Reconsidering the Compatibility Thesis and Eclecticism: Five Proposed Guidelines for Method Use

This essay examines calls for methodological eclecticism based on the “compatibility thesis,” arguing that they fail to take seriously the assumptions of method and, in so doing, fail to provide a methodological perspective that adequately incorporates the centrally important task of critically examining the theoretical background of methods and conceptual frameworks for research. The authors offer an alternative view of method use and a set of guidelines that emphasize the importance of contextual sensitivity, creativity, conceptual awareness, coherence, and critical reflection in research and evaluation practices.

[1]  Madhabi Chatterji,et al.  Evidence on “What Works”: An Argument for Extended-Term Mixed-Method (ETMM) Evaluation Designs , 2004 .

[2]  B. Slife.  Raising the Consciousness of Researchers: Hidden Assumptions in the Behavioral Sciences , 1998 .

[3]  E. Guba,et al.  The Paradigm dialog , 1990 .

[4]  C. D. Green,et al.  Of Immortal Mythological Beasts , 1992 .

[5]  B. Thompson.  Editorial Policies Regarding Statistical Significance Testing : Three Suggested Reforms , 2012 .

[6]  Patti Lather.  Postmodernism and the human sciences , 1990 .

[7]  D. Marks.  Theories of Image Formation , 1985 .

[8]  R. B. Johnson,et al.  Educational Research: Quantitative, Qualitative, and Mixed Approaches , 2007 .

[9]  T. Cook,et al.  Beyond qualitative versus quantitative methods , 1979 .

[10]  R. Hepburn,et al.  BEING AND TIME , 2010 .

[11]  K. Howe.  Against the Quantitative-Qualitative Incompatibility Thesis or Dogmas Die Hard , 1988 .

[12]  T. Cook,et al.  Qualitative and quantitative methods in evaluation research , 1981 .

[13]  A. Giorgi,et al.  Phenomenology and Psychological Research , 1991 .

[14]  Anthony J. Onwuegbuzie,et al.  The Role of Cooperative Learning in Research Methodology Courses: A Mixed-Methods Analysis. , 2001 .

[15]  R. Harré,et al.  Rethinking the Laboratory Experiment , 1992 .

[16]  S. Kvale,et al.  Psychology and postmodernism , 1992 .

[17]  Thomas A. Schwandt.  Evaluation Practice Reconsidered , 2002 .

[18]  Lois-Ellin Datta,et al.  Paradigm wars: A basis for peaceful coexistence and beyond , 1994 .

[19]  Valerie J. Caracelli,et al.  Toward a Conceptual Framework for Mixed-Method Evaluation Designs , 1989 .

[20]  F. Wertz.  Phenomenological research methods for counseling psychology , 2005 .

[21]  Gerald Holton,et al.  Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein. , 1976 .

[22]  M. R. Westcott.  The psychology of human freedom , 1988 .

[23]  J. Greene.  With a Splash of Soda, Please: Towards Active Engagement with Difference , 2002 .

[24]  M. R. Westcott.  The Psychology of Human Freedom: A Human Science Perspective and Critique , 1988 .

[25]  Walter B. Weimer.  Notes on the methodology of scientific research , 1979 .

[26]  Charles Taylor.  Philosophy and the Human Sciences: Contents , 1985 .

[27]  B. Slife,et al.  Time and psychological explanation , 1993 .

[28]  Patti Lather.  Research as Praxis , 1986 .

[29]  Richard N. Williams,et al.  TOWARD A THEORETICAL PSYCHOLOGY: SHOULD A SUBDISCIPLINE BE FORMALLY RECOGNIZED? , 1997 .

[30]  M. R. Westcott.  The Discursive Expression of Human Freedom , 1992 .

[31]  B. Thompson.  Research news and Comment: AERA Editorial Policies Regarding Statistical Significance Testing: Three Suggested Reforms , 1996 .

[32]  S. Yanchar,et al.  On the Nature of a Critical Methodology , 2005 .

[33]  Sharon F. Rallis,et al.  The Qualitative-Quantitative Debate: New Perspectives. , 1994 .

[34]  M. Miles,et al.  Drawing Valid Meaning from Qualitative Data: Toward a Shared Craft , 1984 .

[35]  W. Pillow.  Confession, catharsis, or cure? Rethinking the uses of reflexivity as methodological power in qualitative research , 2003 .

[36]  Donald E. Polkinghorne,et al.  Methodology for the Human Sciences: Systems of Inquiry , 1984 .

[37]  David Williamson Shaffer,et al.  What Good are Statistics that Don’t Generalize? , 2004 .

[38]  J. Richardson.  Handbook of Qualitative Research Methods for Psychology and the Social Sciences , 1996 .

[39]  M. Constas.  Research News And Comment: The Changing Nature of Educational Research and a Critique of Postmodernism , 1998 .

[40]  Identification of Underlying Assumptions is an Integral Part of Research: An Example from Motor Control , 1994 .

[41]  W. Firestone.  Meaning in Method: The Rhetoric of Quantitative and Qualitative Research , 1987 .

[42]  C. Teddlie,et al.  SAGE Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social & Behavioral Research , 2010 .

[43]  John K. Smith,et al.  Closing Down the Conversation: The End of the Quantitative-Qualitative Debate Among Educational Inquirers , 1986 .

[44]  Leslie Goodyear,et al.  The Merits of Mixing Methods in Evaluation , 2001 .

[45]  Martyn Hammersley,et al.  The relationship between qualitative and quantitative research: paradigm loyalty versus methodological eclecticism , 2002 .

[46]  E. Mishler.  Meaning in Context: Is There Any Other Kind? , 1979 .

[47]  E. A. Burtt,et al.  The Metaphysical Foundations of Modern Science , 1925 .

[48]  H. Gadamer,et al.  Truth and Method , 1960 .

[49]  Elizabeth Adams St. Pierre.  The Call for Intelligibility in Postmodern Educational Research , 2000 .

[50]  Jacklyn Martin,et al.  Psychology and the Question of Agency , 2003 .

[51]  Abbas Tashakkori,et al.  Mixed Methodology: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches , 1998 .

[52]  J. Maxwell.  Causal Explanation, Qualitative Research, and Scientific Inquiry in Education , 2004 .

[53]  J. Bohman.  New Philosophy of Social Science: Problems of Indeterminacy , 1991 .

[54]  W. Humes,et al.  Post-structuralism and policy research in education , 2003 .

[55]  W. Pillow.  Deciphering Attempts to Decipher Postmodern Educational Research , 2000 .

[56]  A. Onwuegbuzie,et al.  Mixed Methods Research: A Research Paradigm Whose Time Has Come , 2004 .

[57]  N. Bernsen,et al.  Beyond Objectivism and Relativism: Science, Hermeneutics, and Praxis , 1984 .

[58]  Stephen Brookfield,et al.  Developing critical thinkers: Challenging adults to explore alternative ways of thinking and acting. , 1989 .

[59]  Kurt Danziger,et al.  The Methodological Imperative in Psychology , 1985 .

[60]  J. Ponterotto.  Qualitative research in counseling psychology: A primer on research paradigms and philosophy of science , 2005 .

[61]  Charles Taylor,et al.  Philosophy and the human sciences , 1985 .

[62]  M. Hesse,et al.  Revolutions and Reconstructions in the Philosophy of Science , 1980 .

[63]  Richard N. Williams,et al.  What's Behind the Research?: Discovering Hidden Assumptions in the Behavioral Sciences , 1995 .

[64]  J. Mezirow.  On Critical Reflection , 1998 .

[65]  B. Slife.  The perils of eclecticism as therapeutic orientation. , 1987 .

[66]  Thomas S. Weisner,et al.  Discovering Successful Pathways in Children's Development: Mixed Methods in the Study of Childhood and Family Life. The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Series on Mental Health and Development. , 2005 .