Counterfactuals and Undefinedness: Homogeneity vs. Supervaluations

Theories of counterfactuals agree on appealing to a relation of comparative similarity, but disagree on the quantificational force of counterfactuals. We report on two experiments testing the predictions of three main approaches: universal theories, homogeneity theories, and single-world selection theories (plus supervaluations over selection functions). The critical cases in our experiment were constructed so as to discriminate between the three theories. Our results provide empirical support for the selectional theories, while challenging the other two approaches.

[1]  Florian Schwarz,et al.  False but Slow: Evaluating Statements with Non-referring Definites , 2015, J. Semant..

[2]  Stefan Kaufmann,et al.  The Limit Assumption , 2017 .

[3]  R. Folli,et al.  The abundance inference of pluralised mass nouns is an implicature: Evidence from Greek , 2018, Glossa: a journal of general linguistics.

[4]  K. Fine.  Vagueness, truth and logic , 1975, Synthese.

[5]  Márta Abrusán,et al.  Experimenting with the King of France , 2011, Amsterdam Colloquium on Logic, Language and Meaning.

[6]  Sam Alxatib,et al.  On the Psychology of Truth-Gaps , 2009, ViC.

[7]  Philippe Schlenker,et al.  Conditionals as Definite Descriptions , 2004 .

[8]  Matthew Mandelkern,et al.  Dissatisfaction theory , 2016 .

[9]  Mikael Olsson.  Conditionals , 2018, Modern C Quick Syntax Reference.

[10]  Robert Stalnaker.  A Theory of Conditionals , 2019, Knowledge and Conditionals.

[11]  Anthony S. Gillies,et al.  Counterfactual scorekeeping , 2007 .

[12]  Kai von Fintel,et al.  NPI Licensing, Strawson Entailment, and Context Dependency , 1999, J. Semant..

[13]  Moshe E. Bar-Lev,et al.  An Implicature account of Homogeneity and Non-maximality , 2020, Linguistics and Philosophy.

[14]  E. Chemla,et al.  Two methods to find truth-value gaps and their application to the projection problem of homogeneity , 2015 .

[15]  Donald Nute,et al.  Counterfactuals , 1975, Notre Dame J. Formal Log..

[16]  David Lewis.  Counterfactuals and Comparative Possibility , 1973 .

[17]  Elizabeth Barnes,et al.  A Theory of Metaphysical Indeterminacy , 2011 .

[18]  David Lewis.  Counterfactual Dependence and Time's Arrow , 1979 .

[19]  Nathan Klinedinst,et al.  Quantified Conditionals and Conditional Excluded Middle , 2011, J. Semant..

[20]  Robert Stalnaker.  A Defense of Conditional Excluded Middle , 1980 .

[21]  B. R. George,et al.  Presupposition Repairs : a Static , Trivalent Approach to Predicting Projection ∗ , 2008 .

[22]  Richard Zach,et al.  Vagueness, Logic and Use: Four Experimental Studies on Vagueness , 2011 .

[23]  David Ripley,et al.  Contradictions at the Borders , 2009, ViC.

[24]  Danny Fox,et al.  Presupposition projection from quantificational sentences: trivalence, local accommodation, and presupposition strengthening , 2013 .

[25]  Manuel Kriz,et al.  Aspects of homogeneity in the semantics of natural language , 2015 .

[26]  Kai von Fintel,et al.  Bare Plurals, Bare Conditionals, and Only , 1997, J. Semant..

[27]  Emmanuel Chemla,et al.  Phantom readings: the case of modified numerals , 2015 .

[28]  Moshe E. Bar-Lev,et al.  A unified existential semantics for bare conditionals 1 , 2017 .

[29]  David Kaplan.  Demonstratives: An Essay on the Semantics, Logic, Metaphysics and Epistemology of Demonstratives and other Indexicals , 1989 .

[30]  Lucas Champollion,et al.  Donkeys under discussion , 2019, Semantics and Pragmatics.

[31]  K. Maier.  INQUIRY , 2007 .