Filter Effects and Filter Artifacts in the Analysis of Electrophysiological Data

In a recent review, VanRullen (2011) concludes that electrophysiological data should not be filtered at all when one is interested in the temporal dynamics or onset latencies of the electrophysiological responses. This conclusion was based on the observation that response onset latency was “smeared out in time for several tens or even hundreds of milliseconds” (p. 6) in a simulated dataset. It is correct that any band limitation in the frequency domain necessarily affects the signal in the time domain resulting in reduced precision and artifacts (cf. e.g., Luck, 2005). Nevertheless, here, we will discuss that the problem is overestimated by about an order of magnitude by the assumptions and analysis parameters used in VanRullen's simulated dataset and advertise the cautious usage of carefully designed filters to be able to also detect small signals.