The effectiveness of non-native fish removal techniques in freshwater ecosystems: a systematic review

In aquatic systems, biological invasions can result in adverse ecological effects. Management techniques available for non-native fish removal programs (including eradication and population size control) vary widely, but include chemicals, harvest regimes, physical removal, or biological control. For management agencies, deciding on what non-native fish removal program to use has been challenging because there is little reliable information about the relative effectiveness of these measures in controlling or eradicating non-native fish. We conducted a systematic review, including a critical appraisal of study validity, to assess the effectiveness of different non-native fish removal methods and to identify the factors that influence the overall success rate of each type of method. We found 95 relevant studies, generating 158 data sets. The evidence base was dominated by poorly documented studies with inadequate experimental designs (76% of removal projects). When the management goal was non-native fish eradication, chemical treatments were relatively successful (antimycin 89%; rotenone 75%) compared with other interventions. Electrofishing and passive removal measure studies indicated successful eradication was possible (58% each) but required intensive effort and multiple treatments over a number of years. Of these studies with sufficient information, electrofishing had the highest success for population size control (56% of data sets). Overall, inadequate data quality and completeness severely limited our ability to make strong conclusions about the relationships between non-native fish abundance and different methods of eradication and population control and the factors influencing the overall success rate of each method. Our review highlights that there is considerable scope for improving our evaluations of non-native fish removal methods. It is recommended that programs should have explicitly stated objectives, better data reporting, and study designs that (when possible and appropriate) incorporate replicated and controlled investigations with rigorous, long-term quantitative monitoring. Future research on the effectiveness of non-native fish removal methods should focus on: (i) the efficacy of existing or potentially new removal measures in larger, more complex environments; (ii) a broader range of removal measures in general; and (iii) phenotypic characteristics of individual fish within a population that fail to be eradicated or controlled.

[1]  M. Siefkes.  Use of physiological knowledge to control the invasive sea lamprey (Petromyzon marinus) in the Laurentian Great Lakes , 2017, Conservation physiology.

[2]  Neal R Haddaway,et al.  A Call for Evidence-Based Conservation and Management of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources , 2017 .

[3]  D. Morgan,et al.  Rapid proliferation of an endemic galaxiid following eradication of an alien piscivore (Perca fluviatilis) from a reservoir. , 2017, Journal of fish biology.

[4]  Helen R. Bayliss,et al.  The reliability of evidence review methodology in environmental science and conservation , 2016 .

[5]  Adam J. Sepulveda,et al.  Potential of Environmental DNA to Evaluate Northern Pike (Esox lucius) Eradication Efforts: An Experimental Test and Case Study , 2016, PloS one.

[6]  R. MacNamara,et al.  Bigheaded carps (Hypophthalmichthys spp.) at the edge of their invaded range: using hydroacoustics to assess population parameters and the efficacy of harvest as a control strategy in a large North American river , 2016, Biological Invasions.

[7]  Steven J. Cooke,et al.  The effectiveness of non-native fish eradication techniques in freshwater ecosystems: a systematic review protocol , 2016, Environmental Evidence.

[8]  Ian G. Cowx,et al.  European Non-native Species in Aquaculture Risk Analysis Scheme – a summary of assessment protocols and decision support tools for use of alien species in aquaculture , 2016 .

[9]  J. Britton,et al.  Assessing the efficacy and ecology of biocontrol and biomanipulation for managing invasive pest fish , 2015 .

[10]  Mark K. Taylor,et al.  Nonchemical Eradication of an Introduced Trout from a Headwater Complex in Banff National Park, Canada , 2015 .

[11]  J. Whitney,et al.  Efficacy of Mechanically Removing Nonnative Predators from a Desert Stream , 2015 .

[12]  K. Meyer,et al.  Evaluating the Ability of Tiger Muskellunge to Eradicate Brook Trout in Idaho Alpine Lakes , 2015 .

[13]  R. Britton,et al.  Impacts of invasive fish removal through angling on population characteristics and juvenile growth rate , 2015, Ecology and evolution.

[14]  P. Budy,et al.  Demographic changes following mechanical removal of exotic brown trout in an Intermountain West (USA), high-elevation stream , 2015 .

[15]  S. Cooke,et al.  Improving science-based invasive species management with physiological knowledge, concepts, and tools , 2015, Biological Invasions.

[16]  T. Hrabik,et al.  A whole-lake experiment to control invasive rainbow smelt (Actinoperygii, Osmeridae) via overharvest and a food web manipulation , 2015, Hydrobiologia.

[17]  P. Sorensen.  Applications of Pheromones in Invasive Fish Control and Fishery Conservation , 2014 .

[18]  M. Taper,et al.  Factors Influencing Successful Eradication of Nonnative Brook Trout from Four Small Rocky Mountain Streams Using Electrofishing , 2014 .

[19]  Jason E. Davis,et al.  Fish Community Responses to Mechanical Removal of Nonnative Fishes in a Large Southwestern River , 2014 .

[20]  J. Eilers,et al.  Fate and behavior of rotenone in Diamond Lake, Oregon, USA following invasive tui chub eradication , 2014, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[21]  C. S. Guy,et al.  Comparison of Harvest Scenarios for the Cost-Effective Suppression of Lake Trout in Swan Lake, Montana , 2013 .

[22]  M. Lintermans.  A review of on-ground recovery actions for threatened freshwater fish in Australia , 2013 .

[23]  A. Ruiz-Navarro,et al.  Removal control of the highly invasive fish Gambusia holbrooki and effects on its population biology: learning by doing , 2013, Wildlife Research.

[24]  D. K. Hering,et al.  Eradication of Nonnative Brook Trout with Electrofishing and Antimycin-A and the Response of a Remnant Bull Trout Population , 2013 .

[25]  T. Hoffman.  Fifty Years of Invasion Ecology: The Legacy of Charles Elton , 2012 .

[26]  A. Springer,et al.  Have wet meadow restoration projects in the Southwestern U.S. been effective in restoring geomorphology, hydrology, soils, and plant species composition? , 2012, Environmental Evidence.

[27]  P. H. Rissler,et al.  Effect of Brook Trout Removal from a Spawning Stream on an Adfluvial Population of Lahontan Cutthroat Trout , 2012 .

[28]  Andrew Sih,et al.  Ecological implications of behavioural syndromes. , 2012, Ecology letters.

[29]  P. Donkers,et al.  Validation of mark-recapture population estimates for invasive common carp, Cyprinus carpio, in Lake Crescent, Tasmania , 2012 .

[30]  P. Bajer,et al.  Using the Judas technique to locate and remove wintertime aggregations of invasive common carp , 2011 .

[31]  C. S. Guy,et al.  Response of non-native lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush) to 15 years of harvest in Yellowstone Lake, Yellowstone National Park , 2011 .

[32]  T. Therriault,et al.  Recreational boating: a large unregulated vector transporting marine invasive species , 2011 .

[33]  J. Britton,et al.  Managing non‐native fish in the environment , 2011 .

[34]  A. Champigneulle,et al.  Multiple electrofishing as a mitigate tool for removing nonnative Atlantic brown trout (Salmo trutta L.) threatening a native Mediterranean brown trout population , 2011, European Journal of Wildlife Research.

[35]  D. Russell,et al.  An evaluation of electrofishing as a control measure for an invasive tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus) population in northern Australia , 2011 .

[36]  J. Britton,et al.  A modular assessment tool for managing introduced fishes according to risks of species and their populations, and impacts of management actions , 2011, Biological Invasions.

[37]  H. MacIsaac,et al.  Impacts of Biological Invasions on Freshwater Ecosystems , 2010 .

[38]  J. Marks,et al.  Effects of Flow Restoration and Exotic Species Removal on Recovery of Native Fish: Lessons from a Dam Decommissioning , 2010 .

[39]  P. Moyle,et al.  Brook Trout Removal as a Conservation Tool to Restore Eagle Lake Rainbow Trout , 2010 .

[40]  J. Britton,et al.  Current knowledge on non‐native freshwater fish introductions , 2010 .

[41]  M. Vinson,et al.  Piscicides and Invertebrates: After 70 Years, Does Anyone Really Know? , 2010 .

[42]  S. Rochfort,et al.  Carp chemical sensing and the potential of natural environmental attractants for control of carp: a review , 2009 .

[43]  J. Firehammer,et al.  Coeur d'Alene Tribe Fisheries Program : Implementation of Fisheries Enhancement Opportunities on the Coeur d’Alene Reservation : 2007 Annual Report. , 2009 .

[44]  R. Gozlan,et al.  Identification of a rosette-like agent as Sphaerothecum destruens, a multi-host fish pathogen. , 2009, International journal for parasitology.

[45]  J. Britton,et al.  Case studies on eradicating the Asiatic cyprinid Pseudorasbora parva from fishing lakes in England to prevent their riverine dispersal , 2008 .

[46]  D. Willis,et al.  The effects of mechanically reducing northern pike density on the sport fish community of West Long Lake, Nebraska, USA. , 2008 .

[47]  J. Olden,et al.  A management framework for preventing the secondary spread of aquatic invasive species , 2008 .

[48]  M. Petticrew,et al.  Systematic reviews – do they ‘work’ in informing decision-making around health inequalities? , 2008, Health Economics, Policy and Law.

[49]  K. Fausch,et al.  Analysis of trade-offs between threats of invasion by nonnative brook trout ( Salvelinus fontinalis ) and intentional isolation for native westslope cutthroat trout ( Oncorhynchus clarkii lewisi ) , 2008 .

[50]  C. Kraft,et al.  Littoral Fish Community Response to Smallmouth Bass Removal from an Adirondack Lake , 2007 .

[51]  D. Lodge,et al.  Take a risk: Preferring prevention over control of biological invaders , 2007 .

[52]  V. Vredenburg,et al.  Removal of nonnative fish results in population expansion of a declining amphibian (mountain yellow-legged frog, Rana muscosa). , 2007, Biological conservation.

[53]  Armando J. Contreras-Balderas,et al.  ERADICATION OF SPOTTED JEWELFISH, HEMICHROMIS GUTTATUS, FROM POZA SAN JOSÉ DEL ANTEOJO, CUATRO CIÉNEGAS BOLSÓN, COAHUILA, MEXICO , 2006 .

[54]  A. Pullin,et al.  Guidelines for Systematic Review in Conservation and Environmental Management , 2006, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[55]  K. Meyer,et al.  Evaluation of an Unsuccessful Brook Trout Electrofishing Removal Project in a Small Rocky Mountain Stream , 2006 .

[56]  J. Britton,et al.  Eradicating the invasive topmouth gudgeon, Pseudorasbora parva, from a recreational fishery in northern England. , 2006 .

[57]  Andrew S. Pullin,et al.  Are review articles a reliable source of evidence to support conservation and environmental management? A comparison with medicine , 2006 .

[58]  T. Rayner,et al.  A review of rotenone use for the control of non‐indigenous fish in Australian fresh waters, and an attempted eradication of the noxious fish, Phalloceros caudimaculatus , 2006 .

[59]  A. Lazur,et al.  Acute Toxicity of 5% Rotenone to Northern Snakeheads , 2006 .

[60]  Brian D. Ertel,et al.  Nonnative Lake Trout Result in Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout Decline and Impacts to Bears and Anglers , 2005 .

[61]  P. Genovesi.  Eradications of invasive alien species in Europe: a review , 2005, Biological Invasions.

[62]  D. Pimentel,et al.  Update on the environmental and economic costs associated with alien-invasive species in the United States , 2005 .

[63]  Michael Margolis,et al.  Bang for the Buck : Cost-Effective Control of Invasive Species with Different Life Histories , 2004 .

[64]  S. Santavirta,et al.  Current management , 2005, Acta orthopaedica.

[65]  R. Hoffman,et al.  Responses of Ambystoma gracile to the Removal of Introduced Nonnative Fish from a Mountain Lake , 2004 .

[66]  K. Neilson,et al.  Use of fine‐mesh monofilament gill nets for the removal of rudd (Scardinius erythrophthalmus) from a small lake complex in Waikato, New Zealand , 2004 .

[67]  M. Lintermans.  Human‐assisted dispersal of alien freshwater fish in Australia , 2004 .

[68]  Susan L. Williams,et al.  Beyond ballast water: aquarium and ornamental trades as sources of invasive species in aquatic ecosystems , 2004 .

[69]  A. Vitale,et al.  Implementation of Fisheries Enhancement Opportunities on the Coeur d'Alene Reservation; Coeur d'Alene Tribe Fish, Water, and Wildlife Program, Progress Report 1996-1998. , 2003 .

[70]  J. Post,et al.  Can Anglers Influence the Abundance of Native and Nonnative Salmonids in a Stream from the Canadian Rocky Mountains , 2003 .

[71]  Jonathan M. Levine,et al.  Forecasting Biological Invasions with Increasing International Trade , 2003 .

[72]  D. Schindler,et al.  The Effects of Stocking and Removal of a Nonnative Salmonid on the Plankton of an Alpine Lake , 2001, Ecosystems.

[73]  R. Beamesderfer.  Managing Fish Predators and Competitors: Deciding When Intervention is Effective and Appropriate , 2000 .

[74]  R. B. Jackson,et al.  Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. , 2000, Science.

[75]  S. E. Moore,et al.  Multiple Electrofishing Removals for Eliminating Rainbow Trout in a Small Southern Appalachian Stream , 2000 .

[76]  A. Vitale,et al.  Coeur d'Alene Tribe Fish, Water and Wildlife Program : Coeur d'Alene Tribe Trout Production Facility Master Plan. , 1999 .

[77]  R. Knapp,et al.  Eradication of Nonnative Fish by Gill Netting from a Small Mountain Lake in California , 1998 .

[78]  E. Grosholz,et al.  Global Invasions of Marine and Estuarine Habitats by Non-Indigenous Species: Mechanisms, Extent, and Consequences' , 1997 .

[79]  H. Mooney,et al.  Human Domination of Earth’s Ecosystems , 1997, Renewable Energy.

[80]  J. H. Selgeby,et al.  Evaluation of Piscicides for Control of Ruffe , 1996 .

[81]  J. Leitch,et al.  Interbasin Transfer of Aquatic Biota via Anglers' Bait Buckets , 1996 .

[82]  F. Rahel,et al.  Evaluation of Depletion-Removal Electrofishing of Brook Trout in Small Rocky Mountain Streams , 1996 .

[83]  Robert A. Klumb,et al.  A Review of Fish Control Projects , 1996 .

[84]  R. Gresswell.  Use of Antimycin for Removal of Brook Trout from a Tributary of Yellowstone Lake , 1991 .

[85]  Danny C. Lee,et al.  Angling and Electrofishing for Removing Nonnative Rainbow Trout from a Stream in a National Park , 1986 .

[86]  S. E. Moore,et al.  Population control of exotic rainbow trout in streams of a natural area park , 1986 .

[87]  T. Bills,et al.  Chemical Control of Fish and Fish Eggs in the Garrison Diversion Unit, North Dakota , 1983 .

[88]  G. Meffe.  Attempted Chemical Renovation of an Arizona Springbrook for Management of the Endangered Sonoran Topminnow , 1983 .

[89]  Willie G. Cahoon.  Commercial Carp Removal at Lake Mattamuskeet, North Carolina , 1953 .

[90]  Maynard B. Barrows.  Elimination of Yellow Perch from a Lake by Use of Derris Root , 1939 .

[91]  Mark R. Christie,et al.  Rapid evolution meets invasive species control: the potential for pesticide resistance in sea lamprey , 2018 .

[92]  K. Meyer,et al.  Production of a YY Male Brook Trout Broodstock for Potential Eradication of Undesired Brook Trout Populations , 2016 .

[93]  Miranda Aiken.  The efficacy of small-scale removal of an invasive species (redbreast sunfish, Lepomis auritus) by electrofishing , 2014 .

[94]  D. L. PROPSTa,et al.  EFFICACY OF MECHANICALLY REMOVING NONNATIVE PREDATORS FROM A DESERT STREAM , 2014 .

[95]  J. Aronson,et al.  Impacts of biological invasions: what's what and the way forward. , 2013, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[96]  Nerissa N. Michaels.  Biomanipulation of the largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides population to control invasive species and eutrophication at the Nature Conservancy's Emiquon Preserve , 2011 .

[97]  N. Mandrak,et al.  Summary of the rapid response to round goby (Neogobius melanostomus) in Pefferlaw Brook with an evaluation of the national response framework based on the Pefferlaw Brook experience , 2010 .

[98]  C. Kolar,et al.  Managing undesired and invading fishes , 2010 .

[99]  J. Britton,et al.  Towards the successful control of the invasive Pseudorasbora parva in the UK , 2009, Biological Invasions.

[100]  Lewis George Coggins,et al.  Active adaptive management for native fish conservation in the Grand Canyon: Implementation and evaluation , 2008 .

[101]  J. Robinson,et al.  Management of a Cutthroat Trout Predator to Control Utah Chub in a High-Use Sport Fishery , 2008 .

[102]  A. Pullin,et al.  Are current management recommendations for saproxylic invertebrates effective? A systematic review , 2007, Biodiversity and Conservation.

[103]  L. Walston,et al.  Responses of a Pond-breeding Amphibian Community to the Experimental Removal of Predatory Fish , 2007 .

[104]  David P. Hamilton,et al.  Top down or bottom up? Feasibility of water clarity restoration in the lower Karori Reservoir by fish removal , 2007 .

[105]  K. Fausch,et al.  Strategies for conserving native salmonid populations at risk from nonnative fish invasions: tradeoffs in using barriers to upstream movement , 2006 .

[106]  D. Morgan,et al.  Overview of the feral Goldfish Control Programme in the Vasse River, Western Australia: 2004-2006 , 2006 .

[107]  D. Morgan,et al.  Re-establishment of native freshwater fishes in Bull Creek , 2006 .

[108]  S. Beatty,et al.  Mitigation of the negative impacts on biodiversity and fisheries values of the refurbishment of Waroona Dam, south-western Australia Final report for the Water Corporation of Western Australia , 2005 .

[109]  G. Closs,et al.  Controlling European perch (Perca fluviatilis): lessons from an experimental removal. , 2003 .

[110]  D. Rowe.  Rotenone-based approaches to pest fish control in New Zealand. , 2003 .

[111]  M. Lintermans,et al.  Local Eradication of trout from streams using rotenone: the Australian Experience , 2003 .

[112]  Dennis P. Lee.  Northern Pike Control at Lake Davis, California , 2001 .

[113]  J. Eaton,et al.  Removal of pikeperch (Stizostedion lucioperca) from a British Canal as a management technique to reduce impact on prey fish populations , 1996 .

[114]  D. Rowe,et al.  BIOMANIPULATION OF PLANTS AND FISH TO RESTORE LAKE PARKINSON: A CASE STUDY AND ITS IMPLICATIONS , 1994 .

[115]  R. Mckay,et al.  Occurence of the introduced cichlid Oreochromis mossambicus (Peters) in Queensland , 1984 .

[116]  W. Hooper,et al.  Goldfish eradication, standing crop estimates of fishes and fisheries management recommendations for a small, mesotrophic New Brunswick lake. , 1978 .

[117]  R. E. Lennon.  CONTROL OF FRESHWATER FISH WITH CHEMICALS , 1970 .

[118]  E. Barker,et al.  Department of Fisheries , 2022 .