Artificial Intelligence for Automatic Pain Assessment: Research Methods and Perspectives

Although proper pain evaluation is mandatory for establishing the appropriate therapy, self-reported pain level assessment has several limitations. Data-driven artificial intelligence (AI) methods can be employed for research on automatic pain assessment (APA). The goal is the development of objective, standardized, and generalizable instruments useful for pain assessment in different clinical contexts. The purpose of this article is to discuss the state of the art of research and perspectives on APA applications in both research and clinical scenarios. Principles of AI functioning will be addressed. For narrative purposes, AI-based methods are grouped into behavioral-based approaches and neurophysiology-based pain detection methods. Since pain is generally accompanied by spontaneous facial behaviors, several approaches for APA are based on image classification and feature extraction. Language features through natural language strategies, body postures, and respiratory-derived elements are other investigated behavioral-based approaches. Neurophysiology-based pain detection is obtained through electroencephalography, electromyography, electrodermal activity, and other biosignals. Recent approaches involve multimode strategies by combining behaviors with neurophysiological findings. Concerning methods, early studies were conducted by machine learning algorithms such as support vector machine, decision tree, and random forest classifiers. More recently, artificial neural networks such as convolutional and recurrent neural network algorithms are implemented, even in combination. Collaboration programs involving clinicians and computer scientists must be aimed at structuring and processing robust datasets that can be used in various settings, from acute to different chronic pain conditions. Finally, it is crucial to apply the concepts of explainability and ethics when examining AI applications for pain research and management.

[1]  D. Berish,et al.  A Systematic Review of Barriers and Facilitators of Pain Management in Persons with Dementia. , 2023, The journal of pain.

[2]  G. Finco,et al.  Raising Awareness on the Clinical and Social Relevance of Adequate Chronic Pain Care , 2022, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[3]  C. Eccleston,et al.  Body movement as a biomarker for use in chronic pain rehabilitation: An embedded analysis of an RCT of a virtual reality solution for adults with chronic pain , 2022, Frontiers in Pain Research.

[4]  Catherine D. Chong,et al.  Longitudinal changes in functional connectivity and pain-induced brain activations in patients with migraine: a functional MRI study pre- and post- treatment with Erenumab , 2022, The journal of headache and pain.

[5]  A. Ultsch,et al.  Artificial intelligence and machine learning in pain research: a data scientometric analysis , 2022, Pain reports.

[6]  C. Compagnone,et al.  Understanding basic principles of artificial intelligence: a practical guide for intensivists , 2022, Acta bio-medica : Atenei Parmensis.

[7]  S. Kamarthi,et al.  Personalized Deep Bi-LSTM RNN Based Model for Pain Intensity Classification Using EDA Signal , 2022, Sensors.

[8]  A. Aleman,et al.  A behavioral and brain imaging dataset with focus on emotion regulation of women with fibromyalgia , 2022, Scientific Data.

[9]  M. Cascella,et al.  Different Machine Learning Approaches for Implementing Telehealth-Based Cancer Pain Management Strategies , 2022, Journal of clinical medicine.

[10]  F. Molinari,et al.  Application of explainable artificial intelligence for healthcare: A systematic review of the last decade (2011-2022) , 2022, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[11]  A. Ottaiano,et al.  Pathophysiology of Nociception and Rare Genetic Disorders with Increased Pain Threshold or Pain Insensitivity , 2022, Pathophysiology : the official journal of the International Society for Pathophysiology.

[12]  Stella Lo Giudice,et al.  Wrist Photoplethysmography Signal Quality Assessment for Reliable Heart Rate Estimate and Morphological Analysis , 2022, Sensors.

[13]  J. Shieh,et al.  Comparison of Deep Learning Algorithms in Predicting Expert Assessments of Pain Scores during Surgical Operations Using Analgesia Nociception Index , 2022, Italian National Conference on Sensors.

[14]  V. Denaro,et al.  Natural language processing in low back pain and spine diseases: A systematic review , 2022, Frontiers in Surgery.

[15]  L. Chiari,et al.  Quality Assessment and Morphological Analysis of Photoplethysmography in Daily Life , 2022, Frontiers in Digital Health.

[16]  L. Chiari,et al.  Automatic pain assessment on cancer patients using physiological signals recorded in real-world contexts , 2022, 2022 44th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC).

[17]  G. Alaghband,et al.  Facial Expressions Based Automatic Pain Assessment System , 2022, Applied Sciences.

[18]  Kadija Ferryman Rethinking the AI Chasm , 2022, American Journal of Bioethics.

[19]  P. Pelosi,et al.  Big Data and Artificial Intelligence in Intensive Care Unit: From “Bla, Bla, Bla” to the Incredible Five V’s , 2022, Neurocritical Care.

[20]  R. Thienprayoon,et al.  Managing Pain and Discomfort in Children with Cancer , 2022, Current Oncology Reports.

[21]  F. Marinangeli,et al.  Strengths and Weaknesses of Cancer Pain Management in Italy: Findings from a Nationwide SIAARTI Survey , 2022, Healthcare.

[22]  L. Chiari,et al.  Physiological responses to pain in cancer patients: A systematic review , 2022, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[23]  E. Topol,et al.  Bridging the chasm between AI and clinical implementation , 2022, The Lancet.

[24]  Federica Monaco,et al.  Bibliometric network analysis on rapid-onset opioids for breakthrough cancer pain treatment. , 2022, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[25]  Soon Huat Ng,et al.  Scalp EEG-Based Pain Detection Using Convolutional Neural Network , 2022, IEEE transactions on neural systems and rehabilitation engineering.

[26]  K. Heffner,et al.  Pain and the Alzheimer's Disease and Related Dementia Spectrum in Community-Dwelling Older Americans: A Nationally Representative Study. , 2022, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[27]  Stephen T. C. Wong,et al.  Affective Computing for Late-Life Mood and Cognitive Disorders , 2021, Frontiers in Psychiatry.

[28]  S. Velupillai,et al.  Development of a Lexicon for Pain , 2021, Frontiers in Digital Health.

[29]  K. Prkachin,et al.  Computer Mediated Automatic Detection of Pain-Related Behavior: Prospect, Progress, Perils , 2021, Frontiers in Pain Research.

[30]  Clayton Greenberg,et al.  Natural Language Processing: Practical Applications in Medicine and Investigation of Contextual Autocomplete. , 2021, Acta neurochirurgica. Supplement.

[31]  C. Soriano-Mas,et al.  The Role of the Locus Coeruleus in Pain and Associated Stress-Related Disorders , 2021, Biological Psychiatry.

[32]  G. Di Lorenzo,et al.  A Delphi Consensus Approach for the Management of Chronic Pain during and after the COVID-19 Era , 2021, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[33]  Emad Kasaeyan Naeini,et al.  Objective Pain Assessment Using Wrist-based PPG Signals: A Respiratory Rate Based Method , 2021, 2021 43rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC).

[34]  Robyn Clay-Williams,et al.  Implementing Ethics in Healthcare AI-Based Applications: A Scoping Review , 2021, Science and Engineering Ethics.

[35]  Youngsun Kong,et al.  A Preliminary Study on Automatic Motion Artifact Detection in Electrodermal Activity Data Using Machine Learning , 2021, 2021 43rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC).

[36]  John Kildea,et al.  Development of a generalizable natural language processing pipeline to extract physician-reported pain from clinical reports: Generated using publicly-available datasets and tested on institutional clinical reports for cancer patients with bone metastases , 2021, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[37]  S. Kamarthi,et al.  Exploration of physiological sensors, features, and machine learning models for pain intensity estimation , 2021, PloS one.

[38]  H. Cui,et al.  Low Back Pain Assessment Based on Alpha Oscillation Changes in Spontaneous Electroencephalogram (EEG) , 2021, Neural plasticity.

[39]  Yacine Mahdid,et al.  Clinical use of Electroencephalography in the Assessment of Acute Thermal Pain: A Narrative Review Based on Articles From 2009 to 2019 , 2021, Clinical EEG and neuroscience.

[40]  P. Indic,et al.  Using wearable technology to detect prescription opioid self-administration. , 2021, Pain.

[41]  F. Reis,et al.  Heart rate variability in patients with low back pain: a systematic review , 2021, Scandinavian journal of pain.

[42]  Alessandro Blasimme,et al.  Explainability for artificial intelligence in healthcare: a multidisciplinary perspective , 2020, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[43]  P. Sterkenburg,et al.  Physiological Measures of Acute and Chronic Pain within Different Subject Groups: A Systematic Review , 2020, Pain research & management.

[44]  Jeffrey Soar,et al.  Ensemble neural network approach detecting pain intensity from facial expressions , 2020, Artif. Intell. Medicine.

[45]  D. Borton,et al.  Pain phenotypes classified by machine learning using electroencephalography features , 2020, NeuroImage.

[46]  Linling Li,et al.  EEG Beta-Band Spectral Entropy Can Predict the Effect of Drug Treatment on Pain in Patients With Herpes Zoster , 2020, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[47]  S. Salanterä,et al.  Developing a pain intensity prediction model using facial expression: A feasibility study with electromyography , 2020, PloS one.

[48]  Ali Haddad,et al.  Recognizing Pain in Motor Imagery EEG Recordings Using Dynamic Functional Connectivity Graphs , 2020, 2020 42nd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC).

[49]  N. Dutt,et al.  Prospective Study Evaluating a Pain Assessment Tool in a Postoperative Environment: Protocol for Algorithm Testing and Enhancement , 2020, JMIR research protocols.

[50]  W. Hooten,et al.  Pain—Linguistics and Natural Language Processing , 2020, Mayo Clinic proceedings. Innovations, quality & outcomes.

[51]  H. Traue,et al.  [Multimodal recognition of pain intensity and pain modality with machine learning]. , 2020, Schmerz.

[52]  P. Werner,et al.  Multimodale Erkennung von Schmerzintensität und -modalität mit maschinellen Lernverfahren , 2020, Der Schmerz.

[53]  B. Waller,et al.  Measuring the evolution of facial ‘expression’ using multi-species FACS , 2020, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[54]  M. Maltoni,et al.  Careful Breakthrough Cancer Pain Treatment through Rapid-Onset Transmucosal Fentanyl Improves the Quality of Life in Cancer Patients: Results from the BEST Multicenter Study , 2020, Journal of clinical medicine.

[55]  D. Felson,et al.  Assessment of knee pain from MR imaging using a convolutional Siamese network , 2020, European Radiology.

[56]  Riccardo Miotto,et al.  Identifying Acute Low Back Pain Episodes in Primary Care Practice From Clinical Notes: Observational Study , 2020, JMIR medical informatics.

[57]  T. Cai,et al.  Incorporating natural language processing to improve classification of axial spondyloarthritis using electronic health records. , 2019, Rheumatology.

[58]  Carl Y. Saab,et al.  What does a pain ‘biomarker’ mean and can a machine be taught to measure pain? , 2019, Neuroscience Letters.

[59]  Katyani Singh,et al.  A Comprehensive Review of Convolutional Neural Network based Image Enhancement Techniques , 2019, 2019 IEEE International Conference on System, Computation, Automation and Networking (ICSCAN).

[60]  B Subbulakshmi,et al.  Sentimental Analysis using Naive Bayes Classifier , 2019, 2019 International Conference on Vision Towards Emerging Trends in Communication and Networking (ViTECoN).

[61]  P. Henningsen,et al.  Your Robot Therapist Will See You Now: Ethical Implications of Embodied Artificial Intelligence in Psychiatry, Psychology, and Psychotherapy , 2018, Journal of medical Internet research.

[62]  Yongsheng Ding,et al.  A new image classification model based on brain parallel interaction mechanism , 2018, Neurocomputing.

[63]  M. Cascella,et al.  Chemotherapy-related cognitive impairment: mechanisms, clinical features and research perspectives. , 2018, Recenti progressi in medicina.

[64]  Miriam Kunz,et al.  Facial muscle movements encoding pain—a systematic review , 2018, Pain.

[65]  Rachel McKee The Challenge of Cancer Pain Assessment , 2018, The Ulster medical journal.

[66]  M. Cascella,et al.  The challenge of pain assessment in children with cognitive disabilities: Features and clinical applicability of different observational tools , 2018, Journal of paediatrics and child health.

[67]  G. Deplanque,et al.  Electrochemical Skin Conductance as a Marker of Painful Oxaliplatin-Induced Peripheral Neuropathy , 2018, Neurology research international.

[68]  Aleksandra Vuckovic,et al.  Prediction of central neuropathic pain in spinal cord injury based on EEG classifier , 2018, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[69]  Matthew S. Goodwin,et al.  Automated Pain Assessment using Electrodermal Activity Data and Machine Learning , 2018, 2018 40th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC).

[70]  R. Boostani,et al.  A Novel Classification Strategy to Distinguish Five Levels of Pain Using the EEG Signal Features , 2018, IEEE Transactions on Affective Computing.

[71]  J. Brant,et al.  Complex Cancer Pain Assessment. , 2018, Hematology/oncology clinics of North America.

[72]  R. Froutan,et al.  Challenges faced by nurses in using pain assessment scale in patients unable to communicate: a qualitative study , 2018, BMC Nursing.

[73]  Charles Nduka,et al.  Objectively measuring pain using facial expression: is the technology finally ready? , 2018, Pain management.

[74]  H. Traue,et al.  Head movements and postures as pain behavior , 2018, PloS one.

[75]  J. Miró,et al.  The validity of pain intensity measures: what do the NRS, VAS, VRS, and FPS-R measure? , 2018, Scandinavian journal of pain.

[76]  Bin He,et al.  Quantifying and Characterizing Tonic Thermal Pain Across Subjects From EEG Data Using Random Forest Models , 2017, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[77]  Patrick Thiam,et al.  Multi-modal data fusion for pain intensity assessment and classification , 2017, 2017 Seventh International Conference on Image Processing Theory, Tools and Applications (IPTA).

[78]  Omkar M. Parkhi,et al.  VGGFace2: A Dataset for Recognising Faces across Pose and Age , 2017, 2018 13th IEEE International Conference on Automatic Face & Gesture Recognition (FG 2018).

[79]  Kamal Nasrollahi,et al.  Deep Pain: Exploiting Long Short-Term Memory Networks for Facial Expression Classification , 2017, IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics.

[80]  Arnab Roy,et al.  Automated classification of pain perception using high-density electroencephalography data. , 2017, Journal of neurophysiology.

[81]  J. Gross,et al.  Brain Rhythms of Pain , 2017, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[82]  Thomas B. Moeslund,et al.  Spatio-temporal Pain Recognition in CNN-Based Super-Resolved Facial Images , 2016, VAAM/FFER@ICPR.

[83]  Maja Pantic,et al.  The Automatic Detection of Chronic Pain-Related Expression: Requirements, Challenges and the Multimodal EmoPain Dataset , 2016, IEEE Transactions on Affective Computing.

[84]  R. Fillingim,et al.  Assessment of Chronic Pain: Domains, Methods, and Mechanisms. , 2016, The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society.

[85]  M. Kunz,et al.  Does Parkinson's disease lead to alterations in the facial expression of pain? , 2015, Journal of the Neurological Sciences.

[86]  H. Traue,et al.  Pain Intensity Recognition Rates via Biopotential Feature Patterns with Support Vector Machines , 2015, PloS one.

[87]  C. Chambers,et al.  Ontogeny and phylogeny of facial expression of pain , 2015, Pain.

[88]  Randy L. Gollub,et al.  Simultaneous fMRI–PET of the opioidergic pain system in human brain , 2014, NeuroImage.

[89]  Edmund Keogh,et al.  Pain communication through body posture: The development and validation of a stimulus set , 2014, PAIN®.

[90]  D. Yarnitsky,et al.  Associations between autonomic dysfunction and pain in chemotherapy‐induced polyneuropathy , 2014, European journal of pain.

[91]  Shaun J. Canavan,et al.  BP4D-Spontaneous: a high-resolution spontaneous 3D dynamic facial expression database , 2014, Image Vis. Comput..

[92]  G. Boyle,et al.  Descriptors of pain sensation: a dual hierarchical model of latent structure. , 2012, The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society.

[93]  Jeffrey F. Cohn,et al.  Painful data: The UNBC-McMaster shoulder pain expression archive database , 2011, Face and Gesture 2011.

[94]  William R. Hogan,et al.  Natural Language Processing methods and systems for biomedical ontology learning , 2011, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[95]  Alon Sinai,et al.  Pain assessment by continuous EEG: Association between subjective perception of tonic pain and peak frequency of alpha oscillations during stimulation and at rest , 2010, Brain Research.

[96]  B. Appelhans,et al.  Heart Rate Variability as an Index of Regulated Emotional Responding , 2006 .

[97]  M. Cascella,et al.  Implementation of a Hybrid Care Model for Telemedicine-based Cancer Pain Management at the Cancer Center of Naples, Italy: A Cohort Study , 2023, In Vivo.

[98]  K. Budidha,et al.  Photoplethysmography technology , 2022, Photoplethysmography.

[99]  Shing Chiang Tan,et al.  A Novel Approach to Objectively Quantify the Subjective Perception of Pain Through Electroencephalogram Signal Analysis , 2020, IEEE Access.

[100]  Rangachar Kasturi,et al.  A Review of Automated Pain Assessment in Infants: Features, Classification Tasks, and Databases , 2018, IEEE Reviews in Biomedical Engineering.

[101]  Ayoub Al-Hamadi,et al.  Towards Pain Monitoring: Facial Expression, Head Pose, a new Database, an Automatic System and Remaining , 2013, BMVC.