Statistical Approaches Used to Assess the Equity of Access to Food Outlets: A Systematic Review

Background Inequalities in eating behaviours are often linked to the types of food retailers accessible in neighbourhood environments. Numerous studies have aimed to identify if access to healthy and unhealthy food retailers is socioeconomically patterned across neighbourhoods, and thus a potential risk factor for dietary inequalities. Existing reviews have examined differences between methodologies, particularly focussing on neighbourhood and food outlet access measure definitions. However, no review has informatively discussed the suitability of the statistical methodologies employed; a key issue determining the validity of study findings. Our aim was to examine the suitability of statistical approaches adopted in these analyses. Methods Searches were conducted for articles published from 2000–2014. Eligible studies included objective measures of the neighbourhood food environment and neighbourhood-level socio-economic status, with a statistical analysis of the association between food outlet access and socio-economic status. Results Fifty-four papers were included. Outlet accessibility was typically defined as the distance to the nearest outlet from the neighbourhood centroid, or as the number of food outlets within a neighbourhood (or buffer). To assess if these measures were linked to neighbourhood disadvantage, common statistical methods included ANOVA, correlation, and Poisson or negative binomial regression. Although all studies involved spatial data, few considered spatial analysis techniques or spatial autocorrelation. Conclusions With advances in GIS software, sophisticated measures of neighbourhood outlet accessibility can be considered. However, approaches to statistical analysis often appear less sophisticated. Care should be taken to consider assumptions underlying the analysis and the possibility of spatially correlated residuals which could affect the results.

[1]  R. Bivand Spatial Dependence: Weighting Schemes, Statistics and Models , 2015 .

[2]  K. Lamb,et al.  Categorisation of built environment characteristics: the trouble with tertiles , 2015, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[3]  G. Moon,et al.  Dietary inequalities: what is the evidence for the effect of the neighbourhood food environment? , 2014, Health & place.

[4]  C. Dormann,et al.  Accounting for geographical variation in species–area relationships improves the prediction of plant species richness at the global scale , 2014 .

[5]  D. Gaskin,et al.  The intersection of neighborhood racial segregation, poverty, and urbanicity and its impact on food store availability in the United States. , 2014, Preventive medicine.

[6]  Andrew M. Liebhold,et al.  A highly aggregated geographical distribution of forest pest invasions in the USA , 2013 .

[7]  S. Alvanides,et al.  Creating ‘obesogenic realities’; do our methodological choices make a difference when measuring the food environment? , 2013, International Journal of Health Geographics.

[8]  Hua Peng,et al.  Creating and Managing Spatial-Weighting Matrices with the Spmat Command , 2013 .

[9]  David M. Drukker,et al.  Maximum Likelihood and Generalized Spatial Two-Stage Least-Squares Estimators for a Spatial-Autoregressive Model with Spatial-Autoregressive Disturbances , 2013 .

[10]  T. Creighton,et al.  Deprivation and food access and balance in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. , 2013, Chronic diseases and injuries in Canada.

[11]  L. Gauvin,et al.  Comparison of Two Indices of Availability of Fruits/Vegetable and Fast Food Outlets , 2013, Journal of Urban Health.

[12]  Jina Jun,et al.  Social inequalities in neighborhood conditions: spatial relationships between sociodemographic and food environments in Alameda County, California , 2012 .

[13]  Marie-Soleil Cloutier,et al.  Classifying neighbourhoods by level of access to stores selling fresh fruit and vegetables and groceries: identifying problematic areas in the city of Gatineau, Quebec. , 2012, Canadian journal of public health = Revue canadienne de sante publique.

[14]  J. Lee,et al.  Food deserts in Leon County, FL: disparate distribution of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program-accepting stores by neighborhood characteristics. , 2012, Journal of nutrition education and behavior.

[15]  Candice R. Luebbering,et al.  Does availability of physical activity and food outlets differ by race and income? Findings from an enumeration study in a health disparate region , 2012, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[16]  Christian Ducrot,et al.  Why Did Bluetongue Spread the Way It Did? Environmental Factors Influencing the Velocity of Bluetongue Virus Serotype 8 Epizootic Wave in France , 2012, PloS one.

[17]  C. Saurina,et al.  Does the effect of gender modify the relationship between deprivation and mortality? , 2012, BMC Public Health.

[18]  A. Hilmers,et al.  Neighborhood disparities in access to healthy foods and their effects on environmental justice. , 2012, American journal of public health.

[19]  Johannes Gruber,et al.  Neighbourhood deprivation and outlet density for tobacco, alcohol and fast food: first hints of obesogenic and addictive environments in Germany , 2012, Public Health Nutrition.

[20]  D. Ogilvie,et al.  Sociospatial distribution of access to facilities for moderate and vigorous intensity physical activity in Scotland by different modes of transport , 2012, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[21]  A. Leyland,et al.  Neighbourhood food and physical activity environments in England, UK: does ethnic density matter? , 2012, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[22]  B. Popkin,et al.  Are neighbourhood food resources distributed inequitably by income and race in the USA? Epidemiological findings across the urban spectrum , 2012, BMJ Open.

[23]  J. Schuetz,et al.  Bodegas or Bagel Shops? Neighborhood Differences in Retail and Household Services , 2012 .

[24]  D. Ogilvie,et al.  Recreational physical activity facilities within walking and cycling distance: sociospatial patterning of access in Scotland. , 2011, Health & place.

[25]  Fahui Wang,et al.  Geographic Disparities in Accessibility to Food Stores in Southwest Mississippi , 2011 .

[26]  Nathanael Lauster,et al.  Exploring the distribution of food stores in British Columbia: associations with neighbourhood socio-demographic factors and urban form. , 2011, Health & place.

[27]  Lukar E Thornton,et al.  Using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to assess the role of the built environment in influencing obesity: a glossary , 2011, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[28]  K. Evenson,et al.  A systematic review of fast food access studies , 2011, Obesity reviews : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity.

[29]  L. Powell,et al.  Supermarket and fast-food outlet exposure in Copenhagen: associations with socio-economic and demographic characteristics , 2011, Public Health Nutrition.

[30]  P. Ford,et al.  Neighborhood Deprivation, Neighborhood Acculturation, and the Retail Food Environment in a US–Mexico Border Urban Area , 2011 .

[31]  Marnie Purciel-Hill,et al.  Measuring food deserts in New York City's low-income neighborhoods. , 2011, Health & place.

[32]  Cassandra M Johnson,et al.  Focusing on fast food restaurants alone underestimates the relationship between neighborhood deprivation and exposure to fast food in a large rural area , 2011, Nutrition journal.

[33]  Lars Skog,et al.  Differences in neighborhood accessibility to health-related resources: a nationwide comparison between deprived and affluent neighborhoods in Sweden. , 2011, Health & place.

[34]  K. Lock,et al.  Investigating Environmental Determinants of Diet, Physical Activity, and Overweight among Adults in Sao Paulo, Brazil , 2011, Journal of Urban Health.

[35]  Michael D M Bader,et al.  Disparities in Neighborhood Food Environments: Implications of Measurement Strategies , 2010, Economic geography.

[36]  A. Getis The Analysis of Spatial Association by Use of Distance Statistics , 2010 .

[37]  J. Burke,et al.  Disparities and access to healthy food in the United States: A review of food deserts literature. , 2010, Health & place.

[38]  L. Lisabeth,et al.  The food environment in an urban Mexican American community. , 2010, Health & place.

[39]  L. Fraser,et al.  The Geography of Fast Food Outlets: A Review , 2010, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[40]  David Marshall,et al.  Neighbourhood food environment and area deprivation: spatial accessibility to grocery stores selling fresh fruit and vegetables in urban and rural settings. , 2010, International journal of epidemiology.

[41]  A. Ellaway,et al.  The food retail environment and area deprivation in Glasgow City, UK , 2009, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[42]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity Arterial Roads and Area Socioeconomic Status Are Predictors of Fast Food Restaurant Density in King County, Wa , 2022 .

[43]  E. Kristjansson,et al.  A Systematic Review of Food Deserts, 1966-2007 , 2009, Preventing chronic disease.

[44]  A. Timperio,et al.  Neighbourhood socioeconomic inequalities in food access and affordability. , 2009, Health & place.

[45]  Gyoungju Lee,et al.  A Spatial Statistical Approach to Identifying Areas with Poor Access to Grocery Foods in the City of Buffalo, New York , 2009 .

[46]  Y. Kestens,et al.  Demographic and urban form correlates of healthful and unhealthful food availability in Montréal, Canada. , 2009, Canadian journal of public health = Revue canadienne de sante publique.

[47]  C. Yau,et al.  Inequality in obesigenic environments: fast food density in New York City. , 2009, Health & place.

[48]  J. C. Huber,et al.  Association between neighborhood need and spatial access to food stores and fast food restaurants in neighborhoods of Colonias , 2009, International journal of health geographics.

[49]  Joanna E. Holsten,et al.  Obesity and the community food environment: a systematic review , 2008, Public Health Nutrition.

[50]  Melissa C. Nelson,et al.  Neighborhood environments: disparities in access to healthy foods in the U.S. , 2009, American journal of preventive medicine.

[51]  D. Rainham,et al.  Fast Food and Deprivation in Nova Scotia , 2009, Canadian journal of public health = Revue canadienne de sante publique.

[52]  J. Spence,et al.  The association between neighborhood socioeconomic status and exposure to supermarkets and fast food outlets. , 2008, Health & place.

[53]  Karen Witten,et al.  Regional and Urban–Rural Variations in the Association of Neighbourhood Deprivation with Community Resource Access: A National Study , 2008 .

[54]  A. Ellaway,et al.  Do poorer people have poorer access to local resources and facilities? The distribution of local resources by area deprivation in Glasgow, Scotland☆ , 2008, Social science & medicine.

[55]  J. Spence,et al.  Exploring Obesogenic Food Environments in Edmonton, Canada: The Association between Socioeconomic Factors and Fast-Food Outlet Access , 2008, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[56]  N. Berg,et al.  Access to Grocery Stores in Dallas , 2008 .

[57]  Karen Witten,et al.  Neighbourhood Provision of Food and Alcohol Retailing and Social Deprivation in Urban New Zealand , 2008 .

[58]  P. Howard,et al.  The Density of Retail Food Outlets in the Central Coast Region of California: Associations with Income and Latino Ethnic Composition , 2008 .

[59]  J. Gilliland,et al.  Mapping the evolution of 'food deserts' in a Canadian city: Supermarket accessibility in London, Ontario, 1961–2005 , 2008, International journal of health geographics.

[60]  D. Dzewaltowski,et al.  Disparities in obesity prevalence due to variation in the retail food environment: three testable hypotheses. , 2008, Nutrition reviews.

[61]  J. Sharkey,et al.  Neighborhood socioeconomic deprivation and minority composition are associated with better potential spatial access to the ground-truthed food environment in a large rural area. , 2008, The Journal of nutrition.

[62]  J. Brug,et al.  A systematic review of the evidence regarding efficacy of obesity prevention interventions among adults , 2008, Obesity reviews : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity.

[63]  Gottfried Tappeiner,et al.  Performance contest between MLE and GMM for huge spatial autoregressive models , 2008 .

[64]  Guangqing Chi,et al.  Spatial Regression Models for Demographic Analysis , 2008 .

[65]  James Macinko,et al.  Neighborhoods and obesity. , 2008, Nutrition reviews.

[66]  Kara E MacLeod,et al.  Is the Opening of a Neighborhood Full-Service Grocery Store Followed by a Change in the Food Behavior of Residents? , 2007 .

[67]  C. Burns,et al.  Measuring food access in Melbourne: access to healthy and fast foods by car, bus and foot in an urban municipality in Melbourne. , 2007, Health & place.

[68]  Jesús Mur,et al.  Clues for discriminating between moving average and autoregressive models in spatial processes , 2007 .

[69]  F. Chaloupka,et al.  The availability of fast-food and full-service restaurants in the United States: associations with neighborhood characteristics. , 2007, American journal of preventive medicine.

[70]  Steven Cummins,et al.  Neighbourhood fast food environment and area deprivation—substitution or concentration? , 2007, Appetite.

[71]  W. D. Kissling,et al.  Spatial autocorrelation and the selection of simultaneous autoregressive models , 2007 .

[72]  C. Wells,et al.  Dealing with assumptions underlying statistical tests , 2007 .

[73]  S. Wulff SAS for Mixed Models , 2007 .

[74]  Karen Witten,et al.  Neighborhood deprivation and access to fast-food retailing: a national study. , 2007, American journal of preventive medicine.

[75]  Karen Witten,et al.  Are socially disadvantaged neighbourhoods deprived of health-related community resources? , 2007, International journal of epidemiology.

[76]  C. Dormann Effects of incorporating spatial autocorrelation into the analysis of species distribution data , 2007 .

[77]  Lisa M Powell,et al.  Food store availability and neighborhood characteristics in the United States. , 2007, Preventive medicine.

[78]  Richard Shearmur,et al.  International Journal of Health Geographics Open Access the Case of Montréal's Missing Food Deserts: Evaluation of Accessibility to Food Supermarkets , 2022 .

[79]  Janette F. Walde,et al.  Lag or Error? - Detecting the Nature of Spatial Correlation , 2007, GfKl.

[80]  Lindsay McLaren,et al.  Socioeconomic status and obesity. , 2007, Epidemiologic reviews.

[81]  T. Bailey Spatial Analysis: A Guide for Ecologists , 2006 .

[82]  Mario Schootman,et al.  The Role of Race and Poverty in Access to Foods That Enable Individuals to Adhere to Dietary Guidelines , 2006, Preventing chronic disease.

[83]  Seth Spielman Appropriate use of the K function in urban environments. , 2006, American journal of public health.

[84]  A. D. Diez Roux,et al.  Associations of neighborhood characteristics with the location and type of food stores. , 2006, American journal of public health.

[85]  Youngihn Kho,et al.  GeoDa: An Introduction to Spatial Data Analysis , 2006 .

[86]  J. Kenardy,et al.  Psychological interventions for overweight or obesity. , 2014, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[87]  L. Mckay,et al.  McDonald's restaurants and neighborhood deprivation in Scotland and England. , 2005, American journal of preventive medicine.

[88]  L. Mckay,et al.  Out-of-home food outlets and area deprivation: case study in Glasgow, UK , 2005, The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity.

[89]  S. Austin,et al.  Clustering of fast-food restaurants around schools: a novel application of spatial statistics to the study of food environments. , 2005, American journal of public health.

[90]  Lawrence D. Frank,et al.  Healthy Nutrition Environments: Concepts and Measures , 2005, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[91]  Shuming Bao,et al.  Neighborhood racial composition, neighborhood poverty, and the spatial accessibility of supermarkets in metropolitan Detroit. , 2005, American journal of public health.

[92]  M. Fortin,et al.  Spatial Analysis: A Guide for Ecologists 1st edition , 2005 .

[93]  R. Scribner,et al.  Fast food, race/ethnicity, and income: a geographic analysis. , 2004, American journal of preventive medicine.

[94]  M. Wall A close look at the spatial structure implied by the CAR and SAR models , 2004 .

[95]  J Tuomilehto,et al.  The incidence of type 1 diabetes among children in Finland--rural-urban difference. , 2003, Health & place.

[96]  Badi H. Baltagi,et al.  A companion to theoretical econometrics , 2003 .

[97]  M. Mahoney,et al.  An ecological study of the relationship between social and environmental determinants of obesity. , 2002, Health & place.

[98]  Penelope Vounatsou,et al.  Rise in malaria incidence rates in South Africa: a small-area spatial analysis of variation in time trends. , 2002, American journal of epidemiology.

[99]  M. Fortin,et al.  Spatial autocorrelation and statistical tests in ecology , 2002 .

[100]  T. Lumley,et al.  The importance of the normality assumption in large public health data sets. , 2002, Annual review of public health.

[101]  A. D. Diez Roux,et al.  Neighborhood characteristics associated with the location of food stores and food service places. , 2002, American journal of preventive medicine.

[102]  T. Wansbeek,et al.  A companion to theoretical econometrics , 2001 .

[103]  Jack J. Lennon,et al.  Red-shifts and red herrings in geographical ecology , 2000 .

[104]  B. Swinburn,et al.  Dissecting obesogenic environments: the development and application of a framework for identifying and prioritizing environmental interventions for obesity. , 1999, Preventive medicine.

[105]  Stephen P. Kaluzny,et al.  S+SpatialStats: User’s Manual for Windows® and UNIX® , 1998 .

[106]  R. Pace,et al.  Sparse spatial autoregressions , 1997 .

[107]  L. Havlicek,et al.  Robustness of the T Test: A Guide for Researchers on Effect of Violations of Assumptions , 1974 .