Evaluation of the BIOMIC Video Reader System for Determining Interpretive Categories of Isolates on the Basis of Disk Diffusion Susceptibility Results

ABSTRACT The BIOMIC System (Giles Scientific, New York, N.Y.) includes software and a video-assisted plate reader that functions with a personal computer to automate, speed read, and interpret standard antibiotic disk diffusion test plates. The video reader helps standardize endpoints, speeds quantitative measurements by 40 to 90%, and reduces fatigue and transcription and interpretation errors (H. Wei-Fang, Am. Clin. Lab. 13:28–29, 1994). Organisms tested were isolated from patient specimens collected at Primary Children’s Medical Center and included rapidly growing gram-positive and gram-negative strains that fulfill the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards guidelines for disk diffusion susceptibility testing. A comparison of the plate reader-determined zones and visually measured zones for 3,339 organism-antimicrobial agent combinations was performed. The results demonstrated 0.1% (4 of 3,339) false-susceptible reads and 0.2% (6 of 3,339) false-resistant reads by the video reader compared with visual reads. Minor discrepancies (4.7% [156 of 3339]), resulting in category interpretation changes of intermediate to resistant or susceptible or changes of resistant or susceptible to intermediate, were also encountered. Of the discrepant results, 80.8% (139 of 172) resulted from a 3-mm or less zone diameter difference between the two different techniques. We conclude that the video-assisted plate reader is a reliable system for determining interpretative categories from zone diameters of standard antibiotic disk diffusion test plates.