Error awareness and the error-related negativity: evaluating the first decade of evidence

From its discovery in the early 1990s until this day, the error-related negativity (ERN) remains the most widely investigated electrophysiological index of cortical error processing. When researchers began addressing the electrophysiology of subjective error awareness more than a decade ago, the role of the ERN, alongside the subsequently occurring error positivity (Pe), was an obvious locus of attention. However, the first two studies explicitly addressing the role of error-related event-related brain potentials (ERPs) would already set the tone for what still remains a controversy today: in contrast to the clear-cut findings that link the amplitude of the Pe to error awareness, the association between ERN amplitude and error awareness is vastly unclear. An initial study reported significant differences in ERN amplitude with respect to subjective error awareness, whereas the second failed to report this result, leading to a myriad of follow-up studies that seemed to back up or contradict either view. Here, I review those studies that explicitly dealt with the role of the error-related ERPs in subjective error awareness, and try to explain the differences in reported effects of error awareness on ERN amplitude. From the point of view presented here, different findings between studies can be explained by disparities in experimental design and data analysis, specifically with respect to the quantification of subjective error awareness. Based on the review of these results, I will then try to embed the error-related negativity into a widely known model of the implementation of access consciousness in the brain, the global neuronal workspace (GNW) model, and speculate as the ERN's potential role in such a framework. At last, I will outline future challenges in the investigation of the cortical electrophysiology of error awareness, and offer some suggestions on how they could potentially be addressed.

[1]  P. Rabbitt.  Errors and error correction in choice-response tasks. , 1966, Journal of experimental psychology.

[2]  P. Rabbitt.  Time to detect errors as a function of factors affecting choice-response time. , 1967, Acta psychologica.

[3]  C. Eriksen,et al.  Effects of noise letters upon the identification of a target letter in a nonsearch task , 1974 .

[4]  J. Fodor.  Précis of The Modularity of Mind , 1985, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[5]  B. Baars.  A cognitive theory of consciousness , 1988 .

[6]  Christian Jutten,et al.  Blind separation of sources, part I: An adaptive algorithm based on neuromimetic architecture , 1991, Signal Process..

[7]  J. Hohnsbein,et al.  Effects of crossmodal divided attention on late ERP components. II. Error processing in choice reaction tasks. , 1991, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[8]  D. Meyer,et al.  A Neural System for Error Detection and Compensation , 1993 .

[9]  M. Posner,et al.  Localization of a Neural System for Error Detection and Compensation , 1994 .

[10]  S. Luck,et al.  Electrophysiological correlates of feature analysis during visual search. , 1994, Psychophysiology.

[11]  Natika Newton,et al.  Metacognition and consciousness , 1995 .

[12]  N. Block.  On a confusion about a function of consciousness , 1995, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[13]  D. Chalmers.  Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness , 1995 .

[14]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Error-related scalp potentials elicited by hand and foot movements: evidence for an output-independent error-processing system in humans , 1998, Neuroscience Letters.

[15]  Ali Mansour,et al.  Blind Separation of Sources , 1999 .

[16]  F. Vidal,et al.  Is the ‘error negativity’ specific to errors? , 2000, Biological Psychology.

[17]  J. Hohnsbein,et al.  ERP components on reaction errors and their functional significance: a tutorial , 2000, Biological Psychology.

[18]  M. Coles,et al.  Performance monitoring in a confusing world: error-related brain activity, judgments of response accuracy, and types of errors. , 2000, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[19]  M. Botvinick,et al.  Conflict monitoring and cognitive control. , 2001, Psychological review.

[20]  J. Ridley.  Studies of Interference in Serial Verbal Reactions , 2001 .

[21]  D. V. Cramon,et al.  Subprocesses of Performance Monitoring: A Dissociation of Error Processing and Response Competition Revealed by Event-Related fMRI and ERPs , 2001, NeuroImage.

[22]  N. Block.  Paradox and cross purposes in recent work on consciousness , 2001, Cognition.

[23]  K. R. Ridderinkhof,et al.  Error-related brain potentials are differentially related to awareness of response errors: evidence from an antisaccade task. , 2001, Psychophysiology.

[24]  S. Dehaene,et al.  Towards a cognitive neuroscience of consciousness: basic evidence and a workspace framework , 2001, Cognition.

[25]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Why is there an ERN/Ne on correct trials? Response representations, stimulus-related components, and the theory of error-processing , 2001, Biological Psychology.

[26]  Adrian R. Willoughby,et al.  The Medial Frontal Cortex and the Rapid Processing of Monetary Gains and Losses , 2002, Science.

[27]  R. J. Seitz,et al.  Conscious and Subconscious Sensorimotor Synchronization—Prefrontal Cortex and the Influence of Awareness , 2002, NeuroImage.

[28]  Patrick Rabbitt,et al.  Consciousness is slower than you think , 2002, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[29]  C. Carter,et al.  The Timing of Action-Monitoring Processes in the Anterior Cingulate Cortex , 2002, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[30]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. , 2002, Psychological review.

[31]  D. Rosenthal.  How many kinds of consciousness? , 2002, Consciousness and Cognition.

[32]  Thomas F Münte,et al.  Time Course of Error Detection and Correction in Humans: Neurophysiological Evidence , 2002, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[33]  M. Leboyer,et al.  Conscious and subliminal conflicts in normal subjects and patients with schizophrenia: The role of the anterior cingulate , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[34]  C. Koch,et al.  A framework for consciousness , 2003, Nature Neuroscience.

[35]  R. Simons,et al.  To err is autonomic: error-related brain potentials, ANS activity, and post-error compensatory behavior. , 2003, Psychophysiology.

[36]  Axel Cleeremans,et al.  The Unity of Consciousness: Binding, Integration, and Dissociation , 2003 .

[37]  H. Critchley,et al.  Neural systems supporting interoceptive awareness , 2004, Nature Neuroscience.

[38]  J. Changeux,et al.  Neural Mechanisms for Access to Consciousness , 2004 .

[39]  Ulrich Mayr,et al.  Conflict, consciousness, and control , 2004, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[40]  K. R. Ridderinkhof,et al.  The Role of the Medial Frontal Cortex in Cognitive Control , 2004, Science.

[41]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  The neural basis of error detection: conflict monitoring and the error-related negativity. , 2004, Psychological review.

[42]  A. Engel,et al.  Trial-by-Trial Coupling of Concurrent Electroencephalogram and Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Identifies the Dynamics of Performance Monitoring , 2005, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[43]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  An integrative theory of locus coeruleus-norepinephrine function: adaptive gain and optimal performance. , 2005, Annual review of neuroscience.

[44]  Joshua W. Brown,et al.  Learned Predictions of Error Likelihood in the Anterior Cingulate Cortex , 2005, Science.

[45]  Thérèse J. M. Overbeek,et al.  Dissociable Components of Error Processing on the Functional Significance of the Pe Vis-à-vis the Ern/ne Performance Monitoring Processes Reflected in the Ne and Pe Review of Studies That Report Both Ne and Pe: Associations and Dissociations Pharmacological Effects , 2022 .

[46]  T. Endrass,et al.  Error Awareness in a Saccade Countermanding Task , 2005 .

[47]  Katja Fiehler,et al.  Electrophysiological correlates of error correction. , 2005, Psychophysiology.

[48]  John J. Foxe,et al.  Neural mechanisms involved in error processing: A comparison of errors made with and without awareness , 2005, NeuroImage.

[49]  John J. Foxe,et al.  The Anterior Cingulate and Error Avoidance , 2006, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[50]  D. Yves von Cramon,et al.  How does error correction differ from error signaling? An event-related potential study , 2006, Brain Research.

[51]  Asher Koriat,et al.  The intricate relationships between monitoring and control in metacognition: lessons for the cause-and-effect relation between subjective experience and behavior. , 2006, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[52]  T. Endrass,et al.  ERP correlates of conscious error recognition: aware and unaware errors in an antisaccade task , 2007, The European journal of neuroscience.

[53]  John J. Foxe,et al.  The role of cingulate cortex in the detection of errors with and without awareness: a high‐density electrical mapping study , 2007, The European journal of neuroscience.

[54]  A. Cowey,et al.  Post-decision wagering objectively measures awareness , 2007, Nature Neuroscience.

[55]  N. Block.  Consciousness, accessibility, and the mesh between psychology and neuroscience , 2007, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[56]  Norbert Kathmann,et al.  Neural correlates of error awareness , 2007, NeuroImage.

[57]  S. Dehaene,et al.  Brain Dynamics Underlying the Nonlinear Threshold for Access to Consciousness , 2007, PLoS biology.

[58]  Z. Dienes.  Subjective measures of unconscious knowledge. , 2008, Progress in brain research.

[59]  Marco Steinhauser,et al.  Is the Error-related Negativity Amplitude Related to Error Detectability? Evidence from Effects of Different Error Types , 2008, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[60]  Kenneth Hugdahl,et al.  Prediction of human errors by maladaptive changes in event-related brain networks , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[61]  Shani Shalgi,et al.  On the positive side of error processing: error‐awareness positivity revisited , 2009, The European journal of neuroscience.

[62]  K. R. Ridderinkhof,et al.  To P(E) or not to P(E): a P3-like ERP component reflecting the processing of response errors. , 2009, Psychophysiology.

[63]  Liam Nestor,et al.  Impaired error awareness and anterior cingulate cortex hypoactivity in chronic cannabis users , 2009, Neuropsychopharmacology.

[64]  Jan R. Wessel,et al.  Modulation of the error-related negativity by response conflict. , 2009, Psychophysiology.

[65]  Tim Bayne,et al.  Unity of consciousness , 2009, Scholarpedia.

[66]  John J. Foxe,et al.  The neural correlates of deficient error awareness in attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) , 2009, Neuropsychologia.

[67]  A. Craig,et al.  How do you feel — now? The anterior insula and human awareness , 2009, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[68]  Hilde T. Juvodden,et al.  Mal-Adaptation of Event-Related EEG Responses Preceding Performance Errors , 2010, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[69]  G. Woodman.  Masked targets trigger event-related potentials indexing shifts of attention but not error detection. , 2010, Psychophysiology.

[70]  Franziska M. Korb,et al.  Post-Error Behavioral Adjustments Are Facilitated by Activation and Suppression of Task-Relevant and Task-Irrelevant Information Processing , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[71]  Borís Burle,et al.  Rostral Cingulate Zone and correct response monitoring: ICA and source localization evidences for the unicity of correct- and error-negativities , 2010, NeuroImage.

[72]  N. Yeung,et al.  Decision Processes in Human Performance Monitoring , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[73]  K. R. Ridderinkhof,et al.  Conscious perception of errors and its relation to the anterior insula , 2010, Brain Structure and Function.

[74]  Gordon D Logan,et al.  Cognitive Illusions of Authorship Reveal Hierarchical Error Detection in Skilled Typists , 2010, Science.

[75]  H. Critchley,et al.  Conjoint activity of anterior insular and anterior cingulate cortex: awareness and response , 2010, Brain Structure and Function.

[76]  Joshua W. Brown,et al.  Medial prefrontal cortex as an action-outcome predictor , 2011, Nature Neuroscience.

[77]  Tom Eichele,et al.  Posterior Medial Frontal Cortex Activity Predicts Post-Error Adaptations in Task-Related Visual and Motor Areas , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[78]  N. Yeung,et al.  Dissociable correlates of response conflict and error awareness in error-related brain activity , 2011, Neuropsychologia.

[79]  M. Ullsperger,et al.  Post-Error Adjustments , 2011, Front. Psychology.

[80]  Markus Ullsperger,et al.  Error Awareness Revisited: Accumulation of Multimodal Evidence from Central and Autonomic Nervous Systems , 2011, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[81]  John M. Pearson,et al.  Surprise Signals in Anterior Cingulate Cortex: Neuronal Encoding of Unsigned Reward Prediction Errors Driving Adjustment in Behavior , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[82]  Jan R. Wiersema,et al.  Cascade of Neural Events Leading from Error Commission to Subsequent Awareness Revealed Using EEG Source Imaging , 2011, PloS one.

[83]  M. Coles,et al.  Dissociation of Pe and ERN/Ne in the conscious recognition of an error. , 2011, Psychophysiology.

[84]  Markus Ullsperger,et al.  Selection of independent components representing event-related brain potentials: A data-driven approach for greater objectivity , 2011, NeuroImage.