A comparison of five methods to assess embolism resistance in trees

Vulnerability to drought-induced embolism is a key trait that shapes drought resistance and that could be increasingly used to design climate-smart forest management guidelines and to anticipate the outcome of climate change on populations dynamics and ecosystems functioning. A panel of methods is currently available to measure embolism resistance. This makes crucial a proper identification of which methods are the most accurate for determining this trait. However, the measurement of embolism resistance is sensitive to numerous artifacts that may lead to large errors for a given species. In addition, not all methods are easily accessible because of the cost of some large equipment and/or certain lab facilities. The emergence of the easy and low cost Pneumatic method allows to perform vulnerability curves at high throughput. However, only few studies have evaluated the reliability of this method compared to others. In this study, we proposed a comparison of five methods that allowed to assess embolism resistance in eleven tree species with contrasting xylem anatomy and vessels length (six short vessel angiosperms, two tracheid bearing conifers and three long-vessel angiosperms), covering a large part of the range of embolism resistance observed in trees. Consistent results were obtained among all the methods for short-vessel angiosperm species. In tracheid-bearing conifers, the Pneumatic method overestimated vulnerability to embolism. In long-vessel species, the Pneumatic method led to inconsistent results with accurate vulnerability to cavitation curves (VCs) for one species but led to r-shaped VCs with a underestimation of incipient embolism for the two other ones. The comparison of VC parameters with turgor loss point is proposed as an indicator of the validity of the VCs. The conditions of validity, the advantages and pitfalls of the five methods are discussed. Our results warned against the widespread usages of some methods before rigorous validation tests have been performed.

[1]  John S. Sperry,et al.  Intra‐ and inter‐plant variation in xylem cavitation in Betula occidentalis , 1994 .

[2]  Virginia Hernandez-Santana,et al.  Role of leaf hydraulic conductance in the regulation of stomatal conductance in almond and olive in response to water stress. , 2016, Tree physiology.

[3]  José M. Torres-Ruiz,et al.  The Olive Tree Under Water Stress: Fitting the Pieces of Response Mechanisms in the Crop Performance Puzzle , 2018 .

[4]  R. Oren,et al.  Water deficits and hydraulic limits to leaf water supply. , 2002, Plant, cell & environment.

[5]  M. Zimmermann,et al.  Vessel-length distribution in stems of some American woody plants , 1981 .

[6]  C. Douthe,et al.  Mechanism of water-stress induced cavitation in conifers: bordered pit structure and function support the hypothesis of seal capillary-seeding , 2010, Plant, cell & environment.

[7]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Optical Measurement of Stem Xylem Vulnerability1[OPEN] , 2017, Plant Physiology.

[8]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Testing the plant pneumatic method to estimate xylem embolism resistance in stems of temperate trees , 2018, Tree physiology.

[9]  John A. Milburn,et al.  The conduction of sap , 1966, Planta.

[10]  J. Sperry,et al.  Relationship of Xylem Embolism to Xylem Pressure Potential, Stomatal Closure, and Shoot Morphology in the Palm Rhapis excelsa. , 1986, Plant physiology.

[11]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Evidence for Hydraulic Vulnerability Segmentation and Lack of Xylem Refilling under Tension1[OPEN] , 2016, Plant Physiology.

[12]  Brendan Choat,et al.  fitplc - an R package to fit hydraulic vulnerability curves , 2017 .

[13]  J. Sperry,et al.  Vulnerability to xylem cavitation and the distribution of Sonoran Desert vegetation. , 1996, American journal of botany.

[14]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Improvement to the air-injection technique to estimate xylem vulnerability to cavitation , 2011, Trees.

[15]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Herbaceous Angiosperms Are Not More Vulnerable to Drought-Induced Embolism Than Angiosperm Trees1[OPEN] , 2016, Plant Physiology.

[16]  A. King,et al.  Tomography and imaging at the PSICHE beam line of the SOLEIL synchrotron. , 2016, The Review of scientific instruments.

[17]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Genotypic variability and phenotypic plasticity of cavitation resistance in Fagus sylvatica L. across Europe. , 2011, Tree physiology.

[18]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Genetic differentiation in functional traits among European sessile oak populations. , 2019, Tree physiology.

[19]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Is xylem cavitation resistance a relevant criterion for screening drought resistance among Prunus species? , 2008, Journal of plant physiology.

[20]  Ximeng Li,et al.  Tree hydraulic traits are coordinated and strongly linked to climate-of-origin across a rainfall gradient. , 2018, Plant, cell & environment.

[21]  M. Tyree,et al.  Use of positive pressures to establish vulnerability curves : further support for the air-seeding hypothesis and implications for pressure-volume analysis. , 1992, Plant physiology.

[22]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Mitigating the open vessel artefact in centrifuge-based measurement of embolism resistance , 2018, Tree physiology.

[23]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  New Insights into the Mechanisms of Water-Stress-Induced Cavitation in Conifers , 2009, Plant Physiology.

[24]  Kathy Steppe,et al.  An inconvenient truth about xylem resistance to embolism in the model species for refilling Laurus nobilis L. , 2018, Annals of Forest Science.

[25]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Vulnerability to cavitation in Olea europaea current-year shoots: further evidence of an open-vessel artifact associated with centrifuge and air-injection techniques. , 2014, Physiologia plantarum.

[26]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Plasticity in Vulnerability to Cavitation of Pinus canariensis Occurs Only at the Driest End of an Aridity Gradient , 2016, Front. Plant Sci..

[27]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Direct X-Ray Microtomography Observation Confirms the Induction of Embolism upon Xylem Cutting under Tension1 , 2014, Plant Physiology.

[28]  A. Jacobsen,et al.  Identifying which conduits are moving water in woody plants: a new HRCT-based method , 2018, Tree physiology.

[29]  Frank W. Ewers,et al.  TECHNIQUES FOR MEASURING VESSEL LENGTHS AND DIAMETERS IN STEMS OF WOODY PLANTS , 1989 .

[30]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  A broad survey of hydraulic and mechanical safety in the xylem of conifers , 2014, Journal of experimental botany.

[31]  Sandra J. Bucci,et al.  Strong hydraulic segmentation and leaf senescence due to dehydration may trigger die-back in Nothofagus dombeyi under severe droughts: a comparison with the co-occurring Austrocedrus chilensis , 2014, Trees.

[32]  N. Holbrook,et al.  Cutting xylem under tension or supersaturated with gas can generate PLC and the appearance of rapid recovery from embolism. , 2013, Plant, cell & environment.

[33]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Aridity drove the evolution of extreme embolism resistance and the radiation of conifer genus Callitris. , 2017, The New phytologist.

[34]  T. Brodribb,et al.  Mapping xylem failure in disparate organs of whole plants reveals extreme resistance in olive roots. , 2018, The New phytologist.

[35]  Hamlyn G. Jones,et al.  Stomatal control of xylem embolism , 1991 .

[36]  E Badel,et al.  X-ray microtomography (micro-CT): a reference technology for high-resolution quantification of xylem embolism in trees. , 2015, Plant, cell & environment.

[37]  S. Jansen,et al.  Plasmodesmatal pores in the torus of bordered pit membranes affect cavitation resistance of conifer xylem. , 2012, Plant, cell & environment.

[38]  S. Rambal,et al.  How reliable are methods to assess xylem vulnerability to cavitation? The issue of 'open vessel' artifact in oaks. , 2014, Tree physiology.

[39]  María Elena Fernández,et al.  Leaf and whole-plant water relations of the Patagonian conifer Austrocedrus chilensis (D. Don) Pic. Ser. et Bizzarri: implications on its drought resistance capacity , 2005 .

[40]  Steven Jansen,et al.  The Pneumatron: an automated pneumatic apparatus for estimating xylem vulnerability to embolism at high temporal resolution. , 2019, Plant, cell & environment.

[41]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  XIM4 meeting report, Sept. 25-27 2019, Padua (Italy) , 2019, Journal of Plant Hydraulics.

[42]  M. Tyree,et al.  Water stress induced cavitation and embolism in some woody plants , 1986 .

[43]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Xylem resistance to embolism: presenting a simple diagnostic test for the open vessel artefact. , 2017, The New phytologist.

[44]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Whole tree hydraulic conductance and water loss regulation in Quercus during drought: evidence for stomatal control of embolism? , 1996 .

[45]  Brendan Choat,et al.  Measurement of vulnerability to water stress-induced cavitation in grapevine: a comparison of four techniques applied to a long-vesseled species. , 2010, Plant, cell & environment.

[46]  A. Nardini,et al.  Global convergence in the vulnerability of forests to drought , 2012, Nature.

[47]  N. Michele Holbrook,et al.  Stomatal Closure during Leaf Dehydration, Correlation with Other Leaf Physiological Traits1 , 2003, Plant Physiology.

[48]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  How reliable is the double-ended pressure sleeve technique for assessing xylem vulnerability to cavitation in woody angiosperms? , 2011, Physiologia plantarum.

[49]  David Ackerly,et al.  Low Vulnerability to Xylem Embolism in Leaves and Stems of North American Oaks1[OPEN] , 2018, Plant Physiology.

[50]  Todd E. Dawson,et al.  Cenozoic climate change shaped the evolutionary ecophysiology of the Cupressaceae conifers , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[51]  Andrea Nardini,et al.  Xylem cavitation and hydraulic control of stomatal conductance in Laurel (Laurus nobilis L.) , 2000 .

[52]  William T. Pockman,et al.  Limitation of transpiration by hydraulic conductance and xylem cavitation in Betula occidentalis , 1993 .

[53]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Xylem embolism in leaves does not occur with open stomata: evidence from direct observations using the optical visualisation technique. , 2020, Journal of experimental botany.

[54]  Brendan Choat,et al.  The Dynamics of Embolism Repair in Xylem: In Vivo Visualizations Using High-Resolution Computed Tomography1[C][W][OA] , 2010, Plant Physiology.

[55]  Melvin T. Tyree,et al.  The Measurement of the Turgor Pressure and the Water Relations of Plants by the Pressure-bomb Technique , 1972 .

[56]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Native-source climate determines the Douglas-fir potential of adaptation to drought , 2019, Forest Ecology and Management.

[57]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  A technique for measuring xylem hydraulic conductance under high negative pressures , 2002 .

[58]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Field comparison of transpiration, stomatal conductance and vulnerability to cavitation of Quercus petraea and Quercus robur under water stress , 1993 .

[59]  William T. Pockman,et al.  Use of centrifugal force in the study of xylem cavitation , 1997 .

[60]  A. Tyree,et al.  Vulnerability of Xylem to Cavitation and Embolism , 1989 .

[61]  Manuel Dierick,et al.  Octopus, a fast and user-friendly tomographic reconstruction package developed in LabView® , 2004 .

[62]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Does sample length influence the shape of xylem embolism vulnerability curves? A test with the Cavitron spinning technique. , 2010, Plant, cell & environment.

[63]  Erwin Dreyer,et al.  Use of pressure volume curves in water relation analysis on woody shoots: influence of rehydration and comparison of four European oak species. , 1990 .

[64]  Brendan Choat,et al.  Synchrotron X-ray microtomography of xylem embolism in Sequoia sempervirens saplings during cycles of drought and recovery. , 2015, The New phytologist.

[65]  Hervé Cochard,et al.  Evaluation of a new centrifuge technique for rapid generation of xylem vulnerability curves , 2005 .

[66]  Robert B. Jackson,et al.  ADAPTIVE VARIATION IN THE VULNERABILITY OF WOODY PLANTS TO XYLEM CAVITATION , 2004 .

[67]  H. Cochard,et al.  Plant resistance to drought depends on timely stomatal closure. , 2017, Ecology letters.

[68]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Methods for measuring plant vulnerability to cavitation: a critical review. , 2013, Journal of experimental botany.

[69]  S. Wilkins,et al.  Simultaneous phase and amplitude extraction from a single defocused image of a homogeneous object , 2002, Journal of microscopy.

[70]  Sylvain Delzon,et al.  Limited genetic variability and phenotypic plasticity detected for cavitation resistance in a Mediterranean pine. , 2014, The New phytologist.

[71]  Paulo Mazzafera,et al.  Plant pneumatics: stem air flow is related to embolism - new perspectives on methods in plant hydraulics. , 2016, The New phytologist.