The M&M Critique of the MBH98 Northern Hemisphere Climate Index: Update and Implications

The differences between the results of McIntyre and McKitrick [2003] and Mann et al. [1998] can be reconciled by only two series: The Gaspé cedar ring width series and the first principal component (PC1) from the North American tree ring network. We show that in each case MBH98 methodology differed from what was stated in print and the differences resulted in lower early 15th century index values. In the case of the North American PC1, MBH98 modified the PC algorithm so that the calculation was no longer centered, but claimed that the calculation was “conventional”. The modification caused the PC1 to be dominated by a subset of bristlecone pine ring width series which are widely doubted to be reliable temperature proxies. In the case of the Gaspé cedars, MBH98 did not use archived data, but made an extrapolation, unique within the corpus of over 350 series, and misrepresented the start date of the series. The recent Corrigendum by Mann et al. denied that these differences between the stated methods and actual methods have any effect, a claim we show is false. We also refute the various arguments by Mann et al. purporting to salvage their reconstruction, including their claims of robustness and statistical skill. Finally, we comment on several policy issues arising from this controversy: the lack of consistent requirements for disclosure of data and methods in paleoclimate journals, and the need to recognize the limitations of journal peer review as a quality control standard when scientific studies are used for public policy.

[1]  R. Lawrence,et al.  Spatial Variation in Distribution and Growth Patterns of Old Growth Strip-Bark Pines , 2003 .

[2]  T. Wigley,et al.  On the Average Value of Correlated Time Series, with Applications in Dendroclimatology and Hydrometeorology , 1984 .

[3]  Craig D. Idso,et al.  Reconstructing Climatic and Environmental Changes of the Past 1000 Years: A Reappraisal , 2003 .

[4]  C. P. Sonnett.  Climatic variations and forcing mechanisms of the last 2000 years , 1997 .

[5]  Michael E. Mann,et al.  Global surface temperatures over the past two millennia , 2003 .

[6]  J. Overpeck,et al.  Global Temperature Patterns in Past Centuries: An Interactive Presentation , 2000 .

[7]  Edward R. Cook,et al.  Low-Frequency Signals in Long Tree-Ring Chronologies for Reconstructing Past Temperature Variability , 2002, Science.

[8]  Eduardo Zorita,et al.  Testing the Mann et al. (1998) Approach to Paleoclimate Reconstructions in the Context of a 1000-Yr Control Simulation with the ECHO-G Coupled Climate Model , 2003 .

[9]  S. Idso,et al.  Detecting the aerial fertilization effect of atmospheric CO2 enrichment in tree‐ring chronologies , 1993 .

[10]  Thomas J. Crowley,et al.  How Warm Was the Medieval Warm Period? , 2000 .

[11]  V. Lamarche,et al.  Chronologies from Termperature-Sensitive Bristlecone Pines at Upper Treeline in Western United States , 1974 .

[12]  M. Hughes,et al.  Frequency-Dependent Climate Signal in Upper and Lower Forest Border Tree Rings in the Mountains of the Great Basin , 2003 .

[13]  H. Mooney,et al.  Substrate-oriented Distribution of Bristlecone Pine in the White Mountains of California , 1965 .

[14]  A. Schauer,et al.  Partial cambial mortality in high-elevation Pinus aristata (Pinaceae). , 2001, American journal of botany.

[15]  G. Jacoby,et al.  Tree rings, carbon dioxide, and climatic change. , 1997, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[16]  T. Sisk.  Perspectives on the Land Use History of North America: A Context for Understanding Our Changing Environment , 1998 .

[17]  W. D. Billings,et al.  Composition of a Stand of Old Bristlecone Pines in the White Mountains of California , 1957 .

[18]  M R Rose,et al.  Increasing Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide: Tree Ring Evidence for Growth Enhancement in Natural Vegetation , 1984, Science.

[19]  J. Houghton,et al.  Climate change 2001 : the scientific basis , 2001 .

[20]  Gazette , 2005 .

[21]  Frequency-Dependent Climate Signal in Upper and Lower Forest Border Tree Rings in the Mountains of the Great Basin , 2003 .

[22]  C. Brooks.  Climatic Change , 1913, Nature.

[23]  Ross McKitrick,et al.  Corrections to the Mann et. al. (1998) Proxy Data Base and Northern Hemispheric Average Temperature Series , 2003 .

[24]  H. Mooney,et al.  Altithermal Timberline Advance in Western United States , 1967, Nature.

[25]  Jean Jouzel,et al.  Climatic Variations and Forcing Mechanisms of the Last 2000 Years , 1996 .

[26]  E. Cook,et al.  Constrained Growth, Cambial Mortality, and Dendrochronology of Ancient Thuja occidentalis on Cliffs of the Niagara Escarpment: An Eastern Version of Bristlecone Pine? , 1992, International Journal of Plant Sciences.

[27]  C. Symon,et al.  Arctic climate impact assessment , 2005 .

[28]  V. Lamarche.  Holocene Climatic Variations Inferred from Treeline Fluctuations in the White Mountains, California , 1973, Quaternary Research.

[29]  R. M. Lanner,et al.  Does bristlecone pine senesce? , 2001, Experimental Gerontology.

[30]  Edward R. Cook,et al.  SPATIAL REGRESSION METHODS IN DENDROCLIMATOLOGY: A REVIEW AND COMPARISON OF TWO TECHNIQUES , 1994 .

[31]  R. Bradley,et al.  'Little Ice Age' summer temperature variations: their nature and relevance to recent global warming trends , 1993 .

[32]  A. Schoettle.  Ecological roles of five-needle pine in Colorado: Potential consequences of their loss , 2004 .

[33]  P. Jones,et al.  Low-frequency temperature variations from a northern tree ring density , 2001 .

[34]  Eduardo Zorita,et al.  Reconstructing Past Climate from Noisy Data , 2004, Science.

[35]  Y. Bergeron,et al.  An 802-year tree-ring chronology from the Quebec boreal forest , 1992 .

[36]  P. Brooks,et al.  Microbial activity under alpine snowpacks, Niwot Ridge, Colorado , 1996 .

[37]  H. Fritts,et al.  Bristlecone Pine in the White Mountains of California. , 1970 .

[38]  Jerry G. Thursby,et al.  Replication in Empirical Economics: The Journal of Money, Credit and Banking Project , 1986 .

[39]  H. Mooney,et al.  The Pinyon Woodland Zone in the White Mountains of California , 1965 .

[40]  H. Mooney,et al.  Wintertime Photosynthesis of Bristlecone Pine (Pinus Aristata) In the White Mountains of California , 1967 .

[41]  Michael E. Mann,et al.  Climate over past millennia , 2004 .

[42]  Ranga B. Myneni,et al.  Thresholds for warming‐induced growth decline at elevational tree line in the Yukon Territory, Canada , 2004 .

[43]  Rosanne D'Arrigo,et al.  Reconstructed Northern Hemisphere annual temperature since 1671 based on high-latitude tree-ring data from North America , 1989 .

[44]  G. Jacoby,et al.  A 1000-year record of winter precipitation from northwestern New Mexico, USA: a reconstruction from tree-rings and its relation to El Niño and the Southern Oscillation , 1991 .

[45]  M. Hughes,et al.  Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries , 1998 .

[46]  M. Hughes,et al.  Northern hemisphere temperatures during the past millennium: Inferences, uncertainties, and limitations , 1999 .

[47]  J. Muir,et al.  My first summer in the Sierra , 1911 .

[48]  H. Mooney,et al.  The Gas Exchange Capacity of Plants in Relation to Vegetation Zonation in the White Mountains of California , 1964 .

[49]  L. Graumlich.  Subalpine Tree Growth, Climate, and Increasing CO_2: An Assessment of Recent Growth Trends , 1991 .

[50]  Effects of Tree Age on Pollen, Seed, and Seedling Characteristics in Great Basin Bristlecone Pine , 1991, Botanical Gazette.

[51]  H. Vinod,et al.  Verifying the Solution from a Nonlinear Solver: A Case Study , 2004 .

[52]  Edward R. Cook,et al.  Calculating unbiased tree-ring indices for the study of climatic and environmental change , 1997 .

[53]  Malcolm K. Hughes,et al.  corrigendum: Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries , 2004 .

[54]  Ross McKitrick,et al.  Hockey sticks, principal components, and spurious significance , 2005 .

[55]  J. Wiedemann.  My First Summer in the Sierra , 2007 .

[56]  T. Crowley,et al.  How Warm Was the Medieval Warm Period , 2000 .

[57]  H. Mooney,et al.  Field Measurements of the Metabolic Responses of Bristlecone Pine and Big Sagebrush in the White Mountains of California , 1966, Botanical Gazette.

[58]  M. Hughes,et al.  REPLY TO "Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcings over the past six centuries: A comment." By S. McIntyre and R. McKitrick , 2004 .

[59]  Arctic Monitoring,et al.  Impacts of a warming Arctic : Arctic Climate Impact Assessment , 2004 .

[60]  E. Cook,et al.  A 1397-year tree-ring chronology of Thuja occidentalis from cliff faces of the Niagara Escarpment, southern Ontario, Canada. , 1994 .

[61]  Malcolm K. Hughes,et al.  Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries , 1998, Nature.

[62]  K. Briffa,et al.  Seeing the Wood from the Trees , 1999, Science.

[63]  Fritz H. Schweingruber,et al.  Fennoscandian summers from ad 500: temperature changes on short and long timescales , 1992 .

[64]  P. Jones,et al.  Unusual twentieth-century summer warmth in a 1,000-year temperature record from Siberia , 1995, Nature.

[65]  P. Jones,et al.  Tree-Ring Density Reconstructions of Summer Temperature Patterns across Western North America since 1600 , 1992 .

[66]  T. P. Barnett,et al.  High-resolution palaeoclimatic records for the last millennium: interpretation, integration and comparison with General Circulation Model control-run temperatures , 1998 .

[67]  R. McKitrick,et al.  Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcings over the past six centuries: A comment , 2004 .

[68]  Edward R. Cook,et al.  Climatic change over the last millennium in Tasmania reconstructed from tree-rings , 1992 .

[69]  D. Larson,et al.  Environmental controls of carbon uptake in two woody species with contrasting distributions at the edge of cliffs. , 1990 .

[70]  M. Barbetti,et al.  Climatic Change in Tasmania Inferred from a 1089-Year Tree-Ring Chronology of Huon Pine , 1991, Science.