Health and respirable particulate (PM10) air pollution: a causal or statistical association?

Numerous studies have reported weak but statistically significant acute health effects of particulate air pollution. The associations are observed at levels below the current U.S. standard of 150 micrograms/m3 (24 hr). Health effects include acute increased mortality from cardiopulmonary conditions and acute morbidity such as hospital admissions for related diseases. We reviewed recent epidemiology studies to evaluate whether criteria for causality are met, and we conclude that they are not. The weak associations are as likely to be due to confounding by weather, copollutants, or exposure misclassification as by ambient particulate matter (PM). The results from the same metropolitan areas are inconsistent, and PM explains such a small amount of the variability in mortality/morbidity that the association has little practical significance. Finally, experimental chamber studies of susceptible individuals exposed to PM concentrations well above 150 micrograms/m3 provide no evidence to support the morbidity/mortality findings. None of the criteria for establishing causality of the PM/mortality hypothesis are clearly met at ambient concentrations common in many U.S. cities. Imagesp838-aFigure 1.

[1]  J. Schwartz,et al.  Particulate air pollution and mortality: more than the Philadelphia story. , 1995, Epidemiology.

[2]  J. Samet Particulate air pollution and mortality: the Philadelphia story. , 1995 .

[3]  Suresh H. Moolgavkar,et al.  Air Pollution and Daily Mortality in Philadelphia , 1995, Epidemiology.

[4]  J Sacks,et al.  Effect of outdoor airborne particulate matter on daily death counts. , 1995, Environmental health perspectives.

[5]  J Schwartz,et al.  Short term fluctuations in air pollution and hospital admissions of the elderly for respiratory disease. , 1995, Thorax.

[6]  C. Pope,et al.  Health effects of particulate air pollution: time for reassessment? , 1995, Environmental health perspectives.

[7]  D. V. Steenis Airborne pollutants and acute health effects , 1995, The Lancet.

[8]  R. Agius,et al.  Airborne pollutants and acute health effects , 1995, The Lancet.

[9]  D. Dockery,et al.  Air pollution and mortality in elderly people: a time-series study in Sao Paulo, Brazil. , 1995, Archives of environmental health.

[10]  W. Pan,et al.  Temperature extremes and mortality from coronary heart disease and cerebral infarction in elderly Chinese , 1995, The Lancet.

[11]  W. MacNee,et al.  Particulate air pollution and acute health effects , 1995, The Lancet.

[12]  P Wilmshurst,et al.  Temperature and cardiovascular mortality , 1994, BMJ.

[13]  J Schwartz,et al.  Air pollution and hospital admissions for the elderly in Detroit, Michigan. , 1994, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[14]  D. Dockery,et al.  Air pollution and daily mortality in residential areas of Beijing, China. , 1994, Archives of environmental health.

[15]  S. C. Yang,et al.  Respiratory function changes from inhalation of polluted air. , 1994, Archives of environmental health.

[16]  S. Schwartz The fallacy of the ecological fallacy: the potential misuse of a concept and the consequences. , 1994, American journal of public health.

[17]  G M Böhm,et al.  Association between air pollution and mortality due to respiratory diseases in children in São Paulo, Brazil: a preliminary report. , 1994, Environmental research.

[18]  B. Cohen,et al.  Invited commentary: in defense of ecologic studies for testing a linear-no threshold theory. , 1994, American journal of epidemiology.

[19]  J Schwartz,et al.  Air pollution and hospital admissions for the elderly in Birmingham, Alabama. , 1994, American journal of epidemiology.

[20]  J. Schwartz,et al.  Total suspended particulate matter and daily mortality in Cincinnati, Ohio. , 1994, Environmental health perspectives.

[21]  B. Ostro,et al.  The association of air pollution and mortality: examining the case for inference. , 1993, Archives of environmental health.

[22]  J M Samet,et al.  A review of ecologic studies of lung cancer and indoor radon. , 1993, Health physics.

[23]  B. Brunekreef,et al.  Acute effects of a winter air pollution episode on pulmonary function and respiratory symptoms of children. , 1993, Archives of environmental health.

[24]  M Lippmann,et al.  Associations of London, England, daily mortality with particulate matter, sulfur dioxide, and acidic aerosol pollution. , 1993, Archives of environmental health.

[25]  J Schwartz,et al.  Air pollution and daily mortality in Birmingham, Alabama. , 1993, American journal of epidemiology.

[26]  W. Pierson,et al.  Particulate air pollution and hospital emergency room visits for asthma in Seattle. , 1993, The American review of respiratory disease.

[27]  J. Mackenbach,et al.  Air pollution, lagged effects of temperature, and mortality: The Netherlands 1979-87. , 1993, Journal of epidemiology and community health.

[28]  W Harrington,et al.  Air pollution and respiratory morbidity among adults in southern California. , 1993, American journal of epidemiology.

[29]  F. Martinez,et al.  Air pollution and emergency room admissions for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a 5-year study. , 1993, American journal of epidemiology.

[30]  J. Mackenbach,et al.  Outdoor air temperature and mortality in The Netherlands: a time-series analysis. , 1993, American journal of epidemiology.

[31]  D V Bates,et al.  Health indices of the adverse effects of air pollution: the question of coherence. , 1992, Environmental research.

[32]  F. Lipfert,et al.  Temporal patterns in air pollution and hospital admissions. , 1992, Environmental research.

[33]  C. Pope,et al.  Daily mortality and PM10 pollution in Utah Valley. , 1992, Archives of environmental health.

[34]  D. Dockery,et al.  Acute health effects of PM10 pollution on symptomatic and asymptomatic children. , 1992, The American review of respiratory disease.

[35]  B. Cohen Problems in ecological studies. , 1992, International Journal of Epidemiology.

[36]  J Schwartz,et al.  Increased mortality in Philadelphia associated with daily air pollution concentrations. , 1992, The American review of respiratory disease.

[37]  J. Salvaggio,et al.  Passive cigarette smoke-challenge studies: increase in bronchial hyperreactivity. , 1992, The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology.

[38]  J. Schwartz,et al.  Particulate air pollution and daily mortality in Detroit. , 1991, Environmental research.

[39]  H. Wichmann,et al.  Air pollution and acute respiratory illness in five German communities. , 1991, Environmental research.

[40]  J D Spengler,et al.  Respiratory health and PM10 pollution. A daily time series analysis. , 1991, The American review of respiratory disease.

[41]  D. Fairley,et al.  The relationship of daily mortality to suspended particulates in Santa Clara County, 1980-1986. , 1990, Environmental health perspectives.

[42]  D V Bates,et al.  Asthma attack periodicity: a study of hospital emergency visits in Vancouver. , 1990, Environmental research.

[43]  E. Ingenito,et al.  The effects of deep inhalation on maximal expiratory flow during intensive treatment of spontaneous asthmatic episodes. , 1989, The American review of respiratory disease.

[44]  E. Avol,et al.  Effect of droplet size on respiratory responses to inhaled sulfuric acid in normal and asthmatic volunteers. , 1989, The American review of respiratory disease.

[45]  H. Levison,et al.  Acute asthma: observations regarding the management of a pediatric emergency room. , 1989, Pediatrics.

[46]  J Lellouch,et al.  Short-term effects of sulphur dioxide pollution on mortality in two French cities. , 1989, International journal of epidemiology.

[47]  S Greenland,et al.  Ecological bias, confounding, and effect modification. , 1989, International journal of epidemiology.

[48]  L. Kalkstein,et al.  Weather and Human Mortality: An Evaluation of Demographic and Interregional Responses in the United States , 1989 .

[49]  K J Rothman,et al.  A strengthening programme for weak associations. , 1988, International journal of epidemiology.

[50]  J. Salvaggio,et al.  Cigarette smoke-sensitive asthma: challenge studies. , 1988, The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology.

[51]  S. Piantadosi,et al.  The ecological fallacy. , 1988, American journal of epidemiology.

[52]  E. Avol,et al.  Respiratory Dose-Response Study of Normal and Asthmatic Volunteers Exposed to Sulfuric Acid Aerosol in the Sub-Micrometer Size Range , 1988, Toxicology and industrial health.

[53]  K. R. Anderson,et al.  Short-term respiratory effects of sulfuric acid in fog: a laboratory study of healthy and asthmatic volunteers. , 1988, JAPCA.

[54]  L Collins,et al.  Time series analyses of respiratory responses to indoor and outdoor environmental phenomena. , 1987, Environmental research.

[55]  D Hémon,et al.  Comparison of relative risks obtained in ecological and individual studies: some methodological considerations. , 1987, International journal of epidemiology.

[56]  D T Mage,et al.  Personal exposures to respirable particulates and implications for air pollution epidemiology. , 1985, Environmental science & technology.

[57]  K. R. Anderson,et al.  Controlled exposure to a mixture of SO2, NO2, and particulate air pollutants: effects on human pulmonary function and respiratory symptoms. , 1985, Archives of environmental health.

[58]  D R Hillman,et al.  The pattern of breathing in acute severe asthma. , 1985, The American review of respiratory disease.

[59]  Nowak Rm Acute bronchial asthma. , 1983, Emergency medicine clinics of North America.

[60]  F. Speizer,et al.  The relationship between air pollution and emergency room visits in an industrial community. , 1981, Journal of the Air Pollution Control Association.

[61]  J D Spengler,et al.  Personal exposure to respirable particulates and sulfates. , 1981, Journal of the Air Pollution Control Association.

[62]  G. Bull THE WEATHER AND DEATHS FROM PNEUMONIA , 1980, The Lancet.

[63]  E. Rogot,et al.  Associations of coronary and stroke mortality with temperature and snowfall in selected areas of the United States, 1962-1966. , 1976, American journal of epidemiology.

[64]  W. Addington,et al.  Rapid prediction of need for hospitalization in acute asthma. , 1976, JAMA.

[65]  W. Harland,et al.  Seasonal incidence and mortality of ischaemic heart-disease. , 1970, Lancet.

[66]  A. Woolcock,et al.  Improvement in bronchial asthma not reflected in forced expiratory volume. , 1965, Lancet.

[67]  A. B. Hill The Environment and Disease: Association or Causation? , 1965, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine.

[68]  J. Goldsmith,et al.  AIR POLLUTION AND DAILY MORTALITY , 1961, The American journal of the medical sciences.

[69]  M. Utell,et al.  Particles and Mortality: A Clinical Perspective , 1995 .

[70]  Frederick W. Lipfert,et al.  Uncertainties in Identifying Responsible Pollutants in Observational Epidemiology Studies , 1995 .

[71]  Yuanzhang Li,et al.  Daily Mortality Analysis by Using Different Regression Models in Philadelphia County, 1973–1990 , 1995 .

[72]  G. Thurston,et al.  Air Pollution Epidemiology: Considerations in Time-Series Modeling , 1995 .

[73]  Kazuhiko Ito,et al.  A Sensitivity Analysis of Mortality/Pm-10 Associations in Los Angeles , 1995 .

[74]  Joel Schwartz,et al.  REVIEW OF EPIDEMIOLOGICAL EVIDENCE OF HEALTH EFFECTS OF PARTICULATE AIR POLLUTION , 1995 .

[75]  Joseph L. Lyon,et al.  Is There a causal Association Between Excess Mortality and Exposure to PM-10 air Pollution? Additional Analyses by Location, year, Season, and Cause of Death , 1995 .

[76]  Kazuhiko Ito,et al.  Separating the Effects of Temperature and Season on Daily Mortality from those of Air Pollution in London: 1965–1972 , 1995 .

[77]  Suresh H. Moolgavkar,et al.  Particulate Air Pollution, Sulfur Dioxide, and Daily Mortality: A Reanalysis of the Steubenville Data , 1995 .

[78]  R. Schlesinger,et al.  Toxicological Evidence for Health Effects from Inhaled Particulate Pollution: Does it Support the Human Experience? , 1995 .

[79]  B. Weiss,et al.  Association of particulate air pollution and acute mortality: involvement of ultrafine particles? , 1995, Inhalation toxicology.

[80]  J Schwartz,et al.  What are people dying of on high air pollution days? , 1994, Environmental research.

[81]  J. Schwartz,et al.  Air pollution and daily mortality: a review and meta analysis. , 1994, Environmental research.

[82]  P Corey,et al.  Effects of particulate matter exposure and medication use on asthmatics. , 1992, Archives of environmental health.

[83]  S. Greenland,et al.  Effects of nondifferential exposure misclassification in ecologic studies. , 1992, American Journal of Epidemiology.

[84]  D. Sackett Bias in analytic research. , 1979, Journal of chronic diseases.