This article focuses on ways in which school-age children “make meaning” when they are involved in reading and writing activities. An Analysis of Meaning Construction procedure was developed to describe the knowledge sources, specific strategies, and monitoring behaviors of 67 third-, sixth-, and ninth-grade children when they read and wrote stories and reports. Each student participated in either a think-aloud or retrospective self-report activity during (or after) reading and writing four story and report passages. The resulting transcripts were segmented into communication units and analyzed using the meaning analysis system. Comparisons were made between genres (story and report), domains (reading and writing), and ages (grades 3, 6, and 9). Findings indicate that meaning-making behaviors (1) are complex and varied, (2) change with age and difficulty, and (3) vary consistently between reading and writing. Although reading and writing are related language activities in that they tap similar underlying processes, it is inaccurate to conceptualize them as predominantly similar; reading and writing are also quite different in that the processes they invoke follow markedly different patterns.
[1]
Judith A. Langer.
The Effects of Available Information on Responses to School Writing Tasks.
,
1984
.
[2]
F. Craik,et al.
Levels of Pro-cessing: A Framework for Memory Research
,
1975
.
[3]
Robert de Beaugrande,et al.
Design Criteria for Process Models of Reading.
,
1981
.
[4]
D. Norman,et al.
To Ask a Question, One Must Know Enough to Know What Is Not Known. Report No. 7802.
,
1978
.
[5]
Judith A. Langer.
Children's Sense of Genre
,
1985
.
[6]
A. Graesser,et al.
Answers to why-questions expose the organization of story plot and predict recall of actions
,
1980
.
[7]
K. A. Ericsson,et al.
Verbal reports as data.
,
1980
.
[8]
Judith A. Langer.
Examining Background Knowledge and Text Comprehension.
,
1984
.
[9]
Perry W. Thorndyke,et al.
The role of inferences in discourse comprehension
,
1976
.
[10]
N. Sommers.
Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Experienced Adult Writers.
,
1980
.
[11]
Randolph K. Cirilo.
Referential coherence and text structure in story comprehension
,
1981
.