Virtual reality and live simulation: a comparison between two simulation tools for assessing mass casualty triage skills

Objectives This study tested the hypothesis that virtual reality simulation is equivalent to live simulation for testing naive medical students’ abilities to perform mass casualty triage using the Simple Triage and Rapid Treatment (START) algorithm in a simulated disaster scenario and to detect the improvement in these skills after a teaching session. Methods Fifty-six students in their last year of medical school were randomized into two groups (A and B). The same scenario, a car accident, was developed identically on the two simulation methodologies: virtual reality and live simulation. On day 1, group A was exposed to the live scenario and group B was exposed to the virtual reality scenario, aiming to triage 10 victims. On day 2, all students attended a 2-h lecture on mass casualty triage, specifically the START triage method. On day 3, groups A and B were crossed over. The groups’ abilities to perform mass casualty triage in terms of triage accuracy, intervention correctness, and speed in the scenarios were assessed. Results Triage and lifesaving treatment scores were assessed equally by virtual reality and live simulation on day 1 and on day 3. Both simulation methodologies detected an improvement in triage accuracy and treatment correctness from day 1 to day 3 (P<0.001). The time to complete each scenario and its decrease from day 1 to day 3 were detected equally in the two groups (P<0.05). Conclusion Virtual reality simulation proved to be a valuable tool, equivalent to live simulation, to test medical students’ abilities to perform mass casualty triage and to detect improvement in such skills.

[1]  Edbert B Hsu,et al.  Development of evaluation modules for use in hospital disaster drills. , 2007, American journal of disaster medicine.

[2]  Andrei Sherstyuk,et al.  Teaching mass casualty triage skills using immersive three-dimensional virtual reality. , 2008, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[3]  Linda B. Bourque,et al.  Koenig and Schultz's Disaster Medicine: Comprehensive Principles and Practices: CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK AND STRATEGIC OVERVIEW , 2009 .

[4]  C. Colenda,et al.  A Short Medical School Course on Responding to Bioterrorism and Other Disasters , 2005, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[5]  Klaus-Peter Beier,et al.  Using immersive simulation for training first responders for mass casualty incidents. , 2008, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[6]  Lisa Kurland,et al.  Comparison of the SALT and Smart triage systems using a virtual reality simulator with paramedic students , 2011, European journal of emergency medicine : official journal of the European Society for Emergency Medicine.

[7]  James F. Knight,et al.  Serious gaming technology in major incident triage training: a pragmatic controlled trial. , 2010, Resuscitation.

[8]  Davide Colombo,et al.  Evaluation of medical management during a mass casualty incident exercise: an objective assessment tool to enhance direct observation. , 2010, The Journal of emergency medicine.

[9]  Bonnie Arquilla,et al.  Simulation in a disaster drill: comparison of high-fidelity simulators versus trained actors. , 2008, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[10]  Dale S Vincent,et al.  Mass-Casualty Triage Training for International Healthcare Workers in the Asia-Pacific Region Using Manikin-Based Simulations , 2009, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine.

[11]  Nick Sevdalis,et al.  Emergency preparedness in the 21st century: training and preparation modules in virtual environments. , 2013, Resuscitation.

[12]  Frank Archer,et al.  International Guidelines and Standards for Education and Training to Reduce the Consequences of Events that May Threaten the Health Status of a Community – A Report of an Open International WADEM Meeting, Brussels, Belgium, 29-31 October 2004 , 2007, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine.

[13]  Edbert B Hsu,et al.  Effectiveness of Hospital Staff Mass-Casualty Incident Training Methods: A Systematic Literature Review , 2004, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine.

[14]  W. L. Heinrichs,et al.  Training Healthcare Personnel for Mass-Casualty Incidents in a Virtual Emergency Department: VED II , 2010, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine.

[15]  E. Frykberg,et al.  Medical management of disasters and mass casualties from terrorist bombings: how can we cope? , 2002, The Journal of trauma.

[16]  Richard B Schwartz,et al.  Paramedic Accuracy Using SALT Triage After a Brief Initial Training , 2011, Prehospital emergency care : official journal of the National Association of EMS Physicians and the National Association of State EMS Directors.

[17]  Pier Luigi Ingrassia,et al.  The effectiveness of training with an emergency department simulator on medical student performance in a simulated disaster. , 2010, CJEM.

[18]  S. Rosborough.  A Tale of Two Responses: Haiti Earthquake Highlights the Need for Training in International Disaster Response , 2010, Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness.

[19]  Charlotte Broms.  The tsunami – 26 December 2004 – experiences from one place of recovery, Stockholm, Sweden , 2012, Primary Health Care Research &amp; Development.

[20]  W. McGaghie,et al.  A critical review of simulation‐based medical education research: 2003–2009 , 2010, Medical education.

[21]  Kristi L. Koenig,et al.  Koenig and Schultz's Disaster Medicine: Comprehensive Principles and Practices: ENVIRONMENTAL EVENTS , 2009 .

[22]  Nick Sevdalis,et al.  Tactical and operational response to major incidents: feasibility and reliability of skills assessment using novel virtual environments. , 2013, Resuscitation.

[23]  Amir Khorram-Manesh,et al.  Comparative study of physiological and anatomical triage in major incidents using a new simulation model. , 2011, American journal of disaster medicine.

[24]  J. Brice,et al.  Triage Performance of First-Year Medical Students Using a Multiple-Casualty Scenario, Paper Exercise , 2010, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine.

[25]  W. Lau,et al.  Triage during the week of the Sichuan earthquake: a review of utilized patient triage, care, and disposition procedures. , 2011, Injury.

[26]  Carri Casteel,et al.  The effectiveness of disaster training for health care workers: a systematic review. , 2008, Annals of emergency medicine.

[27]  Davide Colombo,et al.  Impact of training in medical disaster management: a pilot study using a new tool for live simulation , 2014 .

[28]  Yasuharu Tokuda,et al.  Prehospital management of sarin nerve gas terrorism in urban settings: 10 years of progress after the Tokyo subway sarin attack. , 2006, Resuscitation.

[29]  Edbert B Hsu,et al.  Mass-Casualty Triage: Time for an Evidence-Based Approach , 2008, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine.

[30]  Roger Kneebone,et al.  Evaluating Clinical Simulations for Learning Procedural Skills: A Theory-Based Approach , 2005, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[31]  P. Andreatta,et al.  Virtual reality triage training provides a viable solution for disaster-preparedness. , 2010, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[32]  M. Ramirez,et al.  Training medical staff for pediatric disaster victims: a comparison of different teaching methods. , 2008, American journal of disaster medicine.

[33]  Dan Hanfling,et al.  Allocating scarce resources in disasters: emergency department principles. , 2012, Annals of emergency medicine.

[34]  W. Coates,et al.  A Disaster Medicine Curriculum for Medical Students , 2010, Teaching and learning in medicine.