Monitoring Approaches for Faecal Indicator Bacteria in Water: Visioning a Remote Real-Time Sensor for E. coli and Enterococci

A comprehensive review was conducted to assess the current state of monitoring approaches for primary faecal indicator bacteria (FIB) E. coli and enterococci. Approaches were identified and examined in relation to their accuracy, ability to provide continuous data and instantaneous detection results, cost, environmental awareness regarding necessary reagent release or other pollution sources, in situ monitoring capability, and portability. Findings showed that several methods are precise and sophisticated but cannot be performed in real-time or remotely. This is mainly due to their laboratory testing requirements, such as lengthy sample preparations, the requirement for expensive reagents, and fluorescent tags. This study determined that portable fluorescence sensing, combined with advanced modelling methods to compensate readings for environmental interferences and false positives, can lay the foundations for a hybrid FIB sensing approach, allowing remote field deployment of a fleet of networked FIB sensors that can collect high-frequency data in near real-time. Such sensors will support proactive responses to sudden harmful faecal contamination events. A method is proposed to enable the development of the visioned FIB monitoring tool.

[1]  D. Cozzolino,et al.  A review of methods for the detection of pathogenic microorganisms. , 2019, The Analyst.

[2]  Ingun Tryland,et al.  Monitoring of β-d-Galactosidase Activity as a Surrogate Parameter for Rapid Detection of Sewage Contamination in Urban Recreational Water , 2016 .

[3]  S. Guérin-Rechdaoui,et al.  Autonomous system for rapid field quantification of Escherichia coli in surface waters , 2018, Journal of applied microbiology.

[4]  Yu Hen Hu,et al.  A temperature compensation method for CDOM fluorescence sensors in freshwater , 2011 .

[5]  B. Pejcic,et al.  Recent progress in sensing nitrate, nitrite, phosphate, and ammonium in aquatic environment , 2020 .

[6]  K. Garcia,et al.  Applicability of Fluorescence and Absorbance Spectroscopy to Estimate Organic Pollution in Rivers , 2014 .

[7]  D. Hartl,et al.  Genetic applications of an inverse polymerase chain reaction. , 1988, Genetics.

[8]  M. Sterling,et al.  Fluorescence spectroscopy as a tool for determining microbial quality in potable water applications , 2012, Environmental technology.

[9]  S. Aguirre,et al.  Fluorogenic DNAzyme probes as bacterial indicators. , 2011, Angewandte Chemie.

[10]  Joan B. Rose,et al.  Microbial Source Tracking: Current Methodology and Future Directions , 2002, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[11]  Sai Wang,et al.  State of the art: Lateral flow assay (LFA) biosensor for on-site rapid detection , 2017, Chinese Chemical Letters.

[12]  Andrew D. Ellington,et al.  Portable platform for rapid in-field identification of human fecal pollution in water. , 2018, Water research.

[13]  R. Whitman,et al.  Monitoring E. coli in a changing beachscape. , 2018, The Science of the total environment.

[14]  S. Weisberg,et al.  A review of technologies for rapid detection of bacteria in recreational waters. , 2005, Journal of water and health.

[15]  Denise Wilson,et al.  Portable Fluorescence Lifetime Detection for Chlorophyll Analysis in Marine Environments , 2011, IEEE Sensors Journal.

[16]  B. Mizaikoff,et al.  Emerging biosensor platforms for the assessment of water-borne pathogens. , 2018, The Analyst.

[17]  R. A. Deininger,et al.  Detection of E. coli in beach water within 1 hour using immunomagnetic separation and ATP bioluminescence. , 2004, Luminescence : the journal of biological and chemical luminescence.

[18]  A. Hartmann,et al.  Rapid amperometric detection of Escherichia coli in wastewater by measuring β-D glucuronidase activity with disposable carbon sensors. , 2015, Analytica chimica acta.

[19]  A. Baker,et al.  Fluorescence spectroscopy for wastewater monitoring: A review. , 2016, Water research.

[20]  D. Moher,et al.  Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[21]  C. Poole,et al.  Exposure to Human-Associated Chemical Markers of Fecal Contamination and Self-Reported Illness among Swimmers at Recreational Beaches. , 2018, Environmental science & technology.

[22]  E. Bertone,et al.  Understanding and Modeling the Occurrence of E. coli Blooms in Drinking Water Reservoirs , 2019, Water Resources Research.

[23]  David Hannah,et al.  Real-time monitoring of nutrients and dissolved organic matter in rivers: Capturing event dynamics, technological opportunities and future directions. , 2016, The Science of the total environment.

[24]  M. Abbaszadegan,et al.  A Strategy to Establish a Quality Assurance/Quality Control Plan for the Application of Biosensors for the Detection of E. coli in Water , 2017, Biosensors.

[25]  R. Burne,et al.  Fluorescence Tools Adapted for Real-Time Monitoring of the Behaviors of Streptococcus Species , 2019, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[26]  Xiaofeng Wang,et al.  DOM removal by flocculation process: Fluorescence excitation–emission matrix spectroscopy (EEMs) characterization , 2014 .

[27]  D. Mccarthy,et al.  Evaluation of Techniques for Measuring Microbial Hazards in Bathing Waters: A Comparative Study , 2016, PloS one.

[28]  Lauren M. Sassoubre,et al.  Solar Inactivation of Enterococci and Escherichia coli in Natural Waters: Effects of Water Absorbance and Depth. , 2016, Environmental science & technology.

[29]  Kyoungsik Kim,et al.  Development of Rapid Assessment Method to Determine Bacterial Viability Based on Ultraviolet and Visible (UV-Vis) Spectroscopy Analysis Including Application to Bioaerosols , 2012 .

[30]  Sandeep Kumar,et al.  Point-of-Care Strategies for Detection of Waterborne Pathogens , 2019, Sensors.

[31]  Samendra Ps,et al.  Rapid Detection Technologies for Monitoring Microorganisms in Water , 2014 .

[32]  L. Bonacina,et al.  Real-time monitoring of bacterial and organic pollution in a water stream by fluorescence depletion spectroscopy , 2017, Applied Physics B.

[33]  K. Helmi,et al.  Methods for microbiological quality assessment in drinking water: a comparative study. , 2015, Journal of water and health.

[34]  Dijana Stojanović,et al.  Understanding sensitivity, specificity and predictive values. , 2014, Vojnosanitetski pregled.

[35]  Jesus Rodriguez-Manzano,et al.  Molecular detection of pathogens in water--the pros and cons of molecular techniques. , 2010, Water research.

[36]  Benjamin R. Watts,et al.  A photonic‐microfluidic integrated device for reliable fluorescence detection and counting , 2012, Electrophoresis.

[37]  Noel E. O'Connor,et al.  ColiSense, today's sample today: A rapid on-site detection of β-D-Glucuronidase activity in surface water as a surrogate for E. coli. , 2016, Talanta.

[38]  M. Bieroza,et al.  Continuous fluorescence excitation-emission matrix monitoring of river organic matter. , 2010, Water research.

[39]  Marta Valledor Llopis,et al.  A Novel Handheld Fluorimeter for Rapid Detection of Escherichia coli in Drinking Water , 2016 .

[40]  P. Kaushik,et al.  Prevalence of E. coli O157:H7 in water sources: an overview on associated diseases, outbreaks and detection methods. , 2015, Diagnostic microbiology and infectious disease.

[41]  A. Zimmer-Faust,et al.  Performance and Specificity of the Covalently Linked Immunomagnetic Separation-ATP Method for Rapid Detection and Enumeration of Enterococci in Coastal Environments , 2014, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[42]  Brett I. Pletschke,et al.  Suitability of total coliform β-D-galactosidase activity and CFU counts in monitoring faecal contamination of environmental water samples , 2012 .

[43]  A. Broomer,et al.  Rapid Detection, Identification, and Enumeration ofEscherichia coli Cells in Municipal Water by Chemiluminescent In Situ Hybridization , 2001, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[44]  B. Lindsey,et al.  Holding-time and method comparisons for the analysis of fecal-indicator bacteria in groundwater , 2015, Environmental Monitoring & Assessment.

[45]  J. E. Peters,et al.  Reporter bacteriophage T7NLC utilizes a novel NanoLuc::CBM fusion for the ultrasensitive detection of Escherichia coli in water. , 2018, The Analyst.

[46]  J. Lead,et al.  Effects of filtration and pH perturbation on freshwater organic matter fluorescence. , 2007, Chemosphere.

[47]  A. MacDonald,et al.  Real-time detection of faecally contaminated drinking water with tryptophan-like fluorescence: defining threshold values. , 2018, The Science of the total environment.

[48]  J. Baudart,et al.  Rapid detection of Escherichia coli in waters using fluorescent in situ hybridization, direct viable counting and solid phase cytometry , 2010, Journal of applied microbiology.

[49]  Jong-In Han,et al.  Fast detection and quantification of Escherichia coli using the base principle of the microbial fuel cell. , 2013, Journal of environmental management.

[50]  M. Abbaszadegan,et al.  A biosensor platform for rapid detection of E. coli in drinking water. , 2016, Enzyme and microbial technology.

[51]  M. Forouzandeh,et al.  Designing a new biosensor “DNA ELISA” to detect Escherichia coli using genomic DNA and comparison of this method to PCR-ELISA , 2018, Journal of enzyme inhibition and medicinal chemistry.

[52]  B. Durand,et al.  Spatiotemporal prediction of Escherichia coli and Enterococci for the Commonwealth Games triathlon event using Bayesian Networks. , 2019, Marine pollution bulletin.

[53]  W. Lau,et al.  Detection of contaminants in water supply: A review on state-of-the-art monitoring technologies and their applications , 2017, Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical.

[54]  C. Keevil,et al.  Detection of Escherichia coli in Biofilms from Pipe Samples and Coupons in Drinking Water Distribution Networks , 2007, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[55]  D. Wildeboer,et al.  Rapid detection of Escherichia coli in water using a hand-held fluorescence detector. , 2010, Water research.

[56]  Timothy Bartrand,et al.  Estimated human health risks from exposure to recreational waters impacted by human and non-human sources of faecal contamination. , 2010, Water research.

[57]  P. Servais,et al.  Rapid enumeration of Escherichia coli in marine bathing waters: potential interference of nontarget bacteria , 2009, Journal of applied microbiology.

[58]  A. Docoslis,et al.  Fast and sensitive detection of bacteria from a water droplet by means of electric field effects and micro-Raman spectroscopy , 2015 .

[59]  F. Vagliasindi,et al.  Use of fluorescence EEM to monitor the removal of emerging contaminants in full scale wastewater treatment plants. , 2017, Journal of hazardous materials.

[60]  J. Ridal,et al.  A new, automated rapid fluorometric method for the detection of Escherichia coli in recreational waters , 2015 .

[61]  Rachel L. Parks,et al.  A highly specific Escherichia coli qPCR and its comparison with existing methods for environmental waters. , 2017, Water research.

[62]  K. Murphy,et al.  Assessment of drinking water quality at the tap using fluorescence spectroscopy. , 2017, Water research.

[63]  Asja Korajkic,et al.  Microbial source tracking markers for detection of fecal contamination in environmental waters: relationships between pathogens and human health outcomes. , 2014, FEMS microbiology reviews.

[64]  Benjamin R. Watts,et al.  Counting of Escherichia coli by a microflow cytometer based on a photonic–microfluidic integrated device , 2015, Electrophoresis.

[65]  Akbar S. Khan Rapid Advances in Nucleic Acid Technologies for Detection and Diagnostics of Pathogens , 2014 .

[66]  L. Krilov,et al.  Escherichia coli Infections. , 2015, Pediatrics in review.

[67]  Mohd Zainizan Sahdan,et al.  The Detection Method of Escherichia coli in Water Resources: A Review , 2018 .

[68]  B. Marchant,et al.  In-situ tryptophan-like fluorescence: A real-time indicator of faecal contamination in drinking water supplies. , 2015, Water research.

[69]  D. Read,et al.  Online fluorescence spectroscopy for the real-time evaluation of the microbial quality of drinking water. , 2018, Water research.

[70]  Junhong Chen,et al.  Rapid detection of single E. coli bacteria using a graphene-based field-effect transistor device. , 2018, Biosensors & bioelectronics.

[71]  A. van Amerongen,et al.  Nucleic Acid Lateral Flow Immunoassay for the Detection of Pathogenic Bacteria from Food , 2018 .

[72]  N. Gunda,et al.  DipTest: A litmus test for E. coli detection in water , 2017, PloS one.

[73]  Shuai Chen,et al.  Inner filter effect-based fluorescent sensing systems: A review. , 2018, Analytica chimica acta.

[74]  J. Homola Surface plasmon resonance sensors for detection of chemical and biological species. , 2008, Chemical reviews.

[75]  Soumyo Mukherji,et al.  Evanescent wave absorbance based fiber optic biosensor for label-free detection of E. coli at 280 nm wavelength. , 2011, Biosensors & bioelectronics.

[76]  F. Regan,et al.  Protocol for the recovery and detection of Escherichia coli in environmental water samples. , 2017, Analytica chimica acta.

[77]  Seung-ju Lee,et al.  Community-Acquired Urinary Tract Infection by Escherichia coli in the Era of Antibiotic Resistance , 2018, BioMed research international.

[78]  Dan A Buzatu,et al.  Development of a Flow Cytometry-Based Method for Rapid Detection of Escherichia coli and Shigella Spp. Using an Oligonucleotide Probe , 2016, PloS one.

[79]  H. Unno,et al.  Rapid Detection of Escherichia coli O157:H7 by Using Green Fluorescent Protein-Labeled PP01 Bacteriophage , 2004, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[80]  L. Durso,et al.  Culture-based Methods for Detection of Antibiotic Resistance in Agroecosystems: Advantages, Challenges, and Gaps in Knowledge. , 2016, Journal of environmental quality.

[81]  Tu San Park,et al.  Smartphone Detection of Escherichia coli From Field Water Samples on Paper Microfluidics , 2015, IEEE Sensors Journal.

[82]  R. Stuetz,et al.  Fluorescence as a potential monitoring tool for recycled water systems: a review. , 2009, Water research.

[83]  Dorothy L. Espelage,et al.  Best practice guidelines for abstract screening large‐evidence systematic reviews and meta‐analyses , 2019, Research Synthesis Methods.

[84]  A. Baker,et al.  In situ fluorescence measurements of dissolved organic matter: A review. , 2020, The Science of the total environment.

[85]  I. Gupta,et al.  Real-Time Quantitative PCR Measurements of Fecal Indicator Bacteria and Human-Associated Source Tracking Markers in a Texas River following Hurricane Harvey , 2018 .

[86]  Michèle Prévost,et al.  Autonomous online measurement of β-D-glucuronidase activity in surface water: is it suitable for rapid E. coli monitoring? , 2019, Water research.

[87]  D. Hannah,et al.  Understanding dissolved organic matter dynamics in urban catchments: insights from in situ fluorescence sensor technology , 2018 .

[88]  V. Harwood,et al.  Enterococci in the Environment , 2012, Microbiology and Molecular Reviews.

[89]  B. Pletschke,et al.  Comparison of the direct enzyme assay method with the membrane filtration technique in the quantification and monitoring of microbial indicator organisms - seasonal variations in the activities of coliforms and E.coli, temperature and pH , 2009 .

[90]  F. Regan,et al.  Continuous fluorometric method for measuring β-glucuronidase activity: comparative analysis of three fluorogenic substrates. , 2015, The Analyst.

[91]  Geertruida A. Posthuma-Trumpie,et al.  Lateral flow (immuno)assay: its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. A literature survey , 2009, Analytical and bioanalytical chemistry.

[92]  Shimshon Belkin,et al.  Are luminescent bacteria suitable for online detection and monitoring of toxic compounds in drinking water and its sources? , 2010, Analytical and bioanalytical chemistry.

[93]  D. Hannah,et al.  Continuous field estimation of dissolved organic carbon concentration and biochemical oxygen demand using dual‐wavelength fluorescence, turbidity and temperature , 2017 .

[94]  R M Atlas,et al.  Detection of coliform bacteria in water by polymerase chain reaction and gene probes , 1990, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[95]  Jean Pierre Nshimyimana,et al.  Next-generation sequencing (NGS) for assessment of microbial water quality: current progress, challenges, and future opportunities , 2015, Front. Microbiol..

[96]  R. Stewart,et al.  Multi-Parameter Compensation Method for Accurate In Situ Fluorescent Dissolved Organic Matter Monitoring and Properties Characterization , 2018, Water.

[97]  Tao Dong,et al.  Continuous and Real-Time Detection of Drinking-Water Pathogens with a Low-Cost Fluorescent Optofluidic Sensor , 2018, Sensors.

[98]  David P. Hamilton,et al.  Fluorescence probes for real-time remote cyanobacteria monitoring: A review of challenges and opportunities. , 2018, Water research.

[99]  Eberhard Schlücker,et al.  Characterization of Escherichia coli suspensions using UV/Vis/NIR absorption spectroscopy , 2010 .

[100]  A. Baker,et al.  Portable LED fluorescence instrumentation for the rapid assessment of potable water quality. , 2015, The Science of the total environment.

[101]  D. Hannah,et al.  In situ tryptophan-like fluorometers: assessing turbidity and temperature effects for freshwater applications. , 2015, Environmental science. Processes & impacts.

[102]  F. Schmid,et al.  Biological Macromolecules: UV‐visible Spectrophotometry , 2001 .

[103]  L. Domingues,et al.  On the track for an efficient detection of Escherichia coli in water: A review on PCR-based methods. , 2015, Ecotoxicology and environmental safety.

[104]  C. Buckley,et al.  To what extent can portable fluorescence spectroscopy be used in the real-time assessment of microbial water quality? , 2015, The Science of the total environment.

[105]  U. Obst,et al.  Application of the fluorogenic probe technique (TaqMan PCR) to the detection of Enterococcus spp. and Escherichia coli in water samples. , 2003, Journal of microbiological methods.

[106]  P. Servais,et al.  An operational method for the real-time monitoring of E. coli numbers in bathing waters. , 2005, Marine pollution bulletin.

[107]  R. Dickson,et al.  All-optical fluorescence image recovery using modulated Stimulated Emission Depletion. , 2011, Chemical science.