Modeling Tube Clearance and Bounding the Effect of Friction in Concentric Tube Robot Kinematics

The shape of a concentric tube robot depends not only on the relative rotations and translations of its constituent tubes, but also on the history of relative tube displacements. Existing mechanics-based models neglect all history-dependent phenomena with the result that when calibrated on experimental data collected over a robot's workspace, the maximum tip position error can exceed 8 mm for a 200-mm-long robot. In this paper, we develop a model that computes the bounding kinematic solutions in which Coulomb friction is acting either to maximize or minimize the relative twisting between each pair of contacting tubes. The path histories associated with these limiting cases correspond to first performing all tube translations and then performing relative tube rotations of sufficient angle so that the maximum Coulomb friction force is obtained along the interface of each contacting tube pair. The robot tip configurations produced by these path histories are shown experimentally to bound position error with respect to the estimated frictionless model compared to path histories comprised of translation or mixed translation and rotation. Intertube friction forces and torques are computed as proportional to the intertube contact forces. To compute these contact forces, the standard zero-clearance assumption that constrains the concentrically combined tubes to possess the same centerline is relaxed. The effects of clearance and friction are explored through numerical and physical experiments and it is shown that friction can explain much of the prediction error observed in existing models. This model is not intended for real-time control, but rather for path planning—to provide error bounds and to inform how the ordering of tube rotations and translations can be used to reduce the effect of friction.