Moral Principles or Consumer Preferences? Alternative Framings of the Trolley Problem

We created paired moral dilemmas with minimal contrasts in wording, a research strategy that has been advocated as a way to empirically establish principles operative in a domain-specific moral psychology. However, the candidate "principles" we tested were not derived from work in moral philosophy, but rather from work in the areas of consumer choice and risk perception. Participants were paradoxically less likely to choose an action that sacrifices one life to save others when they were asked to provide more reasons for doing so (Experiment 1), and their willingness to sacrifice lives depended not only on how many lives would be saved, but on the number of lives at risk (Experiment 2). The latter effect was also found in a within-subjects design (Experiment 3). These findings suggest caution in the use of artificial dilemmas as a key testbed for revealing principled bases for moral judgment.

[1]  Susan Dwyer.  How Good is the Linguistic Analogy , 2003 .

[2]  Joshua D. Greene,et al.  How (and where) does moral judgment work? , 2002, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[3]  G. Miller,et al.  Cognitive science. , 1981, Science.

[4]  K. Appiah.  The Bleak Implications of Moral Psychology , 2008 .

[5]  Joshua D. Greene,et al.  A Dissociation Between Moral Judgments and Justifications , 2007 .

[6]  S. Levinson,et al.  The myth of language universals: language diversity and its importance for cognitive science. , 2009, The Behavioral and brain sciences.

[7]  John Mikhail.  moral heuristics or moral competence? reflections on sunstein , 2005, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[8]  C. Sunstein,et al.  moral heuristics , 2003, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[9]  Pierre Jacob,et al.  Universal moral grammar: a critical appraisal , 2007, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[10]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  An fMRI Investigation of Emotional Engagement in Moral Judgment , 2001, Science.

[11]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  The Minimalist Program , 1992 .

[12]  J. Baron,et al.  Omission and commission in judgment and choice , 1991 .

[13]  J. Thomson.  The Trolley Problem , 1985 .

[14]  M. Hauser,et al.  Reviving Rawls's linguistic analogy: Operative principles and the causal structure of moral actions , 2007 .

[15]  Jonathan Baron,et al.  Social roles and the moral judgement of acts and omissions , 1996 .

[16]  John M. Frost,et al.  Moral heuristics. Commentaries. Author's reply , 2005 .

[17]  Stephen M. Johnson,et al.  Insensitivity to the Value of Human Life: A Study of Psychophysical Numbing , 1997 .

[18]  P. Foot.  The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of the Double Effect , 2020, The Doctrine of Double Effect.

[19]  Ilana Ritov,et al.  Predictably Incoherent Judgments , 2002 .

[20]  F. Strack,et al.  Ease of retrieval as information: Another look at the availability heuristic. , 1991 .

[21]  M. Waldmann,et al.  Throwing a Bomb on a Person Versus Throwing a Person on a Bomb , 2007, Psychological science.

[22]  T. Gilovich,et al.  Heuristics and Biases: Introduction – Heuristics and Biases: Then and Now , 2002 .

[23]  A. Tversky,et al.  Choices, Values, and Frames , 2000 .

[24]  Peter Unger,et al.  Living high and letting die: Our illusion of innocence , 1998 .

[25]  R. Thaler.  Mental accounting matters , 1999 .

[26]  John Mikhail,et al.  Universal moral grammar: theory, evidence and the future , 2007, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[27]  Norbert Schwarz,et al.  Accessible Content and Accessibility Experiences: The Interplay of Declarative and Experiential Information in Judgment , 1998, Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.

[28]  Walter Sinnott-Armstrong,et al.  Framing moral intuitions. , 2008 .

[29]  Stephen P. Stich,et al.  Is morality an elegant machine or a kludge , 2006 .

[30]  Matthew J. Jorgensen,et al.  An empirical study of moral intuitions: Toward an evolutionary ethics. , 1993 .

[31]  M. Hauser.  Moral Minds: How Nature Designed Our Universal Sense of Right and Wrong , 2006 .

[32]  L. Petrinovich,et al.  Influence of Wording and Framing Effects on Moral Intuitions , 1996 .