The Chorioallantoic Membrane Assay in Nanotoxicological Research—An Alternative for In Vivo Experimentation

Nanomaterials unveil many applicational possibilities for technical and medical purposes, which range from imaging techniques to the use as drug carriers. Prior to any human application, analysis of undesired effects and characterization of their toxicological profile is mandatory. To address this topic, animal models, and rodent models in particular, are most frequently used. However, as the reproducibility and transferability to the human organism of animal experimental data is increasingly questioned and the awareness of animal welfare in society increases at the same time, methodological alternatives are urgently required. The chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) assay is an increasingly popular in ovo experimental organism suitable for replacement of rodent experimentation. In this review, we outline several application fields for the CAM assay in the field of nanotoxicology. Furthermore, analytical methods applicable with this model were evaluated in detail. We further discuss ethical, financial, and bureaucratic aspects and benchmark the assay with other established in vivo models such as rodents.

[1]  E. Choi,et al.  Self-Styled ZnO Nanostructures Promotes the Cancer Cell Damage and Supresses the Epithelial Phenotype of Glioblastoma , 2016, Scientific Reports.

[2]  Andries Zijlstra,et al.  Evaluation of Nanoparticle Uptake in Tumors in Real Time Using Intravital Imaging , 2011, Journal of visualized experiments : JoVE.

[3]  A. Bikfalvi,et al.  VEGF coordinates interaction of pericytes and endothelial cells during vasculogenesis and experimental angiogenesis , 2004, Developmental dynamics : an official publication of the American Association of Anatomists.

[4]  André Chwalibog,et al.  In ovo administration of copper nanoparticles and copper sulfate positively influences chicken performance. , 2016, Journal of the science of food and agriculture.

[5]  F. Otero-Espinar,et al.  Hydrocortisone loaded poly-(3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate) nanoparticles for topical ophthalmic administration: preparation, characterization and evaluation of ophthalmic toxicity. , 2019, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[6]  P. Hoet,et al.  Synthesis, characterization and toxicity assessment of a new polymeric nanoparticle, l-glutamic acid-g-p(HEMA). , 2020, Chemico-biological interactions.

[7]  James R. Smith,et al.  Nanoparticles of alkylglyceryl-dextran-graft-poly(lactic acid) for drug delivery to the brain: Preparation and in vitro investigation. , 2015, Acta biomaterialia.

[8]  Z. Rehman,et al.  Toxicity of Nanoparticles on the Reproductive System in Animal Models: A Review , 2017, Front. Pharmacol..

[9]  Venkateshwaran Krishnaswami,et al.  Development of copolymeric nanoparticles of hypocrellin B: Enhanced phototoxic effect and ocular distribution , 2017, European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences.

[10]  Hong-Boon Lee,et al.  Chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane (CAM): an alternative predictive model in acute toxicological studies for anti-cancer drugs , 2015, Experimental animals.

[11]  M. Vinardell,et al.  Alternative methods for eye and skin irritation tests: an overview. , 2008, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[12]  D. Ribatti The chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane in the study of tumor angiogenesis. , 2008, Romanian journal of morphology and embryology = Revue roumaine de morphologie et embryologie.

[13]  Dong Wook Kim,et al.  Optical imaging to trace near infrared fluorescent zinc oxide nanoparticles following oral exposure , 2012, International journal of nanomedicine.

[14]  J. Deschner,et al.  In Vivo Modulation of Angiogenesis and Immune Response on a Collagen Matrix via Extracorporeal Shockwaves , 2020, International journal of molecular sciences.

[15]  M. Ricci,et al.  Lipid nanoparticles for brain targeting III. Long-term stability and in vivo toxicity. , 2013, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[16]  R. Beck,et al.  An innovative polysaccharide nanobased nail formulation for improvement of onychomycosis treatment , 2017, European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences.

[17]  M. Aqil,et al.  Chitosan-coated PLGA nanoparticles of bevacizumab as novel drug delivery to target retina: optimization, characterization, and in vitro toxicity evaluation , 2017, Artificial cells, nanomedicine, and biotechnology.

[18]  Sandeep Kumar,et al.  Evaluation of tropicamide-loaded tamarind seed xyloglucan nanoaggregates for ophthalmic delivery. , 2013, Carbohydrate polymers.

[19]  Dong Wook Kim,et al.  The effect of fluorination of zinc oxide nanoparticles on evaluation of their biodistribution after oral administration , 2012, Nanotechnology.

[20]  Patrycja Nowak-Sliwinska,et al.  The chicken chorioallantoic membrane model in biology, medicine and bioengineering , 2014, Angiogenesis.

[21]  B. Jiang,et al.  Tungsten Carbide-Cobalt Nanoparticles Induce Reactive Oxygen Species, AKT, ERK, AP-1, NF-κB, VEGF, and Angiogenesis , 2010, Biological Trace Element Research.

[22]  G. Lowry,et al.  Towards a definition of inorganic nanoparticles from an environmental, health and safety perspective. , 2009, Nature nanotechnology.

[23]  D. Ribatti,et al.  The chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane as an in vivo wound healing model. , 1996, Pathology, research and practice.

[24]  S. Ganta,et al.  Anti-angiogenic and anti-cancer evaluation of betulin nanoemulsion in chicken chorioallantoic membrane and skin carcinoma in Balb/c mice. , 2013, Journal of biomedical nanotechnology.

[25]  Pierre Corvol,et al.  Angiotensinogen impairs angiogenesis in the chick chorioallantoic membrane , 2007, Journal of Molecular Medicine.

[26]  Michał R. Radowski,et al.  Influences of opioids and nanoparticles on in vitro wound healing models. , 2009, European journal of pharmaceutics and biopharmaceutics : official journal of Arbeitsgemeinschaft fur Pharmazeutische Verfahrenstechnik e.V.

[27]  V. Gubala,et al.  Improving colloidal stability of silica nanoparticles when stored in responsive gel: application and toxicity study , 2018, Nanotoxicology.

[28]  S. Guterres,et al.  Castor oil and mineral oil nanoemulsion: development and compatibility with a soft contact lens , 2014, Pharmaceutical development and technology.

[29]  F. Tamanoi,et al.  Chick chorioallantoic membrane assay as an in vivo model to study the effect of nanoparticle-based anticancer drugs in ovarian cancer , 2018, Scientific Reports.

[30]  Jie Tang,et al.  Evaluation of Liver Ischemia-Reperfusion Injury in Rabbits Using a Nanoscale Ultrasound Contrast Agent Targeting ICAM-1 , 2016, PloS one.

[31]  M. Amaral,et al.  New Thermoresponsive Eyedrop Formulation Containing Ibuprofen Loaded-Nanostructured Lipid Carriers (NLC): Development, Characterization and Biocompatibility Studies. , 2016, Current drug delivery.

[32]  Stasia A. Anderson,et al.  Magnetic resonance contrast enhancement of neovasculature with αvβ3‐targeted nanoparticles , 2000 .

[33]  A. Chwalibog,et al.  Nanoparticles of Copper Stimulate Angiogenesis at Systemic and Molecular Level , 2015, International journal of molecular sciences.

[34]  A. Chwalibog,et al.  Influence of nanoparticles of platinum on chicken embryo development and brain morphology , 2013, Nanoscale Research Letters.

[35]  A. R. Fernandes,et al.  Peptide-coated gold nanoparticles for modulation of angiogenesis in vivo , 2016, International journal of nanomedicine.

[36]  Gary Jacobs,et al.  From Dose to Response: In Vivo Nanoparticle Processing and Potential Toxicity. , 2017, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[37]  I. Stiharu,et al.  Significant toxic role for single-walled carbon nanotubes during normal embryogenesis. , 2013, Nanomedicine : nanotechnology, biology, and medicine.

[38]  Barrie Condon,et al.  Noninvasive monitoring of chick development in ovo using a 7T MRI system from day 12 of incubation through to hatching , 2007, Journal of magnetic resonance imaging : JMRI.

[39]  Ankur Gupta,et al.  Physicochemical characterization and toxicological evaluation of plant-based anionic polymers and their nanoparticulated system for ocular delivery , 2014, Nanotoxicology.

[40]  T. Koller,et al.  Dynamics of the Developing Chick Chorioallantoic Membrane Assessed by Stereology, Allometry, Immunohistochemistry and Molecular Analysis , 2016, PloS one.

[41]  M. Mashkour,et al.  Enhancement of bone mineral density and body mass in newborn chickens by in ovo injection of ionic-hydroxyapatite nanoparticles of bacterial origin , 2019, Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine.

[42]  J. Martinez-de-Oliveira,et al.  Testing vaginal irritation with the Hen’s Egg Test-Chorioallantoic Membrane assay , 2018, ALTEX.

[43]  P. Bagher,et al.  The mouse cremaster muscle preparation for intravital imaging of the microcirculation. , 2011, Journal of visualized experiments : JoVE.

[44]  M. Leite,et al.  Design and Development of Polysaccharide-Doxorubicin-Peptide Bioconjugates for Dual Synergistic Effects of Integrin-Targeted and Cell-Penetrating Peptides for Cancer Chemotherapy. , 2018, Bioconjugate chemistry.

[45]  A. P. Gadad,et al.  Formulation and comparative evaluation of HPMC and water soluble chitosan-based sparfloxacin nanosuspension for ophthalmic delivery , 2015, Drug Delivery and Translational Research.

[46]  T. Xia,et al.  Toxic Potential of Materials at the Nanolevel , 2006, Science.

[47]  Cheryl L. Willman,et al.  Mesoporous Silica Nanoparticle-Supported Lipid Bilayers (Protocells) for Active Targeting and Delivery to Individual Leukemia Cells. , 2016, ACS nano.

[48]  A. Chwalibog,et al.  Effect of taurine and gold nanoparticles on the morphological and molecular characteristics of muscle development during chicken embryogenesis , 2012, Archives of animal nutrition.

[49]  D. Fischer,et al.  Comprehensive analysis of the in vitro and ex ovo hemocompatibility of surface engineered iron oxide nanoparticles for biomedical applications , 2017, Archives of Toxicology.

[50]  James P. Quigley,et al.  Chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane model systems to study and visualize human tumor cell metastasis , 2008, Histochemistry and Cell Biology.

[51]  Rebekah Drezek,et al.  In vivo biodistribution of nanoparticles. , 2011, Nanomedicine.

[52]  F. Namvar,et al.  Antiangiogenic and antiapoptotic effects of green-synthesized zinc oxide nanoparticles using Sargassum muticum algae extraction , 2018, Cancer Nanotechnology.

[53]  J. O. Flores-Flores,et al.  Influence of shape and dispersion media of titanium dioxide nanostructures on microvessel network and ossification. , 2018, Colloids and surfaces. B, Biointerfaces.

[54]  S. Guterres,et al.  Prednisolone-loaded nanocapsules as ocular drug delivery system: development, in vitro drug release and eye toxicity , 2014, Journal of microencapsulation.

[55]  Sabu Thomas,et al.  Yttrium oxide nanoparticle loaded scaffolds with enhanced cell adhesion and vascularization for tissue engineering applications. , 2019, Materials science & engineering. C, Materials for biological applications.

[56]  F. Abas,et al.  Chitosan Nanoparticles as Carriers for the Delivery of ΦKAZ14 Bacteriophage for Oral Biological Control of Colibacillosis in Chickens , 2016, Molecules.

[57]  Jan Baumgart,et al.  Monitoring of tumor growth and vascularization with repetitive ultrasonography in the chicken chorioallantoic-membrane-assay , 2020, Scientific reports.

[58]  E. Sawosz,et al.  The influence of silver nanoparticles on chicken embryo development and bursa of Fabricius morphology , 2006 .

[59]  Rickard Arvidsson,et al.  A Definition Framework for the Terms Nanomaterial and Nanoparticle , 2016 .

[60]  S. Saravanan,et al.  Biogenic gold nanoparticles synthesis mediated by Mangifera indica seed aqueous extracts exhibits antibacterial, anticancer and anti-angiogenic properties. , 2018, Biomedicine & pharmacotherapy = Biomedecine & pharmacotherapie.

[61]  Christof Asbach,et al.  Nanoparticle exposure at nanotechnology workplaces: A review , 2011, Particle and Fibre Toxicology.

[62]  M. Ghorbani,et al.  In vivo evaluation of toxicity and antiviral activity of polyrhodanine nanoparticles by using the chicken embryo model. , 2017, International journal of biological macromolecules.

[63]  L. B. Lopes,et al.  Development, Skin Targeting And Antifungal Efficacy Of Topical Lipid Nanoparticles Containing Itraconazole. , 2020, European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences.

[64]  S. R. Pinnapireddy,et al.  Lipodendriplexes: A promising nanocarrier for enhanced gene delivery with minimal cytotoxicity , 2019, European journal of pharmaceutics and biopharmaceutics : official journal of Arbeitsgemeinschaft fur Pharmazeutische Verfahrenstechnik e.V.

[65]  S. Gad,et al.  Tolerable Levels of Nonclinical Vehicles and Formulations Used in Studies by Multiple Routes in Multiple Species With Notes on Methods to Improve Utility , 2016, International journal of toxicology.

[66]  T. Hacker,et al.  Altered cardiac function and ventricular septal defect in avian embryos exposed to low-dose trichloroethylene. , 2010, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[67]  Mohammed M Mehanna,et al.  Levofloxacin-loaded naturally occurring monoterpene-based nanoemulgel: a feasible efficient system to circumvent MRSA ocular infections , 2020, Drug development and industrial pharmacy.

[68]  Robert Langer,et al.  Nanoparticle delivery of cancer drugs. , 2012, Annual review of medicine.

[69]  Phil G Campbell,et al.  The use of quantum dots for analysis of chick CAM vasculature. , 2007, Microvascular research.

[70]  N. Jain,et al.  Surface engineered dendrimers as antiangiogenic agent and carrier for anticancer drug: dual attack on cancer. , 2014, Journal of nanoscience and nanotechnology.

[71]  A. Punnoose,et al.  The Influences of Cell Type and ZnO Nanoparticle Size on Immune Cell Cytotoxicity and Cytokine Induction , 2009, Nanoscale research letters.

[72]  S A Wickline,et al.  Novel MRI Contrast Agent for Molecular Imaging of Fibrin: Implications for Detecting Vulnerable Plaques , 2001, Circulation.

[73]  L. Knudsen,et al.  Nordic symposium on "toxicology and pharmacology without animal experiments-Will it be possible in the next 10 years?" , 2019, Basic & clinical pharmacology & toxicology.

[74]  P. Langguth,et al.  Comparative toxicity and cell-tissue distribution study on nanoparticular iron complexes using avian embryos and HepG2-cells. , 2008, Translational research : the journal of laboratory and clinical medicine.

[75]  J. Fellenberg,et al.  Optimization of the chicken chorioallantoic membrane assay as reliable in vivo model for the analysis of osteosarcoma , 2019, PloS one.

[76]  S. Jeurissen,et al.  Ontogeny and function of two non-lymphoid cell populations in the chicken embryo. , 1991, Immunobiology.

[77]  J. L. Paris,et al.  Nanoparticles for Multimodal Antivascular Therapeutics: Dual Drug Release, Photothermal and Photodynamic Therapy. , 2019, Acta biomaterialia.

[78]  A. C. Silva,et al.  Characterization and biocompatibility evaluation of cutaneous formulations containing lipid nanoparticles. , 2017, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[79]  D. Ribatti The chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane as a model for tumor biology. , 2014, Experimental cell research.

[80]  N P Luepke,et al.  Hen's egg chorioallantoic membrane test for irritation potential. , 1985, Food and chemical toxicology : an international journal published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association.

[81]  H. Rachmawati,et al.  Antifibrotic Activity and In Ovo Toxicity Study of Liver-Targeted Curcumin-Gold Nanoparticle. , 2018, Scientia pharmaceutica.

[82]  C. Fernandes,et al.  Vincristine-loaded hydroxyapatite nanoparticles as a potential delivery system for bone cancer therapy , 2017, Journal of drug targeting.

[83]  A. Chwalibog,et al.  Nano-Nutrition of Chicken Embryos. The Effect of in Ovo Administration of Diamond Nanoparticles and l-Glutamine on Molecular Responses in Chicken Embryo Pectoral Muscles , 2013, International journal of molecular sciences.

[84]  Masakazu Umezawa,et al.  In-ovo exposed carbon black nanoparticles altered mRNA gene transcripts of antioxidants, proinflammatory and apoptotic pathways in the brain of chicken embryos. , 2018, Chemico-biological interactions.

[85]  D. Ribatti The chick embryo chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). A multifaceted experimental model , 2016, Mechanisms of Development.

[86]  A. Silva,et al.  Biopharmaceutical evaluation of epigallocatechin gallate-loaded cationic lipid nanoparticles (EGCG-LNs): In vivo, in vitro and ex vivo studies. , 2016, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[87]  T. Rao,et al.  Angiogenic Profiling of Synthesized Carbon Quantum Dots. , 2015, Biochemistry.

[88]  M. Menger,et al.  The dorsal skinfold chamber: A versatile tool for preclinical research in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. , 2016, European cells & materials.

[89]  Mateusz Wierzbicki,et al.  Diamond Nanoparticles Modify Curcumin Activity: In Vitro Studies on Cancer and Normal Cells and In Ovo Studies on Chicken Embryo Model , 2016, PloS one.

[90]  Mateusz Wierzbicki,et al.  Toxicity of pristine graphene in experiments in a chicken embryo model , 2014, International journal of nanomedicine.

[91]  Jonathan T Butcher,et al.  Quantitative three‐dimensional imaging of live avian embryonic morphogenesis via micro‐computed tomography , 2011, Developmental dynamics : an official publication of the American Association of Anatomists.

[92]  T Lammers,et al.  Applications of nanoparticles for diagnosis and therapy of cancer. , 2015, The British journal of radiology.

[93]  M. J. Gómara,et al.  Conjugation of cell-penetrating peptides with poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid)-polyethylene glycol nanoparticles improves ocular drug delivery , 2015, International journal of nanomedicine.

[94]  M. Höpfner,et al.  Synthesis and characterization of quantum dots designed for biomedical use. , 2014, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[95]  A. Małolepszy,et al.  Graphene Oxide in a Composite with Silver Nanoparticles Reduces the Fibroblast and Endothelial Cell Cytotoxicity of an Antibacterial Nanoplatform , 2019, Nanoscale Research Letters.

[96]  Ding Cao,et al.  Photocatalytic production of hydroxyl radicals by commercial TiO2 nanoparticles and phototoxic hazard identification. , 2018, Toxicology.

[97]  G. Benelli,et al.  Biopolymer gelatin-coated zinc oxide nanoparticles showed high antibacterial, antibiofilm and anti-angiogenic activity. , 2018, Journal of photochemistry and photobiology. B, Biology.

[98]  Jackelyn A. Alva,et al.  Selective Binding of Lectins to Embryonic Chicken Vasculature , 2003, The journal of histochemistry and cytochemistry : official journal of the Histochemistry Society.

[99]  Dong Chen,et al.  The shape effect of mesoporous silica nanoparticles on biodistribution, clearance, and biocompatibility in vivo. , 2011, ACS nano.

[100]  U. Schubert,et al.  Effect of surfactant on the size and stability of PLGA nanoparticles encapsulating a protein kinase C inhibitor. , 2019, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[101]  Huan Xie,et al.  Nanoparticles in Daily Life: Applications, Toxicity and Regulations. , 2018, Journal of environmental pathology, toxicology and oncology : official organ of the International Society for Environmental Toxicology and Cancer.

[102]  H. Jennissen,et al.  Chick ex ovo culture and ex ovo CAM assay: how it really works. , 2009, Journal of visualized experiments : JoVE.

[103]  Bryce J Marquis,et al.  Analytical methods to assess nanoparticle toxicity. , 2009, The Analyst.