How to Avoid the Fallacies of Cognitive Subtraction in Brain Imaging

Functional neuroanatomy of cognitive processes is generally derived by subtraction of a control task from an experimental task. We show that this method is logically untenable and propose to replace it with an adaptation of the specific-effect method and of the additive-factor method. The basic flaw that undermines the subtractive method is the comparison between different tasks. We argue that the specific-effect method should be used when investigating activations produced by different levels of a qualitative variable, whereas the additive-factor method should be used for quantitative variables. The use of these methods allows one to distinguish between parallel and serial stages of processing and between local and distributed processing.

[1]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  How the brain learns to see objects and faces in an impoverished context , 1997, Nature.

[2]  Karl J. Friston.  Imaging cognitive anatomy , 1997, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[3]  D. Poeppel.  A Critical Review of PET Studies of Phonological Processing , 1996, Brain and Language.

[4]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Local and Distributed Effects of Apomorphine on Fronto-Temporal Function in Acute Unmedicated Schizophrenia , 1996, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[5]  C D Frith,et al.  Brain activity during memory retrieval. The influence of imagery and semantic cueing. , 1996, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[6]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  The Trouble with Cognitive Subtraction , 1996, NeuroImage.

[7]  Richard S. J. Frackowiak,et al.  Functional anatomy of a common semantic system for words and pictures , 1996, Nature.

[8]  S. Houle,et al.  Activation of medial temporal structures during episodic memory retrieval , 1996, Nature.

[9]  Richard D. Hichwa,et al.  A neural basis for lexical retrieval , 1996, Nature.

[10]  Leslie G. Ungerleider,et al.  Neural correlates of category-specific knowledge , 1996, Nature.

[11]  S. Kosslyn,et al.  Topographical representations of mental images in primary visual cortex , 1995, Nature.

[12]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dopaminergic modulation of impaired cognitive activation in the anterior cingulate cortex in schizophrenia , 1995, Nature.

[13]  S. Kosslyn.  Image and Brain: The Resolution of the Imagery Debate , 1994, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[14]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Functional mapping of brain areas implicated in auditory--verbal memory function. , 1993, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[15]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Functional Connectivity: The Principal-Component Analysis of Large (PET) Data Sets , 1993, Journal of cerebral blood flow and metabolism : official journal of the International Society of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism.

[16]  Michael I. Jordan,et al.  Computational Consequences of a Bias toward Short Connections , 1992, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[17]  J. Maddox.  Making sense of binary metal alloys , 1991, Nature.

[18]  T. Shallice.  From Neuropsychology to Mental Structure: Converging Operations: Specific Syndromes and Evidence from Normal Subjects , 1988 .

[19]  Jeff Miller,et al.  Discrete and continuous models of human information processing: theoretical distinctions and empirical results. , 1988, Acta psychologica.

[20]  M Coltheart,et al.  The psycholinguistic analysis of acquired dyslexias: some illustrations. , 1982, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[21]  A. Treisman,et al.  A feature-integration theory of attention , 1980, Cognitive Psychology.

[22]  James L. McClelland.  On the time relations of mental processes: An examination of systems of processes in cascade. , 1979 .

[23]  Keith E. Stanovich,et al.  Encoding, stimulus-response compatibility, and stages of processing , 1977 .

[24]  R G Pachella,et al.  Encoding processes in memory scanning tasks , 1976, Memory & cognition.

[25]  James T. Townsend,et al.  A note on the identifiability of parallel and serial processes , 1971 .

[26]  R. Cabeza,et al.  Imaging Cognition: An Empirical Review of PET Studies with Normal Subjects , 1997, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[27]  Stanislas Dehaene,et al.  The Organization of Brain Activations in Number Comparison: Event-Related Potentials and the Additive-Factors Method , 1996, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[28]  M. Posner,et al.  Images of mind , 1994 .

[29]  Sebastiano Bagnara,et al.  The cost of a strategy. , 1992 .

[30]  M. Posner.  Chronometric explorations of mind : the third Paul M. Fitts lectures, delivered at the University of Michigan, September 1976 , 1978 .

[31]  J. Brožek.  Attention and Performance II. , 1971 .

[32]  Saul Sternberg,et al.  The discovery of processing stages: Extensions of Donders' method , 1969 .

[33]  THE QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1989 41A (1) 19-45 Chronometric Evidence for Central Postponement in Temporally Overlapping Tasks , 2022 .