Reasoning about knowledge: Children’s evaluations of generality and verifiability

In a series of experiments, we examined 3- to 8-year-old children's (N=223) and adults' (N=32) use of two properties of testimony to estimate a speaker's knowledge: generality and verifiability. Participants were presented with a "Generic speaker" who made a series of 4 general claims about "pangolins" (a novel animal kind), and a "Specific speaker" who made a series of 4 specific claims about "this pangolin" as an individual. To investigate the role of verifiability, we systematically varied whether the claim referred to a perceptually-obvious feature visible in a picture (e.g., "has a pointy nose") or a non-evident feature that was not visible (e.g., "sleeps in a hollow tree"). Three main findings emerged: (1) young children showed a pronounced reliance on verifiability that decreased with age. Three-year-old children were especially prone to credit knowledge to speakers who made verifiable claims, whereas 7- to 8-year-olds and adults credited knowledge to generic speakers regardless of whether the claims were verifiable; (2) children's attributions of knowledge to generic speakers was not detectable until age 5, and only when those claims were also verifiable; (3) children often generalized speakers' knowledge outside of the pangolin domain, indicating a belief that a person's knowledge about pangolins likely extends to new facts. Findings indicate that young children may be inclined to doubt speakers who make claims they cannot verify themselves, as well as a developmentally increasing appreciation for speakers who make general claims.

[1]  S. Gelman,et al.  Generic noun phrases in mother–child conversations , 1998, Journal of Child Language.

[2]  P. Harris,et al.  The good, the strong, and the accurate: preschoolers' evaluations of informant attributes. , 2011, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[3]  Michelle A. Hollander,et al.  Generic language and judgements about category membership: Can generics highlight properties as central? , 2009, Language and cognitive processes.

[4]  V. Jaswal,et al.  Characterizing children's expectations about expertise and incompetence: halo or pitchfork effects? , 2011, Child development.

[5]  E. Robinson,et al.  Children's suggestibility in relation to their understanding about sources of knowledge. , 2003, Child development.

[6]  Elizabeth A. Ware,et al.  Effects of generic language on category content and structure , 2010, Cognitive Psychology.

[7]  C. A. J. Coady,et al.  Testimony: A Philosophical Study. , 1994 .

[8]  J. Woolley,et al.  Preschoolers' Magical Explanations for Violations of Physical, Social, and Mental Laws , 2004 .

[9]  Catharine H. Echols,et al.  Infants' understanding of false labeling events: the referential roles of words and the speakers who use them , 2003, Cognition.

[10]  Development of the Use of Conversational Cues to Assess Reality Status , 2011, Journal of cognition and development : official journal of the Cognitive Development Society.

[11]  Sarah-Jane Leslie,et al.  Cultural transmission of social essentialism , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[12]  P. Harris,et al.  Preschoolers mistrust ignorant and inaccurate speakers. , 2005, Child development.

[13]  Jon Star,et al.  Children's interpretation of generic noun phrases. , 2002, Developmental psychology.

[14]  J. Woolley,et al.  Revisiting the fantasy-reality distinction: children as naïve skeptics. , 2013, Child development.

[15]  Andrew Shtulman The development of possibility judgment within and across domains , 2009 .

[16]  Paul L. Harris,et al.  The Ontogenesis of Trust , 2004 .

[17]  P. Harris,et al.  Trust in testimony: how children learn about science and religion. , 2006, Child development.

[18]  Jennifer Lackey,et al.  Learning from Words: Testimony as a Source of Knowledge , 2008 .

[19]  S. Graham,et al.  24-Month-Olds’ Selective Learning Is Not an All-or-None Phenomenon , 2015, PloS one.

[20]  E. Sosa Testimony and Coherence , 1994 .

[21]  C. Chambers,et al.  When hearsay trumps evidence: How generic language guides preschoolers’ inferences about unfamiliar things , 2008 .

[22]  Elizabeth A. Ware,et al.  Children's sensitivity to the knowledge expressed in pedagogical and nonpedagogical contexts. , 2013, Developmental Psychology.

[23]  V. Jaswal,et al.  Adults Don't Always Know Best , 2006, Psychological science.

[24]  Michael M Chouinard Children's questions: a mechanism for cognitive development. , 2007, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development.

[25]  Daniel A. Wilkenfeld,et al.  Depth and deference: When and why we attribute understanding , 2016 .

[26]  P. Bloom,et al.  Three- and four-year-olds spontaneously use others’ past performance to guide their learning , 2008, Cognition.

[27]  Andrei Cimpian,et al.  Remembering kinds: New evidence that categories are privileged in children’s thinking , 2012, Cognitive Psychology.

[28]  Elizabeth F. Shipley,et al.  Categories, hierarchies, and induction , 1993 .

[29]  D. Sobel,et al.  Children monitor individuals' expertise for word learning. , 2010, Child development.

[30]  Frank C Keil,et al.  Early understanding of the division of cognitive labor. , 2002, Child development.

[31]  S. Gelman Learning from others: children's construction of concepts. , 2009, Annual review of psychology.

[32]  P. Pintrich,et al.  The Development of Epistemological Theories: Beliefs About Knowledge and Knowing and Their Relation to Learning , 1997 .

[33]  David M. Sobel,et al.  Knowledge matters: how children evaluate the reliability of testimony as a process of rational inference. , 2013, Psychological review.

[34]  S. Carey,et al.  Improbable or impossible? How children reason about the possibility of extraordinary events. , 2007, Child development.

[35]  T. Kushnir,et al.  "Who can help me fix this toy?" The distinction between causal knowledge and word knowledge guides preschoolers' selective requests for information. , 2013, Developmental psychology.

[36]  Frank C Keil,et al.  Should you ask a fisherman or a biologist?: Developmental shifts in ways of clustering knowledge. , 2004, Child development.

[37]  S. Birch,et al.  Epistemic states and traits: preschoolers appreciate the differential informativeness of situation-specific and person-specific cues to knowledge. , 2011, Child development.

[38]  Andrei Cimpian,et al.  Tell me about Pangolins! Evidence that children are motivated to learn about kinds. , 2014, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[39]  W. Quine,et al.  The web of belief , 1970 .

[40]  D. Poulin-Dubois,et al.  Is a Bird an Apple? The Effect of Speaker Labeling Accuracy on Infants' Word Learning, Imitation, and Helping Behaviors. , 2013, Infancy : the official journal of the International Society on Infant Studies.

[41]  H. Wellman,et al.  Preschoolers' search for explanatory information within adult-child conversation. , 2009, Child development.

[42]  Candice M. Mills Knowing when to doubt: developing a critical stance when learning from others. , 2013, Developmental psychology.

[43]  Stanka A. Fitneva,et al.  The development of children's information gathering: to look or to ask? , 2013, Developmental psychology.

[44]  Andrei Cimpian,et al.  Children expect generic knowledge to be widely shared , 2012, Cognition.

[45]  J. Bering,et al.  Children's attributions of intentions to an invisible agent. , 2006, Developmental psychology.

[46]  S. Gelman,et al.  Beyond labeling: the role of maternal input in the acquisition of richly structured categories. , 1991, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development.

[47]  Frank C Keil,et al.  Adapted Minds and Evolved Schools , 2008, Educational psychologist.

[48]  P. Faulkner What Is Wrong with Lying , 2007 .

[49]  B. Tizard,et al.  Young Children Learning , 1985 .

[50]  S. Gelman,et al.  Two-year-olds use the generic/nongeneric distinction to guide their inferences about novel kinds. , 2011, Child development.

[51]  Erika Nurmsoo,et al.  Children's trust in previously inaccurate informants who were well or poorly informed: when past errors can be excused. , 2009, Child development.

[52]  Jon R. Star,et al.  Children's Use of Generics in Inductive Inferences , 2002 .

[53]  J. Woolley,et al.  The development of children's ability to use evidence to infer reality status. , 2009, Child development.

[54]  M. Koenig,et al.  Varieties of testimony: Children’s selective learning in semantic versus episodic domains , 2015, Cognition.

[55]  Deanna Kuhn,et al.  Epistemological understanding and the development of intellectual values , 2005 .

[56]  S. Gelman,et al.  Children's Recall of Generic and Specific Labels Regarding Animals and People. , 2015, Cognitive development.

[57]  J. Connell,et al.  Individual differences and the development of perceived control. , 1998, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development.

[58]  R. Pea,et al.  Origins of verbal logic: spontaneous denials by two- and three-year olds , 1982, Journal of Child Language.

[59]  J. Bering The folk psychology of souls , 2006, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[60]  M. Koenig Beyond semantic accuracy: preschoolers evaluate a speaker's reasons. , 2012, Child development.