The Extent of Price Misalignment in Prediction Markets

We study misaligned prices for logically related contracts in prediction markets. First, we uncover persistent arbitrage opportunities for risk-neutral investors between identical contracts on different exchanges. Examining the impact of several thousand dollars of transactions on the exchanges themselves in a randomized field trial, we document that price support extends well beyond what is seen in the published order book and that arbitrage opportunities are significantly larger than purely observational measurements indicate. Second, we demonstrate misalignment among identical and logically related contracts listed on the same exchange that cluster around moments of high information flow, when related contracts systemically shut down or fail to respond efficiently. Third, we document bounded rationality in prediction markets; examples include: consistent asymmetry between buying and selling, leaving the average return for selling higher than for buying; and persistent price lags between exchanges. Despite these signs of departure from theoretical optimality, the markets studied function well on balance, considering the sometimes complex and subtle relationships among contracts. Yet, we detail how to improve prediction markets by moving the burden of finding and fixing logical contradictions into the exchange and providing flexible trading interfaces, both of which free traders to focus on providing meaningful information in the form they find most natural.

[1]  Patrik Sand̊as,et al.  The Impact of Hidden Liquidity in Limit Order Books , 2008 .

[2]  Florian Teschner,et al.  SIMPLIFYING MARKET ACCESS: A NEW CONFIDENCE-BASED INTERFACE , 2013 .

[3]  David M. Pennock,et al.  A combinatorial prediction market for the U.S. elections , 2013, EC '13.

[4]  Leonard Rosenthal,et al.  The seemingly anomalous price behavior of Royal Dutch/Shell and Unilever N.V./PLC , 1990 .

[5]  E. Franck,et al.  Inter‐Market Arbitrage in Betting , 2013 .

[6]  David M. Pennock,et al.  Pricing combinatorial markets for tournaments , 2008, STOC.

[7]  Justin Wolfers,et al.  Using Markets to Inform Policy: The Case of the Iraq War , 2009 .

[8]  Zizhuo Wang,et al.  Parimutuel Betting on Permutations , 2008, WINE.

[9]  Anthony Man-Cho So,et al.  A Convex Parimutuel Formulation for Contingent Claim Markets , 2006 .

[10]  Leslie R. Fine,et al.  Inducing liquidity in thin financial markets through combined-value trading mechanisms , 2002 .

[11]  Michael P. Wellman,et al.  Betting boolean-style: a framework for trading in securities based on logical formulas , 2003, EC '03.

[12]  David M. Pennock,et al.  Extracting collective probabilistic forecasts from web games , 2001, KDD '01.

[13]  David M. Pennock,et al.  Price Updating in Combinatorial Prediction Markets with Bayesian Networks , 2011, UAI.

[14]  Lance Fortnow,et al.  Betting on permutations , 2007, EC '07.

[15]  Abe de Jong,et al.  The Risk and Return of Arbitrage in Dual-Listed Companies , 2008 .

[16]  Koleman S. Strumpf,et al.  Illegal Sports Bookmakers , 2003 .

[17]  Kenneth A. Froot,et al.  How are Stock Prices Affected by the Location of Trade? , 1998 .

[18]  Stanford Wong,et al.  Sharp Sports Betting , 2001 .

[19]  David Rothschild,et al.  Forecasting Elections Comparing Prediction Markets, Polls, and Their Biases , 2009 .

[20]  Thomas S. Gruca,et al.  PUBLIC INFORMATION BIAS AND PREDICTION MARKET ACCURACY , 2012 .

[21]  Kenneth Oliven,et al.  Suckers Are Born but Markets Are Made: Individual Rationality, Arbitrage, and Market Efficiency on an Electronic Futures Market , 2004, Manag. Sci..

[22]  Nicholas Economides,et al.  A Parimutuel Market Microstructure for Contingent Claims Trading , 2001 .

[23]  Paul C. Tetlock,et al.  The Promise of Prediction Markets , 2008, Science.

[24]  Robin Hanson,et al.  A Manipulator Can Aid Prediction Market Accuracy , 2009 .

[25]  Koleman Strumpf,et al.  Manipulating political stock markets: A field experiment and a century of observational data , 2006 .

[26]  Ken Baron,et al.  Parimutuel Applications In Finance: New Markets for New Risks , 2007 .

[27]  Miroslav Dudík,et al.  A tractable combinatorial market maker using constraint generation , 2012, EC '12.

[28]  Koleman Strumpf,et al.  Historical presidential betting markets , 2004 .

[29]  Thomas A. Rietz,et al.  Results from a Dozen Years of Election Futures Markets Research , 2008 .

[30]  Justin Wolfers,et al.  Using Prediction Markets to Track Information Flows: Evidence from Google , 2009, AMMA.

[31]  Mingyu Guo,et al.  Combinatorial prediction markets for event hierarchies , 2009, AAMAS.

[32]  H. Simon,et al.  American Association for Public Opinion Research Bandwagon and Underdog Effects and the Possibility of Election Predictions , 2009 .

[33]  Lance Fortnow,et al.  Complexity of combinatorial market makers , 2008, EC '08.