Modern analogy, cultural theory and experimental replication: a merging point at the cutting edge of archaeology

Abstract An experimental approach to cut-mark investigation has proved particularly successful and should arguably be a prerequisite for individuals interested in developing standard methods to study butchery data. This paper offers a brief review of the criteria used to investigate cut marks and subsequently outlines recent research that has integrated results from replication studies of archaeological tools and cut marks with written resources to study historic butchery practices. The case is made for a degree of standardization to be incorporated into the recording of butchery data and for the integration of evidence from the analysis of cut marks and tool signatures. While the call for standardization is not without precedent the process would benefit from a suitable model: one is proposed herein based in large part on experimental replication and personal vocational experience gained in the modern butchery trade. Furthermore, the paper identifies issues that need to be kept at the forefront of an experimental approach to butchery investigation and places emphasis on the use of modern analogy and cultural theory as a means of improving our interpretation of cut-mark data.

[1]  George C. Frison,et al.  Experimental Use of Clovis Weaponry and Tools on African Elephants , 1989, American Antiquity.

[2]  A. Outram A New Approach to Identifying Bone Marrow and Grease Exploitation: Why the “Indeterminate” Fragments should not be Ignored , 2001 .

[3]  T J U Thompson,et al.  Recent advances in the study of burned bone and their implications for forensic anthropology. , 2004, Forensic science international.

[4]  William Andrefsky Lithics: Macroscopic Approaches to Analysis , 1999 .

[5]  S. Hurlbut The taphonomy of cannibalism: a review of anthropogenic bone modification in the American Southwest , 2000 .

[6]  R. Lyman 5 – Archaeofaunas and Butchery Studies: A Taphonomic Perspective , 1987 .

[7]  K. Seetah A ZOOARCHAEOLOGICAL CONTRIBUTION TO BIOLOGICAL ANTHROPOLOGY: WORKING TOWARDS A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF CUT MARKS AND BUTCHERY , 2007 .

[8]  D. Rixson Butchery evidence on animal bones , 1989 .

[9]  N. Fiddes Meat, a natural symbol , 1991 .

[10]  Ernest L. Sabine Butchering in Mediaeval London , 1933, Speculum.

[11]  Louise H J van Wijngaarden-Bakker,et al.  Replication of butchering marks on pig mandibles , 1990 .

[12]  Phillip L. Walker,et al.  Butchering and Stone Tool Function , 1978, American Antiquity.

[13]  V. Smil Eating Meat: Evolution, Patterns, and Consequences , 2002 .

[14]  G. Bar-Oz,et al.  Gazelle bone marrow yields and Epipalaeolithic carcass exploitation strategies in the southern Levant , 2007 .

[15]  A. Outram,et al.  Meat and Marrow Utility Indices for Horse (Equus) , 1998 .

[16]  T. Thompson The Assessment of Sex in Cremated Individuals: Some Cautionary Notes , 2002 .

[17]  Jean L. Hudson From bones to behavior : ethnoarchaeological and experimental contributions to the interpretation of faunal remains , 1993 .

[18]  Hélène Wallaert-Pêtre Learning How to Make the Right Pots: Apprenticeship Strategies and Material Culture, a Case Study in Handmade Pottery from Cameroon , 2001, Journal of Anthropological Research.

[19]  M. D. Russell Mortuary practices at the Krapina Neandertal site. , 1987, American journal of physical anthropology.

[20]  Alan K. Outram,et al.  Bone fracture and within-bone nutrients: an experimentally based method for investigating levels of marrow extraction , 2002 .

[21]  H. Greenfield The Origins of Metallurgy in the Central Balkans based on the Analysis of Cut Marks on Animal Bones , 2000 .

[22]  Priscilla Parkhurst Ferguson,et al.  What's cooking? , 1995 .

[23]  Isabelle Théry-Parisot,et al.  Taphonomic consequences of the use of bones as fuel: experimental data and archaeological applications , 2005 .

[24]  Phillip L. Walker,et al.  An Experimental Study of the Morphological Characteristics of Tool Marks , 1977, American Antiquity.

[25]  Kildo Choi,et al.  Shell tool use by early members of Homo erectus in Sangiran, central Java, Indonesia: cut mark evidence , 2007 .

[26]  Sandra L. Olsen The identification of stone and metal toolmarks on bone artifacts , 1988 .

[27]  P. Andrews,et al.  Surface modifications of the Sima de los Huesos fossil humans. , 1997, Journal of human evolution.

[28]  Errett Callahan,et al.  Experimental Archaeology , 2021, Anthropology.

[29]  James R. Mathieu Experimental archaeology : replicating past objects, behaviors, and processes , 2002 .

[30]  A. Outram,et al.  Understanding complex fragmented assemblages of human and animal remains: a fully integrated approach , 2005 .

[31]  G. L. Isaac Archaeological Tests of Alternative Models of Early Hominid Behaviour: Excavation and Experiments , 1981 .

[32]  Katherine A. Spielmann,et al.  Energy source, protein metabolism, and hunter-gatherer subsistence strategies , 1983 .

[33]  T. E. White Observations on the Butchering Technique of Some Aboriginal Peoples: I , 1952, American Antiquity.

[34]  V. Valeri The Forest of Taboos: Morality, Hunting, and Identity among the Huaulu of the Moluccas , 2000 .

[35]  J. Savelle,et al.  Derivation and Application of an Otariid Utility Index , 1996 .

[36]  A. Grant Some observations on butchery in England from the Iron Age to the Medieval period , 1987 .

[37]  Robert Ascher,et al.  Analogy in Archaeological Interpretation , 1961, Southwestern Journal of Anthropology.

[38]  K. Seetah The Middle Ages on the Block:: Animals, Guilds and Meat in the Medieval Period , 2007 .

[39]  Julien Louys,et al.  Differentiating bamboo from stone tool cut marks in the zooarchaeological record, with a discussion on the use of bamboo knives , 2007 .

[40]  C. Marean,et al.  Blind tests of inter-analyst correspondence and accuracy in the identification of cut marks, percussion marks and carnivore tooth marks on bone surfaces , 1996 .

[41]  H. Greenfield The Origins of Metallurgy: Distinguishing Stone from Metal Cut-marks on Bones from Archaeological Sites , 1999 .

[42]  Andrew Wilson Practical meat inspection , 1968 .

[43]  Richard L. Fishel Lithics , 2003, Encyclopedic Dictionary of Archaeology.

[44]  J. Bourdillon Of Butchers and Breeds: Report on Vertebrate Remains from Various Sites in the City of Lincoln. By K. M. Dobney, S. D. Jaques and B. G. Irving , 1998 .

[45]  M. Collins,et al.  A practical approach to the identification of low temperature heated bone using TEM , 2003 .

[46]  S. Billington Butchers and Fishmongers: Their Historical Contribution to London's Festivity , 1990 .

[47]  R. Lewin Protohuman activity etched in fossil bones. , 1981, Science.

[48]  S. Ambrose Paleolithic Technology and Human Evolution , 2001, Science.

[49]  Haskel J Greenfield,et al.  Distinguishing Metal (Steel and Low-Tin Bronze) from Stone (Flint and Obsidian) Tool Cut Marks on Bone: An Experimental Approach , 2002 .

[50]  J. Maria Festive Meals in the Late Middle Ages. An Essay on Dining as a Means of Communication , 2003 .

[51]  Nerissa Russell,et al.  Relative frequency of butchering cutmarks produced by obsidian and flint: an experimental approach , 2007 .

[52]  J. Yellen Cultural patterning in faunal remains: evidence from the !Kung bushmen , 1977 .

[53]  L. Aiello,et al.  The Expensive-Tissue Hypothesis: The Brain and the Digestive System in Human and Primate Evolution , 1995, Current Anthropology.

[54]  The importance of cut placement and implement signatures to butchery interpretation , 2007 .

[55]  P. Shipman,et al.  Early hominid hunting, butchering, and carcass-processing behaviors: Approaches to the fossil record , 1983 .

[56]  C. Egeland Carcass Processing Intensity and Cutmark Creation: An Experimental Approach , 2003 .

[57]  P. Villa,et al.  Blade technology and tool forms in the Middle Stone Age of South Africa: the Howiesons Poort and post-Howiesons Poort at Rose Cottage Cave , 2007 .

[58]  R. F. Tylecote,et al.  The early history of metallurgy in Europe , 1987 .

[59]  T. E. White A Method of Calculating the Dietary Percentage of Various Food Animals Utilized by Aboriginal Peoples , 1953, American Antiquity.

[60]  J. Savelle,et al.  An Odontocete (Cetacea) Meat Utility Index , 1996 .

[61]  T. E. White The Study of Osteological Materials in the Plains , 1956, American Antiquity.

[62]  Hind Sadek-Kooros Primitive Bone Fracturing: A Method of Research , 1972, American Antiquity.

[63]  P. Shipman Applications of Scanning Electron Microscopy to Taphonomic Problems * , 1981, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[64]  S. Varela,et al.  De-mystifying Pottery Production in the Maya Lowlands: Detection of Traces of Use-Wear on Pottery Sherds through Microscopic Analysis and Experimental Replication , 2002 .

[65]  K. Hawkes,et al.  Hadza Hunting, Butchering, and Bone Transport and Their Archaeological Implications , 1988, Journal of Anthropological Research.

[66]  P. Stone,et al.  The Constructed Past: experimental archaeology, education and the public , 1999 .

[67]  Sandra Montón Subías Cooking in Zooarchaeology: Is This Issue Still Raw? , 2008 .

[68]  Michael J. Rogers,et al.  Cutmarked bones from Pliocene archaeological sites at Gona, Afar, Ethiopia: implications for the function of the world's oldest stone tools. , 2005, Journal of human evolution.

[69]  Jonathan Brumberg-Kraus Meat-Eating and Jewish Identity: Ritualization of the Priestly “Torah of Beast and Fowl” (Lev 11:46) in Rabbinic Judaism and Medieval Kabbalah , 1999, AJS Review.

[70]  D. Degusta Fijian cannibalism: osteological evidence from Navatu. , 1999, American journal of physical anthropology.

[71]  J. Brink Fat Content in Leg Bones ofBison bison, and Applications to Archaeology , 1997 .

[72]  Peter Jones Experimental butchery with modern stone tools and its relevance for Palaeolithic archaeology , 1980 .

[73]  A. Hill Butchery and Natural Disarticulation: An Investigatory Technique , 1979, American Antiquity.