Physicians' survival predictions for patients with acute congestive heart failure.

BACKGROUND Current guidelines suggest that patients with low likelihoods of survival may be excluded from intensive care. Patients with new or exacerbated congestive heart failure are frequently but not inevitably admitted to critical care units. OBJECTIVE To assess how well physicians could predict the probability of survival for acutely ill patients with congestive heart failure, and in particular how well they could identify patients with small chances of survival. METHODS This was a prospective cohort study done in the emergency departments of a university hospital, a Veterans Affairs medical center, and a community hospital. The study population was consecutive adults for whom new or exacerbated congestive heart failure, diagnosed clinically, was a major reason for the emergency department visit. Physicians caring for the study patients in the emergency departments recorded their judgments of the numeric probability that each patient would survive for 90 days and for 1 year. The patients vital status at 90 days and 1 year was ascertained by multiple means, including interview, chart review, and review of hospital and state databases. RESULTS By calibration curve analysis, the physicians underestimated survival probability at both 90 days and 1 year, particularly for patients they judged to have the lowest probabilities of survival. Their predictions had modest discriminating ability (receiver operating characteristic curve areas, 0.66 [SE = 0.020] for 90 days; 0.63 [SE = 0.017] for 1 year). The physicians identified only 15 patients they judged to have a 90-day survival probability of 10% or less, whose survival rate was actually 33.3%. CONCLUSIONS Physicians have great difficulty predicting survival for patients with acute congestive heart failure and cannot identify patients with poor chances of survival. Current triage guidelines that suggest patients with poor chances of survival may be excluded from critical care may be impractical or harmful.

[1]  M. Chassin.  Costs and Outcomes of Medical Intensive Care , 1982, Medical care.

[2]  M. Osborne.  Physician decisions regarding life support in the intensive care unit. , 1992, Chest.

[3]  R. Bone,et al.  Analysis of indications for intensive care unit admission. Clinical efficacy assessment project: American College of Physicians. , 1993, Chest.

[4]  J. Lockrem.  Recommendations for intensive care unit admission and discharge criteria. , 1989, Critical care medicine.

[5]  Richard W. Carlson,et al.  Comparison of clinical assessment with APACHE II for predicting mortality risk in patients admitted to a medical intensive care unit. , 1988, JAMA.

[6]  U. Ruttimann,et al.  Dynamic assessment of severity of illness in pediatric intensive care , 1986, Critical care medicine.

[7]  J R Thornbury,et al.  Likelihood ratios as a measure of the diagnostic usefulness of excretory urogram information. , 1975, Radiology.

[8]  Roy M. Poses,et al.  Availability, Wishful Thinking, and Physicians' Diagnostic Judgments for Patients with Suspected Bacteremia , 1991, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[9]  R D Cebul,et al.  The accuracy of experienced physicians' probability estimates for patients with sore throats. Implications for decision making. , 1985, JAMA.

[10]  J. Goldberger,et al.  Prognostic factors in acute pulmonary edema. , 1986, Archives of internal medicine.

[11]  K. Levi,et al.  A Signal Detection Framework for the Evaluation of Probabilistic Forecasts , 1985 .

[12]  J. Horowitz,et al.  Acute heart failure: determinants of outcome. , 1991, International journal of cardiology.

[13]  A. Ellrodt,et al.  Triage practice guideline for patients hospitalized with congestive heart failure: improving the effectiveness of the coronary care unit. , 1993, The American journal of medicine.

[14]  Engelhardt Ht,et al.  Intensive care units, scarce resources, and conflicting principles of justice , 1986 .

[15]  APACHE II score and mortality in respiratory failure due to cardiogenic pulmonary edema. , 1988, Critical care medicine.

[16]  D Teres.  Civilian triage in the intensive care unit: The ritual of the last bed , 1993, Critical care medicine.

[17]  S. Lemeshow,et al.  Modeling the severity of illness of ICU patients. A systems update. , 1994, JAMA.

[18]  J J Christensen-Szalanski,et al.  Feedback and the Illusion of Validity in a Medical Clinic , 1981, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[19]  D. Levy,et al.  The epidemiology of heart failure: the Framingham Study. , 1993, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[20]  R M Poses,et al.  The answer to “What are my chances, Doctor?” depends on whom is asked: Prognostic disagreement and inaccuracy for critically ill patients , 1989, Critical care medicine.

[21]  J. Hanley,et al.  The meaning and use of the area under a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve. , 1982, Radiology.

[22]  D. Keefe,et al.  Acute Cardiogenic Pulmonary Edema: Clinical and Noninvasive Evaluation , 1988, Angiology.

[23]  Jay J.J. Christensen-Szalanski,et al.  Physicians' use of probabilistic information in a real clinical setting. , 1981 .

[24]  Robert M. Nelson,et al.  Consensus Statement on the Triage of Critically III Patients , 1994 .

[25]  R. D'Agostino,et al.  A Time‐Insensitive Predictive Instrument for Acute Hospital Mortality Due to Congestive Heart Failure: Development, Testing, and Use for Comparing Hospitals A Multicenter Study , 1994, Medical care.

[26]  T. Wallsten.  Physician and Medical Student Bias in Evaluating Diagnostic Information , 1981, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[27]  D. Berwick,et al.  Receiver Operating Characteristic Analysis of Diagnostic Skill , 1983, Medical care.

[28]  J. Rouleau,et al.  Long-term prognosis of patients presenting to the emergency room with decompensated congestive heart failure. , 1994, The Canadian journal of cardiology.

[29]  H I Goldberg,et al.  Evaluation of plain abdominal radiographs in the diagnosis of abdominal pain. , 1982, Annals of internal medicine.

[30]  B. Brody,et al.  The low frequency of futility in an adult intensive care unit setting. , 1996, Archives of internal medicine.

[31]  Predicting hospital-associated mortality for Medicare patients. A method for patients with stroke, pneumonia, acute myocardial infarction, and congestive heart failure. , 1988 .

[32]  T. Raffin,et al.  Intensive care unit survival of patients with systemic illness. , 1989, The American review of respiratory disease.

[33]  L. Goldman,et al.  The SUPPORT Prognostic Model: Objective Estimates of Survival for Seriously Ill Hospitalized Adults , 1995, Annals of Internal Medicine.