Comparing Specialty and Primary Palliative Care Interventions: Analysis of a Systematic Review.

Background: Investigators have tested interventions delivered by specialty palliative care (SPC) clinicians, or by clinicians without palliative care specialization (primary palliative care, PPC). Objective: To compare the characteristics and outcomes of randomized clinical trials (RCTs) of SPC and PPC interventions. Design: Systematic review secondary analysis. Setting/Subjects: RCTs of palliative care interventions. Measurements: Interventions were classified SPC if delivered by palliative care board-certified or subspecialty trained clinicians, or those with extensive clinical experience; all others were PPC. We abstracted data for each intervention: delivery setting, delivery clinicians, outcomes measured, trial results, and Cochrane's Risk of Bias. We conducted narrative synthesis for quality of life, symptom burden, and survival. Results: Of 43 RCTs, 27 tested SPC and 16 tested PPC interventions. SPC interventions were more comprehensive (4.2 elements of palliative care vs. 3.1 in PPC, p = 0.02). SPC interventions were delivered in inpatient (44%) or outpatient settings (52%) by specialty physicians (44%) and nurses (44%); PPC interventions were delivered in inpatient (38%) and home settings (38%) by nurses (75%). PPC trials were more often of high risk of bias than SPC trials. Improvements were demonstrated on quality of life by SPC and PPC trials and on physical symptoms by SPC trials. Conclusions: Compared to PPC, SPC interventions were more comprehensive, were more often delivered in clinical settings, and demonstrated stronger evidence for improving physical symptoms. In the face of SPC workforce limitations, PPC interventions should be tested in more trials with low risk of bias, and may effectively meet some palliative care needs.

[1]  R. Arnold,et al.  Comparison of Palliative Care Interventions for Cancer versus Heart Failure Patients: A Secondary Analysis of a Systematic Review. , 2019, Journal of palliative medicine.

[2]  I. Higginson,et al.  The escalating global burden of serious health-related suffering: projections to 2060 by world regions, age groups, and health conditions , 2019, The Lancet. Global health.

[3]  L. Hanson,et al.  The Impact of a Community‐Based Serious Illness Care Program on Healthcare Utilization and Patient Care Experience , 2019, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[4]  D. Kavalieratos.  Reading past the p < 0.05’s: The secondary messages of systematic reviews and meta-analyses in palliative care , 2019, Palliative medicine.

[5]  L. Allen,et al.  Effect of a Collaborative Care Intervention vs Usual Care on Health Status of Patients With Chronic Heart Failure: The CASA Randomized Clinical Trial , 2018, JAMA internal medicine.

[6]  Michael Hoerger,et al.  Defining the Elements of Early Palliative Care That Are Associated With Patient-Reported Outcomes and the Delivery of End-of-Life Care. , 2017, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[7]  A. Lala,et al.  Primary palliative care for heart failure: what is it? How do we implement it? , 2017, Heart Failure Reviews.

[8]  Christophe Combescure,et al.  Integrated care at home reduces unnecessary hospitalizations of community-dwelling frail older adults: a prospective controlled trial , 2017, BMC Geriatrics.

[9]  T. Shanafelt,et al.  Future of the Palliative Care Workforce: Preview to an Impending Crisis. , 2017, The American journal of medicine.

[10]  A. Kamal.  "Who Does What?" Ensuring High-Quality and Coordinated Palliative Care With Our Oncology Colleagues. , 2016, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[11]  F. Hopp,et al.  Results of a Hospital-Based Palliative Care Intervention for Patients With an Acute Exacerbation of Chronic Heart Failure. , 2016, Journal of cardiac failure.

[12]  S. Morton,et al.  Association Between Palliative Care and Patient and Caregiver Outcomes: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. , 2016, JAMA.

[13]  M. Krzyzanowska,et al.  Early Palliative Care and Its Role in Oncology: A Qualitative Study. , 2016, The oncologist.

[14]  J. Spetz,et al.  Few Hospital Palliative Care Programs Meet National Staffing Recommendations. , 2016, Health affairs.

[15]  Binhuan Wang,et al.  Emergency Department-Initiated Palliative Care in Advanced Cancer: A Randomized Clinical Trial. , 2016, JAMA oncology.

[16]  Michael B. Spring,et al.  Web‐based collaborative care intervention to manage cancer‐related symptoms in the palliative care setting , 2016, Cancer.

[17]  I. Higginson,et al.  The clinical and cost effectiveness of a Breathlessness Intervention Service for patients with advanced non-malignant disease and their informal carers: mixed findings of a mixed method randomised controlled trial , 2016, Trials.

[18]  A. Abernethy,et al.  Prevalence and Predictors of Burnout Among Hospice and Palliative Care Clinicians in the U.S. , 2016, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[19]  P. Lee,et al.  Effects of a transitional palliative care model on patients with end-stage heart failure: a randomised controlled trial , 2016, Heart.

[20]  S. Gettinger,et al.  An Advanced Practice Nurse Coordinated Multidisciplinary Intervention for Patients with Late-Stage Cancer: A Cluster Randomized Trial. , 2015, Journal of palliative medicine.

[21]  D. Meier,et al.  Evolving the Palliative Care Workforce to Provide Responsive, Serious Illness Care , 2015, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[22]  I. Higginson,et al.  Nurse-led palliative care for HIV-positive patients taking antiretroviral therapy in Kenya: a randomised controlled trial. , 2015, The lancet. HIV.

[23]  John S Rumsfeld,et al.  Primary Results of the Patient-Centered Disease Management (PCDM) for Heart Failure Study: A Randomized Clinical Trial. , 2015, JAMA internal medicine.

[24]  Mark T Hegel,et al.  Early Versus Delayed Initiation of Concurrent Palliative Oncology Care: Patient Outcomes in the ENABLE III Randomized Controlled Trial. , 2015, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[25]  A. Sillah,et al.  Inpatient palliative care for patients with acute heart failure: outcomes from a randomized trial. , 2015, Journal of palliative medicine.

[26]  I. Higginson,et al.  An integrated palliative and respiratory care service for patients with advanced disease and refractory breathlessness: a randomised controlled trial. , 2014, The Lancet. Respiratory medicine.

[27]  J. Temel,et al.  Clinician roles in early integrated palliative care for patients with advanced cancer: a qualitative study. , 2014, Journal of palliative medicine.

[28]  I. Higginson,et al.  Is a specialist breathlessness service more effective and cost-effective for patients with advanced cancer and their carers than standard care? Findings of a mixed-method randomised controlled trial , 2014, BMC Medicine.

[29]  K. Boman,et al.  Effects of person‐centred and integrated chronic heart failure and palliative home care. PREFER: a randomized controlled study , 2014, European journal of heart failure.

[30]  B. McNeil,et al.  Racial disparities in cancer care in the Veterans Affairs health care system and the role of site of care. , 2014, American journal of public health.

[31]  Allan Donner,et al.  Early palliative care for patients with advanced cancer: a cluster-randomised controlled trial , 2014, The Lancet.

[32]  S. Radwany,et al.  Results of the promoting effective advance care planning for elders (PEACE) randomized pilot study. , 2014, Population health management.

[33]  K. Johnson.  Racial and ethnic disparities in palliative care. , 2013, Journal of palliative medicine.

[34]  A. Abernethy,et al.  Generalist plus specialist palliative care--creating a more sustainable model. , 2013, The New England journal of medicine.

[35]  D. Ronis,et al.  Randomized clinical trial of a brief and extensive dyadic intervention for advanced cancer patients and their family caregivers , 2013, Psycho-oncology.

[36]  P. Brown,et al.  Randomized controlled trial of maintaining quality of life during radiotherapy for advanced cancer , 2013, Cancer.

[37]  J. Sloan,et al.  A nurse practitioner directed intervention improves the quality of life of patients with metastatic cancer: results of a randomized pilot study. , 2012, Journal of palliative medicine.

[38]  G. Wallen,et al.  Palliative care outcomes in surgical oncology patients with advanced malignancies: a mixed methods approach , 2011, Quality of Life Research.

[39]  D. Meier,et al.  America's care of serious illness: a state-by-state report card on access to palliative care in our nation's hospitals. , 2011, Journal of palliative medicine.

[40]  C. Landefeld,et al.  Hospital-based palliative medicine consultation: a randomized controlled trial. , 2010, Archives of internal medicine.

[41]  D. Lupu.  Estimate of current hospice and palliative medicine physician workforce shortage. , 2010, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[42]  Alona Muzikansky,et al.  Early palliative care for patients with metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer. , 2010, The New England journal of medicine.

[43]  I. Higginson,et al.  Palliative care for people severely affected by multiple sclerosis: evaluation of a novel palliative care service , 2010, Multiple sclerosis.

[44]  D. Milliss,et al.  Palliative care teams in the intensive care unit: a randomised, controlled, feasibility study. , 2010, Critical care and resuscitation : journal of the Australasian Academy of Critical Care Medicine.

[45]  Mark T Hegel,et al.  Effects of a palliative care intervention on clinical outcomes in patients with advanced cancer: the Project ENABLE II randomized controlled trial. , 2009, JAMA.

[46]  R. D. Della Penna,et al.  Impact of an inpatient palliative care team: a randomized control trial. , 2008, Journal of palliative medicine.

[47]  David C. Smith,et al.  Randomized clinical trial of a family intervention for prostate cancer patients and their spouses , 2007, Cancer.

[48]  R. Grol,et al.  Obstacles to the delivery of primary palliative care as perceived by GPs , 2007, Palliative medicine.

[49]  R. Toseland,et al.  Effectiveness of advanced illness care teams for nursing home residents with dementia. , 2007, Social work.

[50]  S. Enguídanos,et al.  Increased Satisfaction with Care and Lower Costs: Results of a Randomized Trial of In‐Home Palliative Care , 2007, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[51]  D. Meier,et al.  The national agenda for quality palliative care: the National Consensus Project and the National Quality Forum. , 2007, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[52]  P. Brown,et al.  Impacting quality of life for patients with advanced cancer with a structured multidisciplinary intervention: a randomized controlled trial. , 2006, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[53]  R. Toseland,et al.  Effects of a program for coordinated care of advanced illness on patients, surrogates, and healthcare costs: a randomized trial. , 2006, The American journal of managed care.

[54]  Jonathan E. Butner,et al.  Outcome evaluation of a randomized trial of the PhoenixCare intervention: program of case management and coordinated care for the seriously chronically ill. , 2006, Journal of palliative medicine.

[55]  T. Kershaw,et al.  Effects of a family intervention on the quality of life of women with recurrent breast cancer and their family caregivers , 2005, Psycho-oncology.

[56]  P. A. Fox.  Developing primary palliative care , 2005, British medical journal.

[57]  S. Mcphee,et al.  The comprehensive care team: a controlled trial of outpatient palliative medicine consultation. , 2004, Archives of internal medicine.

[58]  T. Peters,et al.  The imPaCT study: a randomised controlled trial to evaluate a hospital palliative care team , 2002, British Journal of Cancer.

[59]  P. Fayers,et al.  Quality of life in palliative cancer care: results from a cluster randomized trial. , 2001, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[60]  P. Fayers,et al.  A palliative-care intervention and death at home: a cluster randomised trial , 2000, The Lancet.

[61]  S. Barclay,et al.  Does hospital at home for palliative care facilitate death at home? Randomised controlled trial , 1999, BMJ.

[62]  William A. Knaus,et al.  A controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatments (SUPPORT). The SUPPORT Principal Investigators. , 1995, JAMA.

[63]  F. Weaver,et al.  A randomized trial of the cost effectiveness of VA hospital-based home care for the terminally ill. , 1992, Health services research.

[64]  C. Moinpour,et al.  A randomized clinical trial of home nursing care for lung cancer patients , 1989, Cancer.

[65]  Arleen Leibowitz,et al.  A RANDOMISED CONTROLLED TRIAL OF HOSPICE CARE , 1984, The Lancet.

[66]  J. McCusker,et al.  Effects of a Physician‐led Home Care Team on Terminal Care , 1984, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[67]  A. Kelley,et al.  Identifying the Population with Serious Illness: The "Denominator" Challenge. , 2018, Journal of palliative medicine.

[68]  Thomas J. Smith,et al.  Integration of Palliative Care Into Standard Oncology Care: American Society of Clinical Oncology Clinical Practice Guideline Update. , 2017, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[69]  J. Higgins.  Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration , 2011 .

[70]  B. Given,et al.  Pain and fatigue management: results of a nursing randomized clinical trial. , 2002, Oncology nursing forum.

[71]  D. Meier,et al.  Palliative care in advanced dementia: a randomized controlled trial and descriptive analysis. , 2000, Journal of palliative medicine.