The efficacy of thyroidectomy for Graves' disease: A meta-analysis.

BACKGROUND Surgery for Graves' disease was largely replaced in the mid-1900s by radioiodine and antithyroid drugs, due to the belief that they were more safe and effective. Since then, thyroid surgery has improved with preoperative drug therapy and modern operative techniques. Recent clinical studies of thyroidectomy for Graves' disease may not reflect outcomes accurately because of small sample size, especially when estimating ideal thyroid remnant size. The purpose of this study was to combine modern clinical trials and use meta-analysis to determine the overall efficacy of both total (TT) and subtotal thyroidectomy (ST) for Graves' disease, compare thyroid function and complications rates of TT and ST, and determine ideal thyroid remnant size. METHODS Meta-analysis was performed on published studies in which patients underwent either TT or ST for Graves' disease. Meta-analysis was performed by weighted least-squares linear regression. P < 0.05 was considered significant. RESULTS There were 35 studies comprising 7241 patients. Mean follow-up was 5.6 years. Overall, persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism occurred in 7.2% of patients. TT was performed on 538 patients and hypothyroidism occurred in all cases. ST was performed in 6703 patients, 59.7% of whom achieved euthyroidism, 25. 6% became hypothyroid, and 7.9% had either persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism. Permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve injury occurred in 0.9% of TT patients and 0.7% of ST patients (P = NS). Permanent hypoparathyroidism occurred in 1.6% of TT patients and 1.0% of ST patients (P = NS). There was an 8.9% decrease in hypothyroidism and 6.9% increase in euthyroidism for each gram of thyroid remnant (P < 0.0001 each). CONCLUSIONS Overall, thyroidectomy successfully treated hyperthyroidism in 92% of patients with Graves' disease. There were no cases of hyperthyroidism following TT. ST achieved a euthyroid state in almost 60% of patients with an 8% rate of persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism. There was no significant difference in complication rates between TT and ST.

[1]  S. Hertz,et al.  RADIOACTIVE IODINE IN THE STUDY OF THYROID PHYSIOLOGY: VII. The Use of Radioactive Iodine Therapy in Hyperthyroidism , 1946 .

[2]  J. J. Taylor,et al.  THE EFFECT OF SUBTOTAL THYROIDECTOMY WITH PROPRANOLOL PREPARATION ON ANTIBODY ACTIVITY IN GRAVES' DISEASE , 1987, Clinical endocrinology.

[3]  M. Farnell,et al.  Hypothyroidism after thyroidectomy for Graves' disease. , 1981, American journal of surgery.

[4]  M. Freissmuth,et al.  Early relapse after operation for Graves' disease: postoperative hormone kinetics and outcome after subtotal, near-total, and total thyroidectomy. , 1998, Surgery.

[5]  R. Bowers.  Hyperthyroidism: comparative results of medical (I-131) and surgical therapy. , 1965, Annals of surgery.

[6]  J. Rastad,et al.  Retrospective evaluation of subtotal and total thyroidectomy in Graves' disease with and without endocrine ophthalmopathy. , 1995, European journal of endocrinology.

[7]  G. Smith,et al.  Meta-analysis: Potentials and promise , 1997, BMJ.

[8]  E. Kaplan,et al.  Reemergence of thyroidectomy as treatment for Graves' disease. , 1979, The Surgical clinics of North America.

[9]  D. Rubello,et al.  Long term thyroid function after subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves’ disease , 1988, Journal of endocrinological investigation.

[10]  D. Goga,et al.  Surgical treatment of Graves' disease0 , 1988 .

[11]  R. Nishiyama,et al.  Thyroidectomy for hyperthyroidism. , 1970, Archives of surgery.

[12]  F. Matsuzuka,et al.  Natural course of Graves' disease after subtotal thyroidectomy and management of patients with postoperative thyroid dysfunction. , 1991, The American journal of the medical sciences.

[13]  S. Perzik.  The place of total thyroidectomy in the management of 909 patients with thyroid disease. , 1976, American journal of surgery.

[14]  W. Maier,et al.  Long-term follow-up of patients with Grave's disease treated by subtotal thyroidectomy. , 1984, American journal of surgery.

[15]  S. Lennquist,et al.  The influence of remnant size, antithyroid antibodies, thyroid morphology, and lymphocyte infiltration on thyroid function after subtotal resection for hyperthyroidism , 1987, World journal of surgery.

[16]  N. Matheson,et al.  Outcome of surgery for Graves' disease re‐examined , 1987, The British journal of surgery.

[17]  A. Pinchera,et al.  Surgical treatment of Graves' disease: subtotal or total thyroidectomy? , 1996, Surgery.

[18]  D. Karakitsos,et al.  Should the primary treatment of hyperthyroidism be surgical? , 1997, The European journal of surgery = Acta chirurgica.

[19]  A. Taube,et al.  Graves' hyperthyroidism: treatment with antithyroid drugs, surgery, or radioiodine--a prospective, randomized study. Thyroid Study Group. , 1996, The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism.

[20]  M. LaValley,et al.  A consumer's guide to meta-analysis. , 1997, Arthritis care and research : the official journal of the Arthritis Health Professions Association.

[21]  K. Norrby,et al.  Thyroid function after subtotal thyroidectomy for hyperthyroidism related to some morphological and immunological features. , 1977, Acta chirurgica Scandinavica.

[22]  N. Painter,et al.  Size of the thyroid remnant in partial thyroidectomy for toxic goitre. , 1962, Lancet.

[23]  O. Beahrs,et al.  Surgical thyroidectomy in the management of exophthalmic goiter. , 1968, Archives of surgery.

[24]  M. Fujimori,et al.  Clinical evaluation of the response to surgical treatment of Graves' disease. , 1990, Surgery, gynecology & obstetrics.

[25]  C. Talbot,et al.  Surgery for thyrotoxicosis , 1983, The British journal of surgery.

[26]  J. Franklyn,et al.  Hyperthyroidism. Current treatment guidelines. , 1998, Drugs.

[27]  L. Braverman,et al.  Surgery still has a role in Graves' hyperthyroidism. , 1993, Surgery.

[28]  S. Silverberg,et al.  Limited subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease. , 1981, Archives of surgery.

[29]  Jacques Lb.  Letter: Standardisation of heparin for clinical use. , 1975 .

[30]  R. D. Liechty,et al.  Modified subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease: a two-institution study. , 1983, Surgery.

[31]  J. Becquemin,et al.  Operation for hyperthyroidism , 1988 .

[32]  O. Ozaki,et al.  Follow-up evaluation of patients with Graves’ disease treated by subtotal thyroidectomy and risk factor analysis for postoperative thyroid dysfunction , 1993, Journal of endocrinological investigation.

[33]  D. Glinoer,et al.  Current trends in the management of Graves' disease. , 1990, The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism.

[34]  B. Thjódleifsson,et al.  OUTCOME OF SUB‐TOTAL THYROIDECTOMY FOR THYROTOXICOSISIN ICELAND AND NORTHEAST SCOTLAND , 1977, Clinical endocrinology.