Decision Support A comparison of multiple criteria analysis techniques for water resource management

Multiple criteria analysis (MCA) is a framework for evaluating decision options against multiple criteria. Numerous techniques for solving an MCA problem are available. This paper applies MCA to six water management decision problems. The MCA methods tested include weighted summation, range of value, PROMTHEE II, Evamix and compromise programming. We show that different MCA methods were in strong agreement with high correlations amongst rankings. In the few cases where strong disagreement between MCA methods did occur it was due to presence of mixed ordinal-cardinal data in the evaluation matrix. The results suggest that whilst selection of the MCA technique is important more emphasis is needed on the initial structuring of the decision problem, which involves choosing criteria and decision options. 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

[1]  Bojan Srdjevic,et al.  An Objective Multi-Criteria Evaluation of Water Management Scenarios , 2004 .

[2]  Steve Russ,et al.  A new paradigm for computer-based decision support , 2002, Decis. Support Syst..

[3]  Kiyotada Hayashi,et al.  Multicriteria analysis for agricultural resource management: A critical survey and future perspectives , 2000, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[4]  S. Hajkowicz,et al.  An Evaluation of Multiple Objective Decision Support Weighting Techniques in Natural Resource Management , 2000 .

[5]  Leonard J. Lane,et al.  Targeting farms to improve water quality , 1997 .

[6]  Ferenc Szidarovszky,et al.  Multi-attribute decision making: dominance with respect to an importance order of the attributes , 1993 .

[7]  Tarik Al-Shemmeri,et al.  Environmental impact assessment and ranking the environmental projects in Jordan , 1999, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[8]  Carlos A. Bana e Costa,et al.  Multicriteria Evaluation of Flood Control Measures: The Case of Ribeira do Livramento , 2004 .

[9]  Carlos Romero,et al.  Natural resource management and the use of multiple criteria decision-making techniques: A review , 1987 .

[10]  Benedetto Matarazzo,et al.  Other Outranking Approaches , 2005 .

[11]  D. Kumar,et al.  Multicriterion decision making in irrigation planning , 1999 .

[12]  Miguel A. Mariño,et al.  Case Study: Application of Multicriteria Decision Making to Urban Water Supply , 2005 .

[13]  H Voogd,et al.  Multicriteria Evaluation with Mixed Qualitative and Quantitative Data , 1982 .

[14]  A. Howard.  A critical look at multiple criteria decision making techniques with reference to forestry applications , 1991 .

[15]  Ali Karnib,et al.  An Approach to Elaborate Priority Preorders of Water Resources Projects Based on Multi-Criteria Evaluation and Fuzzy Sets Analysis , 2004 .

[16]  Lucien Duckstein,et al.  Analysing Water Resources Alternatives and Handling Criteria by Multi Criterion Decision Techniques , 1996 .

[17]  Stelios H. Zanakis,et al.  Multi-attribute decision making: A simulation comparison of select methods , 1998, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[18]  Adel Guitouni,et al.  Tentative guidelines to help choosing an appropriate MCDA method , 1998, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[19]  Michael D. Rowe,et al.  Sensitivity of the weighting summation decision method to incorrect application , 1982 .

[20]  Keith W. Hipel,et al.  Multiple objective decision making for “Lokahi” (balance) in environment management , 1997 .

[21]  J. Voogd,et al.  Multicriteria evaluation for urban and regional planning , 1982 .

[22]  Dennis J. Dunning,et al.  Multiattribute utility analysis for addressing Section 316(b) of the Clean Water Act , 2000 .

[23]  Peter Nijkamp,et al.  Multicriteria evaluation in physical planning , 1990 .

[24]  Aregai Tecle,et al.  SELECTING A MULTICRITERION DECISION MAKING TECHNIQUE FOR WATERSHED RESOURCES MANAGEMENT , 1992 .

[25]  Jyrki Wallenius,et al.  A study of high-level managerial decision processes, with implications for MCDM research , 2000, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[26]  H. D. Klerk,et al.  Fynbos (fine bush) vegetation and the supply of water: a comparison of multi-criteria decision analysis and cost-benefit analysis , 1997 .

[27]  J. Gough,et al.  Environmental Decision-Making and Lake Management , 1996 .

[28]  Mark Gershon,et al.  The role of weights and scales in the application of multiobjective decision making , 1984 .

[29]  Mark Gershon,et al.  Multiobjective Approaches to River Basin Planning , 1981 .

[30]  Matthias Ehrgott,et al.  Multiple criteria decision analysis: state of the art surveys , 2005 .

[31]  David J. Sheskin,et al.  Handbook of Parametric and Nonparametric Statistical Procedures , 1997 .

[32]  L. Duckstein,et al.  Multicriterion Analysis for Sustainable Water Resources Planning: A Case Study in Spain , 2000 .

[33]  T. Stewart,et al.  Evaluation of water supply augmentation and water demand management options for the City of Cape Town , 2003 .

[34]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Problem structuring methods in action , 2004, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[35]  Lucien Duckstein,et al.  Ranking water resource projects and evaluating criteria by multicriterion Q-analysis: an Austrian case study , 1997 .

[36]  B. Mareschal,et al.  Water resources planning in the Middle East: application of the PROMETHEE V multicriteria method , 1995 .

[37]  Jean Pierre Brans,et al.  HOW TO SELECT AND HOW TO RANK PROJECTS: THE PROMETHEE METHOD , 1986 .

[38]  Stanley Zionts,et al.  A problem structuring front end for a multiple criteria decision support system , 2006, Comput. Oper. Res..

[39]  Marshall Flug,et al.  Multicriteria decision analysis applied to Glen Canyon Dam , 2000 .

[40]  Rameswar Panda,et al.  Integrated Management of a Canal Command in a River Delta using Multi-Objective Techniques , 2001 .

[41]  G. Paudyal,et al.  Environmental–economic decision-making in lowland irrigated agriculture using multi-criteria analysis techniques , 1999 .

[42]  Tony Prato,et al.  Multiple attribute decision analysis for ecosystem management , 1999 .

[43]  M. Ramachandran,et al.  Application of multi-criteria decision making to sustainable energy planning--A review , 2004 .

[44]  Holger R. Maier,et al.  Reliability-Based Approach to Multicriteria Decision Analysis for Water Resources , 2004 .

[45]  K. Hipel.  Multiple objective decision making in water resources , 1992 .

[46]  Ron Janssen,et al.  On the use of multi‐criteria analysis in environmental impact assessment in The Netherlands , 2001 .