A period of contention? The politics of post-crisis activation reform and the creeping marketisation of public employment services

ABSTRACT Public employment services (PES) have undergone significant change since 2011, reshaping the roles of the market, state, and community sector within Ireland’s mixed economy of welfare. The post-crisis years saw the replacement of FÁS with a new network of one-stop-shop Intreo activation services, and the procurement of new employment services for the long-term unemployed through competitive tendering and Payment-by-Results. This process of marketisation is now being extended to other PES currently delivered by community organisations under block grants, such as Local Employment Services and Job Clubs. We position Ireland’s PES landscape as a strategic action field wherein various providers compete with one another for position, power and resources during episodes of contention. Applying this lens to the ongoing reform of activation policy and PES institutions, the paper considers how the recent trajectory of PES marketisation has remained politically contentious. It examines the strategies of various providers and policy actors in shaping the politics of reform, focusing especially on the position of community organisations within the field and the degree to which they have been able to strategically mobilise against marketisation. Lessons are drawn about the nature of Irish politics and policy reform.

[1]  M. McGann Meeting the numbers: Performance politics and welfare-to-work at the street-level , 2021, Irish Journal of Sociology.

[2]  M. Considine,et al.  Buying and Selling the Poor , 2021 .

[3]  Nuala Whelan Opening the black box of implementing activation in Ireland , 2021 .

[4]  M. McGann,et al.  Introduction: The dual tracks of welfare and activation reform – Governance and conditionality , 2021, Administration.

[5]  Fiona Dukelow The evolution of social policy analysis in Ireland: , 2021, Policy Analysis in Ireland.

[6]  J. Hogan,et al.  Contextualising policy analysis in Ireland , 2021, Policy Analysis in Ireland.

[7]  Joe Whelan Work and thrive or claim and skive: Experiencing the ‘toxic symbiosis’ of worklessness and welfare recipiency in Ireland , 2020 .

[8]  D. Kenny,et al.  The Resilience of Executive Dominance in Westminster Systems: Ireland 2016-2019 , 2020 .

[9]  Muiris MacCarthaigh,et al.  Exploiting conditionality: EU and international actors and post-NPM reform in Ireland , 2020, Public Policy and Administration.

[10]  M. Millar,et al.  Rational skivers or desperate strivers? The problematisation of fraud in the Irish social protection system , 2020, Critical Social Policy.

[11]  M. Considine,et al.  Locked-in or Locked-out: Can a Public Services Market Really Change? , 2019, Journal of Social Policy.

[12]  Muiris MacCarthaigh,et al.  Public service integration in hard times: Merging unemployment benefit and labour market activation measures , 2019, Administration.

[13]  P. Redmond,et al.  An initial evaluation of the effectiveness of Intreo activation reforms , 2019 .

[14]  M. Cousins Welfare conditionality in the Republic of Ireland after the Great Recession , 2019 .

[15]  Nuala Whelan Evaluating the effectiveness and implementation of new employment enhancement programmes in an Irish context: A focus on well-being and employability , 2018 .

[16]  R. Hick Enter the Troika: The Politics of Social Security during Ireland's Bailout , 2017, Journal of Social Policy.

[17]  Hayley Bennett Re-examining British Welfare-to-Work Contracting using a Transaction Cost Perspective , 2016, Journal of Social Policy.

[18]  Rebecca Taylor,et al.  UK employment services: understanding provider strategies in a dynamic strategic action field , 2016 .

[19]  Féilim Ó hAdhmaill,et al.  The changing landscape of local and community development in Ireland: policy and practice , 2016 .

[20]  J. Wiggan What variety of employment service quasi-market? Ireland’s job path as a private power market , 2015 .

[21]  Fiona Dukelow ‘Pushing against an open door’: Reinforcing the neo-liberal policy paradigm in Ireland and the impact of EU intrusion , 2015 .

[22]  Rebecca Taylor,et al.  Conditionality and the Financing of Employment Services – Implications for the Social Divisions of Work and Welfare , 2014 .

[23]  John Hill The Marketization of Employment Services and the British Work Programme , 2013 .

[24]  D. Mcadam,et al.  A Theory of Fields , 2012 .

[25]  E. Brodkin Policy Work: Street-Level Organizations Under New Managerialism , 2011 .

[26]  C. Grover Privatizing employment services in Britain , 2009 .

[27]  F. Powell,et al.  Community Development, Partnership Governance and Dilemmas of Professionalization: Profiling and Assessing the Case of Ireland , 2006 .

[28]  N. Boyle FAS and Active Labour Market Policy 1985 - 2004 , 2005 .

[29]  S. Levitan Work and the Welfare State , 1977 .