Clinical Decisions in Psychiatry Should Not Be Based On Risk Assessment

Objective: Risk assessments that place patients in high or low risk categories have been widely adopted by mental health services in an attempt to reduce the harms associated with psychiatric disorders. This paper examines the effects of categorization based on the results of a risk assessment. Methods: The violence prediction instrument derived from the MacArthur Study of Mental Disorder and Violence was used to illustrate the nature and effects of risk assessment and the consequent categorization of patients. Results: The majority of patients categorized as being at high risk will not commit any harmful acts. Conclusions: Patients who are classified as high risk share the cost of efforts to reduce harm in the form of additional treatment and restrictions, although the majority will not go on to commit a harmful act. Clinical decisions made on the basis of risk assessment also divert resources away from patients classified as low risk, even though a significant proportion do go on to a commit harmful act. We argue that psychiatric professionals should discuss the risks of treatment and of non-treatment with patients (or with their substitute decision-makers) and should maintain a duty to warn about the consequences of not having treatment. However, assessment of risk of harm should not form the basis for clinical decision making. We should aim to provide optimal care according to the treatment needs of each patient, regardless of the perceived risk of adverse events.

[1]  M. Large,et al.  Mental health laws that require dangerousness for involuntary admission may delay the initial treatment of schizophrenia , 2008, Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology.

[2]  P. Houck,et al.  Role of Intense Affects in Predicting Short-term Risk for Suicidal Behavior: A Prospective Study , 2010, The Journal of nervous and mental disease.

[3]  S. Allnutt,et al.  NSW Clinical Risk Assessment and Management Training Programme , 2009 .

[4]  J. Monahan,et al.  An actuarial model of violence risk assessment for persons with mental disorders. , 2005, Psychiatric services.

[5]  R. Hare,et al.  The Psychopathy Checklist—Revised (PCL-R) , 1992 .

[6]  Sue Lee,et al.  Mental capacity. , 2007, Nursing management.

[7]  J Monahan,et al.  Violence and delusions: data from the MacArthur Violence Risk Assessment Study. , 2000, The American journal of psychiatry.

[8]  A. Carroll.  Risk Assessment and Management in Practice: The Forensicare Risk Assessment and Management Exercise , 2008, Australasian psychiatry : bulletin of Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.

[9]  A. Buchanan.  Risk of violence by psychiatric patients: beyond the "actuarial versus clinical" assessment debate. , 2008, Psychiatric services.

[10]  M. Large,et al.  Homicide of strangers by people with a psychotic illness. , 2011, Schizophrenia bulletin.

[11]  M. Hotopf,et al.  Mental capacity in psychiatric patients , 2007, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[12]  George Szmukler,et al.  Risk assessment: ‘numbers’ and ‘values’ , 2003 .

[13]  D. Mossman.  Critique of Pure Risk Assessment or, Kant Meets Tarasoff , 2007 .

[14]  M. Large,et al.  The danger of dangerousness: why we must remove the dangerousness criterion from our mental health acts , 2008, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[15]  J. Monahan,et al.  A Classification Tree Approach to the Development of Actuarial Violence Risk Assessment Tools , 2000, Law and human behavior.

[16]  S. R. Jammalamadaka,et al.  Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk , 1999 .

[17]  D. Mossman.  The Imperfection of Protection Through Detection and Intervention , 2009, The Journal of legal medicine.

[18]  R. Hockberger,et al.  Assessment of suicide potential by nonpsychiatrists using the SAD PERSONS score. , 1988, The Journal of emergency medicine.

[19]  A. Buchanan.  Risk of Violence by Psychiatric Patients: Beyond the "Actuarial Versus Clinical" Assessment Debate , 2008 .

[20]  R. Snowden,et al.  Assessing risk of future violence among forensic psychiatric inpatients with the Classification of Violence Risk (COVR). , 2009, Psychiatric services.

[21]  G. Mendelson,et al.  Tarasoff down Under: The Psychiatrist's Duty to Warn in Australia , 1991, The Journal of psychiatry & law.

[22]  P. Meehl.  Causes and effects of my disturbing little book. , 1986, Journal of personality assessment.

[23]  No evidence for improvement in the accuracy of suicide risk assessment. , 2010, The Journal of nervous and mental disease.

[24]  Harry G. Kennedy,et al.  The Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Manual (S-RAMM) Validation Study 1 , 2009, Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine.

[25]  S. Bjørkly,et al.  Development of a brief screen for violence risk (V-RISK-10) in acute and general psychiatry: An introduction with emphasis on findings from a naturalistic test of interrater reliability , 2009, European Psychiatry.

[26]  K. Mackway-Jones,et al.  A comparison between clinicians’ assessment and the Manchester Self-Harm Rule: a cohort study , 2007, Emergency Medicine Journal.

[27]  S. R. Jammalamadaka,et al.  Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk , 1999 .

[28]  M. Hotopf,et al.  Retrospective views of psychiatric in-patients regaining mental capacity , 2009, The British journal of psychiatry : the journal of mental science.

[29]  J. Monahan,et al.  Violence by people discharged from acute psychiatric inpatient facilities and by others in the same neighborhoods. , 1998, Archives of general psychiatry.

[30]  K S Douglas,et al.  Assessing risk for violence among psychiatric patients: the HCR-20 violence risk assessment scheme and the Psychopathy Checklist: Screening Version. , 1999, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[31]  M. Daffern,et al.  The Prediction of Imminent Aggression in Patients with Mental Illness and/or Intellectual Disability Using the Dynamic Appraisal of Situational Aggression Instrument , 2009, Australasian psychiatry : bulletin of Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.

[32]  R. Halfens,et al.  Structured risk assessment and violence in acute psychiatric wards: randomised controlled trial , 2008, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[33]  P. Appelbaum,et al.  Civil commitment--the American experience. , 2006, The Israel journal of psychiatry and related sciences.

[34]  M. Large,et al.  The Predictive Value of Risk Categorization in Schizophrenia , 2011, Harvard review of psychiatry.

[35]  G. Szmukler.  Violence risk prediction in practice , 2001, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[36]  M. Large,et al.  Rates of homicide during the first episode of psychosis and after treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2010, Schizophrenia bulletin.

[37]  H. Anckarsäter,et al.  The precarious practice of forensic psychiatric risk assessments. , 2009, International journal of law and psychiatry.