Comparing social worker and non-social worker outcomes: a research review.

This article reports on a review of the literature comparing the outcomes of social workers with those of non-social workers. The review was commissioned by NASW's Texas Chapter to examine empirical evidence regarding the comparative effectiveness of social work to possibly support efforts to educate employers and the public about the value of social work. Because of the limited number of internally valid studies that have compared social workers and non-social workers on actual client outcomes, studies were also included if they examined practitioner variables that might be associated with client outcomes. The mixed findings point to a lack of compelling evidence supporting the superiority of social work in the child welfare field. However, in the mental health and aging fields, the limited evidence suggests that social workers do at least as well as non-social workers regarding practitioner retention, mental health court intervention, efforts to maintain older adult independence in the community, and attitudes toward evidence-based practice. Implications are presented to guide NASW in promoting rigorous research comparing social workers and non-social workers on actual client outcomes, especially in the field of child welfare.

[1]  D. Parrish,et al.  Social workers' orientations toward the evidence-based practice process: a comparison with psychologists and licensed marriage and family therapists. , 2012, Social work.

[2]  T. Franke,et al.  A multivariate analysis of training, education, and readiness for public child welfare practice , 2009 .

[3]  Pamela A. Yankeelov,et al.  Individual and organizational factors in job retention in Kentucky's child welfare agency , 2009 .

[4]  C. Franklin,et al.  A Meta-Analysis of Published School Social Work Practice Studies , 2009 .

[5]  Allan E. Barsky.  The legal and ethical context for knowing and using the latest child welfare research. , 2009, Child welfare.

[6]  Becky F. Antle,et al.  Recruiting and retaining child welfare workers: is preparing social work students enough for sustained commitment to the field? , 2009, Child welfare.

[7]  J. Zlotnik,et al.  Retention of front-line staff in child welfare: A systematic review of research , 2008 .

[8]  S. Dennison,et al.  Students' perceptions of social work: implications for strengthening the image of social work among college students. , 2007, Social work.

[9]  H. Ben-Zur,et al.  Burnout, Social Support, and Coping at Work Among Social Workers, Psychologists, and Nurses , 2007, Social work in health care.

[10]  James J. Clark,et al.  Compassion Fatigue, Compassion Satisfaction, and Burnout: Factors Impacting a Professional's Quality of Life , 2007 .

[11]  R. Perry.  Education and Child Welfare Supervisor Performance: Does a Social Work Degree Matter? , 2006 .

[12]  Michael J. Zyphur,et al.  Investigating the effects of caseworker characteristics in child welfare , 2006 .

[13]  J. Zlotnik.  No Simple Answers to a Complex Question: A Response to Perry , 2006 .

[14]  Alberta J. Ellett.  Broad Study but Narrow Question: A Friendly Critique of Perry's Article , 2006 .

[15]  R. Perry.  Do Social Workers Make Better Child Welfare Workers Than Non–Social Workers? , 2006 .

[16]  Jeannine M. Rowe,et al.  Studies of the Cost-Effectiveness of Social Work Services in Aging: A Review of the Literature , 2006 .

[17]  M. Mugford,et al.  Are occupational therapists more effective than social workers when assessing frail older people? Results of CAMELOT, a randomised controlled trial. , 2005, Age and ageing.

[18]  C. LeCroy,et al.  The public's perception of social work: is it what we think it is? , 2004, Social work.

[19]  Stephen R. Fox,et al.  Finding and Keeping Child Welfare Workers , 2003 .

[20]  Loring P. Jones.  A Follow-Up of a Title IV-E Program's Graduates' Retention Rates in a Public Child Welfare Agency , 2002, Journal of health & social policy.

[21]  K. Gansle,et al.  Child Welfare Knowledge Transmission, Practitioner Retention, and University-Community Impact , 2002, Journal of health & social policy.

[22]  C. Hollister,et al.  Career Paths and Contributions of Four Cohorts of IV-E Funded MSW Child Welfare Graduates , 2002, Journal of Health & Social Policy.

[23]  Judith L. Rozie-Battle.  African American Teens and the Neo-Juvenile Justice System , 2002, Journal of Health & Social Policy.

[24]  Loring P. Jones,et al.  Reprofessionalizing Child Welfare Services: An Evaluation of a Title IVE Training Program , 2000 .

[25]  Justin E. Levitov,et al.  The Public Perception of Mental Health Professions: An Empirical Examination. , 2000 .

[26]  Karen M. Hopkins,et al.  Impact of university/agency partnerships in child welfare on organizations, workers, and work activities , 1999 .

[27]  W. Doherty,et al.  Does academic training background make a difference among practicing marriage and family therapists? , 1998, Journal of marital and family therapy.

[28]  A. Grenier,et al.  The effectiveness of social work with older people and their families: A meta-analysis of conference proceedings , 1998 .

[29]  K. Gorey,et al.  Unpublished social work research: Systematic replication of a recent meta-analysis of published inte , 1997 .

[30]  A. Rubin.  The family preservation evaluation from hell: Implications for program evaluation fidelity , 1997 .

[31]  K. Gorey.  Effectiveness of social work intervention research: Internal versus external evaluations , 1996 .

[32]  D. Vinokur-Kaplan,et al.  Job Satisfaction among Social Workers in Public and Voluntary Child Welfare Agencies. , 1990 .

[33]  S. Dhooper,et al.  Does social work education make a difference? , 1990, Social work.

[34]  U. Aviram,et al.  Institutions and their changing environments: structures and processes for adaptation. Part II. , 2008, Administration in social work.