A Systematic Review for Enabling of Develop a Blockchain Technology in Healthcare Application: Taxonomy, Substantially Analysis, Motivations, Challenges, Recommendations and Future Direction

Blockchain in healthcare applications requires robust security and privacy mechanism for high-level authentication, interoperability and medical records sharing to comply with the strict legal requirements of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996. Blockchain technology in the healthcare industry has received considerable research attention in recent years. This study conducts a review to substantially analyse and map the research landscape of current technologies, mainly the use of blockchain in healthcare applications, into a coherent taxonomy. The present study systematically searches all relevant research articles on blockchain in healthcare applications in three accessible databases, namely, ScienceDirect, IEEE and Web of Science, by using the defined keywords ‘blockchain’, ‘healthcare’ and ‘electronic health records’ and their variations. The final set of collected articles related to the use of blockchain in healthcare application is divided into three categories. The first category includes articles (i.e. 43/58 scientific articles) that attempted to develop and design healthcare applications integrating blockchain, particularly those on new architecture, system designs, framework, scheme, model, platform, approach, protocol and algorithm. The second category includes studies (i.e., 6/58 scientific articles) that attempted to evaluate and analyse the adoption of blockchain in the healthcare system. Finally, the third category comprises review and survey articles (i.e., 6/58 scientific articles) related to the integration of blockchain into healthcare applications. The final articles for review are discussed on the basis of five aspects: (1) year of publication, (2) nationality of authors, (3) publishing house or journal, (4) purpose of using blockchain in health applications and the corresponding contributions and (5) problem types and proposed solutions. Additionally, this study provides identified motivations, open challenges and recommendations on the use of blockchain in healthcare applications. The current research contributes to the literature by providing a detailed review of feasible alternatives and identifying the research gaps. Accordingly, researchers and developers are provided with appealing opportunities to further develop decentralised healthcare applications through a comprehensive discussion of about the importance of blockchain and its integration into various healthcare applications.

[1]  Daniel Davis Wood,et al.  ETHEREUM: A SECURE DECENTRALISED GENERALISED TRANSACTION LEDGER , 2014 .

[2]  Satoshi Nakamoto.  Bitcoin : A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System , 2009 .

[3]  Hamid A. Jalab,et al.  Securing electronic medical records transmissions over unsecured communications: An overview for better medical governance , 2010 .

[4]  Praneeth Babu Marella,et al.  Ancile: Privacy-Preserving Framework for Access Control and Interoperability of Electronic Health Records Using Blockchain Technology , 2018 .

[5]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Design and Develop a Video Conferencing Framework for Real-Time Telemedicine Applications Using Secure Group-Based Communication Architecture , 2014, Journal of Medical Systems.

[6]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Challenges, Alternatives, and Paths to Sustainability: Better Public Health Promotion Using Social Networking Pages as Key Tools , 2015, Journal of Medical Systems.

[7]  M. Veronez,et al.  Spatial analyzes of HLA data in Rio Grande do Sul, south Brazil: genetic structure and possible correlation with autoimmune diseases , 2018, International Journal of Health Geographics.

[8]  Amelia Ritahani Ismail,et al.  A Review of Data Analysis for Early-Childhood Period: Taxonomy, Motivations, Challenges, Recommendation, and Methodological Aspects , 2019, IEEE Access.

[9]  Rui Guo,et al.  Secure Attribute-Based Signature Scheme With Multiple Authorities for Blockchain in Electronic Health Records Systems , 2018, IEEE Access.

[10]  Mohammad S. Obaidat,et al.  BHEEM: A Blockchain-Based Framework for Securing Electronic Health Records , 2018, 2018 IEEE Globecom Workshops (GC Wkshps).

[11]  U. Krieger,et al.  Advanced block-chain architecture for e-health systems , 2017, 2017 IEEE 19th International Conference on e-Health Networking, Applications and Services (Healthcom).

[12]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  An Enhanced Security Solution for Electronic Medical Records Based on AES Hybrid Technique with SOAP/XML and SHA-1 , 2013, Journal of Medical Systems.

[13]  Lin Chen,et al.  CoC: A Unified Distributed Ledger Based Supply Chain Management System , 2018, Journal of Computer Science and Technology.

[14]  Isabel de la Torre Díez,et al.  Proposing New Blockchain Challenges in eHealth , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[15]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Real-Time Remote Health Monitoring Systems Using Body Sensor Information and Finger Vein Biometric Verification: A Multi-Layer Systematic Review , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[16]  Miss Laiha Mat Kiah.  Impact of data privacy and confidentiality on developing telemedicine applications: A review participates opinion and expert concerns , 2011 .

[18]  Bian Yang,et al.  A Blockchain-based Approach to the Secure Sharing of Healthcare Data , 2017 .

[19]  Sheng Liu,et al.  Blockchain-Based Data Preservation System for Medical Data , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[20]  Antonio Puliafito,et al.  Blockchain and IoT Integration: A Systematic Survey , 2018, Sensors.

[21]  Vasilis Katos,et al.  Blockchain-based Electronic Patient Records for Regulated Circular Healthcare Jurisdictions , 2018, 2018 IEEE 23rd International Workshop on Computer Aided Modeling and Design of Communication Links and Networks (CAMAD).

[22]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Open source EMR software: Profiling, insights and hands-on analysis , 2014, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[23]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Multi-criteria analysis for OS-EMR software selection problem: A comparative study , 2015, Decis. Support Syst..

[24]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Electronic medical record systems: decision support examination framework for individual, security and privacy concerns using multi-perspective analysis , 2018, Health and Technology.

[25]  Christian Catalini,et al.  Blockchain Technology for Healthcare: Facilitating the Transition to Patient-Driven Interoperability , 2018, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[26]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Meeting the Security Requirements of Electronic Medical Records in the ERA of High-Speed Computing , 2014, Journal of Medical Systems.

[27]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  A survey on communication components for IoT-based technologies in smart homes , 2018, Telecommunication Systems.

[28]  Brad Chase,et al.  Analysis of the XRP Ledger Consensus Protocol , 2018, ArXiv.

[29]  Marko Hölbl,et al.  A Systematic Review of the Use of Blockchain in Healthcare , 2018, Symmetry.

[30]  Hui Zhang,et al.  System architecture for high-performance permissioned blockchains , 2019, Frontiers of Computer Science.

[31]  Hao Wang,et al.  Secure Cloud-Based EHR System Using Attribute-Based Cryptosystem and Blockchain , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[32]  Davor Svetinovic,et al.  Blockchain AI Framework for Healthcare Records Management: Constrained Goal Model , 2018, 2018 26th Telecommunications Forum (TELFOR).

[33]  Peng Jiang,et al.  A Survey on the Security of Blockchain Systems , 2017, Future Gener. Comput. Syst..

[34]  K. I. Mohammed,et al.  Based Multiple Heterogeneous Wearable Sensors: A Smart Real-Time Health Monitoring Structured for Hospitals Distributor , 2019, IEEE Access.

[35]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Blockchain authentication of network applications: Taxonomy, classification, capabilities, open challenges, motivations, recommendations and future directions , 2019, Comput. Stand. Interfaces.

[36]  Aisha Zahid Junejo,et al.  Applications of Blockchain Technology in Medicine and Healthcare: Challenges and Future Perspectives , 2019, Cryptogr..

[37]  Mohsen Guizani,et al.  MeDShare: Trust-Less Medical Data Sharing Among Cloud Service Providers via Blockchain , 2017, IEEE Access.

[38]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Real-Time Remote-Health Monitoring Systems: a Review on Patients Prioritisation for Multiple-Chronic Diseases, Taxonomy Analysis, Concerns and Solution Procedure , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[39]  Xiao Wang,et al.  Blockchain-Powered Parallel Healthcare Systems Based on the ACP Approach , 2018, IEEE Transactions on Computational Social Systems.

[40]  Wei Jiang,et al.  Healthcare Data Gateways: Found Healthcare Intelligence on Blockchain with Novel Privacy Risk Control , 2016, Journal of Medical Systems.

[41]  Navin Ramachandran,et al.  Authenticating Health Activity Data Using Distributed Ledger Technologies , 2018, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[42]  Mohsen Guizani,et al.  BPDS: A Blockchain Based Privacy-Preserving Data Sharing for Electronic Medical Records , 2018, 2018 IEEE Global Communications Conference (GLOBECOM).

[43]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  A review of the automated detection and classification of acute leukaemia: Coherent taxonomy, datasets, validation and performance measurements, motivation, open challenges and recommendations , 2018, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[44]  A. A. Zaidan,et al.  A review on intelligent process for smart home applications based on IoT: coherent taxonomy, motivation, open challenges, and recommendations , 2018, Artificial Intelligence Review.

[45]  Cristiano André da Costa,et al.  OmniPHR: A distributed architecture model to integrate personal health records , 2017, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[46]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Multiclass Benchmarking Framework for Automated Acute Leukaemia Detection and Classification Based on BWM and Group-VIKOR , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[47]  Yun Peng,et al.  Efficient key management scheme for health blockchain , 2018, CAAI Trans. Intell. Technol..

[48]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Based on Real Time Remote Health Monitoring Systems: A New Approach for Prioritization “Large Scales Data” Patients with Chronic Heart Diseases Using Body Sensors and Communication Technology , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[49]  Douglas C. Schmidt,et al.  Metrics for assessing blockchain-based healthcare decentralized apps , 2017, 2017 IEEE 19th International Conference on e-Health Networking, Applications and Services (Healthcom).

[50]  Md. Zakirul Alam Bhuiyan,et al.  Privacy-friendly platform for healthcare data in cloud based on blockchain environment , 2019, Future Gener. Comput. Syst..

[51]  Douglas C. Schmidt,et al.  Analyzing the performance of a blockchain-based personal health record implementation , 2019, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[52]  Olivia Choudhury,et al.  A Blockchain Framework for Managing and Monitoring Data in Multi-Site Clinical Trials , 2019, ArXiv.

[53]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Based Medical Systems for Patient’s Authentication: Towards a New Verification Secure Framework Using CIA Standard , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[54]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  A Security Framework for Nationwide Health Information Exchange based on Telehealth Strategy , 2015, Journal of Medical Systems.

[55]  Daisuke Ichikawa,et al.  Tamper-Resistant Mobile Health Using Blockchain Technology , 2017, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[56]  José Luis Fernández Alemán,et al.  Security and privacy in electronic health records: A systematic literature review , 2013, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[57]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Real-Time Fault-Tolerant mHealth System: Comprehensive Review of Healthcare Services, Opens Issues, Challenges and Methodological Aspects , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[58]  Miss Laiha Mat Kiah,et al.  Comprehensive review and analysis of anti-malware apps for smartphones , 2019, Telecommunication Systems.

[59]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Conceptual framework for the security of mobile health applications on Android platform , 2018, Telematics Informatics.

[60]  Gang Chen,et al.  Untangling Blockchain: A Data Processing View of Blockchain Systems , 2017, IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering.

[61]  Viacheslav Zhygulin,et al.  Decentralized e-Health Architecture for Boosting Healthcare Analytics , 2018, 2018 Second World Conference on Smart Trends in Systems, Security and Sustainability (WorldS4).

[62]  Sangsuree Vasupongayya,et al.  Blockchain Based Secret-Data Sharing Model for Personal Health Record System , 2018, 2018 5th International Conference on Advanced Informatics: Concept Theory and Applications (ICAICTA).

[63]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Systematic Review of an Automated Multiclass Detection and Classification System for Acute Leukaemia in Terms of Evaluation and Benchmarking, Open Challenges, Issues and Methodological Aspects , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[64]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Sensor-Based mHealth Authentication for Real-Time Remote Healthcare Monitoring System: A Multilayer Systematic Review , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[65]  Sergey P. Novikov,et al.  Blockchain and Smart Contracts in a Decentralized Health Infrastructure , 2018, 2018 IEEE International Conference "Quality Management, Transport and Information Security, Information Technologies" (IT&QM&IS).

[66]  Nor Badrul Anuar,et al.  The landscape of research on smartphone medical apps: Coherent taxonomy, motivations, open challenges and recommendations , 2015, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[67]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Evaluation and selection of open-source EMR software packages based on integrated AHP and TOPSIS , 2015, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[68]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Real-Time Remote Health-Monitoring Systems in a Medical Centre: A Review of the Provision of Healthcare Services-Based Body Sensor Information, Open Challenges and Methodological Aspects , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[69]  Ling Liu,et al.  A Decentralizing Attribute-Based Signature for Healthcare Blockchain , 2018, 2018 27th International Conference on Computer Communication and Networks (ICCCN).

[70]  Miss Laiha Mat Kiah,et al.  Suitability of using SOAP protocol to secure electronic medical record databases transmission , 2010 .

[71]  Gautam Srivastava,et al.  A Decentralized Privacy-Preserving Healthcare Blockchain for IoT , 2019, Sensors.

[72]  Shanlin Yang,et al.  Blockchain-Based Medical Records Secure Storage and Medical Service Framework , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[73]  A. A. Zaidan,et al.  Comprehensive Insights Into the Criteria of Student Performance in Various Educational Domains , 2018, IEEE Access.

[74]  A. A. Zaidan,et al.  Medical emergency triage and patient prioritisation in a telemedicine environment: a systematic review , 2019, Health and Technology.

[75]  Miss Laiha Mat Kiah.  Suitability of SOAP Protocol in Securing Transmissions of EMR Database , 2010 .

[76]  Robert Likić,et al.  Opportunities for Use of Blockchain Technology in Medicine , 2018, Applied Health Economics and Health Policy.

[77]  Manuel Díaz,et al.  On blockchain and its integration with IoT. Challenges and opportunities , 2018, Future Gener. Comput. Syst..

[78]  A. A. Zaidan,et al.  Mobile-Based Patient Monitoring Systems: A Prioritisation Framework Using Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Techniques , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[79]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  A security framework for mHealth apps on Android platform , 2018, Comput. Secur..

[80]  Bishal Lamichhane,et al.  Applications of Blockchain in Healthcare: Current Landscape & Challenges , 2018, ArXiv.

[81]  Vishal Patel,et al.  A framework for secure and decentralized sharing of medical imaging data via blockchain consensus , 2019, Health Informatics J..

[82]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Real-time-based E-health systems: design and implementation of a lightweight key management protocol for securing sensitive information of patients , 2018, Health and Technology.

[83]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Systematic Review of Real-time Remote Health Monitoring System in Triage and Priority-Based Sensor Technology: Taxonomy, Open Challenges, Motivation and Recommendations , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[84]  Tanesh Kumar,et al.  Secure and Efficient Data Accessibility in Blockchain Based Healthcare Systems , 2018, 2018 IEEE Global Communications Conference (GLOBECOM).

[85]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Multi-Criteria Evaluation and Benchmarking for Active Queue Management Methods: Open Issues, Challenges and Recommended Pathway Solutions , 2019, Int. J. Inf. Technol. Decis. Mak..

[86]  Jiannong Cao,et al.  BlocHIE: A BLOCkchain-Based Platform for Healthcare Information Exchange , 2018, 2018 IEEE International Conference on Smart Computing (SMARTCOMP).

[87]  Massimo Bartoletti,et al.  A Survey of Attacks on Ethereum Smart Contracts (SoK) , 2017, POST.

[88]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Secure Topology for Electronic Medical Record Transmissions , 2010 .

[89]  Hyeon-Eui Kim,et al.  Blockchain distributed ledger technologies for biomedical and health care applications , 2017, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[90]  Dimitrios Tzovaras,et al.  On the Design of a Blockchain-Based System to Facilitate Healthcare Data Sharing , 2018, 2018 17th IEEE International Conference On Trust, Security And Privacy In Computing And Communications/ 12th IEEE International Conference On Big Data Science And Engineering (TrustCom/BigDataSE).

[91]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Computerized Algorithm for Fetal Heart Rate Baseline and Baseline Variability Estimation based on Distance Between Signal Average and a Value , 2011 .

[92]  Zibin Zheng,et al.  Blockchain challenges and opportunities: a survey , 2018, Int. J. Web Grid Serv..

[93]  Chao Yang,et al.  BMPLS: Blockchain-Based Multi-level Privacy-Preserving Location Sharing Scheme for Telecare Medical Information Systems , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[94]  Aiqing Zhang,et al.  Towards Secure and Privacy-Preserving Data Sharing in e-Health Systems via Consortium Blockchain , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[95]  Qun Jin,et al.  i-Blockchain: A Blockchain-Empowered Individual-Centric Framework for Privacy-Preserved Use of Personal Health Data , 2018, 2018 9th International Conference on Information Technology in Medicine and Education (ITME).

[96]  Kai Fan,et al.  MedBlock: Efficient and Secure Medical Data Sharing Via Blockchain , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[97]  Douglas C. Schmidt,et al.  FHIRChain: Applying Blockchain to Securely and Scalably Share Clinical Data , 2018, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[98]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Fault-Tolerant mHealth Framework in the Context of IoT-Based Real-Time Wearable Health Data Sensors , 2019, IEEE Access.

[99]  Victor I. Chang,et al.  A Proposed Solution and Future Direction for Blockchain-Based Heterogeneous Medicare Data in Cloud Environment , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[100]  Abderrahim Beni Hssane,et al.  Big data security and privacy in healthcare: A Review , 2017, EUSPN/ICTH.

[101]  Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo,et al.  Blockchain in healthcare applications: Research challenges and opportunities , 2019, J. Netw. Comput. Appl..

[102]  Brennan Bennett,et al.  Blockchain HIE Overview: A Framework for Healthcare Interoperability , 2018 .

[103]  Kevin A Clauson,et al.  Geospatial blockchain: promises, challenges, and scenarios in health and healthcare , 2018, International Journal of Health Geographics.

[104]  Thaier Hayajneh,et al.  Healthcare Blockchain System Using Smart Contracts for Secure Automated Remote Patient Monitoring , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[105]  Chris Khan,et al.  A Distributed-Ledger Consortium Model for Collaborative Innovation , 2017, Computer.

[106]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Novel Methodology for Triage and Prioritizing Using "Big Data" Patients with Chronic Heart Diseases Through Telemedicine Environmental , 2017, Int. J. Inf. Technol. Decis. Mak..

[107]  Rune Hylsberg Jacobsen,et al.  Identity and Access Management with Blockchain in Electronic Healthcare Records , 2018, 2018 21st Euromicro Conference on Digital System Design (DSD).

[108]  Emad Abd-Elrahman,et al.  Multi-tier Blockchain Framework for IoT-EHRs Systems , 2018, EUSPN/ICTH.

[109]  Haibo Tian,et al.  Medical Data Management on Blockchain with Privacy , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[110]  Hugo Levard,et al.  Quantitative Description of Internal Activity on the Ethereum Public Blockchain , 2018, 2018 9th IFIP International Conference on New Technologies, Mobility and Security (NTMS).

[111]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Smart Home-based IoT for Real-time and Secure Remote Health Monitoring of Triage and Priority System using Body Sensors: Multi-driven Systematic Review , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[112]  A. A. Zaidan,et al.  A review on smartphone skin cancer diagnosis apps in evaluation and benchmarking: coherent taxonomy, open issues and recommendation pathway solution , 2018, Health and Technology.

[113]  Andrew Stranieri,et al.  Continuous Patient Monitoring With a Patient Centric Agent: A Block Architecture , 2018, IEEE Access.

[114]  Yasuhiko Nakashima,et al.  A Secure Remote Healthcare System for Hospital Using Blockchain Smart Contract , 2018, 2018 IEEE Globecom Workshops (GC Wkshps).

[115]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Real-Time Medical Systems Based on Human Biometric Steganography: a Systematic Review , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[116]  A. A. Zaidan,et al.  Mobile Patient Monitoring Systems from a Benchmarking Aspect: Challenges, Open Issues and Recommended Solutions , 2019, Journal of Medical Systems.

[117]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Suitability of adopting S/MIME and OpenPGP email messages protocol to secure electronic medical records , 2013, Second International Conference on Future Generation Communication Technologies (FGCT 2013).

[118]  Sherali Zeadally,et al.  A survey on privacy protection in blockchain system , 2019, J. Netw. Comput. Appl..

[119]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Based blockchain-PSO-AES techniques in finger vein biometrics: A novel verification secure framework for patient authentication , 2019, Comput. Stand. Interfaces.

[120]  Tiago M. Fernández-Caramés,et al.  A Review on the Application of Blockchain to the Next Generation of Cybersecure Industry 4.0 Smart Factories , 2019, IEEE Access.

[121]  Ying Liu,et al.  Model Checking PBFT Consensus Mechanism in Healthcare Blockchain Network , 2018, 2018 9th International Conference on Information Technology in Medicine and Education (ITME).

[122]  Marko Vukolic,et al.  Hyperledger fabric: a distributed operating system for permissioned blockchains , 2018, EuroSys.

[123]  Sooyong Park,et al.  Where Is Current Research on Blockchain Technology?—A Systematic Review , 2016, PloS one.

[124]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  MIRASS: Medical Informatics Research Activity Support System Using Information Mashup Network , 2014, Journal of Medical Systems.

[125]  Lijing Zhou,et al.  MIStore: a Blockchain-Based Medical Insurance Storage System , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.

[126]  B. B. Zaidan,et al.  Based Real Time Remote Health Monitoring Systems: A Review on Patients Prioritization and Related "Big Data" Using Body Sensors information and Communication Technology , 2018, Journal of Medical Systems.