Three Statistically Validated K2 Transiting Warm Jupiter Exoplanets Confirmed as Low-mass Stars

We have identified three K2 transiting star-planet systems, K2-51 (EPIC 202900527), K2-67 (EPIC 206155547), and K2-76 (EPIC 206432863), as stellar binaries with low-mass stellar secondaries. The three systems were statistically validated as transiting planets, and through measuring their orbits by radial velocity monitoring we have derived the companion masses to be $0.1459^{+0.0029}_{-0.0032}$ $M_{Sun}$ (EPIC 202900527 B), $0.1612^{+0.0072}_{-0.0067}$ $M_{Sun}$ (EPIC 206155547 B), and $0.0942 \pm 0.0019$ $M_{Sun}$ (EPIC 206432863 B). Therefore they are not planets but small stars, part of the small sample of low-mass stars with measured radius and mass. The three systems are at an orbital period range of $12-24$ days, and the secondaries have a radius within $0.9-1.9$ $R_J$, not inconsistent with the properties of warm Jupiter planets. These systems illustrate some of the existing challenges in the statistical validation approach. We point out a few possible origins for the initial misclassification of these objects, including poor characterization of the host star, the difficulty in detecting a secondary eclipse in systems on an eccentric orbit, and the difficulty in distinguishing between the smallest stars and gas giant planets as the two populations have indistinguishable radius distributions. Our work emphasizes the need for obtaining medium-precision radial velocity measurements to distinguish between companions that are small stars, brown dwarfs, and gas giant planets.

[1]  E. Agol,et al.  Analytic Light Curves for Planetary Transit Searches , 2002, astro-ph/0210099.

[2]  R. Paul Butler,et al.  Radial Velocities for 889 Late-Type Stars , 2001, astro-ph/0112477.

[3]  Aisey M Andel.  ANALYTIC LIGHTCURVES FOR PLANETARY TRANSIT SEARCHES , 2002 .

[4]  P. H. Hauschildt,et al.  Evolutionary models for cool brown dwarfs and extrasolar giant planets. The case of HD 209458 , 2003 .

[5]  A. Claret,et al.  A new non-linear limb-darkening law for LTE stellar atmosphere models III - Sloan filters: Calculations for –5.0 ≤ log [M/H] ≤ +1, 2000 K ≤ T$\mathsf{_{eff}}$ ≤ 50 000 K at several surface gravities , 2004 .

[6]  D. Queloz,et al.  A planet-sized transiting star around OGLE-TR-122. Accurate mass and radius near the hydrogen-burning limit , 2005, astro-ph/0501611.

[7]  C. Moutou,et al.  Radius and mass of a transiting M dwarf near the hydrogen-burning limit. OGLE-TR-123 , 2006 .

[8]  Massachusetts Institute of Technology,et al.  Improving Stellar and Planetary Parameters of Transiting Planet Systems: The Case of TrES-2 , 2007, 0704.2938.

[9]  Darko Jevremovic,et al.  The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database , 2008, 0804.4473.

[10]  J. Valenti,et al.  THE NASA-UC ETA-EARTH PROGRAM. I. A SUPER-EARTH ORBITING HD 7924 , 2009, 0901.4394.

[11]  Howard Isaacson,et al.  MODELING KEPLER TRANSIT LIGHT CURVES AS FALSE POSITIVES: REJECTION OF BLEND SCENARIOS FOR KEPLER-9, AND VALIDATION OF KEPLER-9 d, A SUPER-EARTH-SIZE PLANET IN A MULTIPLE SYSTEM , 2010, 1008.4393.

[12]  G. Furesz,et al.  HAT-P-16b: A 4 MJ PLANET TRANSITING A BRIGHT STAR ON AN ECCENTRIC ORBIT, , 2010, 1005.2009.

[13]  T. Guillot,et al.  CoRoT LRa02_E2_0121: Neptune-size planet candidate turns into a hierarchical triple system with a giant primary , 2011, 1108.5623.

[14]  John Southworth,et al.  Homogeneous studies of transiting extrasolar planets – IV. Thirty systems with space-based light curves , 2011, 1107.1235.

[15]  Kevin Heng,et al.  THE DEPENDENCE OF BROWN DWARF RADII ON ATMOSPHERIC METALLICITY AND CLOUDS: THEORY AND COMPARISON WITH OBSERVATIONS , 2011, 1102.3922.

[16]  L. Buchhave,et al.  KIC 1571511B: a benchmark low-mass star in an eclipsing binary system in the Kepler field , 2011, 1111.2578.

[17]  T. Morton.  AN EFFICIENT AUTOMATED VALIDATION PROCEDURE FOR EXOPLANET TRANSIT CANDIDATES , 2012, 1206.1568.

[18]  K. Stassun,et al.  The EBLM project - I. Physical and orbital parameters, including spin-orbit angles, of two low-mass eclipsing binaries on opposite sides of the brown dwarf limit , 2012, 1208.4940.

[19]  G. Torres.  Fundamental properties of lower main-sequence stars , 2012, 1209.1279.

[20]  G. Marcy,et al.  Precise Radial Velocities of 2046 Nearby FGKM Stars and 131 Standards , 2012, 1207.6212.

[21]  G. Montagnier,et al.  SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates IX. KOI-415 b: a long-period, eccentric transiting brown dwarf to an evolved Sun , 2013, 1309.0905.

[22]  K. von Braun,et al.  The NASA Exoplanet Archive: Data and Tools for Exoplanet Research , 2013, 1307.2944.

[23]  F. Fressin,et al.  THE FALSE POSITIVE RATE OF KEPLER AND THE OCCURRENCE OF PLANETS , 2013, 1301.0842.

[24]  A. Santerne,et al.  SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates. VIII. KOI-205 b: a brown-dwarf companion to a K-type dwarf , 2013, 1302.2628.

[25]  Daniel Foreman-Mackey,et al.  emcee: The MCMC Hammer , 2012, 1202.3665.

[26]  P. Giommi,et al.  The PLATO 2.0 mission , 2013, 1310.0696.

[27]  D. Bayliss,et al.  The mass–radius relationship for very low mass stars: four new discoveries from the HATSouth Survey , 2013, 1310.7591.

[28]  F. Mullally,et al.  The K2 Mission: Characterization and Early Results , 2014, 1402.5163.

[29]  Observatoire de Haute-Provence,et al.  SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates XIII. KOI-189 b and KOI-686 b: two very low-mass stars in long-period orbits , 2014, 1410.5248.

[30]  A. Vanderburg,et al.  A Technique for Extracting Highly Precise Photometry for the Two-Wheeled Kepler Mission , 2014, 1408.3853.

[31]  P. Berlind,et al.  PLANETARY CANDIDATES FROM THE FIRST YEAR OF THE K2 MISSION , 2015, 1511.07820.

[32]  John Asher Johnson,et al.  STELLAR AND PLANETARY PROPERTIES OF K2 CAMPAIGN 1 CANDIDATES AND VALIDATION OF 17 PLANETS, INCLUDING A PLANET RECEIVING EARTH-LIKE INSOLATION , 2015, 1503.07866.

[33]  F. Allard,et al.  New evolutionary models for pre-main sequence and main sequence low-mass stars down to the hydrogen-burning limit , 2015, 1503.04107.

[34]  Khadeejah A. Zamudio,et al.  PLANETARY CANDIDATES OBSERVED BY KEPLER. VII. THE FIRST FULLY UNIFORM CATALOG BASED ON THE ENTIRE 48-MONTH DATA SET (Q1–Q17 DR24) , 2015, 1512.06149.

[35]  Drake Deming,et al.  THE TRANSITING EXOPLANET SURVEY SATELLITE: SIMULATIONS OF PLANET DETECTIONS AND ASTROPHYSICAL FALSE POSITIVES , 2015, 1506.03845.

[36]  Justin R. Crepp,et al.  VALIDATION OF 12 SMALL KEPLER TRANSITING PLANETS IN THE HABITABLE ZONE , 2015, 1501.01101.

[37]  Timothy D. Morton,et al.  VESPA: False positive probabilities calculator , 2015 .

[38]  A. Collier Cameron,et al.  The Sun as a planet-host star: proxies from SDO images for HARPS radial-velocity variations , 2016, 1601.05651.

[39]  M. R. Haas,et al.  FALSE POSITIVE PROBABILITIES FOR ALL KEPLER OBJECTS OF INTEREST: 1284 NEWLY VALIDATED PLANETS AND 428 LIKELY FALSE POSITIVES , 2016, 1605.02825.

[40]  David J Armstrong,et al.  EPIC 201702477b: A TRANSITING BROWN DWARF FROM K2 IN A 41 DAY ORBIT , 2016 .

[41]  Michael C. Liu,et al.  197 CANDIDATES AND 104 VALIDATED PLANETS IN K2's FIRST FIVE FIELDS , 2016, 1607.05263.

[42]  Avi Shporer,et al.  RADIAL VELOCITY MONITORING OF KEPLER HEARTBEAT STARS , 2016, 1606.02723.

[43]  W. Borucki,et al.  KEPLER Mission: development and overview , 2016, Reports on progress in physics. Physical Society.

[44]  David J Armstrong,et al.  Disproving the validated planets K2-78b, K2-82b, and K2-92b - The importance of independently confirming planetary candidates , 2017 .

[45]  D. Bayliss,et al.  K2-114b and K2-115b: Two Transiting Warm Jupiters , 2017, 1708.07128.

[46]  P. Cargile,et al.  The California-Kepler Survey. I. High-resolution Spectroscopy of 1305 Stars Hosting Kepler Transiting Planets , 2017, 1703.10400.

[47]  S. Udry,et al.  The EBLM project III. A Saturn-size low-mass star at the hydrogen-burning limit , 2017, 1706.08781.