Marketplace or Reseller?

Intermediaries can choose between functioning as a marketplace in which suppliers sell their products directly to buyers or as a reseller by purchasing products from suppliers and selling them to buyers. We model this as a decision between whether control rights over a noncontractible decision variable the choice of some marketing activity are better held by suppliers the marketplace mode or by the intermediary the reseller mode. Whether the marketplace or the reseller mode is preferred depends on whether independent suppliers or the intermediary have more important information relevant to the optimal tailoring of marketing activities for each specific product. We show that this trade-off is shifted toward the reseller mode when marketing activities create spillovers across products and when network effects lead to unfavorable expectations about supplier participation. If the reseller has a variable cost advantage respectively, disadvantage relative to the marketplace, then the trade-off is shifted toward the marketplace for long-tail respectively, short-tail products. We thus provide a theory of which products an intermediary should offer in each mode. We also provide some empirical evidence that supports our main results. Data, as supplemental material, are available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2014.2042 . This paper was accepted by Bruno Cassiman, business strategy.