Multiple methods for multiple futures: Integrating qualitative scenario planning and quantitative simulation modeling for natural resource decision making

Abstract Scenario planning helps managers incorporate climate change into their natural resource decision making through a structured “what-if” process of identifying key uncertainties and potential impacts and responses. Although qualitative scenarios, in which ecosystem responses to climate change are derived via expert opinion, often suffice for managers to begin addressing climate change in their planning, this approach may face limits in resolving the responses of complex systems to altered climate conditions. In addition, this approach may fall short of the scientific credibility managers often require to take actions that differ from current practice. Quantitative simulation modeling of ecosystem response to climate conditions and management actions can provide this credibility, but its utility is limited unless the modeling addresses the most impactful and management-relevant uncertainties and incorporates realistic management actions. We use a case study to compare and contrast management implications derived from qualitative scenario narratives and from scenarios supported by quantitative simulations. We then describe an analytical framework that refines the case study’s integrated approach in order to improve applicability of results to management decisions. The case study illustrates the value of an integrated approach for identifying counterintuitive system dynamics, refining understanding of complex relationships, clarifying the magnitude and timing of changes, identifying and checking the validity of assumptions about resource responses to climate, and refining management directions. Our proposed analytical framework retains qualitative scenario planning as a core element because its participatory approach builds understanding for both managers and scientists, lays the groundwork to focus quantitative simulations on key system dynamics, and clarifies the challenges that subsequent decision making must address.

[1]  Rebecca A. Kelly,et al.  A formal framework for scenario development in support of environmental decision-making , 2009, Environ. Model. Softw..

[2]  Ken Thompson,et al.  Grassland invasions: effects of manipulations of climate and management , 2001 .

[3]  K. M. Archie.  Mountain communities and climate change adaptation: barriers to planning and hurdles to implementation in the Southern Rocky Mountain Region of North America , 2014, Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change.

[4]  John F. B. Mitchell,et al.  Anthropogenic climate change for 1860 to 2100 simulated with the HadCM3 model under updated emissions scenarios , 2003 .

[5]  Mohammed Mahmoud,et al.  Scenario development for water resources planning and watershed management: Methodology and semi-arid region case study , 2011, Environ. Model. Softw..

[6]  Jana B. Milford,et al.  Climate Change and Western Public Lands: a Survey of U.S. Federal Land Managers on the Status of Adaptation Efforts , 2012 .

[7]  A. Symstad,et al.  Fire and forest history at Mount Rushmore. , 2008, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[8]  Robert L. Beschta,et al.  Hardwood tree decline following large carnivore loss on the Great Plains, USA , 2007 .

[9]  D. A. King,et al.  Climate change and fire effects on a prairie–woodland ecotone: projecting species range shifts with a dynamic global vegetation model , 2013, Ecology and evolution.

[10]  S. Stephens,et al.  Climate change and forests of the future: managing in the face of uncertainty. , 2007, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[11]  Scott R. Abella,et al.  Climate, trees, pests, and weeds: Change, uncertainty, and biotic stressors in eastern U.S. national park forests , 2014 .

[12]  Jeffrey T. Morisette,et al.  Integrating research tools to support the management of social-ecological systems under climate change , 2014 .

[13]  Lan Xu,et al.  Using Weather Data to Explain Herbage Yield on Three Great Plains Plant Communities , 2007 .

[14]  Stewart J. Cohen,et al.  Future visioning of local climate change: A framework for community engagement and planning with scenarios and visualisation , 2011 .

[15]  Che Biggs,et al.  The Problem of Fit: Scenario Planning and Climate Change Adaptation in the Public Sector , 2014 .

[16]  Kim Starr,et al.  Change in trade wind inversion frequency implicated in the decline of an alpine plant , 2016, Climate Change Responses.

[17]  Mark E. Borsuk,et al.  Methods for translating narrative scenarios into quantitative assessments of land use change , 2016, Environ. Model. Softw..

[18]  Carolyn Hull Sieg,et al.  Historical variability in fire at the ponderosa pine - Northern Great Plains prairie ecotone, southeastern Black Hills, South Dakota , 1999 .

[19]  Amy J. Symstad,et al.  Vegetation projections for Wind Cave National Park with three future climate scenarios: Final report in completion of Task Agreement J8W07100052 , 2013 .

[20]  B. C. Hansen,et al.  Fire cycles in North American interior grasslands and their relation to prairie drought. , 2005, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[21]  Pushpam Kumar.  Agriculture (Chapter8) in IPCC, 2007: Climate change 2007: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change , 2007 .

[22]  Daniel R. Wildcat,et al.  Red Alert!: Saving the Planet with Indigenous Knowledge , 2009 .

[23]  Monica G. Turner,et al.  Surrogates for Resilience of Social–Ecological Systems , 2005, Ecosystems.

[24]  N. Crookston,et al.  Empirical Analyses of Plant‐Climate Relationships for the Western United States , 2006, International Journal of Plant Sciences.

[25]  George Wright,et al.  The origins and evolution of scenario techniques in long range business planning , 2005 .

[26]  Mark West,et al.  Carbon dioxide enrichment alters plant community structure and accelerates shrub growth in the shortgrass steppe , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[27]  Stephen R. Carpenter,et al.  Scenario Planning: a Tool for Conservation in an Uncertain World , 2003, Conservation Biology.

[28]  J. H. Bock,et al.  Effect of Fires on Woody Vegetation in the Pine-grassland Ecotone of the Southern Black Hills , 1984 .

[29]  Robert S. Thompson,et al.  Potential Changes in the Distributions of Western North America Tree and Shrub Taxa under Future Climate Scenarios , 2001, Ecosystems.

[30]  W. Collins,et al.  The Community Climate System Model Version 3 (CCSM3) , 2006 .

[31]  J. Detling,et al.  MAMMALIAN HERBIVORES : ECOSYSTEM-LEVEL EFFECTS IN TWO GRASSLAND NATIONAL PARKS , 1998 .

[32]  S. Walsh,et al.  Using stylized agent-based models for population–environment research: a case study from the Galápagos Islands , 2010, Population and environment.

[33]  Amy J. Symstad,et al.  Historical and projected climate (1901–2050) and hydrologic response of karst aquifers, and species vulnerability in south-central Texas and western South Dakota , 2014 .

[34]  Linda O. Mearns,et al.  The Practitioner's Dilemma: How to Assess the Credibility of Downscaled Climate Projections , 2013 .

[35]  Barbara J. Mahler,et al.  Prediction, time variance, and classification of hydraulic response to recharge in two karst aquifers , 2013 .

[36]  Daniel G. Milchunas,et al.  CO2 ENHANCES PRODUCTIVITY, ALTERS SPECIES COMPOSITION, AND REDUCES DIGESTIBILITY OF SHORTGRASS STEPPE VEGETATION , 2004 .

[37]  Daniel G. Milchunas,et al.  Management Implications of Global Change for Great Plains Rangelands , 2008 .

[38]  Hiroyasu Hasumi,et al.  K-1 Coupled GCM (MIROC) Description , 2004 .

[39]  David R. Easterling,et al.  Regional surface climate conditions in CMIP3 and CMIP5 for the United States : differences, similarities, and implications for the U.S. National Climate Assessment , 2015 .

[40]  Jeffrey S. Kern,et al.  Geographic Patterns of Soil Water-Holding Capacity in the Contiguous United States , 1995 .

[41]  P. Brown,et al.  Climate effects on fire regimes and tree recruitment in Black Hills ponderosa pine forests. , 2006, Ecology.

[42]  Howard E. Epstein,et al.  The relative abundance of three plant functional types in temperate grasslands and shrublands of North and South America: effects of projected climate change , 2002 .

[43]  Ashley Noel Cobb,et al.  Climate change scenario planning: A model for the integration of science and management in environmental decision-making , 2012, Environ. Model. Softw..

[44]  Benjamin M. Sleeter,et al.  Integrated climate and land use change scenarios for California rangeland ecosystem services: wildlife habitat, soil carbon, and water supply , 2015, Landscape Ecology.