The Moving to Health (M2H) approach to natural experiment research: A paradigm shift for studies on built environment and health

Improving the built environment (BE) is viewed as one strategy to improve community diets and health. The present goal is to review the literature on the effects of BE on health, highlight its limitations, and explore the growing use of natural experiments in BE research, such as the advent of new supermarkets, revitalized parks, or new transportation systems. Based on recent studies on movers, a paradigm shift in built-environment health research may be imminent. Following the classic Moving to Opportunity study in the US, the present Moving to Health (M2H) strategy takes advantage of the fact that changing residential location can entail overnight changes in multiple BE variables. The necessary conditions for applying the M2H strategy to Geographic Information Systems (GIS) databases and to large longitudinal cohorts are outlined below. Also outlined are significant limitations of this approach, including the use of electronic medical records in lieu of survey data. The key research question is whether documented changes in BE exposure can be linked to changes in health outcomes in a causal manner. The use of geo-localized clinical information from regional health care systems should permit new insights into the social and environmental determinants of health.

[1]  Donald Rose,et al.  Neighbourhood fruit and vegetable availability and consumption: the role of small food stores in an urban environment , 2008, Public Health Nutrition.

[2]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  Attributes of Environments Supporting Walking , 2007, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[3]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Food environment and socioeconomic status influence obesity rates in Seattle and in Paris , 2013 .

[4]  Allen Dearry,et al.  Editorial: Impacts of Our Built Environment on Public Health , 2004, Environmental health perspectives.

[5]  L. Fraser,et al.  The association between the geography of fast food outlets and childhood obesity rates in Leeds, UK. , 2010, Health & place.

[6]  Kelly R Evenson,et al.  Public Parks and Physical Activity Among Adolescent Girls , 2006, Pediatrics.

[7]  A. D. Diez Roux,et al.  Associations of fast food restaurant availability with dietary intake and weight among African Americans in the Jackson Heart Study, 2000-2004. , 2011, American journal of public health.

[8]  E. Cerin,et al.  Park proximity, quality and recreational physical activity among mid-older aged adults: moderating effects of individual factors and area of residence , 2015, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[9]  S. Raudenbush,et al.  Relationship between Urban Sprawl and Physical Activity, Obesity, and Morbidity , 2003, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[10]  A. D. Diez Roux,et al.  Investigating neighborhood and area effects on health. , 2001, American journal of public health.

[11]  Brian E. Saelens,et al.  Emerging Technologies for Assessing Physical Activity Behaviors in Space and Time , 2014, Front. Public Health.

[12]  Penny Gordon-Larsen,et al.  Changes in walking, body mass index, and cardiometabolic risk factors following residential relocation: Longitudinal results from the CARDIA study. , 2016, Journal of transport & health.

[13]  Orion T Stewart,et al.  Geographic disparities in Healthy Eating Index scores (HEI-2005 and 2010) by residential property values: Findings from Seattle Obesity Study (SOS). , 2016, Preventive medicine.

[14]  Jerome N. Rachele,et al.  Neighborhood Disadvantage and Body Mass Index: A Study of Residential Relocation , 2018, American journal of epidemiology.

[15]  Steven Cummins,et al.  Diet And Perceptions Change With Supermarket Introduction In A Food Desert, But Not Because Of Supermarket Use. , 2015, Health affairs.

[16]  E. Turkheimer,et al.  Quasi-causal associations of physical activity and neighborhood walkability with body mass index: a twin study. , 2015, Preventive medicine.

[17]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Poverty and childhood overweight in California Assembly districts. , 2009, Health & place.

[18]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  The geographic distribution of obesity by census tract among 59 767 insured adults in King County, WA , 2013, International Journal of Obesity.

[19]  Philip M. Hurvitz,et al.  Residential property values are associated with obesity among women in King County, WA, USA. , 2012, Social science & medicine.

[20]  The Geography of Diabetes by Census Tract in a Large Sample of Insured Adults in King County, Washington, 2005–2006 , 2014, Preventing chronic disease.

[21]  Patrick M O'Malley,et al.  Associations between access to food stores and adolescent body mass index. , 2007, American journal of preventive medicine.

[22]  Andy P. Jones,et al.  How can GPS technology help us better understand exposure to the food environment? A systematic review , 2016, SSM - population health.

[23]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  Transportation-Efficient Land Use Mapping Index (TELUMI), a Tool to Assess Multimodal Transportation Options in Metropolitan Regions , 2011 .

[24]  C. Woods,et al.  Obesogenic environments: Are neighbourhood environments that limit physical activity obesogenic? , 2009, Health & place.

[25]  T. Koepsell,et al.  Association of the built environment with physical activity and obesity in older persons. , 2007, American journal of public health.

[26]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Obesity and supermarket access: proximity or price? , 2012, American journal of public health.

[27]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  Built environment and behavior: spatial sampling using parcel data. , 2006, Annals of epidemiology.

[28]  N. Adler,et al.  Using Electronic Health Records for Population Health Research: A Review of Methods and Applications. , 2016, Annual review of public health.

[29]  S. Cummins,et al.  Place effects on health: how can we conceptualise, operationalise and measure them? , 2002, Social science & medicine.

[30]  Greg J Duncan,et al.  Neighborhoods, obesity, and diabetes--a randomized social experiment. , 2011, The New England journal of medicine.

[31]  Michael C Wimberly,et al.  Associations of supermarket accessibility with obesity and fruit and vegetable consumption in the conterminous United States , 2010, International journal of health geographics.

[32]  A. Rundle,et al.  Associations between Body Mass Index and Park Proximity, Size, Cleanliness, and Recreational Facilities , 2013, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[33]  Basile Chaix,et al.  Integrating activity spaces in health research: Comparing the VERITAS activity space questionnaire with 7-day GPS tracking and prompted recall. , 2018, Spatial and spatio-temporal epidemiology.

[34]  A. Schulz,et al.  Longitudinal Associations Between Observed and Perceived Neighborhood Food Availability and Body Mass Index in a Multiethnic Urban Sample , 2017, Health education & behavior : the official publication of the Society for Public Health Education.

[35]  R. Whitaker,et al.  Neighborhood playgrounds, fast food restaurants, and crime: relationships to overweight in low-income preschool children. , 2004, Preventive medicine.

[36]  Jana A. Hirsch,et al.  Neighborhood Built Environment Change and Change in BMI and Waist Circumference: Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis , 2014, Obesity.

[37]  Lance Freeman,et al.  Neighborhood Food Environment and Walkability Predict Obesity in New York City , 2008, Environmental health perspectives.

[38]  P. Zandbergen.  Ensuring Confidentiality of Geocoded Health Data: Assessing Geographic Masking Strategies for Individual-Level Data , 2014, Advances in medicine.

[39]  F. Paccaud,et al.  Persistent spatial clusters of high body mass index in a Swiss urban population as revealed by the 5-year GeoCoLaus longitudinal study , 2016, BMJ Open.

[40]  Adam M. Lippert.  Stuck in Unhealthy Places , 2016, Journal of health and social behavior.

[41]  Richard Shearmur,et al.  International Journal of Health Geographics Open Access the Case of Montréal's Missing Food Deserts: Evaluation of Accessibility to Food Supermarkets , 2022 .

[42]  K. Konty,et al.  Neighbourhood food environments and body mass index among New York City adults , 2013, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[43]  Christine M. Hoehner,et al.  Change in Neighborhood Socioeconomic Status and Weight Gain: Dallas Heart Study. , 2015, American journal of preventive medicine.

[44]  J. Sharkey,et al.  Neighborhood socioeconomic deprivation and minority composition are associated with better potential spatial access to the ground-truthed food environment in a large rural area. , 2008, The Journal of nutrition.

[45]  Thomas Lumley,et al.  Using built environment characteristics to predict walking for exercise , 2008, International journal of health geographics.

[46]  Mitch J Duncan,et al.  Perceived environment and physical activity: a meta-analysis of selected environmental characteristics , 2005, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[47]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  The 3Ds + R: Quantifying Land Use and Urban Form Correlates of Walking , 2006 .

[48]  A. Moudon,et al.  Effects of Site Design on Pedestrian Travel in Mixed-Use, Medium-Density Environments , 1997 .

[49]  Andy P. Jones,et al.  A novel methodology for identifying environmental exposures using GPS data , 2016, Int. J. Geogr. Inf. Sci..

[50]  Adam Drewnowski,et al.  Disparities in obesity rates: analysis by ZIP code area. , 2007, Social science & medicine.

[51]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  Home versus nonhome neighborhood: quantifying differences in exposure to the built environment. , 2012, American journal of preventive medicine.

[52]  Aaron Kofner,et al.  The effect of light rail transit on body mass index and physical activity. , 2010, American journal of preventive medicine.

[53]  Jana A. Hirsch,et al.  Neighborhood Built Environment Change and Change in BMI and Waist Circumference: Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis , 2014, Obesity.

[54]  S. Gortmaker,et al.  Proximity to supermarkets associated with higher body mass index among overweight and obese preschool-age children. , 2013, Preventive medicine.

[55]  Reid Ewing,et al.  The built environment and physical activity levels: the Harvard Alumni Health Study. , 2009, American journal of preventive medicine.

[56]  K. Evenson,et al.  Obesity prevalence and the local food environment. , 2009, Health & place.

[57]  Lisa V. Smith,et al.  The Association between Self-Reported Grocery Store Access, Fruit and Vegetable Intake, Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Consumption, and Obesity in a Racially Diverse, Low-Income Population , 2014, Front. Public Health.

[58]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  How to identify food deserts: measuring physical and economic access to supermarkets in King County, Washington. , 2012, American journal of public health.

[59]  Ana V Diez Roux,et al.  The study of group-level factors in epidemiology: rethinking variables, study designs, and analytical approaches. , 2004, Epidemiologic reviews.

[60]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Residential property values predict prevalent obesity but do not predict 1 year weight change , 2014, Obesity.

[61]  L. Geiss,et al.  Estimated county-level prevalence of diabetes and obesity - United States, 2007. , 2009, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[62]  J. Spence,et al.  A longitudinal and cross-sectional examination of the relationship between reasons for choosing a neighbourhood, physical activity and body mass index , 2010, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[63]  A. Moudon,et al.  Correlates of Walking for Transportation or Recreation Purposes. , 2006, Journal of physical activity & health.

[64]  A. Auchincloss,et al.  Impact of policy and built environment changes on obesity‐related outcomes: a systematic review of naturally occurring experiments , 2015, Obesity reviews : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity.

[65]  Meghan Winters,et al.  Corrigendum to “Impact of new rapid transit on physical activity: A meta-analysis” Preventive Medicine Reports 10 (2018) 184–190 , 2018, Preventive medicine reports.

[66]  Junfeng Jiao,et al.  Access to supermarkets and fruit and vegetable consumption. , 2014, American journal of public health.

[67]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Does diet cost mediate the relation between socioeconomic position and diet quality? , 2011, European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.

[68]  A. Rundle,et al.  Steps Forward: Review and Recommendations for Research on Walkability, Physical Activity and Cardiovascular Health , 2011, Public health reviews.

[69]  David Berrigan,et al.  Neighborhood-level socioeconomic deprivation predicts weight gain in a multi-ethnic population: longitudinal data from the Dallas Heart Study. , 2014, Preventive medicine.

[70]  Paul Mitchell Hess,et al.  Measuring Land Use Patterns for Transportation Research , 2001 .

[71]  A. Schiffrin,et al.  Neighbourhood walkability and home neighbourhood-based physical activity: an observational study of adults with type 2 diabetes , 2016, BMC Public Health.

[72]  B Chaix,et al.  The influence of geographic life environments on cardiometabolic risk factors: a systematic review, a methodological assessment and a research agenda , 2011, Obesity reviews : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity.

[73]  B. Giles-Corti,et al.  The effect of proximity on park and beach use and physical activity among rural adolescents. , 2014, Journal of physical activity & health.

[74]  Basile Chaix,et al.  GPS tracking in neighborhood and health studies: a step forward for environmental exposure assessment, a step backward for causal inference? , 2013, Health & place.

[75]  L. Mckay,et al.  Socio-economic position and health: what you observe depends on how you measure it. , 2003, Journal of public health medicine.

[76]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  A neighborhood wealth metric for use in health studies. , 2011, American journal of preventive medicine.

[77]  Diane M Gibson,et al.  The neighborhood food environment and adult weight status: estimates from longitudinal data. , 2011, American journal of public health.

[78]  R. Hiatt,et al.  Neighborhood Influences on Girls’ Obesity Risk Across the Transition to Adolescence , 2014, Pediatrics.

[79]  Mariana C. Arcaya,et al.  Neighborhood Self-Selection: The Role of Pre-Move Health Factors on the Built and Socioeconomic Environment , 2015, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[80]  S V Subramanian,et al.  The local food environment and diet: a systematic review. , 2012, Health & place.

[81]  K. Pasch,et al.  Neighbourhood food environments: are they associated with adolescent dietary intake, food purchases and weight status? , 2010, Public Health Nutrition.

[82]  G. Booth,et al.  Association of Neighborhood Walkability With Change in Overweight, Obesity, and Diabetes. , 2016, JAMA.

[83]  A. Moudon,et al.  Physical Activity and Environment Research in the Health Field: Implications for Urban and Transportation Planning Practice and Research , 2004 .

[84]  J. Shikany,et al.  How do individual-level sociodemographics and neighbourhood-level characteristics influence residential location behaviour in the context of the food and built environment? Findings from 25 years of follow-up in the CARDIA Study , 2016, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[85]  E. Brunner,et al.  Deprivation and the development of obesity a multilevel, longitudinal study in England. , 2010, American journal of preventive medicine.

[86]  Jana A. Hirsch,et al.  Impact of new rapid transit on physical activity: A meta-analysis , 2018, Preventive medicine reports.

[87]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  The impact of area residential property values on self-rated health: A cross-sectional comparative study of Seattle and Paris , 2016, Preventive medicine reports.

[88]  R. Sturm,et al.  Neighborhood Food Outlets, Diet, and Obesity Among California Adults, 2007 and 2009 , 2013, Preventing chronic disease.

[89]  Basile Chaix,et al.  Mobile Sensing in Environmental Health and Neighborhood Research. , 2018, Annual review of public health.

[90]  R. Reis,et al.  Are park proximity and park features related to park use and park-based physical activity among adults? Variations by multiple socio-demographic characteristics , 2014, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[91]  Ethan M Berke,et al.  Built environment change: a framework to support health-enhancing behaviour through environmental policy and health research , 2014, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[92]  R. Kimbro,et al.  Multiple contexts of exposure: Activity spaces, residential neighborhoods, and self-rated health. , 2015, Social science & medicine.

[93]  Ana V Diez Roux,et al.  Associations of the local food environment with diet quality--a comparison of assessments based on surveys and geographic information systems: the multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. , 2008, American journal of epidemiology.

[94]  J. Sallis,et al.  Neighborhood-based differences in physical activity: an environment scale evaluation. , 2003, American journal of public health.

[95]  Reid Ewing,et al.  Travel and the Built Environment , 2010 .

[96]  Anne Vernez Moudon,et al.  The association between park visitation and physical activity measured with accelerometer, GPS, and travel diary. , 2016, Health & place.

[97]  Adam Drewnowski,et al.  Characterizing the food environment: pitfalls and future directions , 2013, Public Health Nutrition.

[98]  Gavin R McCormack,et al.  Neighbourhood built environment characteristics associated with different types of physical activity in Canadian adults. , 2017, Health promotion and chronic disease prevention in Canada : research, policy and practice.

[99]  A. Tanner,et al.  The association between recreational parks, facilities and childhood obesity: a cross-sectional study of the 2007 National Survey of Children's Health , 2013, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[100]  Jana A. Hirsch,et al.  Change in walking and body mass index following residential relocation: the multi-ethnic study of atherosclerosis. , 2014, American journal of public health.

[101]  R. Wiggins,et al.  Pathways to obesity: identifying local, modifiable determinants of physical activity and diet. , 2007, Social science & medicine.

[102]  Kelly Clifton,et al.  "Do you see what I see?" - correlates of multidimensional measures of neighborhood types and perceived physical activity-related neighborhood barriers and facilitators for urban youth. , 2010, Preventive medicine.

[103]  A. Diamant,et al.  Designed for Disease: The Link Between Local Food Environments and Obesity and Diabetes , 2008 .

[104]  R. Sturm,et al.  School and residential neighborhood food environment and diet among California youth. , 2012, American journal of preventive medicine.

[105]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Health Implications of Adults' Eating at and Living near Fast Food or Quick Service Restaurants , 2015, Nutrition & Diabetes.

[106]  Kathryn M Neckerman,et al.  Neighborhood safety and green space as predictors of obesity among preschool children from low-income families in New York City. , 2013, Preventive medicine.

[107]  Steve Wing,et al.  The contextual effect of the local food environment on residents' diets: the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. , 2002, American journal of public health.

[108]  Anthony F Jerant,et al.  A national study of obesity prevalence and trends by type of rural county. , 2005, The Journal of rural health : official journal of the American Rural Health Association and the National Rural Health Care Association.

[109]  John C. Spence,et al.  Food Deserts in the Prairies? Supermarket Accessibility and Neighborhood Need in Edmonton, Canada* , 2006 .

[110]  Child body mass index, obesity, and proximity to fast food restaurants. , 2011, International journal of pediatric obesity : IJPO : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity.

[111]  N. Adler,et al.  The influence of neighborhood food stores on change in young girls' body mass index. , 2011, American journal of preventive medicine.

[112]  M. Taljaard,et al.  The Influence of Place on Weight Gain during Early Childhood: A Population-Based, Longitudinal Study , 2012, Journal of Urban Health.

[113]  Fuzhong Li,et al.  Obesity and the Built Environment: Does the Density of Neighborhood Fast-Food Outlets Matter? , 2009, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[114]  S. Haneuse,et al.  A Multisite Study of Long-term Remission and Relapse of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Following Gastric Bypass , 2012, Obesity Surgery.

[115]  Ding Ding,et al.  Built environment, physical activity, and obesity: what have we learned from reviewing the literature? , 2012, Health & place.

[116]  Steven H. Woolf,et al.  U.S. Health in International Perspective: Shorter Lives, Poorer Health. , 2016, Military medicine.

[117]  Reid Ewing,et al.  Relationship between urban sprawl and weight of United States youth. , 2006, American journal of preventive medicine.

[118]  B. Saelens,et al.  Stepping towards causation: do built environments or neighborhood and travel preferences explain physical activity, driving, and obesity? , 2007, Social science & medicine.

[119]  Steve Wing,et al.  Supermarkets, other food stores, and obesity: the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. , 2006, American journal of preventive medicine.

[120]  R. Pathak,et al.  Construction of a Multisite DataLink Using Electronic Health Records for the Identification, Surveillance, Prevention, and Management of Diabetes Mellitus: The SUPREME-DM Project , 2012, Preventing chronic disease.