Lamport clocks: verifying a directory cache-coherence protocol

Modern shared-memory multiprocessors use complex memory system implementations that include a variety of non-trivial and interacting optimizations. More time is spent in verifying the correctness of such implementations than in designing the system. In particular, large-scale Distributed Shared Memory (DSM) systems usually rely on a directory cache-coherence protocol to provide the illusion of a sequentially consistent shar ed address space. Verifying that such a distributed protocol satisfies sequential consistency is a difficult task. Current formal protocol verification techniques [18] complement simulation, but ar e some what nonintuitive to system designers and verifiers, and they do not scale well to practical systems. In this paper, we examine a new reasoning technique that is precise and (we find) intuitive. Our technique is based on Lamport’ s logical clocks, which were originally used in distributed systems. We make modest extensions to Lamport’ s logical clocking scheme to assign timestamps to r elevant protocol events to construct a total ordering of such events. Such total orderings can be used to verify that the requirements of a particular memory consistency model have been satisfied. We apply Lamport clocks to prove that a non-trivial directory protocol implements sequential consistency. T o do this, we describe an SGI Origin 2000-like protocol [12] in detail, provide a timestamping scheme that totally orders all protocol events, and then prove sequential consistency (i.e., a load always returns the value of the “last” stor e to the same address in timestamp order).