What is the Impact of Financial Advisors on Retirement Portfolio Choices and Outcomes?

Within the Oregon University System’s defined contribution retirement plan, one investment provider offers access to face-to-face financial advice through its network of brokers. We find that younger, less highly educated, and less highly paid employees are more likely to choose this provider. To benchmark the portfolios of broker clients, we use the actual portfolios of self-directed investors and counterfactual portfolios constructed using target-date funds, a popular default investment. Broker clients allocate contributions across a larger number of investments than self-directed investors, and they are less likely to remain fully invested in the default option. However, broker clients’ portfolios are significantly riskier than self-directed investors’ portfolios, and they underperform both benchmarks. Exploiting across-fund variation in broker compensation, we find that broker clients’ allocations are higher when broker fees are higher. Survey responses from current plan participants support our identifying assumption that the portfolio choices of broker clients reflect the recommendations of their brokers.

[1]  Edwin J. Elton,et al.  Are Investors Rational? Choices Among Index Funds , 2002 .

[2]  Gergana Y. Nenkov,et al.  Investing for Retirement: The Moderating Effect of Fund Assortment Size on the 1/N Heuristic , 2012 .

[3]  Brad M. Barber,et al.  Boys Will Be Boys: Gender, Overconfidence, and Common Stock Investment , 1998 .

[4]  Yigitcan Karabulut.  Financial Advice: An Improvement for Worse? , 2013 .

[5]  O. Mitchell,et al.  Target-Date Funds in 401(K) Retirement Plans , 2012 .

[6]  Richard A. Ippolito.  Consumer Reaction to Measures of Poor Quality: Evidence from the Mutual Fund Industry , 1992, The Journal of Law and Economics.

[7]  Paula A. Tkac,et al.  Broker Incentives and Mutual Fund Market Segmentation , 2010 .

[8]  T Hathway.  ASSESSING THE COSTS AND BENEFITS , 1996 .

[9]  Steven D. Dolvin.  Target Date Funds , 2012 .

[10]  René M. Stulz,et al.  Working Paper Series the Determinants of the Flow of Funds of Managed Portfolios: Mutual Funds versus Pension Funds the Determinants of the Flow of Funds of Managed Portfolios: Mutual Funds versus Pension Funds , 2022 .

[11]  Shawn Cole,et al.  Understanding the Incentives of Commissions Motivated Agents: Theory and Evidence from the Indian Life Insurance Market , 2012 .

[12]  O. Mitchell,et al.  Financial Literacy and Retirement Preparedness: Evidence and Implications for Financial Education Programs , 2007 .

[13]  Lisa Xu,et al.  Financial Literacy Around the World: An Overview of the Evidence with Practical Suggestions for the Way Forward , 2012 .

[14]  R. Thaler,et al.  Naive Diversification Strategies in Defined Contribution Saving Plans , 2001 .

[15]  Steffen Meyer,et al.  Is Unbiased Financial Advice to Retail Investors Sufficient? Answers from a Large Field Study , 2011 .

[16]  O. Mitchell,et al.  Baby Boomer Retirement Security: The Roles of Planning, Financial Literacy, and Housing Wealth , 2006 .

[17]  Shawn Cole,et al.  Bad Advice: Explaining the Persistence of Whole Life Insurance , 2011 .

[18]  J. Reuter,et al.  How Do Retirees Value Life Annuities? Evidence from Public Employees , 2009 .

[19]  Martin J. Gruber,et al.  Another puzzle: the growth in actively managed mutual funds , 1996, Annals of Operations Research.

[20]  O. Mitchell,et al.  Implications for Retirement Wellbeing of Financial Literacy and Planning , 2010 .

[21]  Pierluigi Balduzzi,et al.  Heterogeneity in Target-Date Funds: Optimal Risk-Taking or Risk Matching? , 2015 .

[22]  Lu Zheng,et al.  Out of Sight, Out of Mind: The Effects of Expenses on Mutual Fund Flows , 2003 .

[23]  O. Mitchell,et al.  Financial Literacy, Schooling, and Wealth Accumulation. NBER Working Paper No. 16452. , 2010 .

[24]  Pierluigi Balduzzi,et al.  Heterogeneity in Target-Date Funds and the Pension Protection Act of 2006 , 2011 .

[25]  Terrance Odean,et al.  Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses? , 1996 .

[26]  David A. Wise,et al.  Social Security Policy in a Changing Environment , 2009 .

[27]  Tabea Bucher-Koenen,et al.  Who Lost the Most? Financial Literacy, Cognitive Abilities, and the Financial Crisis , 2011, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[28]  ohn,et al.  Measuring the Financial Sophistication of Households , 2008 .

[29]  Terrance Odean.  Do Investors Trade Too Much? , 1998 .

[30]  E. Fama,et al.  Risk, Return, and Equilibrium: Empirical Tests , 1973, Journal of Political Economy.

[31]  B. Carlin.  Strategic Price Complexity in Retail Financial Markets , 2006 .

[32]  Julie R. Agnew,et al.  Portfolio Choice and Trading in a Large 401(k) Plan , 2003 .

[33]  Sheridan Titman,et al.  On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance , 1997 .

[34]  Shlomo Benartzi,et al.  Excessive Extrapolation and the Allocation of 401(k) Accounts to Company Stock , 2001 .

[35]  J. Davis.  Four Factor Model , 2012 .

[36]  David K. Musto,et al.  What do Consumers’ Fund Flows Maximize? Evidence from Their Brokers’ Incentives , 2012 .

[37]  Glenn Ellison,et al.  Risk Taking by Mutual Funds as a Response to Incentives , 1995, Journal of Political Economy.

[38]  Peter Tufano,et al.  Assessing the Costs and Benefits of Brokers in the Mutual Fund Industry , 2007 .

[39]  Paula A. Tkac,et al.  The Determinants of the Flow of Funds of Managed Portfolios: Mutual Funds Versus Pension Funds , 2000 .

[40]  Eric Zitzewitz,et al.  Do Ads Influence Editors? Advertising and Bias in the Financial Media , 2005 .

[41]  Annamaria Lusardi,et al.  Financial Literacy and Planning: Implications for Retirement Wellbeing , 2005 .

[42]  Steffen Meyer,et al.  Trading on Advice , 2010 .

[43]  Roman Inderst,et al.  Financial Advice and Stock Market Participation , 2014, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[44]  S. Mullainathan,et al.  The Market for Financial Advice: An Audit Study , 2012 .

[45]  Annamaria Lusardi,et al.  Financial Literacy and Retirement Preparedness: Evidence and Implications for Financial Education , 2007 .

[46]  Peter Tufano,et al.  Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows , 1998 .

[47]  Brad M. Barber,et al.  Trading is Hazardous to Your Wealth: The Common Stock Investment Performance of Individual Investors , 2000 .

[48]  Education and Saving: The Long-Term Effects of High School Financial Curriculum Mandates , 1997 .

[49]  O. Mitchell,et al.  Financial Literacy, Schooling, and Wealth Accumulation , 2010 .