A hybrid model using data mining and multi-criteria decision-making methods for landslide risk mapping at Golestan Province, Iran

The accurate modelling of landslide risk is essential pre-requisite for the development of reliable landslide control and mitigation strategies. However, landslide risk depends on the poorly known environmental and socio-economic factors for regional patterns of landslide occurrence probability and vulnerability, which constitute still a matter of research. Here, a hybrid model is described that couples data mining and multi-criteria decision-making methods for hazard and vulnerability mapping and presents its application to landslide risk assessment in Golestan Province, Northeastern Iran. To this end, landslide probability is mapped using three state-of-the-art machine learning (ML) algorithms – Maximum Entropy, Support Vector Machine and Genetic Algorithm for Rule Set Production – and combine the results with Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process computations of vulnerability to obtain the landslide risk map. Based on obtained results, a discussion is presented on landslide probability as a function of the main relevant human-environmental conditioning factors in Golestan Province. In particular, from the response curves of the machine learning algorithms, it can be found that the probability 𝑝 of landslide occurrence decreases nearly exponentially with the distance 𝑥 to the next road, fault or river. Specifically, the results indicated that 𝑝≈exp(−𝜆𝑥), where the length-scale 𝜆 is about 0.0797 km−1 for road, 0.108 km−1 for fault and 0.734 km−1 for river. Furthermore, according to the results, 𝑝 follows, approximately, a lognormal function of elevation, while the equation 𝑝=𝑝0−𝐾∙(𝜃−𝜃0)2 fits well the dependence of landslide modeling on the slope-angle 𝜃, with 𝑝0≈0.64, 𝜃0≈25.6° and |𝐾|≈6.6×10−4. However, the highest predicted landslide risk levels in Golestan Province are located in the south and southwest areas surrounding Gorgan City, owing to the combined effect of dense local human occupation and strongly landslide-prone environmental conditions. Obtained results provide insights for quantitative modelling of landslide risk, as well as for priority planning in landslide risk management.

[1]  Xueling Wu,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping based on rough set theory and support vector machines: A case of the Three Gorges area, China , 2014 .

[2]  D. Stockli,et al.  Exhumation of the west-central Alborz Mountains, Iran, Caspian subsidence, and collision-related tectonics , 2001 .

[3]  P. Reichenbach,et al.  The Influence of Land Use Change on Landslide Susceptibility Zonation: The Briga Catchment Test Site (Messina, Italy) , 2013, Environmental Management.

[4]  B. Pradhan,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping at Golestan Province, Iran: A comparison between frequency ratio, Dempster-Shafer, and weights-of-evidence models , 2012 .

[5]  Irasema Alcántara-Ayala,et al.  Hazard and population vulnerability analysis: a step towards landslide risk assessment , 2017, Journal of Mountain Science.

[6]  Thorsten Pöschel,et al.  Attractive particle interaction forces and packing density of fine glass powders , 2014, Scientific Reports.

[7]  Aykut Akgün,et al.  A comparison of landslide susceptibility mapping of the eastern part of the North Anatolian Fault Zone (Turkey) by likelihood-frequency ratio and analytic hierarchy process methods , 2013, Natural Hazards.

[8]  Gongzhuang Peng,et al.  Landslide Susceptibility Assessment Using Integrated Deep Learning Algorithm along the China-Nepal Highway , 2018, Sensors.

[9]  B. Pradhan,et al.  Urban flood risk mapping using the GARP and QUEST models: A comparative study of machine learning techniques , 2019, Journal of Hydrology.

[10]  Wei Chen,et al.  Landslide spatial modeling: Introducing new ensembles of ANN, MaxEnt, and SVM machine learning techniques , 2017 .

[11]  R. Fell,et al.  Landslide Risk Assessment , 1997 .

[12]  Adel Soltani,et al.  An integrated data-mining and multi-criteria decision-making approach for hazard-based object ranking with a focus on landslides and floods , 2018, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[13]  T. Blaschke,et al.  Landslide Susceptibility Mapping for the Urmia Lake basin, Iran: A multi- Criteria Evaluation Approach using GIS , 2013 .

[14]  B. Pradhan,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping using support vector machine and GIS at the Golestan Province, Iran , 2013, Journal of Earth System Science.

[15]  M. Anderson,et al.  Landslide Hazard and Risk: Glade/Landslide , 2005 .

[16]  Vladimir N. Vapnik,et al.  The Nature of Statistical Learning Theory , 2000, Statistics for Engineering and Information Science.

[17]  Thomas Glade,et al.  The Nature of Landslide Hazard Impact , 2012 .

[18]  Greg P. Kotze,et al.  Landslide susceptibility and hazard mapping in Australia for land-use planning — with reference to challenges in metropolitan suburbia , 2008 .

[19]  B. Pham,et al.  Bagging based Support Vector Machines for spatial prediction of landslides , 2018, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[20]  W. Sang,et al.  Predicting the spatial distribution of an invasive plant species (Eupatorium adenophorum) in China , 2007, Landscape Ecology.

[21]  Biswajeet Pradhan,et al.  Estimation of rainfall threshold and its use in landslide hazard mapping of Kuala Lumpur metropolitan and surrounding areas , 2015, Landslides.

[22]  Jacek Malczewski,et al.  GIS and Multicriteria Decision Analysis , 1999 .

[23]  Robert P. Anderson,et al.  Maximum entropy modeling of species geographic distributions , 2006 .

[24]  A. Yalçın GIS-based landslide susceptibility mapping using analytical hierarchy process and bivariate statistics in Ardesen (Turkey): Comparisons of results and confirmations , 2008 .

[25]  A. Townsend Peterson,et al.  Transferability and model evaluation in ecological niche modeling: a comparison of GARP and Maxent , 2007 .

[26]  Simon Ferrier,et al.  Evaluating the predictive performance of habitat models developed using logistic regression , 2000 .

[27]  De Blasio,et al.  Introduction to the Physics of Landslides: Lecture notes on the dynamics of mass wasting , 2011 .

[28]  A. Kornejady,et al.  Landslide susceptibility assessment using maximum entropy model with two different data sampling methods , 2017 .

[29]  Thomas Blaschke,et al.  Evaluation of Different Machine Learning Methods and Deep-Learning Convolutional Neural Networks for Landslide Detection , 2019, Remote. Sens..

[30]  Mattia De Amicis,et al.  Mapping social vulnerability to natural hazards in Italy: A suitable tool for risk mitigation strategies , 2016 .

[31]  Manfred F. Buchroithner,et al.  Landslide Susceptibility Mapping by Neuro-Fuzzy Approach in a Landslide-Prone Area (Cameron Highlands, Malaysia) , 2010, IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing.

[32]  W. Z. Savage,et al.  Guidelines for landslide susceptibility, hazard and risk zoning for land-use planning. Commentary , 2008 .

[33]  Amy K Stockman,et al.  An evaluation of a GARP model as an approach to predicting the spatial distribution of non‐vagile invertebrate species , 2006 .

[34]  A. Rezaei,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping by combining the three methods Fuzzy Logic, Frequency Ratio and Analytical Hierarchy Process in Dozain basin , 2014 .

[35]  María Teresa Lamata,et al.  Consistency in the Analytic Hierarchy Process: a New Approach , 2006, Int. J. Uncertain. Fuzziness Knowl. Based Syst..

[36]  Hamid Reza Pourghasemi,et al.  Erratum to: Landslide susceptibility mapping using random forest, boosted regression tree, classification and regression tree, and general linear models and comparison of their performance at Wadi Tayyah Basin, Asir Region, Saudi Arabia , 2016, Landslides.

[38]  John Bell,et al.  A review of methods for the assessment of prediction errors in conservation presence/absence models , 1997, Environmental Conservation.

[39]  D. Varnes,et al.  Landslides — Cause and effect , 1976 .

[40]  Saro Lee,et al.  A Support Vector Machine for Landslide Susceptibility Mapping in Gangwon Province, Korea , 2017 .

[41]  B. Theilen-Willige,et al.  Landslide hazard zonation assessment using GIS analysis at the coastal area of Safi (Morocco) , 2019, Proceedings of the ICA.

[42]  Omid Rahmati,et al.  Land subsidence hazard modeling: Machine learning to identify predictors and the role of human activities. , 2019, Journal of environmental management.

[43]  R. Chander,et al.  Landslide zoning in a part of the Garhwal Himalayas , 1998 .

[44]  Fuchu Dai,et al.  Landslide risk assessment and management: an overview , 2002 .

[45]  V. Doyuran,et al.  Data driven bivariate landslide susceptibility assessment using geographical information systems: a method and application to Asarsuyu catchment, Turkey , 2004 .

[46]  E. E. Brabb Innovative approaches to landslide hazard and risk mapping , 1985 .

[47]  Iuliana Armaş An analytic multicriteria hierarchical approach to assess landslide vulnerability. Case study: Cornu village, Subcarpathian Prahova Valley/Romania , 2011 .

[48]  R. Anbalagan,et al.  Landslide susceptibility zonation in part of Tehri reservoir region using frequency ratio, fuzzy logic and GIS , 2015, Journal of Earth System Science.

[49]  David R. B. Stockwell,et al.  The GARP modelling system: problems and solutions to automated spatial prediction , 1999, Int. J. Geogr. Inf. Sci..

[50]  M. Ghose,et al.  Synergistic application of fuzzy logic and geo-informatics for landslide vulnerability zonation—a case study in Sikkim Himalayas, India , 2013 .

[51]  Hasan Ahmadi,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping using Genetic Algorithm for the Rule Set Production (GARP) model , 2018, Journal of Mountain Science.

[52]  J. Zêzere,et al.  Combining Social Vulnerability and Physical Vulnerability to Analyse Landslide Risk at the Municipal Scale , 2018, Geosciences.

[53]  T. L. Saaty A Scaling Method for Priorities in Hierarchical Structures , 1977 .

[54]  Xiaoqin Li,et al.  GIS-based landslide susceptibility mapping using analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and certainty factor (CF) models for the Baozhong region of Baoji City, China , 2015, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[55]  Juan Remondo,et al.  Quantitative landslide risk assessment and mapping on the basis of recent occurrences , 2008 .

[56]  C. F. Lee,et al.  Assessment of landslide susceptibility on the natural terrain of Lantau Island, Hong Kong , 2001 .

[57]  Omid Ghorbanzadeh,et al.  Evaluation of deep learning algorithms for national scale landslide susceptibility mapping of Iran , 2021, Geoscience Frontiers.

[58]  William J. Elliot,et al.  Spatially and temporally distributed modeling of landslide susceptibility , 2006 .

[59]  E. Sánchez-Flores GARP modeling of natural and human factors affecting the potential distribution of the invasives Schismus arabicus and Brassica tournefortii in ‘El Pinacate y Gran Desierto de Altar’ Biosphere Reserve , 2007 .

[60]  Oddvar Kjekstad,et al.  Economic and Social Impacts of Landslides , 2009 .

[61]  Trevor Hastie,et al.  A statistical explanation of MaxEnt for ecologists , 2011 .

[62]  T. Zhao,et al.  Coupled DEM-CFD investigation on the formation of landslide dams in narrow rivers , 2017, Landslides.

[63]  Umi Kalthum Ngah,et al.  Determination of importance for comprehensive topographic factors on landslide hazard mapping using artificial neural network , 2014, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[64]  D. Varnes Landslide hazard zonation: A review of principles and practice , 1984 .

[65]  Suzanne Lacasse,et al.  A conceptual framework for quantitative estimation of physical vulnerability to landslides , 2008 .

[66]  Thomas Blaschke,et al.  A GIS based spatially-explicit sensitivity and uncertainty analysis approach for multi-criteria decision analysis☆ , 2014, Comput. Geosci..

[67]  B. Choubin,et al.  Susceptibility Mapping of Soil Water Erosion Using Machine Learning Models , 2020, Water.

[68]  A. Peterson,et al.  Predicting distributions of Mexican birds using ecological niche modelling methods , 2002 .

[69]  S. Kazama,et al.  Probabilistic modelling of rainfall induced landslide hazard assessment , 2010 .

[70]  Alexander Brenning,et al.  Landslide susceptibility near highways is increased by 1 order of magnitude in the Andes of southern Ecuador, Loja province , 2014 .

[71]  M. Mokhtari,et al.  A comparison study on landslide prediction through FAHP and Dempster–Shafer methods and their evaluation by P–A plots , 2020, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[72]  Wang Yunsheng,et al.  Application of ROC curve analysis in evaluating the performance of alien species' potential distribution models. , 2007 .

[73]  Sultan Kocaman,et al.  A Novel Performance Assessment Approach Using Photogrammetric Techniques for Landslide Susceptibility Mapping with Logistic Regression, ANN and Random Forest , 2019, Sensors.

[74]  R. Gil Pontius,et al.  Land-cover change model validation by an ROC method for the Ipswich watershed, Massachusetts, USA , 2001 .

[75]  M. Marjanović,et al.  Landslide susceptibility assessment using SVM machine learning algorithm , 2011 .

[76]  Saro Lee,et al.  Modelling gully-erosion susceptibility in a semi-arid region, Iran: Investigation of applicability of certainty factor and maximum entropy models. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[77]  John R. Dymond,et al.  Validation of a region-wide model of landslide susceptibility in the Manawatu-Wanganui region of New Zealand , 2006 .

[78]  K. Woldearegay,et al.  GIS-based Landslide Susceptibility Evaluation Using Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) Approach: The Case of Tarmaber District, Ethiopia , 2019, Momona Ethiopian Journal of Science.

[79]  J. Chacón,et al.  Engineering geology maps: landslides and geographical information systems , 2006 .

[80]  Sunil Kumar,et al.  Maxent modeling for predicting suitable habitat for threatened and endangered tree Canacomyrica monticola in New Caledonia , 2009 .

[81]  Hamid Reza Pourghasemi,et al.  How do machine learning techniques help in increasing accuracy of landslide susceptibility maps? , 2020 .

[82]  Seyed Amir Naghibi,et al.  GIS-based landslide spatial modeling in Ganzhou City, China , 2016, Arabian Journal of Geosciences.

[83]  Reducing Landslide Risk Using Airborne Lidar Scanning Data , 2019, Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering.

[84]  Alexander Brenning,et al.  Evaluating machine learning and statistical prediction techniques for landslide susceptibility modeling , 2015, Comput. Geosci..

[85]  Piotr Jankowski,et al.  An optimized solution of multi-criteria evaluation analysis of landslide susceptibility using fuzzy sets and Kalman filter , 2010, Comput. Geosci..

[86]  Vojislav Kecman,et al.  Support Vector Machines – An Introduction , 2005 .

[87]  Hamid Reza Pourghasemi,et al.  Landslide Susceptibility Mapping Using GIS-Based Data Mining Algorithms , 2019, Water.

[88]  M. Mokhtar,et al.  Treated water quality based on conventional method in Langat River Basin, Malaysia , 2020, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[89]  Abbas Alimohammadi,et al.  A GIS-based neuro-fuzzy procedure for integrating knowledge and data in landslide susceptibility mapping , 2010, Comput. Geosci..

[90]  T. Glade,et al.  A Review of Scale Dependency in Landslide Hazard and Risk Analysis , 2012 .

[91]  C. F. Lee,et al.  Landslide characteristics and, slope instability modeling using GIS, Lantau Island, Hong Kong , 2002 .

[92]  R. Soeters,et al.  Landslide hazard and risk zonation—why is it still so difficult? , 2006 .

[93]  Miroslav Dudík,et al.  Modeling of species distributions with Maxent: new extensions and a comprehensive evaluation , 2008 .

[94]  C. Gokceoğlu,et al.  Effects of land-use changes on landslides in a landslide-prone area (Ardesen, Rize, NE Turkey) , 2009, Environmental monitoring and assessment.

[95]  A. Erener,et al.  Landslide susceptibility assessment: what are the effects of mapping unit and mapping method? , 2012, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[96]  Sunil Saha,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping using knowledge driven statistical models in Darjeeling District, West Bengal, India , 2019, Geoenvironmental Disasters.

[97]  David R. B. Stockwell,et al.  Induction of sets of rules from animal distribution data: a robust and informative method of data analysis , 1992 .

[98]  Paraskevas Tsangaratos,et al.  Comparing the prediction performance of a Deep Learning Neural Network model with conventional machine learning models in landslide susceptibility assessment , 2020, CATENA.

[99]  Jianhong Zhang,et al.  Satellite-based analysis of landfill landslide: the case of the 2015 Shenzhen landslide , 2019, International Journal of Geotechnical Engineering.

[100]  G. Qiao,et al.  Predicting potential distribution of chestnut phylloxerid (Hemiptera: Phylloxeridae) based on GARP and Maxent ecological niche models , 2010 .

[101]  Robert Tibshirani,et al.  The Elements of Statistical Learning: Data Mining, Inference, and Prediction, 2nd Edition , 2001, Springer Series in Statistics.

[102]  Bahareh Kalantar,et al.  Assessment of the effects of training data selection on the landslide susceptibility mapping: a comparison between support vector machine (SVM), logistic regression (LR) and artificial neural networks (ANN) , 2018 .

[103]  F. D. Blasio,et al.  Introduction to the Physics of Landslides , 2011 .

[104]  C. Gokceoğlu,et al.  Assessment of landslide susceptibility for a landslide-prone area (north of Yenice, NW Turkey) by fuzzy approach , 2002 .

[105]  Biswajeet Pradhan,et al.  Hazard zoning for spatial planning using GIS-based landslide susceptibility assessment: a new hybrid integrated data-driven and knowledge-based model , 2019, Arabian Journal of Geosciences.

[106]  Xiaoqing Chen,et al.  Characteristics of earthquake-triggered landslides and post-earthquake debris flows in Beichuan County , 2010 .

[107]  E. Yesilnacar,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping : A comparison of logistic regression and neural networks methods in a medium scale study, Hendek Region (Turkey) , 2005 .

[108]  F. Guzzetti,et al.  Landslide inventory maps: New tools for an old problem , 2012 .

[109]  V. Doyuran,et al.  A comparison of the GIS based landslide susceptibility assessment methods: multivariate versus bivariate , 2004 .

[110]  B. Pradhan,et al.  Application of fuzzy logic and analytical hierarchy process (AHP) to landslide susceptibility mapping at Haraz watershed, Iran , 2012, Natural Hazards.

[111]  J. Malet,et al.  Recommendations for the quantitative analysis of landslide risk , 2013, Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment.

[112]  Farrokh Nadim,et al.  Statistical modelling of Europe-wide landslide susceptibility using limited landslide inventory data , 2012, Landslides.

[113]  Saro Lee Application and verification of fuzzy algebraic operators to landslide susceptibility mapping , 2007 .

[114]  Maryam Mokhtari,et al.  Spatial prediction of landslide susceptibility in Taleghan basin, Iran , 2019, Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment.

[115]  T. Pöschel,et al.  Packings of micron-sized spherical particles – Insights from bulk density determination, X-ray microtomography and discrete element simulations , 2020 .

[116]  T. Joyner,et al.  Old health risks in new places? An ecological niche model for I. ricinus tick distribution in Europe under a changing climate. , 2014, Health & place.

[117]  Peter Brewer,et al.  openModeller: a generic approach to species’ potential distribution modelling , 2011, GeoInformatica.

[118]  Wei Chen,et al.  Spatial prediction of landslide susceptibility using an adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system combined with frequency ratio, generalized additive model, and support vector machine techniques , 2017, Geomorphology.

[119]  N. Park Using maximum entropy modeling for landslide susceptibility mapping with multiple geoenvironmental data sets , 2015, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[120]  Omar S. Baghabra Al-Amoudi,et al.  A review on the angle of repose of granular materials , 2018 .

[121]  Mark B. Allen,et al.  Accommodation of late Cenozoic oblique shortening in the Alborz range, northern Iran , 2003 .

[122]  Ashraf Dewan,et al.  Floods in a Megacity: Geospatial Techniques in Assessing Hazards, Risk and Vulnerability , 2013 .

[123]  N. Bhushan,et al.  Strategic Decision Making: Applying the Analytic Hierarchy Process , 2004 .

[124]  José Luís Zêzere,et al.  Probabilistic landslide risk analysis considering direct costs in the area north of Lisbon (Portugal) , 2008 .

[125]  W. Z. Savage,et al.  Guidelines for landslide susceptibility, hazard and risk zoning for land-use planning , 2008 .

[126]  H. Pourghasemi,et al.  Random forests and evidential belief function-based landslide susceptibility assessment in Western Mazandaran Province, Iran , 2016, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[127]  Steven J. Phillips,et al.  Sample selection bias and presence-only distribution models: implications for background and pseudo-absence data. , 2009, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[128]  Veronica Tofani,et al.  Landslide susceptibility estimation by random forests technique: sensitivity and scaling issues , 2013 .

[129]  Filippo Catani,et al.  Detecting fingerprints of landslide drivers: A MaxEnt model , 2013 .

[130]  Alex Smola,et al.  Kernel methods in machine learning , 2007, math/0701907.

[131]  C. Gokceoğlu,et al.  Use of fuzzy relations to produce landslide susceptibility map of a landslide prone area (West Black Sea Region, Turkey) , 2004 .

[132]  Miroslav Dudík,et al.  A maximum entropy approach to species distribution modeling , 2004, ICML.

[133]  B. Pradhan,et al.  Landslide vulnerability and risk assessment for multi-hazard scenarios using airborne laser scanning data (LiDAR) , 2017, Landslides.

[134]  Fausto Guzzetti,et al.  Landslide Vulnerability Criteria: A Case Study from Umbria, Central Italy , 2007, Environmental management.

[135]  L. Tham,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping based on Support Vector Machine: A case study on natural slopes of Hong Kong, China , 2008 .

[136]  W. L. Shirley,et al.  Social Vulnerability to Environmental Hazards , 2003 .

[137]  Chiara Lepore,et al.  Rainfall-induced landslide susceptibility zonation of Puerto Rico , 2012, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[138]  H. A. Nefeslioglu,et al.  Application of logistic regression for landslide susceptibility zoning of Cekmece Area, Istanbul, Turkey , 2006 .

[139]  Basant Kumar,et al.  Review on remote sensing methods for landslide detection using machine and deep learning , 2020, Trans. Emerg. Telecommun. Technol..

[140]  G. Ohlmacher The Relationship Between Geology and Landslide Hazards of Atchison, Kansas, and Vicinity , 2000, Current Research in Earth Sciences.

[141]  H. Yamada,et al.  Analysis of the geographical accessibility of neurosurgical emergency hospitals in Sapporo city using GIS and AHP , 2007, Int. J. Geogr. Inf. Sci..

[142]  Sailesh Samanta,et al.  Landslide vulnerability mapping (LVM) using weighted linear combination (WLC) model through remote sensing and GIS techniques , 2016, Modeling Earth Systems and Environment.

[143]  Majid Shadman Roodposhti,et al.  PROMETHEE II and fuzzy AHP: an enhanced GIS-based landslide susceptibility mapping , 2014, Natural Hazards.

[144]  H. Pourghasemi,et al.  Assessing and mapping multi-hazard risk susceptibility using a machine learning technique , 2020, Scientific Reports.

[145]  Birgit Terhorst,et al.  Landslide susceptibility assessment using “weights-of-evidence” applied to a study area at the Jurassic escarpment (SW-Germany) , 2007 .

[146]  Á. Felicísimo,et al.  Mapping landslide susceptibility with logistic regression, multiple adaptive regression splines, classification and regression trees, and maximum entropy methods: a comparative study , 2013, Landslides.

[147]  Y. Wang,et al.  The landslide problem , 2015 .

[148]  Cristiano Ballabio,et al.  Support Vector Machines for Landslide Susceptibility Mapping: The Staffora River Basin Case Study, Italy , 2012, Mathematical Geosciences.

[149]  Vijendra Kumar Pandey,et al.  Landslide susceptibility mapping using maximum entropy and support vector machine models along the highway corridor, Garhwal Himalaya , 2018, Geocarto International.

[150]  Stephen J. Carver,et al.  Integrating multi-criteria evaluation with geographical information systems , 1991, Int. J. Geogr. Inf. Sci..

[151]  L. C. Leung,et al.  On consistency and ranking of alternatives in fuzzy AHP , 2000, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[152]  Graham A. Tobin,et al.  Natural Hazards: Explanation and Integration , 1997 .