IN THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF M&S , 2020 .

[113]  Florian Jaehn Sustainable Operations , 2016, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[114]  Michael Lewis,et al.  Agent models I: UTSAF: a multi-agent-based framework for supporting military-based distributed interactive simulations in 3D virtual environments , 2003, WSC '03.

[115]  Fran Ackermann,et al.  Mixing OR methods in practice: Past, present and future directions , 2011, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[116]  Bhakti Stephan Onggo,et al.  Symbiotic Simulation System (S3) for Industry 4.0 , 2019, Springer Series in Advanced Manufacturing.

[117]  C. Binder,et al.  The reality of transdisciplinarity: a framework-based self-reflection from science and practice leaders , 2015, Sustainability Science.

[118]  Andreas Tolk,et al.  How is M&S Interoperability different from other Interoperability AUTHORS , 2012 .

[119]  Marcos Pereira Estellita Lins,et al.  Integrating soft and hard operational research to improve surgical centre management at a university hospital , 2015, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[120]  G. Nigel Gilbert,et al.  Simulation for the social scientist , 1999 .

[121]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  An investigation into modeling and simulation approaches for sustainable operations management , 2016, Simul..

[122]  D. Iliško,et al.  Sustainability from the Transdisciplinary Perspective: An Action Research Strategy for Continuing Education Program Development , 2016 .

[123]  Christos Vasilakis,et al.  A participative and facilitative conceptual modelling framework for discrete event simulation studies in healthcare , 2014, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[124]  C. Pohl,et al.  Ten reflective steps for rendering research societally relevant , 2017 .

[125]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  Widening requirements capture with soft methods: an investigation of hybrid M&S studies in health care , 2017, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[126]  Luis F. Luna-Reyes,et al.  Modeling and Simulation as Boundary Objects to Facilitate Interdisciplinary Research , 2018, Systems Research and Behavioral Science.

[127]  Daniel Teichroew,et al.  Computer simulation—discussion of the technique and comparison of languages , 1966, CACM.

[128]  Robert G. Batson The Modern Role of MS/OR Professionals in Interdisciplinary Teams , 1987 .

[129]  Stephen John Turner,et al.  A Service Oriented HLA RTI on the Grid , 2007, IEEE International Conference on Web Services (ICWS 2007).

[130]  Brian A. Nosek,et al.  Call for transparency of COVID-19 models , 2020, Science.

[131]  Imrich Chlamtac,et al.  Internet of things: Vision, applications and research challenges , 2012, Ad Hoc Networks.

[132]  Edward I. Powers,et al.  An Evaluation of the High Level Architecture (HLA) as a Framework for NASA Modeling and Simulation , 2000 .

[133]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  A hybrid approach using forecasting and discrete-event simulation for endoscopy services , 2017, 2017 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[134]  Ian Foster,et al.  The Grid 2 - Blueprint for a New Computing Infrastructure, Second Edition , 1998, The Grid 2, 2nd Edition.

[135]  Richard E. Nance,et al.  Hybrid Simulation: Historical lessons, present challenges and futures , 2016, 2016 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[136]  홍윤기,et al.  생산시스템 시뮬레이션을 위한 High Level Architecture/Run­Time Infrastructure의 적용 , 2000 .

[137]  María Haydeé,et al.  The Oxford Handbook of Interdisciplinarity , 2015 .

[138]  Bernard P. Zeigler,et al.  Theory of Modeling and Simulation: Integrating Discrete Event and Continuous Complex Dynamic Systems , 2000 .

[139]  Martin Kunc,et al.  Hybrid simulation modelling in operational research: A state-of-the-art review , 2019, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[140]  Csaba Attila Boer Distributed Simulation in Industry , 2005 .

[141]  M. Knight,et al.  Maturity model for advancing smart grid interoperability , 2013, 2013 IEEE PES Innovative Smart Grid Technologies Conference (ISGT).

[142]  Simon J. E. Taylor,et al.  Distributed simulation: state-of-the-art and potential for operational research , 2019, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[143]  Teresa Rebelo,et al.  Organizational learning and the learning organization: Reviewing evolution for prospecting the future , 2008 .

[144]  Geoff Royston,et al.  Operational Research for the Real World: big questions from a small island , 2013, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[145]  Petr Páta,et al.  THE GLOBAL ROBOTIC TELESCOPES INTELLIGENT ARRAY FOR E-SCIENCE (GLORIA) , 2014 .

[146]  Helen Gill,et al.  Cyber-Physical Systems , 2019, 2019 IEEE International Conference on Mechatronics (ICM).

[147]  F. LeRon Shults,et al.  Human Simulation: A Transdisciplinary Approach to Studying Societal Problems , 2019 .

[148]  C.J.H. Mann,et al.  Handbook of Dynamic System Modelling , 2008 .

[149]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  The pragmatic logic of OR consulting practice: Towards a foundational view , 2020, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[150]  John W. Fowler,et al.  How simulation modelling can help reduce the impact of COVID-19 , 2020, J. Simulation.

[151]  John Mingers,et al.  Multimethodology: Towards a framework for mixing methodologies , 1997 .

[152]  Navonil Mustafee,et al.  Broadening Participation in Modelling , 2019, 2019 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[153]  Ian T. Foster The Anatomy of the Grid: Enabling Scalable Virtual Organizations , 2001, Euro-Par.

[154]  Steffen Straßburger,et al.  Migration of HLA into Civil Domains: Solutions and Prototypes for Transportation Applications , 1999, Simul..