Three‐dimensional Printing in Anatomy Education: Assessing Potential Ethical Dimensions

New technological developments have frequently had major consequences for anatomy education, and have raised ethical queries for anatomy educators. The advent of three‐dimensional (3D) printing of human material is showing considerable promise as an educational tool that fits alongside cadaveric dissection, plastination, computer simulation, and anatomical models and images. At first glance its ethical implications appear minimal, and yet the more extensive ethical implications around clinical bioprinting suggest that a cautious approach to 3D printing in the dissecting room is in order. Following an overview of early groundbreaking studies into 3D printing of prosections, organs, and archived fetal material, it has become clear that their origin, using donated bodies or 3D files available on the Internet, has ethical overtones. The dynamic presented by digital technology raises questions about the nature of the consent provided by the body donor, reasons for 3D printing, the extent to which it will be commercialized, and its comparative advantages over other available teaching resources. In exploring questions like these, the place of 3D printing within a hierarchical sequence of value is outlined. Discussion centers on the significance of local usage of prints, the challenges created by regarding 3D prints as disposable property, the importance of retaining the human side to anatomy, and the unacceptability of obtaining 3D‐printed material from unclaimed bodies. It is concluded that the scientific tenor of 3D processes represents a move away from the human person, so that efforts are required to prevent them accentuating depersonalization and commodification.

[1]  Charleen Moore,et al.  Gunther von Hagens and Body Worlds Part 1: the anatomist as prosektor and proplastiker. , 2004, The Anatomical Record Part B The New Anatomist.

[2]  M. Pizzimenti,et al.  Constructing stories of past lives: cadaver as first patient: "clinical summary of dissection" writing assignment for medical students. , 2008, The Permanente journal.

[3]  Gordon G. Wallace,et al.  Biofabrication: an overview of the approaches used for printing of living cells , 2013, Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology.

[4]  Anne M. Gilroy,et al.  Atlas of Anatomy , 2008 .

[5]  David Gareth Jones Human Anatomy: A Review of the Science, Ethics and Culture of a Discipline in Transition , 2017 .

[6]  Anthony Atala,et al.  3D bioprinting of tissues and organs , 2014, Nature Biotechnology.

[7]  D. Jones,et al.  The bequest of human bodies for dissection: a case study in the Otago Medical School. , 1992, The New Zealand medical journal.

[8]  B. K. Billings,et al.  Making the Ethical Transition in South Africa: Acquiring Human Bodies for Training in Anatomy , 2018, Anatomical sciences education.

[9]  L. Ciaccia,et al.  The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks , 2010, The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine.

[10]  Sven Reese,et al.  Fabrication and assessment of 3D printed anatomical models of the lower limb for anatomical teaching and femoral vessel access training in medicine , 2016, Anatomical sciences education.

[11]  Helen Macdonald Human Remains: Episodes in Human Dissection , 2005 .

[12]  Jon Cornwall,et al.  The ethics of 3D printing copies of bodies donated for medical education and research: What is there to worry about? , 2016, The Australasian medical journal.

[13]  James J. Yoo,et al.  Complex heterogeneous tissue constructs containing multiple cell types prepared by inkjet printing technology. , 2013, Biomaterials.

[14]  D Gareth Jones,et al.  Anatomy's use of unclaimed bodies , 2012, Clinical anatomy.

[15]  Ming Xiao,et al.  An ethical solution to the challenges in teaching anatomy with dissection in the Chinese culture , 2008, Anatomical sciences education.

[16]  Savas Tasoglu,et al.  Bioprinting: Functional droplet networks. , 2013, Nature materials.

[17]  Liberato J. A. DiDio Prof. International Federation of Associations of Anatomists , 2005, Anatomia Clinica.

[18]  J. T. Harbaugh Do You Own Your 3D Bioprinted Body? , 2015, American Journal of Law & Medicine.

[19]  T. Champney,et al.  A proposal for a policy on the ethical care and use of cadavers and their tissues , 2011, Anatomical sciences education.

[20]  Jan H. Kietzmann,et al.  Disruptions, decisions, and destinations: enter the age of 3-D printing and additive manufacturing , 2015, IEEE Engineering Management Review.

[21]  A. Glazier Organ Donation and the Principles of Gift Law. , 2018, American Society of Nephrology. Clinical Journal.

[22]  José L Bueno-López,et al.  The legal and ethical framework governing Body Donation in Europe - 1st update on current practice , 2012 .

[23]  D. Jones,et al.  Genetic privacy and the use of archival human material in genetic studies – current perspectives , 2015 .

[24]  S. Nicholls The Body in Bioethics , 2010 .

[25]  ‘It's a personal thing': visitors' responses to Body Worlds , 2012 .

[26]  Justin W. Adams,et al.  Use of 3D printed models in medical education: A randomized control trial comparing 3D prints versus cadaveric materials for learning external cardiac anatomy , 2016, Anatomical sciences education.

[27]  Lei Tang,et al.  Maximizing modern distribution of complex anatomical spatial information: 3D reconstruction and rapid prototype production of anatomical corrosion casts of human specimens , 2012, Anatomical sciences education.

[28]  Derek Covill,et al.  Take away body parts! An investigation into the use of 3D‐printed anatomical models in undergraduate anatomy education , 2018, Anatomical sciences education.

[29]  Susan Dodds,et al.  Print Me an Organ? Ethical and Regulatory Issues Emerging from 3D Bioprinting in Medicine , 2017, Science and Engineering Ethics.

[30]  T. Champney The business of bodies: Ethical perspectives on for‐profit body donation companies , 2016, Clinical anatomy.

[31]  F. M. Townsend,et al.  An improved method for the preservation of teaching specimens. , 1981, Archives of pathology & laboratory medicine.

[32]  Alastair V. Campbell,et al.  The Body in Bioethics , 2009 .

[34]  S. Bloom Into the Valley: Death and the Socialization of Medical Students , 1992 .

[35]  Wojciech Pawlina,et al.  An Addition to the neighborhood: 3D printed anatomy teaching resources , 2014, Anatomical sciences education.

[36]  T. Shakya.,et al.  Historical Introduction , 2002, Jewish Identities: Fifty Intellectuals Answer Ben-Gurion.

[37]  B. Hurwitz,et al.  Donors' attitudes towards body donation for dissection , 1995, The Lancet.

[38]  G. O’Keeffe,et al.  Anatomy education for the YouTube generation , 2015, Anatomical sciences education.

[39]  James J. Yoo,et al.  A 3D bioprinting system to produce human-scale tissue constructs with structural integrity , 2016, Nature Biotechnology.

[40]  Gill Haddow,et al.  3D bioprint me: a socioethical view of bioprinting human organs and tissues , 2017, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[41]  W. Pawlina,et al.  Honoring our donors: A survey of memorial ceremonies in united states anatomy programs , 2014, Anatomical sciences education.

[42]  Alan Faulkner-Jones,et al.  Bioprinting of human pluripotent stem cells and their directed differentiation into hepatocyte-like cells for the generation of mini-livers in 3D , 2015, Biofabrication.

[43]  Jerry Y. H. Fuh,et al.  3D bioprinting – An Ethical, Legal and Social Aspects (ELSA) framework , 2016 .

[44]  Townsend Fm,et al.  An improved method for the preservation of teaching specimens. , 1981 .

[45]  L. P. Le Quesne,et al.  Death, Dissection and the Destitute , 1988, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine.

[46]  A. Murphy,et al.  Bioprinting , 2019, Radiopaedia.org.

[47]  G. Štrkalj,et al.  Current Applications and Future Perspectives of the Use of 3D Printing in Anatomical Training and Neurosurgery , 2016, Front. Neuroanat..

[48]  Vladimir Mironov,et al.  Organ printing: tissue spheroids as building blocks. , 2009, Biomaterials.

[49]  Alan Faulkner-Jones,et al.  3 D bioprint me : a socioethical view of bioprinting human organs and tissues , 2017 .

[50]  Jeffrey D. Strauss,et al.  The hand that gives the rose. , 2011, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[51]  C. Moore,et al.  Gunther von Hagens and Body Worlds part 2: The anatomist as priest and prophet. , 2004, Anatomical record. Part B, New anatomist.

[52]  Ibrahim T. Ozbolat,et al.  The bioink: A comprehensive review on bioprintable materials. , 2017, Biotechnology advances.

[53]  S. Hildebrandt Lessons to be learned from the history of anatomical teaching in the United States: The example of the University of Michigan , 2010, Anatomical sciences education.

[54]  T. L. Lewis,et al.  Anatomy education for the YouTube generation: Technical, ethical, and educational considerations , 2016, Anatomical sciences education.

[55]  G. Hagens,et al.  Impregnation of soft biological specimens with thermosetting resins and elastomers. , 1979, The Anatomical record.

[56]  D. Jones Anatomical investigations and their ethical dilemmas , 2007, Clinical anatomy.

[57]  Sean Cordell,et al.  The Ethics of Biobanking: Key Issues and Controversies , 2011, Health Care Analysis.

[58]  C. Kiessling,et al.  Bodies for Anatomy Education in Medical Schools: An Overview of the Sources of Cadavers Worldwide , 2018, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[59]  N. Pather,et al.  Commemorations and Memorials: Exploring the Human Face of Anatomy , 2017 .

[60]  S. Frampton Possessing the Dead: The Artful Science of Anatomy , 2014 .

[61]  David Gareth Jones,et al.  Re‐inventing anatomy: The impact of plastination on how we see the human body , 2002, Clinical anatomy.

[62]  J. Jones,et al.  Dual‐extrusion 3D printing of anatomical models for education , 2018, Anatomical sciences education.

[63]  S. Cargill Biobanking and the Abandonment of Informed Consent: An Ethical Imperative , 2016 .

[64]  G. Hagens Impregnation of soft biological specimens with thermosetting resins and elastomers , 1979, The Anatomical record.

[65]  Y. Barilan Bodyworlds and the Ethics of Using Human Remains: A Preliminary Discussion , 2006, Bioethics.

[66]  A. Winkelmann,et al.  BODIES R US: Ethical Views on the Commercialization of the Dead in Medical Education and Research , 2018, Anatomical sciences education.

[67]  V. Fan,et al.  “Silent virtuous teachers”: anatomical dissection in Taiwan , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[68]  Klaus Tiedemann,et al.  The current potential of plastination , 2004, Anatomy and Embryology.

[69]  F. Horan,et al.  Gray’s Anatomy: the anatomical basis of clinical practice , 2009 .

[70]  H. Greely,et al.  The Henrietta Lacks legacy grows , 2013, EMBO reports.

[71]  J. Cornwall,et al.  Ethical issues surrounding the use of images from donated cadavers in the anatomical sciences , 2016, Clinical anatomy.

[72]  E. L. Giannaris,et al.  Population representation among anatomical donors and the implication for medical student education , 2018, Clinical anatomy.

[73]  N. Jones Science in three dimensions: The print revolution , 2012, Nature.

[74]  F. Auricchio,et al.  The clinical use of 3D printing in surgery , 2018, Updates in Surgery.

[75]  J. Cornwall,et al.  “Why did you really do it?” A mixed‐method analysis of the factors underpinning motivations to register as a body donor , 2018, Anatomical sciences education.

[76]  David Gareth Jones The public display of plastinates as a challenge to the integrity of anatomy , 2016, Clinical anatomy.

[77]  C. Moore,et al.  Experiencing Body Worlds: Voyeurism, Education, or Enlightenment? , 2007, The Journal of medical humanities.

[78]  W. May Religious justifications for donating body parts. , 1985, The Hastings Center report.

[79]  Justin W. Adams,et al.  The production of anatomical teaching resources using three‐dimensional (3D) printing technology , 2014, Anatomical sciences education.

[80]  S. Hildebrandt Thoughts on practical core elements of an ethical anatomical education , 2016, Clinical anatomy.

[81]  D. Jones,et al.  I See Dead People: Insights From the Humanities Into the Nature of Plastinated Cadavers , 2013, Journal of Medical Humanities.

[82]  Thenkurussi Kesavadas,et al.  3D printing for preoperative planning and surgical training: a review , 2018, Biomedical Microdevices.

[83]  S. Mackinnon,et al.  Ethical considerations in the use of Pernkopf's Atlas of Anatomy: A surgical case study. , 2019, Surgery.

[84]  Carl Gray,et al.  Anatomy Art: Fascination beneath the Surface , 2001, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[85]  S. Peitzman,et al.  Medical Students' Assessment of Eduard Pernkopf's Atlas: Topographical Anatomy of Man. , 2017, Annals of anatomy = Anatomischer Anzeiger : official organ of the Anatomische Gesellschaft.

[86]  A. Ferguson The making of Mr Gray’s anatomy: bodies, books, fortune, fame , 2009, Medical Humanities.

[87]  Ian M. Sander,et al.  Three‐dimensional printing of X‐ray computed tomography datasets with multiple materials using open‐source data processing , 2017, Anatomical sciences education.

[88]  S. Standring Gray's Anatomy: The Anatomical Basis of Clinical Practice , 2015 .

[89]  D. Sullivan Speaking for the Dead: Cadavers in Biology and Medicine , 2002 .

[90]  Paul G McMenamin,et al.  Three‐Dimensional Printing of Archived Human Fetal Material for Teaching Purposes , 2018, Anatomical sciences education.

[91]  S. Hildebrandt The Anatomy of Murder: Ethical Transgressions and Anatomical Science During the Third Reich , 2021, Journal of Biocommunication.

[92]  B. Riederer,et al.  Anatomy, respect for the body and body donation - a guide for good practice , 2014 .

[93]  D. Jones,et al.  Maintaining the anonymity of cadavers in medical education: Historic relic or educational and ethical necessity? , 2017, Anatomical sciences education.

[94]  L. S. Stone,et al.  An Atlas of Anatomy , 1943, The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine.

[95]  David Gareth Jones Searching for good practice recommendations on body donation across diverse cultures , 2016, Clinical anatomy.

[96]  A. Winkelmann Consent and consensus—ethical perspectives on obtaining bodies for anatomical dissection , 2016, Clinical anatomy.

[97]  P. Li 3D Bioprinting Technologies: Patents, Innovation and Access , 2014 .

[98]  D. Jones Use of bequeathed and unclaimed bodies in the dissecting room , 1994 .