Hidden in plain view: degeneracy in complex systems

Degeneracy is a word with two meanings. The popular usage of the word denotes deviance and decay. In scientific discourse, degeneracy refers to the idea that different pathways can lead to the same output. In the biological sciences, the concept of degeneracy has been ignored for a few key reasons. Firstly, the word "degenerate" in popular culture has negative, emotionally powerful associations that do not inspire scientists to consider its technical meaning. Secondly, the tendency of searching for single causes of natural and social phenomena means that scientists can overlook the multi-stranded relationships between cause and effect. Thirdly, degeneracy and redundancy are often confused with each other. Degeneracy refers to dissimilar structures that are functionally similar while redundancy refers to identical structures. Degeneracy can give rise to novelty in ways that redundancy cannot. From genetic codes to immunology, vaccinology and brain development, degeneracy is a crucial part of how complex systems maintain their functional integrity. This review article discusses how the scientific concept of degeneracy was imported into genetics from physics and was later introduced to immunology and neuroscience. Using examples of degeneracy in immunology, neuroscience and linguistics, we demonstrate that degeneracy is a useful way of understanding how complex systems function. Reviewing the history and theoretical scope of degeneracy allows its usefulness to be better appreciated, its coherency to be further developed, and its application to be more quickly realized.

[1]  H. Reddel,et al.  Treating according to asthma control: does it work in real life? , 2012, Clinics in chest medicine.

[2]  G Tononi,et al.  Measures of degeneracy and redundancy in biological networks. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[3]  Paul H. Mason,et al.  Intracultural and intercultural dynamics of Capoeira training in Brazil , 2013 .

[4]  W M Mitchell.  A model for protein biosynthesis predicated on the concept of metastable states: a postulated role for genetic code degeneracy. , 1968, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[5]  Jaehoon Yeon,et al.  Korean: A Comprehensive Grammar , 2011 .

[6]  G W Siskind,et al.  Degeneracy of antibody specificity. , 1983, Journal of immunology.

[7]  Mary-Jo DelVecchio Good,et al.  Picturing Personhood: Brain Scans and Biomedical Identity , 2005 .

[8]  Liao Fu Luo.  The degeneracy rule of genetic code , 2005, Origins of life and evolution of the biosphere.

[9]  Sven Grawunder,et al.  The phonetic profile of Korean formal and informal speech registers , 2012, J. Phonetics.

[10]  Marcus Perlman,et al.  Iconic pitch expresses vertical space , 2013 .

[11]  Ludovic Seifert,et al.  Neurobiological degeneracy: supporting stability, flexibility and pluripotentiality in complex motor skill. , 2015, Acta psychologica.

[12]  S. Gaulin,et al.  Men's voices as dominance signals: vocal fundamental and formant frequencies influence dominance attributions among men , 2007 .

[13]  Ronald R. Grunstein,et al.  Drug effects on ventilatory control and upper airway physiology related to sleep apnea , 2013, Respiratory Physiology & Neurobiology.

[14]  S. Sacre,et al.  Emerging Role of Endosomal Toll-Like Receptors in Rheumatoid Arthritis , 2013, Front. Immunol..

[15]  S. Benzer,et al.  A DEMONSTRATION OF CODING DEGENERACY FOR LEUCINE IN THE SYNTHESIS OF PROTEIN. , 1965, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[16]  Sian Barris,et al.  Increasing Functional Variability in the Preparatory Phase of the Takeoff Improves Elite Springboard Diving Performance , 2014, Research quarterly for exercise and sport.

[17]  Lasse Vinner,et al.  A polyvalent influenza A DNA vaccine induces heterologous immunity and protects pigs against pandemic A(H1N1)pdm09 virus infection. , 2013, Vaccine.

[18]  Ronald R Grunstein,et al.  Phenotyping interindividual variability in obstructive sleep apnoea response to temazepam using ventilatory chemoreflexes during wakefulness , 2011, Journal of sleep research.

[19]  Nigel Curtis,et al.  Non-specific effect of Bacille Calmette-Guérin vaccine on the immune response to routine immunisations. , 2013, Vaccine.

[20]  Gregory G. King,et al.  Ventilation heterogeneity is associated with airway responsiveness in asthma but not COPD , 2013, Respiratory Physiology & Neurobiology.

[21]  H. Eisen,et al.  Specificity and degeneracy in antigen recognition: yin and yang in the immune system. , 2001, Annual review of immunology.

[22]  Paul H. Mason.  The Choreomusicology of self-accompanied and musician-accompanied plate-dancing in West Sumatra , 2013 .

[23]  Raymond M. Welsh,et al.  No one is naive: the significance of heterologous T-cell immunity , 2002, Nature Reviews Immunology.

[24]  Bodo Winter.  Spoken language achieves robustness and evolvability by exploiting degeneracy and neutrality , 2014, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[25]  R T Damian,et al.  Parasite immune evasion and exploitation: reflections and projections , 1997, Parasitology.

[26]  G Schöner,et al.  A synergetic theory of quadrupedal gaits and gait transitions. , 1990, Journal of theoretical biology.

[27]  G. Fricchione.  Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason and the Human Brain , 1995 .

[28]  Soldano Ferrone,et al.  A Degenerate HLA-DR Epitope Pool of HER-2/neu Reveals a Novel In vivo Immunodominant Epitope, HER-2/neu88-102 , 2010, Clinical Cancer Research.

[29]  Tao Pan,et al.  Environmental perturbations lift the degeneracy of the genetic code to regulate protein levels in bacteria , 2012 .

[30]  Sang Joon Kim,et al.  A Mathematical Theory of Communication , 2006 .

[31]  G. Edelman,et al.  Degeneracy and complexity in biological systems , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[32]  A. Malhotra,et al.  Defining phenotypic causes of obstructive sleep apnea. Identification of novel therapeutic targets. , 2013, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[33]  K. Jacobson,et al.  EVIDENCE FOR DEGENERACY AND AMBIGUITY IN INTERSPECIES AMINOACYL-SRNA FORMATION. , 1964, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[34]  Ralph J. Greenspan,et al.  Biological Indeterminacy , 2012, Science and Engineering Ethics.

[35]  M. A. Gray,et al.  Prefrontal activity in Huntington's disease reflects cognitive and neuropsychiatric disturbances: The IMAGE-HD study , 2013, Experimental Neurology.

[36]  Bodo Winter,et al.  Phonetics and politeness: Perceiving Korean honorific and non-honorific speech through phonetic cues , 2014 .

[37]  Axel Bender,et al.  Degeneracy: a design principle for achieving robustness and evolvability. , 2009, Journal of theoretical biology.

[38]  A. Rich,et al.  Formation of a DNA-soluble RNA hybrid and its relation to the origin, evolution, and degeneracy of soluble RNA. , 1962, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[39]  Marlene Johansson Falck,et al.  Iconic Prosody in Story Reading , 2015, Cogn. Sci..

[40]  Peter Aaby,et al.  Non-specific effects of standard measles vaccine at 4.5 and 9 months of age on childhood mortality: randomised controlled trial , 2010, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[41]  Sian Barris,et al.  Do the kinematics of a baulked take-off in springboard diving differ from those of a completed dive , 2013, Journal of sports sciences.

[42]  Gabrielle Hodge,et al.  Points, Depictions, Gestures and Enactment: Partly Lexical and Non-Lexical Signs as Core Elements of Single Clause-Like Units in Auslan (Australian Sign Language)* , 2014 .

[43]  Paolo Tieri,et al.  Network, degeneracy and bow tie. Integrating paradigms and architectures to grasp the complexity of the immune system , 2010, Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling.

[44]  Y Ben-Shlomo,et al.  Heterogeneity of Parkinson's disease. , 2006, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[45]  Ryszard Maleszka,et al.  Contrasting Effects of Histone Deacetylase Inhibitors on Reward and Aversive Olfactory Memories in the Honey Bee , 2014, Insects.

[46]  J. A. Scott Kelso,et al.  Multistability and metastability: understanding dynamic coordination in the brain , 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[47]  K. Davids,et al.  Neurobiological Degeneracy and Affordance Perception Support Functional Intra-Individual Variability of Inter-Limb Coordination during Ice Climbing , 2014, PloS one.

[48]  T Alvager,et al.  On the information content of the genetic code. , 1989, Bio Systems.

[49]  R. N. Ohde,et al.  Fundamental frequency as an acoustic correlate of stop consonant voicing. , 1984, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[50]  Paul H. Mason,et al.  Degeneracy: Demystifying and destigmatizing a core concept in systems biology , 2015, Complex..

[51]  L. Boulet,et al.  The revised 2014 GINA strategy report: opportunities for change , 2015, Current opinion in pulmonary medicine.

[52]  Clemencia Pinilla,et al.  Specificity and degeneracy of T cells. , 2004, Molecular immunology.

[53]  Kenneth N. Stevens,et al.  Quantal theory, enhancement and overlap , 2010, J. Phonetics.

[54]  Alexander Johnson.  Concerning a Form of Degeneracy. I. The Condition and Increase of the Feeble-Minded , 1898, American Journal of Sociology.

[55]  D W TALMAGE,et al.  Immunological Specificity , 1959, Science.

[56]  C. Kurland,et al.  Evolution of mitochondrial genomes and the genetic code. , 1992, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[57]  O. Sporns.  Networks of the Brain , 2010 .

[58]  G. Edelman.  The Problem of Molecular Recognition by a Selective System , 1974 .

[59]  E. Sercarz,et al.  Degenerate recognition of a dissimilar antigenic peptide by myelin basic protein-reactive T cells. Implications for thymic education and autoimmunity. , 1993, Journal of immunology.

[60]  Klaus R. Scherer,et al.  Vocal communication of emotion: A review of research paradigms , 2003, Speech Commun..

[61]  Francis Crick,et al.  On Degenerate Templates and the Adaptor Hypothesis: A Note for the RNA Tie Club , 1955 .

[62]  J. Kelso,et al.  A Dynamical Basis for Action Systems , 1984 .

[63]  G Tononi,et al.  Theoretical neuroanatomy: relating anatomical and functional connectivity in graphs and cortical connection matrices. , 2000, Cerebral cortex.

[64]  Jennifer S. Pardo,et al.  Perceiving the causes of coarticulatory acoustic variation: Consonant voicing and vowel pitch , 1997, Perception & psychophysics.

[65]  C. Gussenhoven.  The phonology of tone and intonation , 2004 .

[66]  G Tononi,et al.  A complexity measure for selective matching of signals by the brain. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[67]  Anthony Leonardo,et al.  Degenerate coding in neural systems , 2005, Journal of Comparative Physiology A.

[68]  John J. Ohala,et al.  Explaining the intrinsic pitch of vowels , 1976 .

[69]  Sarah Hawkins,et al.  Phonological features, auditory objects, and illusions , 2010, J. Phonetics.

[70]  M. Larché,et al.  Allergen isoforms for immunotherapy: diversity, degeneracy and promiscuity , 1999, Clinical and experimental allergy : journal of the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology.

[71]  Joann Wheeler Kealiinohomoku.  Dance and Self-Accompaniment , 1965 .

[72]  M. A. Gray,et al.  Automated differentiation of pre-diagnosis Huntington's disease from healthy control individuals based on quadratic discriminant analysis of the basal ganglia: The IMAGE-HD study , 2013, Neurobiology of Disease.

[73]  Raymond M. Welsh,et al.  CD4 T-Cell-Mediated Heterologous Immunity between Mycobacteria and Poxviruses , 2009, Journal of Virology.

[74]  Robert Busch,et al.  High Degeneracy of HLA DR-Peptide Interactions: Possible Ramifications for Vaccine Design , 1989 .

[75]  E. Hall,et al.  The Hidden Dimension , 1970 .

[76]  Melvin Cohn,et al.  Degeneracy, mimicry and crossreactivity in immune recognition. , 2005, Molecular immunology.

[77]  Fabio Sambataro,et al.  Default-mode network changes in preclinical Huntington's disease , 2012, Experimental Neurology.

[78]  Richard Grantham,et al.  Working of the genetic code , 1980 .

[79]  H. Eisen,et al.  Degeneracy in the secondary immune response: stimulation of antibody formation by cross-reacting antigens. , 1969, Israel journal of medical sciences.

[80]  G. Edelman,et al.  A Universe Of Consciousness: How Matter Becomes Imagination , 2000 .

[81]  Ronald W. Davis,et al.  Role of duplicate genes in genetic robustness against null mutations , 2003, Nature.

[82]  Barnett We,et al.  EVIDENCE FOR DEGENERACY AND AMBIGUITY IN INTERSPECIES AMINOACYL-SRNA FORMATION. , 1964 .

[83]  F H C Crick.  On Degenerate Templjates and the Adaptor Hypothesis , .

[84]  Christopher Lawrence,et al.  Degeneration under the Microscope at the fin se siècle , 2009, Annals of science.

[85]  Olaf Sporns,et al.  The Human Connectome: A Structural Description of the Human Brain , 2005, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[86]  K. Kohler.  F₀ in the Production of Lenis and Fortis Plosives , 1982, Phonetica.

[87]  Andrew Sangpil Byon.  Korean honorifics and politeness in second language learning , 2012 .

[88]  K. Morton,et al.  Expression in Speech: Analysis and Synthesis , 2003 .

[89]  S. Frank,et al.  Genetic variation of polygenic characters and the evolution of genetic degeneracy , 2003, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[90]  Paul H. Mason,et al.  Tapping the Plate or Hitting the Bottle: Sound and Movement in Self-accompanied and Musician-accompanied Dance , 2014 .

[91]  Joachim L Schultze,et al.  Degeneracy instead of specificity: is this a solution to cancer immunotherapy? , 2002, Trends in immunology.

[92]  Maninder Singh Setia,et al.  The role of BCG in prevention of leprosy: a meta-analysis. , 2006, The Lancet. Infectious diseases.

[93]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Structural and Functional Brain Networks: From Connections to Cognition , 2013, Science.

[94]  Chengjin Huang,et al.  Dual-subtype feline immunodeficiency virus vaccine provides 12 months of protective immunity against heterologous challenge , 2010, Journal of feline medicine and surgery.

[95]  A. Mehrabian.  Significance of posture and posiion in the communication of attitude and status relationships. , 1969, Psychological bulletin.

[96]  John Kingston,et al.  Phonetic Knowledge , 2015 .

[97]  James M. Whitacre,et al.  Degeneracy allows for both apparent homogeneity and diversification in populations , 2012, Biosyst..

[98]  Govinda R. Poudel,et al.  Multi-Modal Neuroimaging in Premanifest and Early Huntington’s Disease: 18 Month Longitudinal Data from the IMAGE-HD Study , 2013, PloS one.

[99]  Ronald R Grunstein,et al.  Obstructive sleep apnoea: does one treatment not fit all? , 2014, The Lancet. Respiratory medicine.

[100]  Rajiv Khanna,et al.  Promiscuous CTL Recognition of Viral Epitopes on Multiple Human Leukocyte Antigens: Biological Validation of the Proposed HLA A24 Supertype 1 , 2003, The Journal of Immunology.

[101]  Kim E. A. Silverman,et al.  Vowel Intrinsic Pitch in Connected Speech , 1984 .

[102]  Christof Koch,et al.  The Minimal Complexity of Adapting Agents Increases with Fitness , 2012, ALIFE.

[103]  D. M. Hutton,et al.  Coding and Redundancy: Man‐made and Animal‐evolved Signals , 2009 .

[104]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Degeneracy and cognitive anatomy , 2002, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[105]  Ohad Parnes,et al.  From interception to incorporation: degeneracy and promiscuous recognition as precursors of a paradigm shift in immunology. , 2004, Molecular immunology.

[106]  Freek Van de Velde,et al.  Degeneracy: the maintenance of constructional networks , 2012 .

[107]  J. Dempsey,et al.  Physiology in medicine: obstructive sleep apnea pathogenesis and treatment--considerations beyond airway anatomy. , 2014, Journal of applied physiology.

[108]  E. Mayr,et al.  Population thinking and neuronal selection: metaphors or concepts? , 1994, International review of neurobiology.

[109]  G. Downey.  CULTURAL VARIATION IN RUGBY SKILLS: A PRELIMINARY NEUROANTHROPOLOGICAL REPORT , 2012 .

[110]  M Cohn,et al.  The wisdom of hindsight. , 1994, Annual review of immunology.

[111]  Paul H. Mason,et al.  Degeneracy at Multiple Levels of Complexity , 2010 .

[112]  Julie C Stout,et al.  Functional magnetic resonance imaging of working memory in Huntington's disease: Cross‐sectional data from the IMAGE‐HD study , 2014, Human brain mapping.

[113]  Andrew B. Barron,et al.  Epigenomics and the concept of degeneracy in biological systems , 2013, Briefings in functional genomics.

[114]  J A Scott Kelso,et al.  Synergies: atoms of brain and behavior. , 2009, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[115]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Degenerate neuronal systems sustaining cognitive functions , 2004, Journal of anatomy.

[116]  J. Slack.  Topobiology: An introduction to molecular embryology G. M. Edelman. Basic Books, New York (1988), 240 pp. price $69.50 , 1991, Neuroscience.

[117]  Robert Kucharski,et al.  Insights into DNA hydroxymethylation in the honeybee from in-depth analyses of TET dioxygenase , 2014, Open Biology.

[118]  Phillip M Devlin,et al.  The history of the smallpox vaccine. , 2006, The Journal of infection.

[119]  T. M. Harding.  17. Degeneracy of Vaccine Lymph by Frequent Transmission.???On this subject the most contradictory opinions have been expressed , 1866 .

[120]  R. Symons,et al.  Experimental Evidence for the Degeneracy of the Nucleotide Triplet Code , 1962, Nature.

[121]  Michael Lachmann,et al.  Evolution of Genetic Potential , 2005, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[122]  Paul H. Mason,et al.  Music, dance and the total art work: choreomusicology in theory and practice , 2012 .

[123]  Joana Sequeira-Mendes,et al.  On the opportunistic nature of transcription and replication initiation in the metazoan genome , 2012, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[124]  Jean-Luc Jestin,et al.  A rationale for the symmetries by base substitutions of degeneracy in the genetic code , 2010, Biosyst..

[125]  Gerhard Werner,et al.  Metastability, criticality and phase transitions in brain and its models , 2007, Biosyst..

[126]  K L Flanagan,et al.  Heterologous ("nonspecific") and sex-differential effects of vaccines: epidemiology, clinical trials, and emerging immunologic mechanisms. , 2013, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[127]  A. Tartar,et al.  Confronting the degeneracy of convergent combinatorial immunogens, or 'mixotopes', with the specificity of recognition of the target sequences. , 1997, Vaccine.

[128]  Greg Downey,et al.  Listening to Capoeira: Phenomenology, Embodiment, and the Materiality of Music , 2002 .

[129]  Herman N. Eisen,et al.  SPECIFICITY OF THE IMMUNE RESPONSE TO THE 2, 4-DINITROPHENYL AND 2, 4, 6-TRINITROPHENYL GROUPS , 1969, The Journal of experimental medicine.

[130]  S. Sapir.  The intrinsic pitch of vowels: Theoretical, physiological, and clinical considerations , 1989 .

[131]  James M. Whitacre,et al.  Degeneracy: a link between evolvability, robustness and complexity in biological systems , 2009, Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling.

[132]  Ho-min Sohn,et al.  The Korean language , 1999 .

[133]  Chelsea D Specht,et al.  Adaptation in flower form: a comparative evodevo approach. , 2015, The New phytologist.

[134]  S. Benzer,et al.  A phsyical basis for degeneracy in the amino acid code. , 1962, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[135]  Tianhai Tian,et al.  The origins of cancer robustness and evolvability. , 2011, Integrative biology : quantitative biosciences from nano to macro.

[136]  Gregory G King,et al.  The relationship between airflow obstruction, emphysema extent, and small airways function in COPD. , 2012, Chest.

[137]  Franco Celada,et al.  Heterologous immunity: Immunopathology, autoimmunity and protection during viral infections , 2011, Autoimmunity.

[138]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Degeneracy and redundancy in cognitive anatomy , 2003, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[139]  Yoav Vardy,et al.  The Alzheimer conundrum: Entanglements of dementia and aging , 2015, Global public health.

[140]  Ludovic Seifert,et al.  Key Properties of Expert Movement Systems in Sport , 2013, Sports Medicine.

[141]  R. M. Siegel,et al.  Bright Air, Brilliant Fire: On the Matter of the Mind , 1992 .

[142]  Uri Hershberg,et al.  Antigen-receptor degeneracy and immunological paradigms. , 2004, Molecular immunology.

[143]  Kerstin M. Mueller.  Neural Darwinism The Theory Of Neuronal Group Selection , 2016 .

[144]  S. Gaulin,et al.  Dominance and the evolution of sexual dimorphism in human voice pitch , 2006 .

[145]  D. Mason,et al.  A very high level of crossreactivity is an essential feature of the T-cell receptor. , 1998, Immunology today.

[146]  Paolo Garagnani,et al.  Towards a Liquid Self: How Time, Geography, and Life Experiences Reshape the Biological Identity , 2014, Front. Immunol..

[147]  G. Edelman.  Biochemistry and the Sciences of Recognition , 2004, Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[148]  Marcus Perlman,et al.  Talking Fast: The Use of Speech Rate as Iconic Gesture , 2008 .