Elusiveness of menstrual cycle effects on mate preferences: comment on Gildersleeve, Haselton, and Fales (2014).

This comment uses meta-analytic techniques to reconcile the apparent conflict between Gildersleeve, Haselton, and Fales's (2014) conclusion of "robust" effects of menstrual cycles on women's preferences for men of purported genetic quality and Wood, Kressel, Joshi, and Louie's (2014) assessment that the few, limited effects in this literature appear to be research artifacts. Despite these divergent conclusions, the literature in both reviews shows a broad distribution of effects, with fully one third of findings countering evolutionary psychology predictions. We demonstrate that Gildersleeve et al.'s conclusions were influenced by a small minority of supportive studies. Furthermore, we show that in both reviews, these supportive studies used imprecise estimates of women's cycle phase by failing to validate cycle day (e.g., with hormonal tests) or by including a large number of days in the fertile phase. More recently, as published studies have used more precise methods to estimate menstrual phase, the effect has declined to zero. Additionally, publication status proved important in both reviews, with published but not unpublished studies showing the predicted effects. In general, the limited evidence for evolutionary psychology predictions calls for more sophisticated models of hormonal processes in human mating.

[1]  K. Levy,et al.  The media construct a menstrual monster: a content analysis of PMS articles in the popular press. , 1990, Women & health.

[2]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  Systematic Review of the Empirical Evidence of Study Publication Bias and Outcome Reporting Bias , 2008, PloS one.

[3]  D. Perrett,et al.  Preferences for symmetry in faces change across the menstrual cycle , 2007, Biological Psychology.

[4]  J. Hyde,et al.  Comment: Menstrual Cycle Fluctuations in Women’s Mate Preferences , 2014 .

[5]  S. Anders Comment: The Social Neuroendocrinology Example: Incorporating Culture Resolves Biobehavioral Evolutionary Paradoxes , 2014 .

[6]  V. Vitzthum The ecology and evolutionary endocrinology of reproduction in the human female. , 2009, American journal of physical anthropology.

[7]  R. Thornhill,et al.  Women's preferences for men's scents associated with testosterone and cortisol levels: Patterns across the ovulatory cycle , 2013 .

[8]  R. Thornhill,et al.  The scent of symmetry: A human sex pheromone that signals fitness? , 1999 .

[9]  D. Perrett,et al.  Evidence for Menstrual Cycle Shifts in Women's Preferences for Masculinity: A Response to Harris (in Press) “Menstrual Cycle and Facial Preferences Reconsidered” , 2010, Evolutionary psychology : an international journal of evolutionary approaches to psychology and behavior.

[10]  D. Ruble,et al.  Menstrual symptoms: A social cognition analysis , 1979, Journal of Behavioral Medicine.

[11]  D. Ruble,et al.  Premenstrual symptoms: a reinterpretation. , 1977, Science.

[12]  P. Sleight,et al.  Publication bias , 1991, The Lancet.

[13]  D. Perrett,et al.  Effects of Menstrual Cycle Phase on Face Preferences , 2008, Archives of sexual behavior.

[14]  Wendy Wood,et al.  Advantages of certainty and uncertainty , 2009 .

[15]  Victoria Martínez,et al.  Introduction to Meta-Analysis , 2002 .

[16]  Yuliya M. Zaretskaya,et al.  Major Histocompatibility Complex. , 1999, Russian journal of immunology : RJI : official journal of Russian Society of Immunology.

[17]  L. Hedges,et al.  The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis , 2009 .

[18]  P. Caplan,et al.  The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Ms. Hyde: How PMS Became a Cultural Phenomenon and a Psychiatric Disorder , 2002, Annual review of sex research.

[19]  Wendy Wood,et al.  Meta-Analysis of Menstrual Cycle Effects on Women’s Mate Preferences , 2014 .

[20]  S. Gangestad,et al.  Mate preferences and infectious disease: theoretical considerations and evidence in humans , 2011, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[21]  Han L. J. van der Maas,et al.  Science Perspectives on Psychological an Agenda for Purely Confirmatory Research on Behalf Of: Association for Psychological Science , 2022 .

[22]  A. Palmer,et al.  Detecting Publication Bias in Meta‐analyses: A Case Study of Fluctuating Asymmetry and Sexual Selection , 1999, The American Naturalist.

[23]  M. Haselton,et al.  Do women's mate preferences change across the ovulatory cycle? A meta-analytic review. , 2014, Psychological bulletin.

[24]  R. Thornhill,et al.  Human Fluctuating Asymmetry and Sexual Behavior , 1994 .

[25]  D. Mazmanian,et al.  Facial symmetry detection ability changes across the menstrual cycle , 2007, Biological Psychology.

[26]  D. Dunson,et al.  Likelihood of conception with a single act of intercourse: providing benchmark rates for assessment of post-coital contraceptives. , 2001, Contraception.

[27]  R. Thornhill,et al.  Menstrual cycle variation in women's preferences for the scent of symmetrical men , 1998, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[28]  D. Perrett,et al.  Shifts in Women’s Mate Preferences Across the Ovulatory Cycle: A Critique of Harris (2011) and Harris (2012) , 2013 .

[29]  J. Ioannidis Contradicted and Initially Stronger Effects in Highly Cited Clinical Research , 2005 .

[30]  C. Harris Menstrual Cycle and Facial Preferences Reconsidered , 2010, Sex roles.

[31]  C. Harris,et al.  Shifts in Methodology and Theory in Menstrual Cycle Research on Attraction , 2013 .

[32]  Stefan Van Dongen,et al.  Human fluctuating asymmetry in relation to health and quality: a meta-analysis , 2011 .

[33]  Goust Jm,et al.  Major histocompatibility complex. , 1990 .

[34]  G. Jasienska,et al.  Women's preferences for sexual dimorphism in height depend on menstrual cycle phase and expected duration of relationship , 2005, Biological Psychology.

[35]  R. Thornhill,et al.  Major histocompatibility complex genes, symmetry, and body scent attractiveness in men and women , 2003 .

[36]  A. Little,et al.  Preferences for masculinity in male bodies change across the menstrual cycle , 2007, Hormones and Behavior.

[37]  L. Harris,et al.  Do women's preferences for symmetry change across the menstrual cycle? , 2007 .