Interventions to reduce the impact of unemployment and economic hardship on mental health in the general population: a systematic review

Background Job loss, debt and financial difficulties are associated with increased risk of mental illness and suicide in the general population. Interventions targeting people in debt or unemployed might help reduce these effects. Method We searched MEDLINE, Embase, The Cochrane Library, Web of Science, and PsycINFO (January 2016) for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of interventions to reduce the effects of unemployment and debt on mental health in general population samples. We assessed papers for inclusion, extracted data and assessed risk of bias. Results Eleven RCTs (n = 5303 participants) met the inclusion criteria. All recruited participants were unemployed. Five RCTs assessed ‘job-club’ interventions, two cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) and a single RCT assessed each of emotional competency training, expressive writing, guided imagery and debt advice. All studies were at high risk of bias. ‘Job club’ interventions led to improvements in levels of depression up to 2 years post-intervention; effects were strongest among those at increased risk of depression (improvements of up to 0.2–0.3 s.d. in depression scores). There was mixed evidence for effectiveness of group CBT on symptoms of depression. An RCT of debt advice found no effect but had poor uptake. Single trials of three other interventions showed no evidence of benefit. Conclusions ‘Job-club’ interventions may be effective in reducing depressive symptoms in unemployed people, particularly those at high risk of depression. Evidence for CBT-type interventions is mixed; further trials are needed. However the studies are old and at high risk of bias. Future intervention studies should follow CONSORT guidelines and address issues of poor uptake.

[1]  F. Carinci Deeks JJ, Higgins JPT on behalf of the Statistical MethodsGroup of The Cochrane Collaboration, Statistical algorithms in Review Manager 5 , 2017 .

[2]  J. Donovan,et al.  Understanding vulnerability to self-harm in times of economic hardship and austerity: a qualitative study , 2016, BMJ Open.

[3]  M. Whitehead,et al.  Fit-for-work or fit-for-unemployment? Does the reassessment of disability benefit claimants using a tougher work capability assessment help people into work? , 2015, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[4]  F. Zenasni,et al.  The Effects of Emotional Competences Training among Unemployed Adults: A Longitudinal Study. , 2015, Applied psychology. Health and well-being.

[5]  J. Donovan,et al.  Characteristics of people dying by suicide after job loss, financial difficulties and other economic stressors during a period of recession (2010-2011): A review of coroners׳ records. , 2015, Journal of affective disorders.

[6]  Eva M. Lira,et al.  Can intervention in emotional competences increase employability prospects of unemployed adults , 2015 .

[7]  P. Corcoran,et al.  Impact of the economic recession and subsequent austerity on suicide and self-harm in Ireland: An interrupted time series analysis. , 2015, International journal of epidemiology.

[8]  D. Gunnell,et al.  Economic recession and suicidal behaviour: Possible mechanisms and ameliorating factors , 2015, The International journal of social psychiatry.

[9]  C. M. van der Feltz-Cornelis,et al.  Interventions to improve return to work in depressed people. , 2014, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[10]  T. Norström,et al.  The Great Recession, unemployment and suicide , 2014, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[11]  Jason L. Huang,et al.  Effectiveness of Job Search Interventions: A Meta-Analytic Review , 2014, Psychological bulletin.

[12]  J. Cylus,et al.  Do generous unemployment benefit programs reduce suicide rates? A state fixed-effect analysis covering 1968-2008. , 2014, American journal of epidemiology.

[13]  J. Hofman,et al.  Psychological Wellbeing and Work: Improving Service Provision and Outcomes. , 2014, Rand health quarterly.

[14]  Rustam Al-Shahi Salman,et al.  Increasing value and reducing waste in biomedical research regulation and management , 2014, The Lancet.

[15]  David Gunnell,et al.  Impact of 2008 global economic crisis on suicide: time trend study in 54 countries , 2013, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[16]  A. Zaslavsky,et al.  The Oregon experiment--effects of Medicaid on clinical outcomes. , 2013, The New England journal of medicine.

[17]  David Moher,et al.  Consolidated standards of reporting trials (CONSORT) and the completeness of reporting of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) published in medical journals. , 2012, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[18]  S. Katikireddi,et al.  Trends in population mental health before and after the 2008 recession: a repeat cross-sectional analysis of the 1991–2010 Health Surveys of England , 2012, BMJ Open.

[19]  P. Bassett,et al.  The relationship between personal debt and mental health: a systematic review , 2011 .

[20]  B. Lutz,et al.  Public health nursing case management for women receiving temporary assistance for needy families: a randomized controlled trial using community-based participatory research. , 2011, American journal of public health.

[21]  S. Brophy,et al.  Interventions for latent autoimmune diabetes (LADA) in adults. , 2011, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[22]  Delphine Nélis,et al.  Emotional plasticity: conditions and effects of improving emotional competence in adulthood. , 2011, The Journal of applied psychology.

[23]  Michele Tarsilla Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions , 2010, Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation.

[24]  U. Sambamoorthi,et al.  Experimental evidence of welfare reform impact on clinical anxiety and depression levels among poor women. , 2010, Social science & medicine.

[25]  D. Moher,et al.  CONSORT 2010 Statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomized trials , 2010, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[26]  D. Moher,et al.  CONSORT 2010 Statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials , 2010, BMC medicine.

[27]  J. Sluiter,et al.  Vocational Interventions for Unemployed: Effects on Work Participation and Mental Distress. A Systematic Review , 2010, Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation.

[28]  H. Tsang,et al.  Three Year Follow-Up Study of an Integrated Supported Employment for Individuals with Severe Mental Illness , 2010, The Australian and New Zealand journal of psychiatry.

[29]  Martin McKee,et al.  The public health effect of economic crises and alternative policy responses in Europe: an empirical analysis , 2009, The Lancet.

[30]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[31]  E. Harris,et al.  Reducing the impact of unemployment on health: revisiting the agenda for primary health care , 2009, The Medical journal of Australia.

[32]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[33]  G. Bond,et al.  The working alliance and employment outcomes for people with severe mental illness enrolled in vocational programs. , 2009, Rehabilitation psychology.

[34]  P. Morris,et al.  Losing the safety net: how a time-limited welfare policy affects families at risk of reaching time limits. , 2009, Developmental psychology.

[35]  Dean S. Karlan,et al.  Small individual loans and mental health: a randomized controlled trial among South African adults , 2008, BMC public health.

[36]  M. Petticrew,et al.  Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidance , 2008, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[37]  D. Altman,et al.  Chapter 8: Assessing risk of bias in included studies , 2008 .

[38]  P. Pleasence Trials and Tribulations: Conducting Randomized Experiments in a Socio‐legal Setting , 2008 .

[39]  P. Pleasence,et al.  Changing Fortunes: Results from a Randomized Trial of the Offer of Debt Advice in England and Wales , 2007 .

[40]  D. DeGarmo,et al.  Accelerating Recovery from Poverty: Prevention Effects for Recently Separated Mothers. , 2007, Journal of early and intensive behavior intervention : JEIBI.

[41]  Jean Adams,et al.  A systematic review of the health, social and financial impacts of welfare rights advice delivered in healthcare settings , 2006, BMC public health.

[42]  S. Moebus,et al.  An analysis of sickness absence in chronically ill patients receiving Complementary and Alternative Medicine: A longterm prospective intermittent study , 2006, BMC public health.

[43]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Job‐search preparedness as a mediator of the effects of the Työhön Job Search Intervention on re‐employment and mental health , 2005 .

[44]  J. Vuori,et al.  The benefits of a preventive job search program on re-employment and mental health at 2-year follow-up , 2005 .

[45]  M. Mugford,et al.  The Social Support and Family Health Study: a randomised controlled trial and economic evaluation of two alternative forms of postnatal support for mothers living in disadvantaged inner-city areas. , 2004, Health technology assessment.

[46]  E. Harris,et al.  Are CBT interventions effective with disadvantaged job-seekers who are long-term unemployed? , 2002 .

[47]  A. Rodgers,et al.  Randomised studies of income supplementation: a lost opportunity to assess health outcomes. , 1999, Journal of epidemiology and community health.

[48]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Mastery and inoculation against setbacks as active ingredients in the JOBS intervention for the unemployed. , 1997, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[49]  Graham Dunn,et al.  Effect of cognitive-behavioural training on job-finding among long-term unemployed people , 1997, The Lancet.

[50]  O. Gureje,et al.  The validity of two versions of the GHQ in the WHO study of mental illness in general health care , 1997, Psychological Medicine.

[51]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Hard times and hurtful partners: how financial strain affects depression and relationship satisfaction of unemployed persons and their spouses. , 1996, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[52]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Impact of the JOBS intervention on unemployed workers varying in risk for depression , 1995, American journal of community psychology.

[53]  JAMES W. PENNEBAKER,et al.  Expressive Writing and Coping with Job Loss , 1994 .

[54]  John R. Belcher,et al.  Assisting Unemployed Older Workers to Become Reemployed: An Experimental Evaluation , 1994 .

[55]  Amiram D. Vinokur,et al.  How did it work? An examination of the mechanisms through which an intervention for the unemployed promoted job-search behavior , 1992, American journal of community psychology.

[56]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Impact of a preventive job search intervention on the likelihood of depression among the unemployed. , 1992, Journal of health and social behavior.

[57]  A. Vinokur,et al.  From field experiments to program implementation: Assessing the potential outcomes of an experimental intervention program for unemployed persons , 1991, American journal of community psychology.

[58]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Long-term follow-up and benefit-cost analysis of the Jobs Program: a preventive intervention for the unemployed. , 1991, The Journal of applied psychology.

[59]  R. Caplan,et al.  Job seeking, reemployment, and mental health: a randomized field experiment in coping with job loss. , 1989, The Journal of applied psychology.

[60]  D. Watson,et al.  Health complaints, stress, and distress: exploring the central role of negative affectivity. , 1989, Psychological review.

[61]  D. Gray,et al.  A job club for older job seekers: an experimental evaluation. , 1983, Journal of gerontology.

[62]  Robert A. Philip,et al.  The Job Club Method for the Job Handicapped: A Comparative Outcome Study. , 1979 .

[63]  S. J. Kaplan,et al.  Job-finding club: A group-assisted program for obtaining employment , 1975 .

[64]  R. Emsley,et al.  Debt Counselling for Depression in Primary Care: an adaptive randomised controlled pilot trial (DeCoDer study). , 2017, Health technology assessment.

[65]  J. Cook,et al.  Supported employment outcomes for transition age youth and young adults. , 2012, Psychiatric rehabilitation journal.

[66]  S. Basu,et al.  Impact of economic crises on mental health , 2011 .

[67]  J. Higgins Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration , 2011 .

[68]  Jonathan J Deeks,et al.  Statistical algorithms in Review Manager , 2010 .

[69]  C. Normand,et al.  A systematic review of the role of bisphosphonates in metastatic disease. , 2004, Health technology assessment.

[70]  A. Vinokur,et al.  The Työhön Job Search Program in Finland: benefits for the unemployed with risk of depression or discouragement. , 2002, Journal of occupational health psychology.

[71]  M. Greenberg,et al.  The effects of a career transition program on reemployment success in laid-off professionals. , 2001 .

[72]  A. Vinokur,et al.  Two years after a job loss: long-term impact of the JOBS program on reemployment and mental health. , 2000, Journal of occupational health psychology.

[73]  G. Dunn,et al.  Psychological training improves mental health and job-finding among unemployed people. , 1999, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[74]  D. Revitt,et al.  The influence of personal protection, environmental hygiene and exposure to pesticides on the health of immigrant farm workers in a desert country , 1999, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[75]  A. Vinokur,et al.  The Jobs I preventive intervention for unemployed individuals: Short- and long-term effects on reemployment and mental health. , 1995 .

[76]  Steven L. Sauter,et al.  Job stress interventions , 1995 .

[77]  R. Salokangas,et al.  [DEPS--a new tool in screening for depression]. , 1994, Duodecim; laaketieteellinen aikakauskirja.

[78]  John E. Ware,et al.  SF-36 physical and mental health summary scales : a user's manual , 1994 .

[79]  S. J. Frank,et al.  Paradoxical intervention and struggle to maintain homeostasis in a nursing care facility , 1992 .

[80]  L. Covi,et al.  The Hopkins Symptom Checklist (HSCL): a self-report symptom inventory. , 1974, Behavioral science.