Carotid Angioplasty with or without Stent Placement versus Carotid Endarterectomy for Treatment of Carotid Stenosis: A Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE: Carotid angioplasty with or without stent placement (CAS) has been proposed as an alternative method to carotid endarterectomy (CEA) for treatment of carotid stenosis. Small randomized trials have evaluated the comparative efficacy of both methods; however, definitive evidence is lacking. METHODS: A search was made for randomized clinical trials comparing CAS and CEA for treatment of carotid stenosis. A literature search of MEDLINE, PubMed, and Cochrane databases was supplemented by a review of bibliographies of relevant articles and personal files. A meta-analysis was performed using a random effects model because significant heterogeneity was observed. Outcomes compared included 1-month composite rates of stroke or death, all strokes, disabling strokes, myocardial infarction, cranial nerve injury, and major bleeding and 1-year rates of both minor and major ipsilateral strokes. RESULTS: We analyzed five randomized trials totaling 1154 patients (577 randomized to CEA and 577 randomized to CAS). The composite end point of 1-month stroke or death rate was not different between patients treated with CAS compared with those treated with CEA (relative risk [RR], 1.3; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.6–2.8; P = 0.5). The 1-month stroke rate (831 patients analyzed: RR, 1.3; 95% CI, 0.4–3.6; P = 0.7) and disabling stroke rate (831 patients analyzed: RR, 0.9; 95% CI, 0.2–3.5; P = 0.9) was similar for CAS and CEA. The 1-month rates of myocardial infarction (814 patients analyzed: RR, 0.3; 95% CI, 0.1–0.9) and cranial nerve injury (918 patients analyzed: RR, 0.05; 95% CI, 0.01–0.3) were significantly lower for CAS. No significant differences were observed in 1-year rates of ipsilateral stroke (814 patients analyzed: RR, 0.8; 95% CI, 0.5–1.2; P = 0.2). CONCLUSION: The 30-day stroke and death rates associated with CAS and CEA were not significantly different. Lower rates of myocardial infarction and cranial nerve injury were observed with CAS compared with CEA.

[1]  T. Bajwa,et al.  Protected carotid-artery stenting versus endarterectomy in high-risk patients. , 2004, The New England journal of medicine.

[2]  R. Peto,et al.  Prevention of disabling and fatal strokes by successful carotid endarterectomy in patients without recent neurological symptoms: randomised controlled trial , 2004, The Lancet.

[3]  John F. Maroney,et al.  Multicenter clinical trial of the NexStent coiled sheet stent in the treatment of extracranial carotid artery stenosis: immediate results and late clinical outcomes. , 2003, Journal of neurosurgery.

[4]  Adnan I. Qureshi,et al.  Management of carotid artery stenosis: Comparing endarterectomy and stenting , 2003, Current cardiology reports.

[5]  G. Stone,et al.  PERIPHERAL VASCULAR DISEASE Original Studies Initial Multicenter Experience With a Novel Distal Protection Filter During Carotid Artery Stent Implantation , 2003 .

[6]  G. New,et al.  Multicenter study of the feasibility and safety of using the memotherm carotid arterial stent for extracranial carotid artery stenosis. , 2002, Journal of neurosurgery.

[7]  H. Jaeger,et al.  Carotid Artery Stenting Protected With an Emboli Containment System , 2002, Stroke.

[8]  D. Antoniucci,et al.  Use of the Parodi anti-embolism system in carotid stenting: Italian trial results. , 2002, Journal of endovascular therapy : an official journal of the International Society of Endovascular Specialists.

[9]  S. Macdonald,et al.  Multicenter evaluation of carotid artery stenting with a filter protection system. , 2002, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[10]  A. Wakhloo,et al.  Stent placement for the treatment of occlusive atherosclerotic carotid artery disease in patients with concomitant coronary artery disease. , 2002, Journal of neurosurgery.

[11]  Gordon H Guyatt,et al.  Can we individualize the 'number needed to treat'? An empirical study of summary effect measures in meta-analyses. , 2002, International journal of epidemiology.

[12]  R. Hobson.  Update on the Carotid Revascularization Endarterectomy versus Stent Trial (CREST) protocol. , 2002, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[13]  O. Dirsch,et al.  Balloon-Protected Carotid Artery Stenting: Relationship of Periprocedural Neurological Complications With the Size of Particulate Debris , 2001, Circulation.

[14]  R. McClure,et al.  Carotid angioplasty and stenting versus carotid endarterectomy: randomized trial in a community hospital. , 2001, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[15]  Jonathan A C Sterne,et al.  Systematic reviews in health care: Investigating and dealing with publication and other biases in meta-analysis. , 2001, BMJ.

[16]  C. Di Mario,et al.  Cerebral Protection With Filter Devices During Carotid Artery Stenting , 2001, Circulation.

[17]  J M Bland,et al.  Endovascular versus surgical treatment in patients with carotid stenosis in the Carotid and Vertebral Artery Transluminal Angioplasty Study (CAVATAS): a randomised trial , 2001, The Lancet.

[18]  A. Ringer,et al.  Open-label Phase I Clinical Study to Assess the Safety of Intravenous Eptifibatide in Patients Undergoing Internal Carotid Artery Angioplasty and Stent Placement , 2001, Neurosurgery.

[19]  K. Ouriel,et al.  Preprocedural risk stratification: identifying an appropriate population for carotid stenting. , 2001, Journal of vascular surgery.

[20]  S S Iyer,et al.  Immediate and Late Clinical Outcomes of Carotid Artery Stenting in Patients With Symptomatic and Asymptomatic Carotid Artery Stenosis: A 5-Year Prospective Analysis , 2001, Circulation.

[21]  M. Alberts,et al.  Results of a Multicenter Prospective Randomized Trial of Carotid Artery Stenting vs. Carotid Endarterectomy , 2001, Stroke.

[22]  C. Mounayer,et al.  Carotid Stenting for Radiation-Induced Stenoses: A Report of 7 Cases , 2001, Stroke.

[23]  Stephen R. Ramee,et al.  Safety, Efficacy, and Durability of Carotid Artery Stenting for Restenosis following Carotid Endarterectomy: A Multicenter Study , 2000, Journal of endovascular therapy : an official journal of the International Society of Endovascular Specialists.

[24]  S. Feuerbach,et al.  Karotisendarteriektomie und Karotisstenting Pilotstudie eines prospektiven, randomisierten und kontrollierten Vergleichs , 2000, Der Radiologe.

[25]  Hobson Rw nd.  CREST (Carotid Revascularization Endarterectomy versus Stent Trial): background, design, and current status. , 2000 .

[26]  G. Roubin,et al.  Systematic comparison of the early outcome of angioplasty and endarterectomy for symptomatic carotid artery disease. , 2000, Stroke.

[27]  A M Malek,et al.  Endovascular management of extracranial carotid artery dissection achieved using stent angioplasty. , 2000, AJNR. American journal of neuroradiology.

[28]  A. Luft,et al.  Identification of patients at risk for periprocedural neurological deficits associated with carotid angioplasty and stenting. , 2000, Stroke.

[29]  V. Hachinski,et al.  The North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial : surgical results in 1415 patients. , 1999, Stroke.

[30]  A. Wakhloo,et al.  Carotid artery angioplasty and use of stents in high-risk patients with contralateral occlusions. , 1999, Journal of neurosurgery.

[31]  R. Hobson,et al.  Carotid restenosis: operative and endovascular management. , 1999, Journal of vascular surgery.

[32]  D. Sackett,et al.  Benefit of carotid endarterectomy in patients with symptomatic moderate or severe stenosis. North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial Collaborators. , 1998, The New England journal of medicine.

[33]  A. Wakhloo,et al.  Carotid Angioplasty and Stent Placement in Patients with Tandem Stenoses , 1998 .

[34]  P R Bell,et al.  Randomized study of carotid angioplasty and stenting versus carotid endarterectomy: a stopped trial. , 1998, Journal of vascular surgery.

[35]  J. Slattery,et al.  Randomised trial of endarterectomy for recently symptomatic carotid stenosis: final results of the MRC European Carotid Surgery Trial (ECST) , 1998, The Lancet.

[36]  E S Fisher,et al.  Variation in carotid endarterectomy mortality in the Medicare population: trial hospitals, volume, and patient characteristics. , 1998, JAMA.

[37]  G. Samsa,et al.  Multicenter review of preoperative risk factors for endarterectomy for asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis. , 1998, Stroke.

[38]  J. Slattery,et al.  Clinical and angiographic predictors of stroke and death from carotid endarterectomy: systematic review , 1997, BMJ.

[39]  George Davey Smith,et al.  Meta-analysis: Principles and procedures , 1997, BMJ.

[40]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  Quantitative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews , 1997, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[41]  G. Smith,et al.  Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test , 1997, BMJ.

[42]  G. Stukenborg,et al.  Comparison of carotid endarterectomy outcomes from randomized controlled trials and Medicare administrative databases. , 1997, Archives of neurology.

[43]  M. Massetti,et al.  Asymptomatic carotid stenosis in patients undergoing major cardiac surgery: can percutaneous carotid angioplasty be an alternative? , 1997, European journal of cardio-thoracic surgery : official journal of the European Association for Cardio-thoracic Surgery.

[44]  A R Jadad,et al.  Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary? , 1996, Controlled clinical trials.

[45]  C. Begg,et al.  Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. , 1994, Biometrics.

[46]  G. Samsa,et al.  Multicenter Review of Preoperative Risk Factors for Carotid Endarterectomy in Patients With Ipsilateral Symptoms , 1994, Stroke.

[47]  W S Moore,et al.  Efficacy of carotid endarterectomy for asymptomatic carotid stenosis. The Veterans Affairs Cooperative Study Group. , 1993, The New England journal of medicine.

[48]  D. Sackett,et al.  Beneficial effect of carotid endarterectomy in symptomatic patients with high-grade carotid stenosis. , 1991, The New England journal of medicine.

[49]  L. Wilkins.  North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial. Methods, patient characteristics, and progress. , 1991, Stroke.

[50]  Lippincott Williams Wilkins,et al.  Study design for randomized prospective trial of carotid endarterectomy for asymptomatic atherosclerosis. The Asymptomatic Carotid Atherosclerosis Study Group. , 1989, Stroke.

[51]  A. Casasco,et al.  Percutaneous angioplasty of atherosclerotic and postsurgical stenosis of carotid arteries. , 1987, AJNR. American journal of neuroradiology.

[52]  N. Laird,et al.  Meta-analysis in clinical trials. , 1986, Controlled clinical trials.

[53]  C. Kerber,et al.  Catheter dilatation of proximal carotid stenosis during distal bifurcation endarterectomy. , 1980, AJNR. American journal of neuroradiology.