Evaluating the effect of organization and context on technical efficiency: a second-stage DEA analysis of Italian hospitals

Objective: the purpose of this study was to compare the technical efficiency of Italian hospitals at a regional level and to examine if differences could be explained by organisational and contextual factors. Technical efficiency was defined as the ability of the operating units evaluated to use optimal resource levels for their level of output. Methods: the effect of external factors was explored through a second stage Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). Efficiency scores were calculated for each hospital using the DEA method (Stage I). Through Tobit regression analysis, the estimated efficiency scores were regressed against a set of organisational and contextual characteristics beyond managerial control, which reflected differences in the population demographics and regional health expenditure (Stage II). Stage I and Stage II efficiency scores were compared in order to indirectly assess managerial contribution in relation to hospital efficiency. Results: the highest efficiency (M±SD) was observed in hospitals in the North-West (75.7±15.1), followed by those in the North-East (75.5±15.1), Central Italy (73.9±16.4) and then Southern Italy (70.6±17.9). Hospital Trusts (HTs) were shown to be more technically efficient than Local Public Hospitals (LPHs). Organisational and contextual indicators were statistically significantly different at Tobit regression analysis for HTs and LPHs. Emilia Romagna and Lombardia were the regions whose management contributed to increased efficiency. Conclusions: in our study, the distribution of regions according to technical efficiency only partly reflected the North-South gradient shown by other studies regarding the gap of expenditure. The important role of organisation and environment in establishing efficiency differences among hospitals was demonstrated.

[1]  S. Grosskopf,et al.  Measuring hospital performance. A non-parametric approach. , 1987, Journal of health economics.

[2]  Ilde Rizzo,et al.  Competition and Efficiency in Health Care: An Analysis of the Italian Case , 2000 .

[3]  A. Charnes,et al.  Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis , 1984 .

[4]  Gianpaolo Barbetta,et al.  L'analisi dell'efficienza tecnica nel settore della sanità. Un'applicazione al caso della Lombardia , 2001 .

[5]  Nick Kontodimopoulos,et al.  The effect of environmental factors on technical and scale efficiency of primary health care providers in Greece , 2007, Cost effectiveness and resource allocation : C/E.

[6]  M. Tambour,et al.  Internal markets and health care efficiency: a multiple-output stochastic frontier analysis. , 1999, Health economics.

[7]  D. Cutler,et al.  Demographics and Medical Care Spending: Standard and Non-Standard Effects , 1998, Working paper series.

[8]  Y A Ozcan,et al.  A national study of the efficiency of hospitals in urban markets. , 1993, Health services research.

[9]  Sergio Maturana,et al.  A Multiple Stage Approach for Performance Improvement of Primary Healthcare Practice , 2010, Journal of Medical Systems.

[10]  Jos L. T. Blank,et al.  Governance and Performance: The Performance of Dutch Hospitals Explained by Governance Characteristics , 2010, Journal of Medical Systems.

[11]  Kaoru Tone,et al.  Data Envelopment Analysis , 1996 .

[12]  G. Smith,et al.  Disease aetiology and materialist explanations of socioeconomic mortality differentials: a research note , 1997 .

[13]  B. Hollingsworth.  The measurement of efficiency and productivity of health care delivery. , 2008, Health economics.

[14]  Georgios Tsakos,et al.  Using DEA to Evaluate Efficiency and Formulate Policy Within a Greek National Primary Health Care Network , 2002, Journal of Medical Systems.

[15]  V. Valdmanis,et al.  East-west: does it make a difference to hospital efficiencies in Ukraine? , 2006, Health economics.

[16]  Dimitrios Niakas,et al.  Separating Managerial Inefficiency from Influences of the Operating Environment: An Application in Dialysis , 2010, Journal of Medical Systems.

[17]  Gilberto Turati,et al.  Behavioral differences between public and private not-for-profit hospitals in the Italian National Health Service. , 2007, Health economics.

[18]  Dimitrios Niakas,et al.  The Impact of Non-Discretionary Factors on DEA and SFA Technical Efficiency Differences , 2010, Journal of Medical Systems.

[19]  Antonio Giuffrida,et al.  Organizzazione dell'assistenza ospedaliera: analisi dell'efficienza delle aziende ospedaliere e dei presidi ospedalieri , 2000 .

[20]  C. Binns,et al.  Health for All , 2015, Asia-Pacific journal of public health.

[21]  V. Valdmanis,et al.  Hospital quality, efficiency, and input slack differentials. , 2008, Health services research.

[22]  P. Kooreman.  Nursing home care in The Netherlands: a nonparametric efficiency analysis. , 1994, Journal of health economics.

[23]  L. Iezzoni,et al.  Measuring hospital efficiency with frontier cost functions. , 1994, Journal of health economics.

[24]  G. Costa,et al.  Individual and Contextual Determinants of Inequalities in Health: The Italian Case , 2003, International journal of health services : planning, administration, evaluation.

[25]  Fabio Pammolli,et al.  Le differenze regionali nella governance della spesa sanitaria - SaniRegio-2011 , 2011 .

[26]  Roberto Ippoliti,et al.  Data Envelopment Analysis e sistemi sanitari regionali italiani , 2011 .

[27]  Marion S. Rauner,et al.  A cross-national comparison and taxonomy of DEA-based hospital efficiency studies , 2008 .

[28]  D. Vitaliano,et al.  Cost and efficiency in nursing homes: a stochastic frontier approach. , 1994, Journal of health economics.

[29]  L. Pritchett,et al.  The impact of public spending on health: does money matter? , 1999, Social science & medicine.

[30]  V. Sena,et al.  Has DRG payment influenced the technical efficiency and productivity of diagnostic technologies in Portuguese public hospitals? An empirical analysis using parametric and non‐parametric methods , 1999, Health care management science.

[31]  Michael D. Rosko,et al.  Impact of internal and external environmental pressures on hospital inefficiency , 1999, Health care management science.

[32]  P. W. Wilson,et al.  Estimation and inference in two-stage, semi-parametric models of production processes , 2007 .

[33]  Ayoe Hoff,et al.  Second stage DEA: Comparison of approaches for modelling the DEA score , 2007, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[34]  Hsuan-Lien Chu,et al.  Does the Implementation of Responsibility Centers, Total Quality Management, and Physician Fee Programs Improve Hospital Efficiency?: Evidence from Taiwan Hospitals , 2002, Medical care.

[35]  V. Valdmanis.  Ownership and technical efficiency of hospitals. , 1990, Medical care.

[36]  M. Linna,et al.  Measuring hospital cost efficiency with panel data models. , 1998, Health economics.

[37]  Abraham Charnes,et al.  Measuring the efficiency of decision making units , 1978 .

[38]  Jos L. T. Blank,et al.  Environmental factors and productivity on Dutch hospitals: a semi-parametric approach , 2009, Health care management science.

[39]  M. Farrell.  The Measurement of Productive Efficiency , 1957 .

[40]  Daniele Fabbri.  Riforma sanitaria e produzione ospedaliera , 1999 .

[41]  E. Lettieri,et al.  Efficiency and quality of care in nursing homes: an Italian case study , 2011, Health care management science.

[42]  J S Zinn,et al.  The Effects of Ownership, Operating Environment, and Strategic Choices on Nursing Home Efficiency , 1995, Medical care.