Passive-Dynamic Ankle–Foot Orthoses Substitute for Ankle Strength While Causing Adaptive Gait Strategies: A Feasibility Study

Bending stiffness of passive-dynamic ankle–foot orthoses (PD-AFOs) is a functional characteristic thought to restore lost ankle function due to weakened plantar flexors. However, lower extremity impairment profiles of patients are seldom limited to plantar flexion weakness, and PD-AFO characteristics often influence gait in other ways. Combined, all PD-AFO characteristics and patient impairments likely mask the main effect of PD-AFO bending stiffness and complicate the PD-AFO bending stiffness prescription process. In this study, we propose a biomechanical probing paradigm, where customized PD-AFOs with a range of precise stiffness values are worn by healthy subjects, to experimentally test a PD-AFO strength substitution hypothesis while simultaneously documenting gait adaptations to PD-AFO use. Two healthy subjects walked at a scaled velocity while wearing a series of three PD-AFOs that ranged in bending stiffness levels. Supporting the strength substitution hypothesis, peak ankle plantar flexion moments remained unchanged across PD-AFO stiffness conditions. Further biomechanical analyses documented a complex series of ankle related kinematic and kinetic adaptive movement strategies due to PD-AFO use. This study demonstrated the utility of the biomechanical probing paradigm to help understand the contribution of PD-AFO stiffness to ankle strength and its secondary effects on ankle biomechanics.