SYNTAX OR SEMANTICS? HANDLING NONLOCAL DEPENDENCIES WITH MCTAGS OR SYNCHRONOUS TAGS

We show how multicomponent TAGs, although in their “local” version equivalent to “simple” TAGs, enable one to associate the derived structures with a richer set of derivations. This is especially useful for representing some nonlocal dependencies such as wh‐extraction out of NP or extraposition, as soon as one interprets the derivation structures as representing the predicate‐argument dependencies. However, there is a formal alternative in the formalism of synchronous TAGs that achieves a similar result, namely, that associates standard syntactic derivations with nonisomorphic semantic derivations, and relies on the latter to represent the dependency relations. We show that the latter treatment accounts for a different range of extraposition facts in French, where the relationship between the head noun and its extraposed dependent is a semantic one.